Blaise Pascal's proof of the supernatural to the French king

Blaise Pascal
4 followers
is the famous answer that Blaise Pascal gave to the French king's request for proof of the
supernatural relevant today. Roger showed me on his smartphone what he read on the Jewish website
piash.com about the French philosopher Blaise Pascal. Over 300 years ago, Louis XIV of France
asked Blaise Pascal, the great French philosopher, to give him proof of the supernatural. Pascal
answered, why the Jews, your majesty, the Jews? An astonishing answer. The best proof of the
supernatural that Pascal could think of was the Jews. We don't have to speculate what Pascal meant
when he gave this answer because he took the trouble to spell it out. Pascal said that the
fact that the Jewish people survived until the 17th century when he lived was nothing short of
a supernatural phenomenon. There was simply no logical explanation for it. Have you ever thought
about what Blaise Pascal would think of his answer now, Roger asked me? Yes, I replied. I expect that
he would be even more satisfied and confident in giving it again. The fact that the Jews not only
survived but they are thriving in Israel would be further remarkable confirmation of his argument,
Roger said. He would be horrified by the Holocaust, I said, and the great evil that befell the Jews
of Europe but very much struck by their restoration to their ancient homeland, I suggested. Roger, I
said, I remember reading many years ago that one of the French philosopher Voltaire's objections to
the Bible was that the land of Israel could never have supported the civilization described in the
Bible. It was so desolate, barren and devoid of life at the time when he lived. That was in the
18th century, the one that followed Pascal's life in the 17th century. Voltaire was one of the Age
of Enlightenment's leading skeptics, recalled Roger, and so it does not surprise me he would
form a conclusion on evidence like that. But how wrong he was. Sadly, however, I said, that kind of
argument persuaded some of his contemporaries to turn away from the Bible and from the God of the
Bible. If it was his answer to Pascal, how miserably he failed. Where in the Bible does it say that
Israel would be a witness for God, Roger asked me. The most direct reference I answered is in the
prophecy of Isaiah. Can you direct me there, Roger requested? There are three times in Isaiah's
prophecy where God declares that the people of Israel are his witnesses, I said to Roger.
But first, God challenges the nations to bring forward their witnesses in order to establish
what is true. Let me read from Isaiah 43 verse 9. All the nations gather together in the people's
assemble. Who among them can declare this and show us the former things? Let them bring their witnesses
to prove them right and let them hear and say it is true. What are the former things that the
prophet is referring to, Roger asked me. They could be understood to be events that go back in time
right to the beginning of creation, I answered. Only God has a precise and accurate knowledge
of human history. But then Isaiah continued, I stated, to explain who his witnesses to the
nations are. You are my witnesses, declares the Lord, and my servant whom I have chosen,
that you may know and believe me and understand that I am he. Before me, no God was formed,
nor shall there be any after me. Who is that pronoun you referring to in this passage,
Roger asked me. At the beginning of Isaiah 43, the people to whom God was speaking are identified,
I said. But now, thus says the Lord, he who created you, O Jacob, he who formed you, O Israel,
fear not, for I have redeemed you. I have called you by name. You are mine.
There is more, I said to Roger. Whereas God challenged the nations to show what is true
concerning the former things, the past, I said, he declared that he would disclose future things
concerning his people. Why does Isaiah say that, asked Roger. In the next chapter, chapter 44,
I replied. Who is like me, let him proclaim it. Let him declare and set it before me,
since I appointed an ancient people. Let them declare what is to come and what will happen.
Fear not, nor be afraid. Have not I told you from of old and declared it? And you are my witnesses.
Is there a God besides me? There is no rock. I know not any. I see, said Roger, that God declares
that in Israel he will show in advance what will happen and that the nations do not have that
foresight. Yes, I said, the ability to know the future before it happens is reserved to God only.
It is unique to him. And God revealed that future as it relates to Israel, I said to Roger.
There are two objections that I have heard raised to this argument, said Roger,
and I would like to get your response, he said. What would those objections be, I asked.
The first one is that the Jews cannot be God's witnesses because many leading Jews over the
centuries have been atheists who do not believe in God. That observation regarding a level of
unbelief among some of the Jewish people is correct, I said. Theodor Herzl, who is often
viewed as the father of Zionism, is a case in point. He was not motivated by religious conviction
but by a recognition of the need for Jewish national identity. But in no way does their
unbelief invalidate their witness. As instruments that brought about Israel's remarkable restoration,
they contributed to the power of the witness of the Jews.
It is one of the paradoxes of Israel's witness, observed Roger, that many of the people of Israel
served that function unwillingly, or at least without any conscious or deliberate idea of doing
so. And the second objection, I asked Roger. The second objection is that not all the things that
the prophets foretold have happened, Roger said. Were you given any specific example, I asked Roger.
Somewhere, doesn't it say in the Bible that the Mount of Olives would be split in two
by an earthquake, I asked Roger. Yes, I said, that reference is in Zechariah 14.
That's the example that I was given, said Roger. Ezekiel was given a vision of Israel's restoration
being like a corpse coming back to life in discrete stages, I said. First the bones would
rattle and shake, then they would form a skeletal structure, then sinews would be laid on the
skeleton, and then it would have breath imparted to it and stand up on its feet. The prophets foretold
that there would be a series of steps by which Israel's national identity came to be.
That's exactly how it has been, said Roger. Yes, I agreed. There are important elements of the final
outcome that have not occurred, such as Messiah reigning from Jerusalem and sending God's law
forth to the ends of the earth. It's the fact that so many of the steps have occurred already, said
Roger, that gives us confidence in the completion of the prophet's vision. Yes, I agreed. Just as
Voltaire's objection was cast down by the march of time, so will this one, I said. I look forward
to that outcome when the prophet's vision is completed, said Roger. The world needs it urgently.
To consider more Bible study, please visit our website, thegoodnewsplan.org.
