Louis Pasteur: Between Myth and Reality - Jean-Marc Cavaillon

Louis Pasteur
28 followers
This is Ambassador, Mr. President
of the Organizing Societies in Medicine and in Science.
Ladies and gentlemen, it's a great honor
to be here today in Helsinki to give a talk about Louis Pasteur
and total my presentation between myth and reality.
No doubt that Louis Pasteur is a hero.
As a lay saint, as shown here, as the angel of extermination
of raddies, or as an immortal icon, as shown after his death.
He's a hero.
There is no French person who has
his figure on the stamps of many countries
all over the world, like those.
And this is just a small number of stamps.
There are plenty of others.
And also, he has his name.
For example, in France, there are 3,300 cities
which have a Pasteur street.
But not only in France, you have in Vietnam, in Mexico,
in Algeria, and even in Boston.
This is Avenue Louis Pasteur.
And this Avenue Louis Pasteur is where this Harvard University
medical school is.
And we have also this Pasteur railway station,
which is, in fact, in Buenos Aires.
He's also the hero in some movie.
There were two movies, one with Sacha Getry as the hero,
and the other one the next year in 1836 in the States
with Paul Muni, who got the Oscar for his interpretation
of Louis Pasteur.
Of course, he has his statues.
No less than three statues of Louis Pasteur are in Paris.
One in Place de Breteuil, one at the Institut Pasteur,
and one at the Sorbonne.
There are also many statues all around the country.
Of course, each time, inauguration
were a major event, like this one in Lille in 1899,
and other statues in places where he has been working,
or where he's born, or where he has been spending
his childhood time.
There are also statues in other countries.
You have this one in Chicago.
This was in Coonoor in India, in Mexico City, in Montreal,
in Bogota.
Interestingly, I just realized that this one in Chicago
was inaugurated by one of the three kids.
I heard that there were kids coming from Finland,
but there were also kids coming from the States, from New
Jersey, to get the vaccine of Louis Pasteur.
And that statue was inaugurated by one of these kids
later on as an adult.
So first, we start with a legend.
And the legend started thanks to his son-in-law,
René Valéry Radeau, who wrote in 1883,
Mr. Pasteur, The Story of a Scientist by an Ignorant.
To be honest, this book has been made under the dictation
of Louis Pasteur.
And the second book he wrote is The Life of Louis Pasteur
in 1900.
The other contributor to the legend is Émile Duclos.
Émile Duclos was his collaborator,
and he succeeded Louis Pasteur at the head of Institut Pasteur.
And he wrote this book, Pasteur, Histoire d'un Esprit.
Then the reality appeared when his nephew
published his book In the Shadow of Louis Pasteur.
And in this book, you learn a lot of information
that so far have been hidden by those
who were building the legend.
And most interestingly, the publication
of his correspondence by his grandson.
Here you see his grandson when he was a kid with Louis Pasteur
and as an adult.
And can you imagine that between 1840 to 1895,
all correspondence by Louis Pasteur
were copied by his wife?
So that's why we have access to all what
the letters sent by Pasteur were in a collection.
But most interestingly, the published correspondence
of Pasteur is redacted from a certain number of documents
and with certain letters from certain passages
so as not to affect the legend.
So now, in fact, there are quite a few letters
that now we can rediscover, which in fact provide
a new light on the life of Louis Pasteur,
but his grandson avoided to put them
in this collection of correspondence.
And then are the laboratory notebooks of Louis Pasteur.
And once again, the grandson played a major role.
René Valéry Hadot was told by Pasteur,
never show my laboratory notebook to anyone.
In 1964, his grandson made a donation
to the National French Library.
In 1964, and he said that those could be open
to be studied and have access after his own death.
So then, it was possible to study
and try to make a link between the legend
and the laboratory notebook.
And the main player in this story is Gerald Jason.
He was professor of history of science
at Princeton University and could study
the Cayida of Louis Pasteur and all these notebooks
and all the notes that were in these laboratory notebooks.
And finally, he wrote the Private Science of Louis Pasteur.
And for that book, he got in 1996,
the William Welsh Medal for his book
by the American Association for the History of Medicine.
And I was told that at the Institute Pasteur Library,
there was a major question.
Can we get that book in our library
or we leave it outside of the Institute Pasteur?
But most interestingly is this text you can find
in the obituary of Louis Pasteur
when he passed away in 1895.
And this is very interesting statement.
Pasteur is regarded as the father of modern bacteriology,
but we must remember that he was not a pioneer
in these lines of work.
There was hardly a problem that he studied
which has not been already recognized
and haven't studied to a greater or less extent
by his predecessors.
And in fact, what an interesting statement
in this obituary was others discovered facts.
Pasteur determined laws.
I like also to quote Jean Rostand.
Jean Rostand is a very famous French historian of science
and a scientist by himself.
He said, it's commonly believed in the public
that it was Pasteur who discovered the role of microbes
in the production of infectious disease.
In truth, this considerable discovery
does not belong to him,
but belongs to another French scientist, Daven,
who was the first to dare to affirm
and was able to demonstrate that by experimental method
that microorganism is the agents responsible
for a disease.
And that work was from Gadesimi Daven in 1863.
When he studied sheeps with anthrax,
he could see the microbes within the blood
of these sick animals and injected the blood
of these sick sheep into rabbits,
transmit the disease and the death.
Now, another aspect of interesting to build the reality
is this preface that Joseph Grandchaud
has been mentioned earlier,
was the one who was making the vaccination of the kids
or of the adults.
Joseph Grandchaud wrote a preface on this book,
Etudes sur les virus, by Jean Hamot.
Jean Hamot was a medical doctor in Arcachon area,
and he was an amazing visionary.
And he mentioned everything which will be later on
demonstrated by Louis Pasteur
was already considered by Jean Hamot.
And in his preface, Joseph Grandchaud wrote,
but Germany had already surpassed us in microbial technique
and Mr's laboratory, faithful to culture in liquid media,
neglected the art of coloring microbes
and that of cultivating them on solid media.
It was Mr. Babesh, who was a Romanian scientist,
who coming from Germany,
made known in France, in Mr. Cornille's laboratory,
the methods of staining microbes
then in use in Mr. Corr's laboratory.
And we know that between Pasteur and Corr,
then we are not truly friends.
So to be honest, the main discovery of Louis Pasteur
that was really original,
is the work on molecular correlative,
on molecular asymmetry.
And you have to be aware that Pasteur,
as it has been mentioned, was a chemist first,
and form as a chemist.
And he realized that tartrate deflects polarized light,
not para-tartrate, and came to this concept
of molecular asymmetry.
And the great chemist of that time,
like Jean-Baptiste Dubiau in France,
or William Gottlieb Henkel in Germany,
or Erhard Mietscherlich in Germany,
truly admire this discovery
and Mietscherlich said to Pasteur,
you saw what I could not find.
So clearly that was the main discovery of Louis Pasteur.
But then of course, as you know,
he moved to another field,
it's particularly the alcoholic fermentation,
writing this book in his memory,
on the fermentation.
And one of the key observation of Louis Pasteur
was that yeast involved in fermentation
was an animal nature.
But he was not the first one to say that,
as I said, many precursors before Pasteur.
The first one to recognize,
probably not that it was an animal nature,
but to draw them, to see them under the microscope,
was in 1680, Anthony van Leeuwenhoek,
who was in fact the very first scientist to see bacteria.
But also in Italy, Adamo Fabbroni,
in France, Louis-Jacques Ténard,
Theodore Schwan.
By the way, Schwan was the only one
who was well recognized by Pasteur
to be one of his precursor.
Still in Germany, Kotzing,
in France, Charles Kenyard de Latour,
and again in France, Pierre-Jean-François Turpin.
All those people had coined the concept
that yeast was animal in nature.
The other, which were opponent to Pasteur,
were, for example, in Germany, von Liebig.
I put this, it's a soup,
but I don't know if in Finland you have that kind of soup,
but in France, we have Liebig,
and Liebig is very well known,
not as a scientist, but as a soup.
So Liebig worked together with Wohler,
and they were supporting the idea
that fermentation was a mechanical process.
They had no experimental evidence
to refute the cellular basis of fermentation.
Instead, they resorted to polemical mockery,
and they published in the Analogues de Chemie and Pharmacie,
of which both were editor-in-chief.
And indeed, I think this is what is known nowadays
as the insidious links
between scientists and the scientific press.
And during the COVID-19,
we have seen how much that was influencing,
and we have a very famous French medical doctor
called Raoult in France, in Marseille,
who was clearly an illustration of those insidious links.
Among the other opponents was Claude Bernard,
who is the founder of experimental medicine,
and for him, alcohol was formed
by a subtle ferment outside of life.
But Marcelin Berthelot published
some posthumous notes of Claude Bernard,
and to those notes,
a pastor felt that he had to make this publication,
so Examen Critique des travaux posthumes
de Claude Bernard sur la fermentation,
and he wrote the following.
The question of the subtle ferment is settled.
It does not exist.
Bernard deleted himself.
But Pasteur is wrong,
and the one who was clearly the precursor
who was right is Antoine Béchamp.
He began his work on fermentation in 1854
and presented his work on the subject in 1867
in a book entitled
About the Circulation of Carbon in Nature
and the Intermediaries of this Circulation.
This is the book.
And yet, Béchamp demonstrated
that he had understood everything about fermentation
before Pasteur and better than him.
He wrote.
Oh, I'm stuck.
Thank you.
I'm stuck, so you will have to just wait.
Yeah, so he wrote,
the substance that brings about this transformation,
I can't isolate it.
I've named it zymase.
Zymase are pure chemical agents
produced by a living being.
Insoluble ferments are recognized being,
and their chemical action is of the physiological order.
So he was really the first one to understand that.
Next.
Now, let's move to another field of research
was the research on wine disease.
On July 1863, it was called by Colonnade de Fonse-Favé,
who was the aide-de-camp of the Emperor Napoleon III,
who suggested the name of Pasteur
for a study on wine disease.
In fact, of course, as you can imagine,
producing wine and selling wine,
it was a major business in France.
The problem was that those wine arrived in foreign countries,
especially in UK, as completely altered.
So that was a major problem for the market
and for the business.
Next.
So Pasteur said, agreed to do that.
He asked to receive some Pommard,
for those who know a bit of the French wine,
it's not bad wine, and some Volnay.
Of course, the wine from his area,
the wine of Arbois and the Gros Plant du Pays Nantais,
which is not that good, but that's still.
Next.
And the main effort of Pasteur was to bring the microscope
to study the wines.
And these are the drawings of Pasteur.
I did not make the translation
because it's a bit difficult.
It was the name of the different disease of the wine,
La Cessance, La Tourne, La Grèce, La Merture.
And each time you recognize
that there were different microbes
that were contaminating these different wine.
So he understood that these four undesirable microbes
were present in wine, had been introduced by men
before bottling wine,
and he proposed the principle of pasteurization.
Next.
Here we see this cartoon made with showing Pasteur
with his wife in the train,
bringing back wine branches from Arbois
for his study on wine.
So he obtained his patent on pasteurization
on April 1st, 1865.
And that was to heat the wines
to prevent them from disease.
Next.
Was he the first one?
The answer is no.
And in fact, the idea came to Nicolas Appert.
So it's another French citizen.
In fact, he was a confectioner.
And he's the one to whom we do,
who invented the way of making preserved.
So Appert published L'Art de conserver
pendant plusieurs années
toutes les substances animales et végétales.
And he published a series of books
for the different years.
The first one being in 1810.
And the next one, next slide,
being in 1831, for the first time,
he considered the wines.
And he proposed to heat the wines.
By the way, pasteurization of milk
was made by a German scientist many years later.
So Pasteur published his studies on wines.
Next.
But he also made studies on vinegar.
And next, on beer.
Next.
About vinegar, next.
He went to Orléans,
which was a city where most of the factories
of vinegar were made.
And he made the observation
that the vinegar were possible
thanks to this organism, Mycoderma aceti.
But he made a major observation,
and once again, thanks to the microscope,
that the problems of those vinegar makers
was that there was a contamination
with anguillules, which were a kind of parasites.
Next.
Then happened the war between France and Prussia in 1870.
And he had to move from Paris in south of France
and went close to Clermont-Ferrand in Chamalières
and started to work on the beer,
on the fabrication of beer.
Next.
Then he went to London, to the white bread breweries.
And here we see Louis Pasteur in white bread laboratory.
And once again, he was one of the very first one
to propose to the use of microscope
to study the problem of beers.
Next.
And then finally, he obtained a patent on that,
which was published on June, 1871.
And in his patent, next, he wrote,
I want beers made with my process to beer in France,
the name National Revenge.
National Revenge Beer.
And this is illustration of, again, his Germanophobia.
And for him, it was very important.
By the way, Joseph Meister was coming from Alsace,
and Alsace at that time was in Germany.
So that's why for Pasteur, a very important event.
Next.
He went also in Mertemoiselle in Jules Tourtel breweries.
Next.
And also in Copenhagen, in Carlsberg.
And you can find the statue of Louis Pasteur
in Carlsberg factory.
By the way, Jean-Baptiste, who have been told before,
was a diplomat in Copenhagen at that time.
Next.
Oh, it's working again.
It's working again.
Thank you for your efforts.
By the way, to finish with the work on fermentation,
Pasteur brought plots of vineyard,
and which is Claude Rosier,
and you can even buy a bottle of wine
with the picture of Pasteur.
But he made, honestly, a very clever experiment.
So he put bunch of grapes wrapped in cotton.
So you see here the plant with the grapes,
and so you see some are free
and some are wrapped in cotton.
And then he showed that those who were freely exposed
to air could allow making wine,
where those were protected from the environment.
So that means from the germs from outside,
there was no possibility to make wines with those.
Next.
All right, good.
So, of course, a great effort was the work
of refutation of spontaneous generation
and ending to the germ theory.
But once again, there were precursors.
There were some people, of course,
who didn't make any demonstration,
but who had the intuition.
The most amazing are this Roman Veyron,
or Greek Gallien, who were already thinking
that probably disease were caused by elements,
of course, not known at that time,
that were causing the infectious disease.
And, of course, many others contributed.
Fra Castor, who was unknown from Pasteur,
but one of the main contributor was Lazaro Spallanzani.
And this painting is, in fact,
in the main dining room of Louis Pasteur,
a Pasteur who had a lot,
we heard this before with Edelfeldt,
but not only with Edelfeldt.
He had a lot of connection with many painters,
and he asked to have the painting of Spallanzani.
So, in 1961, he published
Les corpuscules organisées qui existent dans l'atmosphère,
and this famous
swan-neck flask,
adding to this theory of germs.
And you see here, Louis Pasteur on the Mer de Glace,
testing his flask, opening the flask on the Mer de Glace,
so in the Alps, in the mountain,
showing that the air there is free of microbes,
and that there was no contamination
in comparison to the same flask open in Paris, for example.
Of course, there were opponents,
and the main opponent was Félix Archimède Pouchet.
So, for the poor guy, it's no chance,
because he made more or less the same experiment than Pasteur.
In the Pyrénées, I don't think that makes a difference
with the Alps, and in fact, it was even higher,
so we can think that the air was even purer.
And it came to the concept of hétérogénie,
which is, in fact, the concept of spontaneous generation.
And in 1864, he published a new book
on the spontaneous generation.
Amusingly, he sent his book to Gustave Flaubert,
and here we have a letter of Gustave Flaubert to Pouchet,
saying how he was admiring the science proposed by Pouchet,
so it's interesting to see how there was a connection
between all this intelligentsia.
But finally, on February 20th, 1865,
the commission of the Academy of Science
ruled in favor of Louis Pasteur against Félix Pouchet,
and it was over, the concept
of spontaneous generation was solved.
And clearly, the GM theory ended to a main consequence
is the one made by Joseph Lister.
In 1865, he learned Louis Pasteur's theory
that microorganisms cause infection.
So using phenol as an antiseptic,
and here we have this machine that he was using
to spray all around the body who was under surgery,
and he reduced the mortality of amputated patient
to 15% in four years, compared to 45 to 50%
who previously died of sepsis.
And this is his first publication in 1876
in the British Medical Journal,
where Lister proposed the antiseptic principle
for the practice of surgery,
and that was made with a boy of 11 years
who was badly
amputated on the leg.
Maybe you know this painting.
This was made in 1902, so interestingly,
that was the jubilee of Louis Pasteur
for his 17th anniversary,
and the painting was made 10 years later.
And in fact, some people who are on the painting
were not present during that jubilee.
But most importantly, here you see the Sadi Carnot,
the French president, who is Louis Pasteur,
and the person who is exactly in the middle of the painting
is not Pasteur, it's Lister,
and Lister is getting up some few steps
to congratulate Pasteur.
Another key work of Pasteur was the silkworm disease.
He was called by Jean-Baptiste Dumas
to investigate silkworm disease,
but he didn't know anything about it.
So he went to meet Henri Fabre,
who was an entomologist,
and here is what Fabre wrote.
Ignoring caterpillar, cocoon, chrysalis, metamorphosis,
Pasteur came to regenerate the silkworm.
The ancient gymnasts presenting themselves
necked to the fight.
Genius fighter against the scourge of the manuneries,
he also came to the battle necked.
That is to say, without the simplest notion
about the insect to get out of the purée.
I was stunned.
Better than that, I was amazed.
Once again, we meet Antoine Béchamp.
Antoine Béchamp, in 1865, and as soon as 1865,
said the pebrine, that was the name of the disease,
was a parasitic disease.
During that same period of time,
Pasteur said, no, it's a constitutive disease.
Till 1867, finally, Pasteur admitted
it was an infectious disease.
In 1870, he published his book on the study
on the disease of the silkworm.
In fact, Pasteur was using the method
proposed by Emilio Cornelia in 1856
to make selection of the diseased worms and eggs
to avoid the...
I can give you five more minutes.
So this is the statue of the savior of sericulture.
Pasteur wrote, this poor Mr. Béchamp is at this moment
one of the most curious examples
of the influence of preconceived ideas
gradually turned into fixed idea.
All these assertions are so biased
that I wonder if he has ever observed
more than 10 silkworms in his life.
And Béchamp said, I am the precursor of Pasteur,
exactly as the robber is the precursor
of the fortune of the happy and insolent thieves
who taunt and slander them.
So I will move very fastly,
just because I wanted to at least mention
one Finnish scientist, so that's why
this is an important slide.
It's Robert Hestrom about peripheral sepsis,
because in fact, he was thinking it was due to miasma,
but he considered that the disease was contagious
and that was very important.
So the two other key person were Viktor Fels and Leon Kos,
who showed that deadly bacteria are present
in the blood of patients.
And that work published in La Gazette Medicale de Strasbourg
was published in 1969.
10 years later, 10 years later,
Pasteur published the same thing,
that indeed a woman who died of peripheral fever
had bacteria in their blood.
And he suggested the use of boric acid
to wash the genital tract.
So let's finish with three minutes.
Let's say four, because one per vaccine.
With the four vaccine of Louis Pasteur.
So the first is the full cholera.
So they used virulent pastorella, which was killing hen,
and because vacation are very important in France,
everything is stopped during vacation time.
So once they came back from vacation,
they took back their virulent pastorella culture,
re-injected in hen, and the hen survived.
So they came, they did the experiment
that they took back this hen
and re-prepared virulent pastorella in culture,
and the hen survived.
And they came to the conclusion
that in the field of observation,
chance only favors prepared minds.
But this is a fairy tale.
And once again, this is just what has been told,
but it's not the reality.
The second vaccine is on drugs.
The precursor is Henri Toussaint,
who made the key vaccine using fennel
to attenuate the bacteria and inject it in sheep
and protected the sheep.
The most known experiment was made a year later,
the so-called Puy-le-Feu demonstration
where Pasteur was successfully addressing the problem,
but there was no information about the nature of the vaccine
and it was thought, at least it's what Pasteur
was suggesting that like the fall cholera,
the attenuation was made by air and by oxygen.
And in fact, the top secret,
the use of potassium dichromate was,
that's mean according to Toussaint,
I mean, using antiseptic,
potassium dichromate was in fact
the way to prepare the vaccine.
The third vaccine was on pig erycipelas.
They changed their mind in terms of preparing the vaccine
and make attenuation from rabbit to rabbit.
And of course, Pasteur was successful and got his statue.
And of course, the most known is the rabies vaccine.
Once again, there was a precursor.
It's Pierre-Victor Galtier who was the first
to vaccinate animals and protect those animals.
And a very important precursor was Pierre-Henri Dubué
because he was the one who discovered
that rabies was getting to the brain
through the nervous system.
At that time, people of the Pasteur team
were looking for the virus within the bloodstream.
And as Pierre-Henri Dubué said,
there cannot be preventive treatment
with attenuated viruses without prior culture
of rabies virus and no culture of the later
without knowledge of the tissue
or organs where the virus resides.
And indeed, you have seen that painting by Edelfeld
and this is indeed a rabbit spinal cord.
The idea came from Emile Roux.
The addition of potash to accelerate the drying process
was made by Pasteur.
In fact, they were fighting each other at that time.
You have seen those.
And this is again, the legend.
Joseph Meister, the first person to be vaccinated
and Jean-Baptiste Jupil, the second one.
The legend, Joseph Meister and Jean-Baptiste Jupil
became later on, the gatekeeper of Institut Pasteur
and Joseph Meister killed himself
when the Nazi enter in Paris.
By the way, Jean-Baptiste Jupil,
who has his statue in the gardens of Institut Pasteur
has never been attacked by a dog.
He's the one who attacked the dog.
So in fact, the reality again,
coming from the laboratory notebooks
is that in fact, the very first to be vaccinated
was this sir, Mr. Girard, who was at the Nicare Hospital.
He became very sick after the vaccine
and the hospital authority decided
to stop the vaccination process.
And finally, the guy left alive.
And the second person to be vaccinated,
and this is in the notebook of Pasteur,
is this little girl, Juliette Antoinette Pougon,
11 years old.
Unfortunately, it was too late.
She died the following day after the vaccine.
So I would like to end with two quotation of Pasteur,
science knows no border because knowledge belongs
to humanity and I think this is,
the pandemic is an example of that humanity
working together to fight the pandemic and the microbe.
He said also another statement,
science and peace will triumph over ignorance and war.
Unfortunately, it was wrong and the events in Ukraine
are just showing that unfortunately, we are not yet there.
And I'm sorry to have taken too long
and I still have a few things about,
but you can find more information
in this paper just published this year.
I thank you for your attention.
Thank you.
