Great Schism (1054)

Christianity
6 followers
Growing up in the modern world, it can be easy, particularly if you're Protestant and you grew
up in the context of North America, to neglect the reality that there is an entire wing of the church
known as the Orthodox Church. Depending on your context and depending on the world that you grew
up in, and your denominational affiliation, etc., it can be a challenge at times to have
a great deal of exposure to the Orthodox Church. I think this is symbolized, most importantly,
by the fact that so often, at the lay level, it becomes common simply to refer to the Orthodox
Church as Greek Orthodox, which is a misnomer because while there is a Greek Orthodox Church,
the Orthodox Church itself is actually quite varied, both geographically and in terms of its
language, and in terms of the patriarchy of those who are governing the church.
Another name that's often used is the Byzantine Church, which again, is a misnomer. It simply
locates the epicenter of the Orthodox Church entirely in the Byzantine lands,
out in Asia Minor, and in particular, in the former city of Constantinople,
which is the modern-day Istanbul. I often joke that if it weren't for that Seinfeld episode,
where George Costanza attempts to convert to Latvian Orthodox, that many people would be
unaware that there is a denomination or a branch of the church known as the Orthodox Church.
Well, this needs to be fixed. We need to have an awareness of the wide-ranging and significant
development within the church away from the Catholic Church that arose in the Middle Ages.
As it now stands today, the Orthodox Church is actually the second-largest single-unit church
in the entirety of the world. The Orthodox Church numbers somewhere around 250 million people.
Now, that number needs some context. There are roughly two and a half billion Christians in
the world. Somewhere in the neighborhood of 1.5 to 1.7 billion named themselves as Catholic.
There are roughly 800 million Protestants in the world today. But of course, trying to label all
the Protestantism as the same is a bit of a challenge, given that you have everything from
High Church Anglican, Lutheran, all the way down through Methodist and Presbyterian,
and all the way to the end with Anabaptists and a number of other non-denominational churches
in the world today. So, when we say that the Orthodox Church is the second-largest
single church, what we mean by that is that it's the second-largest church that self-identifies
as one body. And at 250 million people, it is a vitally important church in the world.
And it's even more important, given that so much of the Orthodox Church today
is located in regions that are quite hostile at times, at least in the modern world,
to the Christian Church itself. Well, the natural question is,
how did this church come about? How did this branch that calls itself the Orthodox Church
come to reside in a place that is different from both the Catholic Church and subsequently the
Protestant Church? Well, the answer is the Great Schism. The Great Schism of 1054.
And so, in this lecture, we're going to be looking at the Great Schism. We're going to
determine what caused it, and then look at some of the implications of this schism all the way
down until today. And we can begin with vocabulary, because there are a number of schisms throughout
the centuries, particularly in the Middle Ages, that sometimes are called the Great Schism,
or at least for the first student coming to this period of time, can feel as if they all kind of
jumble up together. When people refer to the Great Schism, very often what they have in mind
is this schism from 1054. The Great Schism is a time when the Catholic Church, the Western Church,
sundered from the Eastern Church, which would later be identified as the Orthodox Church.
Now, that is to be distinguished, obviously, from Papal Schisms, which we'll have a lecture
on in a later lecture, which unfortunately, historians sometimes call the Great Schism as
well. Now, ideally, historians will call this the Great Papal Schism and not simply the Great
Schism itself. But you have to be aware that when we're referring to the Great Schism,
we're referring to the separation of Catholic and Eastern Churches. And in our lectures on
the Crusades, we did make mention of the schism. When the Crusades got underway, the first one
in the 1090s, we mentioned that there was already a schism between East and West
that complicated the issue and made it quite tense between both the Catholic Church and the
Eastern Church. Well, now we want to double back and get a running start at just what this schism
was. There are a number of factors that led to the separation between the East and the West.
Some are political, some are theological, and some just simply have to do with the bozos that
were running the show at the time. And we're going to go through all three of these in this order.
First of all, the political issues that were in play. As we've seen throughout a number of lectures,
coming out of the Constantinian world, the Christian world saw itself politically as a
united empire. This was the heritage of Constantine. He had united East and West. He had put it under
the banner of Christ, even if we deny, though we're not going to do this, but even if we deny
that Constantine was actually a committed Christian, still the Constantinian revolution
paved the way for the ongoing Christianization of the empire. And for centuries after Constantine,
the Church saw itself as a united front. When we looked at the Byzantine world, for example,
we commented on how those who were in the Byzantine world would not have called themselves
anything but Roman, at least not in the first several centuries after Constantine comes to the
throne, if not quite a bit thereafter. And there are a number of ways that this sort of presented
itself. First and foremost was for centuries, down until roughly the eighth or ninth century,
there was this tension between the Byzantine emperor, the emperor over Constantinople,
who was at least in terms of the heritage believed by some, particularly those in the East,
to also be emperor over the West. And just as in the Byzantine world, those who are patriarchs,
the patriarch of Constantinople, the primary seat of the Byzantine Church for centuries,
and even until today, it was customary for the Eastern emperor to at least give his vote of
approval whenever someone was appointed to the chair or to the office of a patriarch or to a
primary bishop. And what many people don't realize is that for a number of years, for centuries,
the papacy actually had to be approved in name by the Eastern emperor. Now, this rarely created
much problem. At times it did, but it rarely created this real strong problem where someone
wanted to be pope or someone was elected to be pope, and the Eastern emperor simply denied this.
By and large, it was rubber stamped. But all the way until roughly the beginning of the
real serious Middle Ages, in particular, after the time of Charlemagne, it was still
considered to be appropriate for the papacy to be ratified or approved by the Eastern emperor.
But what happens over the course of the early Middle Ages and on into the high Middle Ages
is the papacy in particular is not comfortable with always answering to the Eastern emperor.
All the way back in around the 5th of the 6th century, what you see happen is the papacy
beginning to assert some of its own independence. Now, none of this is controversial in the major
sense of that word. It doesn't create massive friction or schism. There are only a number of
cases where there is actually a real tussle as to who is in charge, papacy or the East.
But it is an issue. And in fact, as we've seen, when the pope, when Leo, coronates Charlemagne
on Christmas Day 800, there is a conscientious move in the West for the papacy to coronate his
own emperor that was over the Western half of what was formerly Constantine's world.
Now, by and large, the Eastern emperor looked on this with suspicion. He knew what was afoot. He
knew that what was going on here and what would continue for some time is the disentangling of
the empire from East and West. But by and large, this was the pope's move. The West wanted to go
its own way. It wanted to have its own autonomous authority in a manner of speaking. And though the
ideal was always for East and West to be united as one Christendom, the fact of the matter is that
this was nearly impossible given the complexities of life in the Middle Ages. Not only was there a
with the East primarily speaking Greek and with the West increasingly speaking only Latin,
but there were cultural issues and issues of communication and issues of real political
authority and influence over these areas of the West. No matter how much the Eastern emperor
claimed to be over all of Christendom, it was simply impossible for him or her ever to exert
enough authority over these regions to claim them as their own. And this really comes to a head in
962 after a famous battle, the Battle of Letchfield. In this battle, some of the heirs to the
Charlemagne regions rose up and there was founded what's called the Autonian dynasty. And this is
the dynasty of Otto himself, the great emperor who would claim, just as Charlemagne had before,
the title Holy Roman Emperor. Now, when Otto comes to the throne, this title, Holy Roman Emperor,
takes on a new significance and a new depth of meaning in the self-identity of the West as its
own entity and its own Christendom apart from the Eastern world. Part of what's driving this is
simply the fact that the West wants to go its own way. But also what's driving this is the fact that
in so many of the lands out East, in Asia Minor, down in Palestine, and in North Africa, the Arab
conquest and expansion had at least severed any Christian identity or any connection between the
Christians of the West with these other regions. And so, in a number of ways, the West simply says,
that's it, there is now a Holy Roman Emperor and he is here in the West and his name is Otto.
And following on that, in 1049, Otto's successor, Henry III, has appointed to the papacy,
Leo IX, who will be Pope during the Schism. Now, in this day, of course, politics and church
government are not all that separate. They are separate in terms of theme or in terms of their
influence. But this is not a world of separation of church and state. And so, it's no surprise then
there's an analogy between the tension that is going on between the Emperor of the East and the
rise and the cementing of the legacy of the Holy Roman Empire in the government of the church
itself. A fundamental difference between the way the East understands authority in the church
and the way the West was beginning to really significantly understand the power of the papacy
really hinges again on this separation between East and West. If you were to find an Eastern
Orthodox person, either in this point in the Middle Ages, and frankly, even until today,
their model of government is not to have a single papacy or a single Pope over the entirety of
their church. This is one of the great myths that's often out there, which is that the
Patriarch of Constantinople is somehow Pope of the entire Orthodox Church. Rather, what happens
in the Eastern Church is they believe that there are principal patriarchies that are governed by
someone who is sometimes called the Pope, but who with the other patriarchs rules in a collaborative
unity with each other. Now, the legacy of this argument goes all the way back to the
Constantinople Council, the second great ecumenical council. It was at that council
where there was appointed and named five principal seats or bishops who have a preeminence within the
church. That is to be considered at least first among equals, though increasingly it became
superior to the other bishoprics in the Christendom world. At that time, it was Antioch,
Alexandria, Jerusalem, Constantinople, and Rome. Now, the two big ones here, obviously,
are Constantinople and Rome. The papacy actually at this time resisted the idea that Constantinople
would be made a de facto patriarch or de facto leading bishop that was seen to be at least
coterminous, if not equal with that of the papacy. In other words, from the Eastern perspective,
from the Orthodox perspective, the Bishop of Rome is a significant seat of power. Their perspective,
though, as the Middle Ages continued on, and again, even down until today, is that the Bishop of Rome
is one of these patriarchs. He is part of their band of brothers, even if he has first chair,
even if he has primary voice, even if he leads in some ways in a way that the others do not,
at least in terms of first among equals. In the Orthodox Church, the Bishop of Rome
is simply one of these patriarchs. In this case, he is the patriarch of the West.
Constantinople is patriarch over Constantinople and its regions, so on and so forth.
Now, that might help you understand some of where the Orthodox Church has come down to
to the modern period. Because if you look around the modern Orthodox Church,
you'll find a number of patriarchs, as they're called. For example, the Russian patriarch,
who is considered to be yet another, a new patriarch, who is the lead bishop over a given
region, in this case, Russia. Now, this is the kernel of the fight. All the theological and
historical squabbles that go on between East and West, frankly, always have at their root,
right at the core, the distinction and the division over the issue of where the Pope or
the Bishop of Rome fits in with these other patriarchs. Just about every issue, just about
every fight, seemingly comes down to the issue of, does the Pope have to answer to the will of the
body, the will of the other patriarchs? Can he be checked? Or does he have supremacy and the other
patriarchs out East need to therefore listen to the will of the Pope? And I think that's important
to realize as the real root cause of this schism. Because we're going to notice that there are a
that tend to be cited as the real cause, or at least the beginning of the cause of the schism.
The problem, though, is that many of these fights occur hundreds and hundreds of years
before the schism itself. Rather, a better way to understand this is that the root cause,
the root distinction, the root issue between East and West is the role of the Bishop of Rome
in the life of the Eastern Church and vice versa. And as we'll see repeatedly, the issue becomes
that the Pope will not succumb or bow to the will or the pressure of those who are the patriarchs
of the East. And it all comes to a head in the 11th century. So if that's the political and
the ecclesiological context, what were some of these percolating fights? Well, one we've already
looked at in our lectures on the Byzantine world, we looked at the trouble of the issue of iconoclasm.
Now let's just look at this as an example or a microcosm of this problem.
What we have is the Emperor of the East declaring, and getting the Eastern patriarchs to back his
position, that the use of images and icons in the Church is itself now to be condemned. Well,
the Church out West, led by the papacy, said, not in your life. You will not tell us to throw down
our art, our images, and our statuary that are used to make worship beautiful and that decorate
the inner sanctuaries of our churches. In the East, muscling up with the Emperor,
stress of the Church needed to follow suit out in the West, and the Church refuses to do so.
So that's one. There is another issue, though, between East and West that is frequently cited
as a massive theological problem that, again, though, has at root the issue of the authority
of the papacy. And that is the controversy over the filioque. The filioque clause, or the filioque
controversy, goes all the way back to the Council of Nicaea, though the filioque itself was not
written at this time. Those of you who have grown up in the West saying the Nicene Creed in your
churches will be accustomed to saying, under the rubric of the Holy Spirit, that the Spirit proceeds
from the Father and the Son. Now that phrase there, and the Son, in Latin is filioque. And
just so you understand this, que, the ending there, is something that is attached to just
about any word in Latin when you want to add the phrase and the. So you see the que ending there
is simply just a way of saying and the. Filio is, of course, the root of so many of our modern words
that means son. Filios is the root here. So the phrase filioque means, at the beginning, the Son,
and the ending there, and the. So in one word, you have the phrase and the Son. Well, in the
Western version of the Nicene Creed, there is this affirmation that the Spirit, the Holy Spirit,
proceeds from the Father and the Son. Well, if you were to go to an Eastern church,
an Orthodox church of any variety, you will not find the phrase and the Son expressed in the
Nicene Creed. This issue, in other words, is one of the major theological problems between East and
West. It's still debated today, and there's all kinds of spectrum of positions on this issue,
both from the Eastern Church and from the Catholic Church. Well, the issues are is that when the
Council of Nicaea met, and when Nicaea Constantinople was finished, the original Greek
version of the Creed simply said that the Spirit proceeds from the Father. So the image or the
theology that is in play here is that you have the Father as you might say the source, who is
eternally begetting the Son, and according to the original Creed, from whom proceeds the Spirit.
Now, there's all kinds of reasons why this is a problem in the West,
and we really can't go into every single one of them. First and foremost, though, is the issue
that in the West in particular, they are concerned primarily with the subject of Arianism. You'll
recall, of course, that Arianism spread quite rapidly in the West, that after it was quashed
pretty rigorously in the East, that a number of these Arians went up into the Northern European
areas, and they converted a number of the Gothic tribes to their faith. Well, if you just look at
the mental image, the mental sort of representation of the way the Creed could be misunderstood,
at least according to the way the West viewed it, is that if you have the Father at the top,
and from the Father there is proceeding the Son, being begotten from eternity past,
and from the Father only you have proceeding the Spirit, well, the West is particularly concerned
that this is just sort of a clause of Arianism, or at least it could be interpreted by Arians
to espouse their own teachings on the subject of the lack of divinity, of the creation of the Son
and the Spirit. They believe, in other words, you could draw a line and say that the Father is only
really God, and he is begetting the Son, and he is the one from whom proceeds the Spirit.
Well, sometime around the 6th century, the West began to include in the Creed this phrase,
and the Son. And people always scratched their head, why would they do this? Why would they add
this? Well, the belief was, theologically, and there are all kinds of biblical reasons why they
believe this, by the way. I'm just going to give you the historical reasons, the contextual reasons.
The biblical reasons are numerous, and I'm not going to simply make this only an issue of
historical issues. But the historical issues were that with Arianism afoot in the Western
part of the world, it made more sense to affirm that because the Father and the Son are equal,
therefore, if the Spirit is proceeding from the Father, if there is a procession of the
Holy Spirit from the Father, that it made sense also theologically to affirm that the Son,
being consubstantial with the Father, that from him also proceeds the Spirit. This is the doctrine
that is referred to as the double procession of the Spirit. But don't get lost in the jargon.
The issue here is the divinity of the Son, as well as a number of verses that people in the
West believe champion the fact that the Spirit comes from the Son. Well, as you can imagine,
the issues between the East and West are significant on this issue, because you
have essentially the West saying, we're going to change the Creed. We're going to add to it
in order to clarify the theology of the Creed in the midst of our context.
It was really only a century later, in the 7th century, in fact, that the East began to notice
this and began to criticize this vociferously. They found this to be an anathema. The only place
that a Creed can be formed or changed is in the context of a council. Well, what do you think
the West's response to this was? The West responds about this time and thereafter with the simple
proclamation that the papacy has so decreed this and therefore it is good theology because the
papacy has led the church and has ratified this by his own authority. He did not need the East
in order to allow for this. Again, you'll see the controversy is more about authority and the right
to do things between East and West than anything else. And to this day, the vast majority of the
hinges on the opinion of whether or not the West had the authority or the right
to add the filioque to the confession or the Creed from the 4th century.
Now, I can stop right now and just give you some of the modern context on this.
In the summer of 2004, I was studying in the city of Rome, studying all kinds of things like
Roman Catholicism, the Reformation, etc. And because of who I was invited to study with there,
I was actually given a ticket to attend a pretty significant event in terms of the history of the
church. I didn't know it at the time. I showed up in jeans and a t-shirt, a typical seminary student,
and I was ushered up onto the dais, believe it or not, sitting with the dignitaries across the way
from the College of Cardinals. And the event was important because this was still the regency of
John Paul II. But at this time, the Patriarch of Constantinople had come out and there had
been a number of high-level discussions as well as some important meetings between these two
patriarchs. They came out and did a service together. And there in 2004, for the first time
that I can find record of, the two of them said the Creed, the Nicene Creed together.
Only in this case, they said it in the Greek, which is probably why it went unnoticed by a
number of people. But they said it in the Greek and famously, John Paul II did not say the filioque.
And I remember asking the professors of the curriculum that I was taking part in
what the significance of this was. And I was told that they had come to some sort of an agreement
that when they are together, the Eastern Patriarch and the Pope will agree not to say the filioque.
But it was understood that when the West is doing its own liturgy by itself in the Catholic Church,
that the filioque will still remain and that this will not be a massive offense,
at least on a principle, to the Eastern Church. Now, I have no way of verifying if that's still
an effect or if that was simply the opinions of the professors who taught me. But it was
nevertheless the case that in 2004, the Eastern Patriarch, the Patriarch of Constantinople,
and the Pope, for the first time since roughly the 6th century, left the filioque off.
But you can see historically that this is the issue. The issue is the West added the filioque
and even if it's theologically and biblically justifiable, the issue becomes one of the East
feeling like the West had usurped and overly extended its own authority by altering the
creed itself. So, in the end, with these contextual issues of the church and the state,
as well as the theological underpinnings of the authority of the papacy, it's no wonder then that
this fight didn't happen earlier, frankly. Well, it didn't. It happened in the year 1054.
Now, how did it happen? Well, as you can imagine, given the tension between East and West,
there were always, again, percolating little bubble ups of fights and accusations from one
side or the other. The issue on this side, though, is that there was a man who was the
papal advisor to the Byzantine world by the name of Humbert of Silva Candida. Now, Humbert was a
well-educated man, extraordinarily well-educated. He had the ear of the Pope and he was his right-hand
man theologically. Well, it happens that Humbert was down in the area of Apulia in the Italian
peninsula in 1053 when he heard of a letter from Leo, who was Archbishop of Awkward, one of the
Eastern archbishops out in the East. And the letter had arrived in Apulia and it was written in Greek
and it condemned a number of practices in the Western church. It condemned the filioque,
of course, sort of a standard argument at this point, but it also condemned the West because it
practiced the Eucharist with unleavened bread. And Leo, the Eastern archbishop, alleges that the
West had caved to what he called a Judaistic practice of maintaining unleavened bread as part
of the Eucharistic service. Well, Humbert hears about this. He's a man who knows Greek himself
and he gets the letter, he translates it, and in a bit of a gossipy kind of way, he runs
to the Pope, Pope Leo IX, saying, look what these Easterns have said about you and what they've said
about us. Not surprisingly, the Pope was incensed and he sends a letter back. This time, he sends
it to the patriarch, Michael I, sometimes referred to as Michael Cellularius. And it all comes to a
head when Humbert and some others are sent as a delegation to the city of Constantinople in an
effort to smooth this out. Now, Humbert and others are in no mood to compromise, but not
surprisingly, Michael I was not in a position to compromise either. And really what happens in 1054
is you have two egomaniacs throwing temper tantrums at each other and as a result,
sundering the church. Humbert and his entourage arrive in 1054 and Michael, to kind of put them
in their place, refuses to see them for a number of weeks. And this is a typical move by diplomats
of all kinds, all throughout the centuries, which is if someone comes and meet with you, if you
really want to show them who's boss, you don't tell them off. Usually what you do is you make
them sit and wait. Humbert, of course, is incensed by this. He finds this to be an affront both to
his own personal dignity, as well as to the dignity of the Pope. When Michael and Humbert
do eventually meet, they eventually get into a shouting match over these issues between the East
and the West. Now, again, the issue is the authority of the papacy. It's not necessarily
with all these ticky-tack issues. Of course, it's a bit insulting to say that these are ticky-tack
issues, but the issue is if Humbert's there to assert the authority of the papacy, then Michael,
as patriarch of Constantinople, is not willing to hear it. And in the end, on Easter Sunday, 1054,
while Michael is in Hagia Sophia performing the vigil for the Easter service, Humbert marches in
and slaps a bull of excommunication down on the altar, thereby excommunicating Michael for his
insolence. As you can imagine, Michael eventually does the same thing to the entourage, to Humbert
and to others. And if you can believe it, that action, the double excommunication of each other
in 1054, was the cause of the Great Schism. Now, to clarify, no one in his time believed
that it was a de facto schism that was going to last for nearly a millennia. By and large,
most people in both the East and West would have seen this as a couple of egomaniacs
duking it out with each other. But as the centuries wore on, and as the Crusades get launched,
and as East and West come, actually at one point in the Fourth Crusade, to attacking each other,
the schism, started by two men throwing a tantrum,
eventually became a fixed reality of the separation between the East and the West.
