(Ep. 66) Your Interest Is Not Nearly as Bad as You Think | Student Loan Planner

Channeldo Credit
5 followers
1 Video View·Nov 22, 2024
If you’re overwhelmed by the idea of student loan interest raging out of control, this episode is for you. I sat down with our senior student loan consultant, Rob Bertman, CFP®, CFA to dig into the details about why student loan interest isn’t as bad as you think. Bertman has over 15 years’ experience as a financial planner and is the mastermind behind Family Budget Expert. Here’s what he has to say about how interest can impact your student loans.
Welcome to the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
I've got a special treat for you today.
I have our senior consultant, Rob Burtman, CFP, CFA,
joining me to answer reader questions today,
or listener questions, rather,
and also just to talk about some weird stuff
about student loan interest
and how everybody thinks it's way worse than it actually is,
when it's really not nearly as bad as you think it is.
So Rob, thanks for joining us on the show today.
Yeah, thanks for having me.
I feel like I have to defend my age
because every podcast you put out,
it seems like you make a little jab at that I'm 40.
So Rob did just turn 40, and I just turned 30.
So Rob is the resident grandfather of Student Loan Planner
at the ripe old age of 40.
That is very true.
Whenever we think about kind of hiring somebody,
they've got to be younger than Rob,
or else Rob gets displaced in the age stack ranking.
Right, this is definitely not an ageist organization.
No, no, definitely not.
I think it's just, you know, the boomers,
you know, they just don't understand the struggle, right?
They don't understand the student loan, you know,
you know, my student loans, I had 1% interest,
and I easily paid back my $5,000 of student loans
working at Jiffy Lube on Fridays, you know?
Why can't the kids do it now?
It's like, oh man, I don't know,
maybe because vet school costs $300,000
instead of $3,000, Mr. 1960s.
Exactly.
And the Gen Xers, I mean, they didn't get it off easy,
but they still didn't get smacked
as nearly as bad as the millennials, right?
Oh, for sure, no question there.
But I'm glad that we have a variety of age experience,
right, so we do have a wide, multi-decade stretch
of the youngest consultants and writers to the oldest.
So I will defend our age distribution on the team,
at least for that.
So the first thing I wanted to do
just to kick it off for this week
is we have actually four listener questions
on our voicemail, which is a good amount.
So if you, listener, wanted to submit your own question,
just go to studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
It's really super easy.
You just type that into your browser,
and then it's gonna take you to this really simple screen
that you just press the record button on your phone,
and then just speak your question into the phone,
or just like you're maybe having a telephone call
with somebody, like you're leaving a voicemail.
Like literally, it's that easy.
And then ask your question, because it's really fun.
It gives us a lot of fun stuff to talk about.
So the link for that, again,
studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
So the first question we have is from Douglas,
who wants to know if he can delay his tax filing this year.
Let's listen.
Hi, Travis.
This is Douglas calling from New York City.
It's the tax season, so I thought I'd ask a question
that would be really helpful for me,
and I imagine many others about taxes and student loans.
Specifically, I was wondering if you could tell me
what you thought about a strategy that you mentioned
several months ago on the blog,
which is basically I want to take advantage
of my lower income from a previous tax filing.
So you'd mentioned that with taxes,
you're allowed to defer or to delay tax filing
up until October.
As many of us know, the income certification
is required to be submitted, I think, as early as August.
So therefore, if you had a previously low income
in, say, 2018, you could, by this measure,
continue to pay on that low income,
so to get your payment with IBR down even lower.
You could continue to do that for an additional year
if you were to delay tax filing until October.
So I think you had mentioned that there was some
controversy on that method or on that loophole
that you'd encountered in speaking
with some of your colleagues.
But specifically, I wanted to, controversy meaning
whether or not it was legal or some kind of fraud.
But I was specifically wanting to know
if you thought that it was risky at all,
if there was any risk that it would pose
for someone who's planning to do
public service loan forgiveness.
Would there be any risk at the end of the 10 years,
especially if you're starting off those 10 years,
to pursue a strategy like this that would save you
a lot in, or let's say a considerable amount
in that payment for just one year?
Very curious to hear your thoughts, Travis.
Thanks so much for all that you do.
This is not the first time we've heard this question.
Basically, Douglas is saying you can file an extension,
and you can extend when you file your income taxes
up to, I think it's October of a given calendar year.
So in other words, if I'm in the year 2020
and I wanna extend when I file my taxes,
I can file an extension, and instead of filing in April
with a regular tax day deadline, I can extend that
up until the point where it's like October.
Yeah, it's like October 15th, yep.
Right, so Rob, kinda walk me through,
walk our listeners through why somebody
would be interested in this in the first place.
Well, first of all, a lot of people file extensions
if they have really, really complicated tax situations,
or maybe they have a tax form that someone
hasn't gotten to them yet, so they literally
cannot make the deadline of April 15th.
And so what they do is, actually the tax preparer
has to prepare their taxes, and if they owe any taxes,
they actually have to pay those estimated taxes,
even though they're not actually gonna file until October.
So they have to file for an extension.
If they're gonna owe any money,
they still have to pay that money,
but then they can delay the actual filing
of their tax return until October.
So where this could be interesting
for people with student loans is that
if you use your tax return as proof of income,
which most people should do as long as their income
keeps going up every year, that they could actually,
let's just say their recertification date is in June,
like Douglas said, and rather than using
their prior year tax return, they actually get to use
two years ago tax return.
So if it's a resident who became an attending physician,
they can actually delay paying based upon
their attending physician salary for like an extra year,
which could really, really save a bunch of money
on student loans.
So the question for you, Travis, is is that a good idea?
So I don't think it flies.
Here's why.
So I think that the servicers are starting
to get a little wise to these sort of tactics.
So we've seen an increase in the number of letters
that have been mailed out recently
that have basically said people have literally submitted
their tax returns and they've given lower incomes
or something kind of unusual, right?
And then the servicer sends out a letter saying
we want additional information,
like we want additional proof of income,
which never used to happen before.
But some servicers are asking for this.
And so we've told people, in a lot of cases,
just respond again with your tax return.
Try not to give them the pay stubs
unless they literally force you to give pay stubs.
So I think that this is an example of something
where we're all for people optimizing,
but we don't want people to over optimize, right?
So I think that this is something that I would consider
to be over optimizing, where it could be something
that could kind of get you flagged
or get more attention drawn to your account,
and we would not recommend it.
That would be my thought.
Totally agree.
Next, we have a question from Giancarlo,
who's a CFP from Puerto Rico.
Hi, Travis.
First of all, I want to congratulate you on your podcast.
I find it super helpful.
The reason I'm reaching out to you is I am CFP
from Puerto Rico, and I was recently reached out
by one of PR's medical to go talk to their students
on their student loans.
And as you well know, there's a lot of misinformation
on this topic out there.
I'm going to be having the opportunity to have them
for 45 minutes to an hour.
I want to make sure that I cover
the most important information with them.
I'm going to be talking to a fourth year students
in a couple of days.
I was hoping that maybe you could shed some light,
maybe some recommendations or some talking points
that you might find more useful
or more important that I should be discussing
with these students.
Let me know if you can help me in any way.
Anything will be very much appreciated.
Thank you.
Okay, this is an interesting one, Rob.
First of all, I'm flattered that we have people
listening to the show in Puerto Rico.
I got a thanks from a reader recently
because we listed one of the Puerto Rico universities
as being on our cheapest list for one particular program.
I think sometimes people forget about Puerto Rico
because it doesn't have official statehood, right?
So in terms of some of the Puerto Rico universities,
I actually see them being a lot cheaper
than a lot of the American schools
for people that are residents of Puerto Rico.
So my guess would be that you would probably come out
with a lot less student loan debt
from med school in Puerto Rico,
which would be my first instinct.
But the same rules for PSLF for physicians
apply to every US state and territory, right?
So I guess let's pretend for a moment
that we've got a Puerto Rico med school grad
with 150,000 of student loan debt, Rob.
What would you tell somebody like that to do?
Yeah, it's a good question.
I mean, obviously, residency is a great time
to be on income-driven repayment
because even though they might have the long-term capacity
to pay off their student loans,
on a resident salary, it's not as easy
with six-figure student debt.
So I wanna talk about how to handle
student debt and residency,
whether it's doing something like repay
with the interest subsidy,
and then possibly refinance when they become an attending
or maybe going for PSL, unless you're PSLF eligible.
Obviously, that's one of the things
we wanna make sure that they preserve
in case they wanna go that path.
So definitely, residency repayment
would be a big thing I'd put on.
I'm sure you have some other thoughts too.
Yeah, so first of all, when you graduate medical school,
immediately consolidate your student loans, right?
There's really no downside.
And make sure that you include absolutely everything
that you possibly can in that consolidation.
So any health professions loans, any Perkins loans,
basically anything you can think of,
try to consolidate it and put it all together
because you probably don't have credit already
towards forgiveness.
So first do that, and you know your payment
for the first year is gonna be $0 a month
if you use your prior year tax return
showing no earnings, right?
So I would say for that person
who wants to make as much money as possible eventually
and pay off all their loans,
sign up for that revised pay as you earn program, right?
So that's why I would be telling anybody
who's a physician who thinks
they're gonna pay off everything,
do the repay plan because you're gonna get interest subsidies
at least for the first couple of years,
probably the entire time you're in residency,
and it's probably gonna be a better interest rate
than if you had refinanced.
And it gives you flexibility
just in case you don't need to pay it off at some point.
So that would be the advice I'd give.
And then also, if you're sure you have your heart set
on working at a not-for-profit or an academic place,
then I tend to suggest people to do pay as you earn
because then you can stay on that same repayment plan
without having to change plans.
If you get married,
you can file taxes separately, jointly.
There's no complications there,
and your payment can be capped.
And my guess is coming out
of a lower-cost Puerto Rico institution,
you probably would hit that standard tenure cap more easily.
Rob, I have to admit,
I've seen some weird stuff,
incomes for medical professionals in Puerto Rico.
I don't know if you've ever heard of this,
but I had somebody once that was doing teleradiology,
and he had moved his whole family to Puerto Rico,
and he was making like 400-something grand a year,
and I think he wasn't even paying income tax, maybe.
Maybe I'm making this up,
but I feel like there's some sort of loophole
with Puerto Rico where you don't have to pay income tax
on a lot of your income or something.
I don't know.
Yeah, it's a good question.
I mean, there's this teleradiology thing
where you don't have to be physically in the hospital
to review the charts and everything.
You could actually just be anywhere.
So it's one of the easier specialties
to do that telemedicine idea.
But I don't know about the tax implications
of Puerto Rico being a U.S. territory versus a state.
I'm not sure about that.
Probably the residents of Puerto Rico,
I would just guess,
are underserved in terms of the number
of physicians per population, right?
So if anything, the PSLF program
should probably be rewarding people
and paying off their loans
that just stay in lower-served places
like Puerto Rico or rural America or something like that,
regardless of what your not-for-profit status is.
Do you know what I mean?
For sure.
I mean, at the end of the day,
I'm thinking about a place like UPMC,
Pittsburgh's medical center.
I read that they recently got hit with a lawsuit
because the town's basically saying
this is a for-profit hospital
that just happens to be called a not-for-profit, right?
And you could certainly say that I think overall
there's tons of doctors in that area
that's not an underserved place.
So your family doctor in Puerto Rico
that's maybe making, I would guess,
a lower income than the U.S. mainland,
so maybe say like $100,000 a year,
that person's not getting subsidized,
but we're subsidizing brain surgeons in Boston.
So I think that that's why the PSLF program
is going to change,
just because it probably doesn't make financial sense
to set it up the way that it has.
You probably want either just mass forgiveness in general
and have higher income taxes to pay for it,
or you'd want more of a targeted plan
that makes more rational sense
for what the biggest underserved areas are in society.
I don't know.
I mean, that's probably a whole nother podcast,
but it's certainly a really interesting question.
So the next one comes from Joe,
who has a question about what to do when he graduates.
Hey guys, love the show.
My question is something that I haven't really been able
to find anything about online.
I think it'll probably be applicable
to most of your audience,
at least the ones that are graduating shortly.
And it's going to be about beginning
an income-based repayment plan after graduation,
and I guess possibly finding a loophole.
I'll be graduating this May,
then taking a month or two off,
starting a job making about $100,000 a year
in the middle of 2020.
The way I understand it, if I do nothing,
I'll have about a six month grace period
and then have to apply for an income-based plan
started in 2021,
using my 2020 adjusted gross income of 50,000,
which is just the half year of my salary.
So I guess my question is,
is it wise and is it possible to apply
for an income-based plan as soon as I graduate
and then start making monthly payments
based on a AGI of nearly nothing while I was in school?
Is it possible to even do this?
And is it wise?
If it is possible,
is it something that I would have to consolidate
right after I graduate in order to do?
And would I need a tax return on file for 2019
to prove that my adjusted gross income for 2019
was nearly nothing?
Thanks, guys, love the show.
So this seems like to me is like,
do I do the grace period or do I consolidate
and what are the benefits of that?
Rob, maybe you can talk to that for a little bit.
Yeah, in general, right after graduating,
income is never gonna be lower,
hopefully, than it ever will be 20 years from now
or 25 years from now.
So when we talk about starting student loan payments
as quickly as possible after graduating,
it's usually a good idea to do that
because 20 years from now,
you're gonna be hopefully in your peak earning
stage of your life
and so your payments are gonna be higher.
So any months of payments or any years of payments
that you can get early on is gonna save you dollars
because if you don't pay at a lower payment now
after graduating,
then you're gonna be paying that higher payment at the end.
So yeah, consolidating and waiving the grace period,
similar to what we just talked about
with resident positions is a great idea.
Consolidate all the loans, waive the grace period,
you can choose your repayment plan,
get going on a zero payment
if you're between graduation and your job.
That way your first year is zero payments.
That could save a bunch of money paying back student loans.
To describe it more specifically,
he said he'd have a 50K AGI in 2020,
but what we usually would see
and then he's gonna have 100K AGI year after.
So what we would usually see somebody
who doesn't get any kind of advice or do any reading
or doesn't listen to a podcast like this,
what they'll do is they'll just do nothing, right?
Because that's the default is if you have to do something,
the most people are probably gonna do nothing.
So let's say that he does nothing.
Okay, so he waits until like December, January
to actually start his income driven repayment
and what's gonna happen is his servicer
is gonna ask for proof of income.
Well, he doesn't have his tax return
for 2020 yet, he has it for 2019.
Maybe he didn't have that at all
because he didn't file a tax return, right?
Then he's gonna submit his pay stubs.
Well, he submits his pay stubs,
that payment is gonna be $800 a month,
seven or $800 a month.
And instead, if he consolidates immediately
after he graduates and he has a 2019 tax return
that shows a $0 income on it,
which is totally legal by the way,
that you submit that tax return as proof of income
and then basically you have a $0 monthly payment
and then you can consolidate and get payments started
basically two months after graduation,
whereas if you wait for the grace period
at six months after graduation.
So you get four months of free forgiveness payments
because it's $0 a month, right?
So you get those four months of extra credit,
you can call it, and that extra credit,
those four months are coming off of the end,
like you said, right?
Like the 20 to 25 years,
your payment and income's gonna be way higher.
So that four months of credit comes up at the end,
whether that's 10 years from now with PSLF
or 20 something years from now with IDR forgiveness.
So that's gonna cost you
probably thousands of dollars per month.
So that's four times that, four months of saving that amount.
And then on top of that,
you also get your $0 a month payment
instead of making a mistake submitting a pay stub
and then getting an $800 a month payment.
And that mistake would last from like,
I guess, December 2020 to December 2021
versus your payment's probably gonna be zero
and then you're gonna have your 2020 tax return submitted,
which would show a 50K income.
So that payment would be like $300, right?
So that just simple example would be probably a cost of,
I would guess around probably about $10,000.
And that's not even taking into account interest subsidies.
If he happened to need to pay the loan off,
you know, like repay,
he could have gotten half of his interest covered
instead of less of it covered with the higher payment,
you know?
So that's pretty staggering, right?
It's like basically this guy could literally lose $10,000
in the first year just by submitting his paperwork
and using the wrong strategy for his loans right off the bat.
That's pretty intense to me.
Yeah, no question.
And plus just starting out,
there's a lot of expenses and if someone's moving
or someone's trying to get their job
or get their savings started,
it's much better to have $0 payments for the first 12 months
than to have $800 payments starting six months from now.
Then like you said, the savings tacked on on the end.
So it really helps someone in his situation get situated,
get moved, you know, start the job
and not feel like they have the financial pressure
to make $800 or $500 student loan payments right off the bat.
So all around a really, really solid strategy.
And so just for those listening, right?
Again, this is why you consolidate
immediately after you graduate.
You go to studentaid.gov, you click consolidate my loans,
you throw everything into it that you possibly can.
You know, you send it to Great Lakes
if you're not doing PSLF or you send it to FedLoan
if you are doing PSLF
and then you select the right repayment plan
and you make sure you use, you know, a tax return
that's from the prior year that shows lower income, right?
You do all this right, that's the blueprint you follow.
And if you do that, you could literally save
four or five figures really easily in the first year
or alternatively, you know,
that's one reason why people hire us, right?
I mean, if you kind of think about it,
like, you know, you pay a few hundred bucks
to make sure something is done right
or you kind of gamble that it's done right
and if you're kind of uncertain,
then you probably just hire somebody.
So studentloanplanner.com slash help
basically, you know, Rob, we tend to get kind of booked up
around like May, June timeframe
because everybody's graduating.
It gets super busy.
So this is, you know, we're in March when this episode airs.
So, you know, I mean, it's not a bad idea
if you're graduating,
you know you want to get this done right,
probably book for within a week after you graduate
and sort of anticipate that.
I think you can book like 60 days in advance.
So try to probably get that reserved
if you want your choice of times
because it's really easy to mess this up
and it's really easy to get it right
and save a lot of money if you know what you're doing.
If it's a $10,000 decision, it's worth it.
Well, it's more than that
because the long-term strategy, I would argue,
is even more important than that.
Oh, no question.
Yeah, because I mean, you can look at the projected savings
by profession and a lot of them are in the mid five figures
and that's just because, you know,
somebody doesn't know that they live
in a community property state, right?
Like you've got a Wisconsin person that's Packers fan
that doesn't know that Wisconsin's the only state
in the Midwest that has community property laws, you know,
and then that has implications for paying less
on your student loans, right?
And then, so I'm trying to come up with a good name
for this repay pay filing separate loophole,
but it's like the fighting spouses loopholes,
the name I like.
I don't know if you have a better one.
If both spouses are pursuing PSLF,
that's a loophole that you could almost certainly miss
if you didn't, you know, have a lot of expertise in this.
Isn't it funny how like the more you do this, Rob,
like the more complicated it seems like it becomes?
Oh man, yeah.
And big shout out to Megan too,
one of our New York consultants.
I mean, she's really hitting the ground running
and coming up and helping us develop
some of these more advanced student loan strategies,
putting our heads together,
and it's just wonderful to have her on the team.
Yeah, and everybody contributes in their own way.
Like, you know, Ben is super helpful as the CPA,
one of our other new consultants, you know,
but the problem is he's so busy with tax season right now.
It's kind of funny, right?
Because like anybody who has that CPA combo,
it's like, hey, I'm gonna be super available
after April 15th, like whatever.
But yeah, I mean, like it's just so helpful
to have a team approach
because people probably don't know this,
but you know, we have consultant meetings
probably every couple of weeks or something like that
just to talk through all the complex cases.
We've seen all the new changes to servicer information,
like complaints that we're seeing with people that,
you know, weird stuff that they're getting in the mail.
We just do that to try to be, you know,
the cutting edge basically, right?
It's just something that we try to make sure
that we're really on top of.
So we got one more question.
This is about CBO report that recently came out.
So let's listen to this one now.
Hi, Travis.
I'm sure you saw the CBO report
that came out this past week
that showed over the next 10 years,
there'll be $200 billion
in federal student loan forgiveness
and 81% of that forgiveness will go
to graduate and professional students.
And I was curious your thoughts on that.
And if you notice the fact that the report
did not analyze taxable forgiveness
at the end of the 20 to 25 years pay or free pay.
So thoughts on that?
And yes, that is my baby in the background.
The CBO report is really interesting.
This is something that was put out
at the request of two Republican senators,
Senator Alexander on the higher education committee
in the Senate.
I think it's called the HELP committee,
health, education, labor and pensions.
So he's the person that would be in charge
of writing the student loan reform for the Senate,
at least right now, but he's retiring.
And he really, really, really wanted to have a legacy
of rewriting the student loan rules for the next 10 years
before he retired in 2020.
That's not gonna happen now,
probably because nobody wants to compromise
until the election is over, right?
So he kind of got this parting shot in
for this request for CBO report.
And I forget the other guy who did it.
I think he's like the Wyoming Senator.
I wanna say Enzi off the top of my head for some reason,
but basically he also requested this bill.
I forget his position in the Senate
as to how it was really specific to student loans,
but he really wanted to see this too.
If you think about Wyoming, right?
It's a place that has a very low proportion
of six-figure borrowers,
people that probably don't like the idea
of lavishing a lot of money on higher education
that's mostly spent on coastal,
high urban concentration areas, right?
So I think that's the background
of why this report was commissioned.
But the CBO is a nonpartisan organization
and it's staffed with a bunch of really smart economists
that do try to do their best guess
and their best job of forecasting
what the cost of federal programs will be.
But oftentimes it can be super wrong too.
The report, I've read it actually,
it's like fairly long,
but it's really interesting
to look at the different scenarios
that they modeled for Congress.
So they actually said that they expect about 81%
of all student loan forgiveness
to go to graduate and professional students
over the next 10 years,
which is really pretty interesting.
Rob and I think this kind of aligns
with what we know and what we think.
So they're basically saying about 160 billion of forgiveness
is gonna go to people with graduate and professional degrees
and about 40 billion or so
is gonna go to people with undergrad degrees.
And that makes sense
because undergrad degrees have capped limits.
You cannot borrow more than 30 to $50,000 period.
And most people, 10% of a 50K income over 20 years
is gonna pay that off in full.
So you're not gonna get a whole lot forgiven.
Meanwhile, you have all these graduate degrees
where you can take out
an unlimited amount of money for grad school
and that's gonna result in a lot of people
that owe way more than their income
and they're gonna have a lot
that's gonna be forgiven because of that.
And same thing with PSLF
where if you have a 30 to 50K balance,
10% of a 50K income or something like that
is gonna pay off a lot of it
before you even get anything forgiven.
Whereas with a graduate degree,
you have a lot more potentially that could be forgiven.
So it doesn't really make me that shocked about the ratio.
So first off, let me just see what your thoughts are
on that split of forgiveness.
Do you foresee that 80% of forgiveness
going to graduate students being a realistic number?
Yeah, well, first I just wanna give a shout out
to our caller who is reading the CBO report
while managing a young child, which is pretty awesome.
I have three kids of my own,
so I know how hard it is to read through financial stuff
while having a baby on my lap
or trying to feed them or whatever.
So kudos to you.
But no, I'm not at all shocked.
In fact, I'm shocked the percentage isn't higher
for the reasons that you said.
I mean, there are a lot of graduate level professions.
There are only maybe a few exceptions
like maybe dentists or specialty physicians
that really might have the capacity to pay off their debt.
So right, for example, so anyone who has
basically more than twice their income in student loans,
income driven repayment is gonna be
like a really, really great option for them.
And most of those people are graduate level professions.
And a lot of graduate programs,
they provide a higher income potentially,
but a lot of them don't provide enough of a higher income
to compensate for the multiple of student debt
that they've had to take out.
And typically in order to get the forgiveness,
you have to be in an income driven repayment plan.
And so a lot of people,
a lot of graduate level professionals who,
they can't go on the graduated or extended
or standard plans or anything like that
because they couldn't afford the payments.
So they're forced to go on income driven repayment
where maybe someone with like the undergrad
and capped borrowing and a lower debt to income ratio,
they can afford those payments.
So they just end up paying off the loans in full anyway,
whether they're on those plans
or if they're on income driven repayment.
So I'm surprised the number is not higher.
The percentage isn't higher to be honest.
Another thing that kind of bothered me with this report
is apparently there's this law that requires them
to estimate the value of all the forgiveness
using like basically I think the treasury bond
or something like that.
So in other words, you have to discount
all of these cash flows with like a super low,
super low risk rate that you're looking at.
And so what they came up with was the subsidy
for student loans over like 10 years or something like that
was only gonna be like $11 billion
or something like super, super low, right?
And that was including basically them theorizing
that they would make a bunch of money
on the fixed payment plan options.
So in other words, they kind of assumed
that a lot of people would pay back their loans
over 10 years and they would make a bunch
of interest income on it
because they're comparing it to what the treasury bond is.
So like, oh, we're gonna make all this money.
And then the kind of really interesting thing
is like you cannot discount a student loan
at the rate of a treasury bond
because a student loan is an unsecured debt
made to an individual
with probably an average credit score of like 600.
I mean, this is a very risky-
A risky loan.
You know, loan.
And so they made a point of that in the CBO report
and they said that, well, what is the subsidy?
Well, it depends on what your belief is
as to what people would have to pay to borrow
in the private market.
Like basically they said,
so the subsidy is something between 11 billion
and 263 billion.
Oh, man.
And they said the subsidy is 263 billion
if you use what people would need to borrow at the market,
you know, reasonable estimate.
And they assumed that they would earn $72 billion
of interest income from the fixed payment plans.
But then when they used like a normal rate of interest,
like for the market to measure the subsidies,
then they lost $51 billion of interest.
So this is really kind of like when you read these reports
and you really read the details,
it's kind of like a joke, really.
I mean, and the people who are doing the modeling
are doing a good job.
But this is why the system is so complicated
and so screwed up,
is because you've got all these requirements
that they measure the costs
according to some stupid formula
that makes no sense in the real world.
And then, you know, you look at the costs,
you know, using a market kind of interest rate,
what the real subsidy is,
and that's, you know, a lot more expensive.
So just to use an example,
a lot of people I know think that the student loan
interest rate is too high on student loans,
and maybe it is.
But if you charge 1.5% on student loans,
then the subsidy that America provides
to student loan borrowers is essentially the difference
between what a private lender would issue the debt at
and what the government is charging.
So let's say that you're issuing debt at 1.5%,
and the market would make that loan at, say, 7.5%.
So then you're giving a subsidy to borrowers that spread.
So 6% difference on the total amount
of student loans issued per year.
Let's say there's 100 billion
of student loans issued per year.
And, you know, that includes student loan borrowers,
but the taxpayer is providing a subsidy
of $6 billion per year, in that case,
in the form of interest subsidies.
So, you know, I mean, it's really kind of nuts.
One thing that I did kind of think was sort of interesting,
they assumed that the pay-as-you-earn plan
would result in the largest amount of subsidies.
So that kind of aligns with our advice.
I was excited to see that,
because they know that, you know,
you can pay for a shorter period of time, and that counts.
One thing that was not in the CBO report
was talking about the benefits
of filing your taxes separately.
We know that that's a huge source of savings for people
that caused them to pay way, way less
than they would otherwise pay.
And that was not really being modeled all that well.
I thought that was kind of interesting.
It just goes to show
that there's no way to figure this out,
because we have some of the smartest people in the room,
economic forecasters,
but even when we're doing individual student loan consults,
I mean, you think about where someone is,
let's just say they're 10 years into their career.
Chances are, 10 years ago,
they didn't know what they'd be earning
or that they'd be where they are today.
That changes things drastically
when talking about calculating income-driven repayment
and forgiveness and subsidies.
And just the fact that, I mean,
the most compelling thing that you said
is that the subsidies either are 11 billion
or what did you say, 296 billion?
So that's like-
Yeah, it's a big difference.
It's either X or like 30X, you know?
Yeah.
It's kind of a ridiculous assumption.
I don't know.
So here was the most ridiculous assumption of all.
This was the most ridiculous,
like the thing that just made me fall out of my chair
that I was like,
this is one of the dumbest things
I've ever seen in my life.
So they assumed that for PLUS loans,
so Grad PLUS loans made to graduate school level borrowers,
so people in dentistry, medicine,
law school, things like that.
So they assumed that the government
would earn a 40% margin
on all of the fixed payment plan loan amounts
that were lent under the Grad PLUS program,
which has gotta be the stupidest, worst thing,
assumption in student loans to ever model in history
because they're assuming
that all these graduate school folks
are gonna pay back their PLUS loan at 7%
for the full length of the term.
And guess what?
That's not happening.
That ain't happening.
You're gonna refinance it, you know,
because grad school people are smart
and you're either gonna go for forgiveness
or you're gonna refinance it
and cut your 7% down to 3.5% or 4%.
You're gonna pay it back with a private lender
that gives you a better deal.
And yet their model that they forecasted the subsidies under
and they put this into the model
for their estimate of, you know, whatever,
the 11 billion or 260 billion of subsidies
that they're gonna give borrowers,
they put this into their model
even under that 260 billion subsidy number
that you're gonna get billions of interest income
from all these graduate school people
that are too stupid to apply to refinance their loans,
which is just not gonna happen.
So, I mean, I really think that if you look through this,
the subsidies are even higher than their modeling, really.
Like the true market value of subsidies
is probably instead of 260 billion, you know,
it's probably in the neighborhood
of probably like 400 billion
on a trillion dollars of issued loans.
So I mean, it is enormously high.
And yes, most of this was going to go
to graduate school borrowers,
but that's just because you don't look at the fact
that undergrad borrowers had their loans capped.
And so the people that we see
the carnage stories for undergrads
is parents who take out unlimited borrowing
because the parents take out the unlimited borrowing
because they don't have any caps.
And so the parents are the ones that get screwed over
for people that borrow too much for undergrad.
But it's just, it was really interesting study.
And the thing that he mentioned also,
the last point is just that they did not talk
about the tax bomb anywhere in this forecast at all.
And so they said that if you measure all of the tax income
that the government would get back
when people have their student loans forgiven,
they said that would significantly reduce
the subsidies that we're modeling.
So I thought that was interesting
that they basically just said,
like even Congress's own budget forecaster is,
yeah, like we're not so sure
that you're actually gonna get
all this tax income from this.
They even know that you're not gonna get all these people
with $5,000 in the checking account
to pay back a lot of tax and student loans, right?
Most graduate student professionals, unfortunately,
have all their money in their businesses,
their practice owners, their house and their retirement.
And that's pretty much it.
That's your typical graduate professional.
You do not have 100,000 sitting around in cash
that you're gonna be able to pay the IRS with.
It just doesn't exist for your average person.
So I think that that was the most interesting part
of the CBO study for me,
the fact that they just threw their hands up basically.
They're like, you know what, tax bomb?
Yeah, we don't know how to model it.
You know, I mean, holy cow.
I mean, the good news is,
we're getting into the weeds a little bit here
in terms of like the technical,
but as it applies to those of you,
if you're listening and you have student debt,
here's the good news.
The good news is that they're modeling
that there's gonna be some sort of forgiveness
there for you.
They're modeling that this income-driven repayment
is going to be working.
That's a good sign,
because if you hear some of the talking heads out there,
they're saying,
everyone's still kind of latching onto this headline
about only 1% of people who applied for PSLF
got loan forgiveness so the program doesn't work,
which is not true.
And this shows that it's starting, it's going to happen.
So one more little anecdotal story.
I mean, this is kind of like a,
I hope it's not too scatterbrained of a podcast for people,
but this is a really interesting one.
So I had this person from a vet school
just eviscerate me on the blog the other day.
So I want to talk more about student loan interest.
And student loan interest is bad,
but it's not as bad as you think it is.
And if you look at that,
this person on our blog basically attacked me
because I told one of this prospective student
for their school that I thought a back of the napkin
estimate of how much debt they were gonna leave with
was about $350,000, right?
And then I said, 200,000 if you're in state.
And so this person posted a comment.
They were so angry.
I mean, so angry.
This is like a recruitment director for this vet school.
And they were just saying like,
you have no experience in the real world.
How about you talk to somebody
that actually works at these schools?
I just had a talk with somebody from our class of 2019
who's already planning on paying off
her full student loan balance of 100,000 by 2029.
And so I was like, okay.
So I went on their website
and literally, I can't make this stuff up.
I literally, they list on their website
total cost for residents of the state.
And it was like 50K per year for four years.
So it was 200.
And then total cost for non-residents was like 85K or so.
So if you summed up that number,
it literally, I just guessed, by the way,
like my 350,000 projected debt was a guess.
And it literally summed up at 352,000.
And I was like, bam, your own freaking website says this.
I'd like to be charitable,
but like I posted that link
and the person was like, people get assistance.
Like they get financial assistance
to pay for all their expenses.
And that's just not representative at all
of what people actually have.
And I felt like responding,
like I didn't wanna be a jerk,
but like I felt like responding.
So are you just like a freaking idiot or something?
Are you literally not capable of doing basic arithmetic
or does your school pay you a bonus
every time you sign somebody up
and lie to them about how much debt they're gonna have?
I mean, that's what I wanted to say.
I didn't say it exactly that way.
Because I truly believe that a lot of people
are just ignorant.
I think it's just one of those things where like,
they mean well, they're not bad people,
but they're just literally clueless.
I think that's like the majority of the people
that tell all these students and prospective students
things about their debt and what it's gonna be.
And just don't really understand like the details
because they just haven't looked into it deeply.
I don't know if you have any thoughts about that.
In my advanced age of 40, I usually look at,
I've learned to not look at what people say,
but the meaning behind what they say.
And yes, this person is probably clueless,
but they're also probably clouded.
They probably love their school
and they see the students coming in
and that they're very excited to become veterinarians
and that this is gonna cause people
not to pursue their passion because of this.
And so it's probably just a prideful person
who loves their school,
which there's nothing wrong with that,
but tact is everything and facts are everything, right?
So the bottom line is you are right
and he just doesn't have the numbers.
She's just like so excited about the school probably.
But we do need to answer this because I get this a lot too.
I mean, the difference between accrued interest
and how student loan interest works
versus most other kinds of debt
is really, really incredibly fascinating.
It makes a huge difference
on the projections for loan repayment.
So what's interesting is the interest actually is really bad
in the early part of your loan
and then it's really, really, really not bad at all
in the later stages of your loan.
Just like, and as an example of this,
so this person that I said was gonna leave
with 350,000 in student loan debt,
they're actually gonna leave with about 450,000.
And the reason for that is because yes,
you have like six or 7% interest loans
that are accumulating interest while you're in school.
You've got, if you're borrowing like 80,000 a year,
you're gonna have whatever, like 6,000 a year of interest
and then for the first year that you borrow,
you're gonna have four years worth of that.
And then you also have your loan fees,
which are 4% for a plus loan approximately.
So that's an additional couple thousand dollars every year.
And then you know the school's gonna raise costs too
that you're gonna have to borrow for,
when they raise the tuition and everything.
And so you tack on all that accrued interest
and then the 350K like stated amount
that the cost of attendance sheet says
is actually gonna be higher by about 25% more
than what that figure was, right?
You're gonna leave with $450,000 of debt
because that's about 25% more
than what the stated cost of attendance is.
But so now let's assume that, you know,
you have that $450,000 of debt.
So for the first couple of years,
the difference between simple and compound interest
is really not all that great.
I mean, walk me through that a little bit,
why simple versus compound interest
really does look the same mostly for the first five years.
Right, so just, I guess,
talking through the mechanics of it.
So what compound interest is,
is that every year that a loan grows
or like an investment grows,
the interest in the growth of what happened every year,
that then also gets growth too.
So let's just say someone has $100,000 at 7%
and they don't make any payments
and after a year, the loan grows to 107.
Well, then that 107 in a compound interest situation,
that whole 107 gets charged an extra 7% interest.
So it's not another $7,000,
it's another $7,000 and change on top of that.
And so what happens with compound interest
is over time, you know, the exponential growth curve
where it kind of like goes off
into infinity straight up eventually,
that's what happens with compound interest.
But with accrued interest and simple interest,
the way that I like to describe it is
you take the interest rate.
So let's just say that their interest rate is 7%
on $450,000 of debt.
So you'll take that 7%, charge it on the loan
and then whatever the payments don't cover,
it picks up that interest
and drops it in a separate bucket.
And that separate bucket of accrued interest stays stagnant.
It doesn't get charged the interest again.
So then what happens is the 7%,
the following year goes back on to the 450,000 again,
minus payments and then that gets picked up
and put in that separate bucket and it gets
and stays stagnant.
So the bucket doesn't grow,
but the principal is where the interest is charged on.
But in the first couple of years, 7% is 7%.
So let me see, what's 7% of 450,000?
It's a lot, 30,000 or something like that.
Yeah, so in the first year,
whether it's simple or compound interest,
there's gonna be $30,000 of interest charged on the loan.
The difference with simple interest is that even in year 20,
it's gonna be $30,000 of interest charged on the loan.
But in the case where it's a,
in fact, I can do this real quick.
In the case where it's compound interest,
the final year interest, instead of being that,
it's actually gonna be like $113,000 of interest in one year
with compound interest, as opposed to the 30,000,
it'll be like four times that amount.
But in the first year, it's identical.
Yeah, so think about, I don't wanna turn people off,
but think about your Algebra II class.
Think about your TI-84.
You remember that?
I don't know, is that past your time, Rob,
or did you use TI-84s too?
I had 82.
82?
Okay, so I had an 84.
Some of you advanced people out there
might've had the 89 titanium version.
Long story, basically, my calculator,
it was my best friend in high school, right?
I'm just showing off my weirdness.
So think about how you could model y equals x,
where it's just a straight up line,
versus y equals x squared.
And so that's the difference between simple
and compound.
And if you remember, look at the very early part
of that graph, those lines are pretty much
blended in together.
You really can't tell very much of a difference
between the two lines, because it just looks so similar.
But then long-term, there's this massive difference,
where it's extremely different.
And so what kinda happens with the way
student loan interest works, is it's the same exact interest
every single year, but your overall balance
grows on this additive level.
And so, for example, the 450,000 of student loans,
just pretending the person's paying back
on pay-as-you-earn or something,
with 100-ish K income.
So early on, you have that 7% interest
that you're getting hit with mostly all of it.
But later on down the road, because that interest amount
is just kind of growing additively,
your total balance in 20 years is 800-something thousand.
But the interest that's accumulating
is only about 15,000 at that point,
partly because your required payments
are covering some of it.
So if you look at the actual interest growth
after your payments, it's like 15,000 of 800K is like 2%.
And if you even look at the full 30,000 of interest
based off of that 800K, what is that?
That's like 3% or something like that.
The effective interest rate on pay-as-you-earn
actually gets better and better and better over time.
Like it gets less and less bad,
which is really quite extraordinary.
Because what if you have some inflation?
Well, I mean, then student loans in the past 10 years
could be like super free money.
Any inflation at all would cause student loans
to look like a great deal.
And then with revised pay-as-you-earn,
the interest is actually even better than that,
because you have interest subsidies
that the balance is super high relative to your income.
So for example, with revised pay-as-you-earn,
the effective interest rate at the very end
of your repayment, it's literally about 1%.
Just because again, that interest is so subsidized
and it's simple rate of interest,
so that subsidy really doesn't show up for a long time,
what makes student loan interest compound interest?
So in the early part of your repayment,
when that person leaves school,
and they have 350,000 of principal
and 100,000 of interest,
when you leave school, that 100K capitalizes
because you can't avoid it.
Because whenever you exit your grace period,
the loan interest capitalizes.
And so you have that one compounding event.
And what a lot of people do early on in their careers,
Rob, they use a lot of forbearance.
How often have you seen borrowers use forbearance
in the first five years after graduation?
Much too often.
All the time, right?
And so when you do that, every time you do forbearance,
it compounds your interest.
And so then, what do people do?
Well, we just extrapolate and just assume
things are gonna be the worst ever.
That's what humans do mentally,
is we just extrapolate what's currently going on
and assume this is the exact way it's gonna be
and this is the crisis that's gonna happen.
So for example, coronavirus.
So I hope I'm correct in this.
I really do hope I'm correct in this.
But I think probably in six months,
we won't be talking about coronavirus at all.
And so the reason being is like,
everybody just extrapolates what's going on right now
and says the world is going to fall apart
because we had an additional number of cases
and it's growing exponential.
And so I'm gonna map out this exponential growth
just for forever,
because that's what I see right in front of my face.
So I'm just gonna assume that that's gonna happen forever.
And like, that's not the case, right?
Before coronavirus broke out,
everybody is probably thinking about whatever,
like some major threat to America.
Whatever the most recent crisis was,
that's the crisis that's gonna ruin us.
And I'm not saying that they're not things to worry about,
but it's just we have all these behavioral biases as humans,
where we don't look at things at all rationally.
We look at them just kind of
what's the most recent thing that occurred to us.
And so when people think about
how bad their interest is growing,
well, it's because we know that it grows really bad
in the very beginning,
but then it gets really not bad at all later on.
Now, there is one big exception to this.
If you were paying so much
that you're basically covering all of your interest
because your income-driven repayment is high enough
to basically cover all the interest,
then that's the case
where somebody would go ahead and refinance
because what you're doing in that case
is just paying back your loan
at a six or 7% interest rate
and incurring extra interest expense.
You're not getting any subsidies
because your income is too high.
Those are the people that need to refinance
as your required payment is so high
that your balance is falling, not increasing,
because your required payment on your loans is so high
and you're not gonna qualify for PSLF or anything.
Now, that's a case where the subsidies
actually are not that relevant
because you're making too much money
relative to your balance.
So I think that that's kind of an interesting point.
Do you have any thoughts about that?
Yeah, no, I did a projection of,
let's just say it's a veterinarian
who owes 300,000 and is making 100,000
and their salary is gonna grow each year.
So if their loan were to grow compounded
and they're making like $700 a month payments a year
on pay as you earn,
if their loan were to grow like at 7% compounded
despite making those payments,
at the end of the 20 years,
their loan would have grown to like $741,000
all the while making like $200,000 of payments
over the years.
So that's huge.
Now, with simple interest or with accrued interest,
the loan balance grows, but only to 500,000.
So it actually, compound interest versus simple interest
over 20 years would save this person about a third,
their loan balance would be a third lower
just by having it be simple interest.
But in the first few years,
like five years, four years in,
the difference in loan balance is only like $5,000.
Compound interest would grow to 355
and the other one would grow to 350.
It's super close, right?
Like it's super close together.
Yeah, and then if you take the net interest
of their payments in year one, it's the same.
But in the 20th year of making payments on pay as you earn,
if it was compound interest,
they'd actually, their loan would have accrued $35,000
of interest after payments.
But with simple interest,
it's only $6,000 of interest after payments.
So that's like literally a $30,000 difference
because the interest is advantageous
to student loan borrowers
compared to like a compound interest situation.
You have to fight your biases, right?
Your biases, I don't know how you say that plural form,
but your biases are your enemy
when it comes to personal finance
because it causes you to do things that are not rational.
And we all have our biases.
I'm not saying that they're not things
that you need to pay attention to,
but we have them and you gotta try to avoid them
or else you're gonna make a lot of mistakes.
Clearest example ever, right?
Everybody is thinking, okay, my interest is so bad.
It's always gonna be bad.
I'm gonna be destroyed.
My balance is going to be 10 times what I owe today.
And you haven't even run the numbers.
You haven't run them.
Like math is the best disinfectant.
When I responded to that school recruitment person,
I just literally explained the math.
I was like, hey, like I get that you feel this way
because you have pride in your school, but here's the math.
You're gonna borrow this amount.
You're gonna have this much.
You're gonna have this much loan fees,
this much accrued interest, blah, blah, blah.
You're quoting all these things
that literally don't make sense when you look at the math.
Yeah, and to be fair though too,
I mean, you used to be a bond trader
and we both have our CFA,
so we were well-versed in debt and stuff like that.
There's no other debt that I can think of out there
that is nearly as complex and so different
than any other sort of like debt rules of engagement.
Like student loans are just a whole different ball of wax.
If we treat it, we just have to go,
everyone has to go with the assumption
that student debt, it is a little bit of an epidemic,
but the rules that apply are actually better
than trying to pay back credit card debt
or mortgage debt or car debt.
And you really need someone who knows the nuances of it
to understand how this works
because it is so, so different than anything else.
Well, like if I'm putting my investor hat on for a moment,
the reason why people like buying
the refinance student loans products like as an investor
is because the treasury bond yields 1.5.
So lending with an extra 2% yield to a doctor
who's almost certainly gonna pay it back at 3.5
kind of makes sense.
For sure.
And the doctor's happy
because instead of paying seven to the government,
they're paying 3.5.
That makes sense from an investor standpoint,
but for somebody who owes a large balance
relative to what they earn in income,
dude, I'd have to pay like pennies on the dollar
for that kind of debt.
Like that is awful debt to own
from an investor's perspective.
I remember that earlier topic of the CBO
like saying the subsidy is somewhere between 11 billion
or maybe it's 260 billion
or maybe it's our number, which is 400 billion, right?
I mean, that's because it's so attractive
to pay back your loans on an income-based program long-term
if you have a low income relative to what you owe
just because of this interest subsidy
that people don't understand.
And so maybe that's our job, Rob,
is most people are not pharmacists or physicians or lawyers,
but those professions, when they have special expertise,
have to kind of like explain it
in a simplified way for mass consumption.
Because like your typical person
doesn't need to know what a tort is
or what a specific surgical name is,
but if you can explain it for when people need to know
about it, that's what's helpful.
So that's why I really wanted to focus on this
for today's episode is just to really hammer home
this idea that your student loan interest
is not nearly as bad as you think it is.
And that's because of this behavioral bias
where you myopically focus on what's happened
in the past couple of years
and that you just project that forward
for the entire future of your loan repayment
and that's not it at all.
Yeah, absolutely.
I guess the action steps for this are,
if you're freaked out about your student loan interest,
don't be.
If you haven't downloaded our calculator already,
go to our site and just try to download that calculator
because it shows you how this interest works.
If you go to one of the tabs of the calculator,
it's probably one of the most emailed questions I get
is people who send me an email, they're like,
hey, I saw an error in your calculator, it's wrong.
Your balance is gonna be like triple what you modeled.
I used the one on the student aid website
and it came up with something different.
Yeah, exactly.
It's because you literally need to account
for this accrued interest difference
because it's the biggest thing ever.
Finance people, when I'm on calls
and I explain this to them,
the light bulb goes off and they're like,
oh my gosh, this is the biggest thing ever.
And it's so funny because people that are not in finance,
they hear that and they're like, oh, cool.
Cool, accrued interest, great.
It's like, no, this is such a big deal.
I remember for me, when I joined up with you
in the winter of 2017, a little bit over two years ago,
this blew my mind.
I had absolutely no idea that this was how it worked.
I had like 15 years of experience in the financial industry
and I had my CFA and CFP,
and I still was like, this is incredible.
It's like unbelievable.
Yeah, Rob is a pretty level-headed guy.
He doesn't get thrown off by much.
So that tells you how amazing this concept is,
that he's even flabbergasted, right?
Flabbergasted, good word.
So what are the action steps?
Okay, so if you have a student loan payment
on federal loans that is fully covering
all of your interest,
you should have refinanced a while ago, right?
So if you're not doing PSLF,
let's keep that kind of front and center.
Like you're not doing PSLF,
your payment's really covering most all of your interest,
well, go ahead and refinance it.
So studentloanplanner.com slash refi,
apply a lot of those different companies.
Also, people need to know
that there's a whole bunch of people out there
that if you have a private loan already,
because you've already refinanced,
if you have refinanced any length of time,
like longer than three months ago,
you need to refinance again,
because the rates are so, so low, Rob.
They've really fallen off of a cliff
because of weird combination of coronavirus
and credit risk being super low at the same time.
It's very strange, honestly,
but basically what you need to know
is rates are super, super low.
I just saw the 30-year treasury yesterday was at like 1.8%.
It's kind of nuts.
It's totally nuts.
Yeah, let's lock up our money
for below inflation for 30 years.
Sounds like nothing bad's gonna happen, right?
You know, if you have debt that you're paying back,
like take advantage of it,
because it might never happen again.
You know, say the coronavirus gets cured,
interest rates go up a percent,
you're not gonna be able to get anywhere close to
as good of a deal on your student loan refinancing.
So get moving on that if you need to.
And then, you know, for people who are stressed out
about their student loan interest,
if you can't model this and explain, like,
why it's okay and why it's not a problem
to your, you know, family, spouse
that's really worried about your debt,
that's when you need a student loan plan, right?
So studentloanplanner.com slash help.
Just check that out, get a plan,
understand what your interest is
and what the specifics are for your situation.
But just don't freak out about it.
There's a thousand and one things worse
than student loan interest.
As painful as it seems,
it's just because the pain always happens early on
and we're humans and we extrapolate
what happened yesterday for the next 20 years.
And that's just the bias we all have to fight against.
Right, I found too that clarity,
like understanding exactly how things are gonna go
in the future and like the projections
beyond any type of cost savings that come from a consult,
just the clarity of knowing what things look like
and how things are actually going to be
is just a huge relief for people
because now they know what they need to do.
You know, instead of uncertainty
and making things more drastic than they probably will be,
the clarity plus the savings
is like a really, really good reason
to download that calculator.
And if you need more help,
then obviously schedule a consult with us.
Absolutely, so thanks so much, folks.
And the best thing that you could do for us
is just tell people about the show.
Student Loan Planner Podcast,
there's a whole bunch of people out there
that can't afford our services that we wanna help.
And the best way I can think of
to do that is by telling them about our blog,
but especially this podcast.
So Student Loan Planner Podcast,
available everywhere, Spotify, iTunes.
Suggest it to your friends, hit the subscribe button,
and hopefully we can keep entertaining you
and making something as boring as student loan interest
slightly exciting.
Does that sound good, Rob?
Yeah, sounds good.
Yeah, thanks, everybody.
