Will Trump Abolish the Department of Education

Loan Solutions
2 followers
#Finance#Loans
It’s an unlikely scenario, but the possibility of President Trump abolishing the
Department of Education in his second term is a hot topic that’s sparked questions and concerns among student loan borrowers. We’ll explore what that might mean, unpack the fears and anxieties expressed by our listeners, and provide context around the policy implications. Plus, stick around for our “listener mailbag,” where we tackle specific questions and worries that have been pouring into our inboxes.
Hello and welcome to another episode of the Student Loan Planner Podcast. Today we're going
to talk about will President Trump in his second term abolish the Department of Education. We're
going to talk about the fears and concerns that we've been getting in our email and just people's
questions about that. We're also going to do a listener mailbag at the end of today's episode
just to kind of cover some things that we're getting in our inbox. Just fears, concerns,
anxieties that people have. We're here for you throughout however long it takes for you to handle
your student loans fully. That means zero. And so we're going to go through some just some things
that you might want to be aware of, some things that you might want to be concerned about, and
some things you shouldn't be concerned about. So first we're going to cover this idea of will
Trump abolish the Department of Education. We are getting this worry a lot and I thought it
would be very very useful to go look at history and talk through what that history means, what
it suggests, and why ultimately I don't think that you should be concerned about this particular
fear that people have. And so let me go back to the founding of Department of Education around
the Carter administration in 1979. So education and the federal government's functions on education
used to be wrapped up in the Department of Health and Human Services is what it's called now. It was
called like Health Education and something like that and Health Services. And then what they did
is they took out education out of that department basically to give a more you know elevated role
to government's policy on education. And then obviously in 1980 what happened, President
Reagan won in a big decisive election in a very big way. Kind of you know a little bit of a not
obviously the same situation but sort of a similar type of situation where you had an incumbent
president that with President Biden that was unpopular, Carter was unpopular, you had this
very decisive victory of Reagan in 1980. Decisive victory although not nearly as big probably in
in you know 2024 with Trump's victory over Vice President Harris. And so the reason I'm making
that analogy is because in 1981 right away President Trump, President Reagan and his
administration tried to repeal the Department of Ed. And what happened is there was not agreement
on that, they couldn't get it done, and they instead passed a big education bill but one that did not
include abolishing the Department of Ed. So as far back as 1981 Republicans had been trying to abolish
the Department of Education. Now what we had happen next is you know you had George H.W. Bush
become president in 88, he ran for election in 92 and lost to Bill Clinton. And the next time
Republicans focused again on repealing the Department of Education was 1996 with Bob Dole
as a presidential candidate they put it in the party's platform to abolish the Department of
Education. So if you recall like Newt Gingrich era contract with America, it was a very conservative
era, very sort of activist sort of era where conservatives were very energized. So that's
one of the reasons why you know a more you know very clearly sort of more I don't want to I don't
know if I should call it a far-right position or not but a very to the right position of abolishing
the Department of Education. That was in the party's platform in 1996 and of course Bob Dole
lost the lost election lost the election to Bill Clinton. Now in 2000 and during the Bush
administration kind of interestingly enough No Child Left Behind happened. I remember this my
dad was a teacher at the time he really did not like No Child Left Behind at all but that bill
proposed a big role for the federal government in education that was actually a bill that was
worked together with George Bush and Ted Kennedy of all people right. So there was no discussion
or no serious discussion of abolishing Department of Ed during the Bush George W. Bush administration
but in 2016 when Trump won that surprise election there was a big push again towards abolishing the
Department of Education. In 2016 what they wanted to do was take Department of Education and abolish
it but take the functions of Department of Ed that had to happen and roll it up into the Department
of Labor. Now interestingly enough Congress actually organizes itself somewhat this way. So if you look
at the Senate Committee it's the Senate Committee it's called the Senate HELP Committee. It's the
Senate Committee on Health Education Labor and Pensions HELP. In the House it's the Committee
on Education in the Workforce during when Republicans control it and it's the House
Committee on Education and Labor when the Democrats control it basically trying to telegraph you know
who their sympathies lie with obviously right. Republicans being kind of anti-organized labor
and Democrats being pro-organized labor. So just to be clear right off the bat we should know that
Republicans plan is not actually to eliminate Department of Ed and everything it does. Its plan
is to reorganize and merge Department of Ed with other things and de-emphasize the powers and
and you know authority of Department of Ed and specifically what does it want to do. Republicans
are really more interested in K-12 usually on Department of Ed kind of stuff and in particular
I think this administration is going to be very focused on cultural issues right. Quote unquote
the war on woke right. The war on you know transgender you know cultural issues right. I
mean that's what their focus is going to be it's not going to be on student loans most likely. Now
I think in the world where they would depolish Department of Education they would take those
student loan functions and put them under a new agency and what would that agency be hard to say.
Some Republicans have proposed it should be the Treasury. Some Republicans have proposed making
it like the Fed making an independent agency to administer the student loan programs that would
be free from political interference. The truth though is we will never know because Republicans
will not abolish the Department of Education and let me explain why. So because the filibuster was
not nuked during the first couple years of the Biden administration as some were pushing for
that means the Democrats are going to be able to use the filibuster to stop some of the most
extreme things that they do not want Republicans to achieve and one of those things would certainly
be to abolish the Department of Education. You would not get 60 votes in the Senate to repeal that
or to support abolishing Department of Education. So what that means is you will see a bill that
will abolish Department of Education. Actually fun fact a Kentucky congressman has been
introducing a bill every single year to abolish the Department of Education for a long time.
You don't even know about it. You don't even hear about it. Why? Because the media didn't report on
it and ultimately this is what I would call headline risk is you know generally speaking
you know any media whether it's a traditional media outlet or one of these sort of newer
more partisan outlets right they're going to be telling you things that will get them clicks.
That's the incentive right just to be clear right any organization frankly including student loan
planner wants people to read its stuff and so when you report on the random Kentucky congressman
wants to abolish Department of Ed and introduce that bill every single year well you don't report
on it because people are like it's just some one-off person yelling into the wind it's not
worth paying attention to. But when you know the bully pulpit of the presidency says you they want
to do it then people are worried and then you're going to see a lot of stories that are going to
be like should you worry about this? Do you need to be fearful? And the answer is no you don't need
to be fearful. So keep in mind even you know if the most like far-out statements by Republicans
became reality they still have to issue federal student loans they still have to do that function
and they have only ever proposed abolishing grad plus and limiting parent plus loans.
Republicans have never proposed completely eliminating in a serious way everything the
government does on student loans right they've only they only want it to be you know Stafford
loans only or something like that and that means that you're not going to see the government
completely get out of the student loan program like many people would like and the reason that
wouldn't happen is because you know the government's role in student loans keeps interest rates down
for borrowers it takes a lot of business out of you know the private student loan market and it
just you know it just sort of prevents folks from having you know just those sorts of
sorts of worries and issues because they're able to get better interest rates. So no you don't have
to be worried about what happens with you know the apartment event. I just want to make that clear.
One thing though to be aware of is if Republicans do not believe an agency organization should
exist then it's natural to you know not be shocked that they're going to appoint people that probably
also have that same point of view right. So you probably will see the Secretary of Education
under the Trump administration make policy in such a way that reflects the belief that the
Department of Ed shouldn't exist and should have a more limited role and so that possibly means
slower processing times for things that the administration doesn't agree with.
It might mean less generous executive actions it will mean that. It might mean a more difficult time
getting through the bureaucracy to get certain things accomplished like making sure your payment
account is updated correctly. It might mean the impossibility of getting a discharge of your student
loans if you went to certain types of for-profit programs. So those are the sorts of things that
the belief of abolishing the Department of Ed might actually you know impact because you know
any executive actions or those sorts of things could absolutely be impacted by you know the
Republican view the Department of Ed shouldn't exist. So just wanted to kind of clarify some
things there. Remember 60 votes in the Senate that's still a very important thing. There's a lot
of stuff you can accomplish without 60 votes in the Senate but it's typically stuff that affects
spending levels or taxes. So those are the big things that you can accomplish and also I guess
appointments right. You can make different kinds of appointments to different sorts of offices
right. So the courts appointments to like cabinet agencies you can probably fire a lot of people
that are political appointees you can do that. You can also make changes to spending for example if
you know Republicans wanted to dramatically cut spending on the Department of Education they could
probably do that and that would have downstream impacts on a lot of things that the Department
of Education does. But to completely eliminate it to completely block PSLF and things like that
you cannot do that unless you've got 60 votes in the Senate. So that's a bit of good news is you
really do need to be very careful and paying attention to what is achievable with the current
state of things you know and what is not achievable with the current state of things. So now let's
listen to a few listener questions. I think these will be pretty interesting to listen to.
So let's take a listen and we'll see what the answer is going to be.
Hi Travis I have a question about recertifying income for an IDR plan during a gap in employment
when there's no income being brought in. As an example assume someone graduates from residency
in June and plans to take a break before starting as an attending physician in October. If their
IDR anniversary is in August how should they recertify their income? The most strategic but
potentially morally gray answer would be to truthfully report zero dollars of current income
in August which would allow zero dollars a month as payments for the next 12 months at which point
a 2025 tax return would show a partial residency partial attending salary. This is consistent with
well-established practice of recertifying any time the income goes down. Are there legal slash
ethical implications to this that I'm missing or is this a potential loophole in how the yearly
income recertification process is structured? The correct answer would seem to be more clear
if the timeline were much shorter such as a few weeks of a break between employment
or if it was much longer such as several months in between employment.
Wondering how you're seeing this issue. Thanks. So with IDR recertification you can absolutely
recertify any time your income goes down. The way I would do this in terms of a gray area is if you
have not started employment yet and you have finished your let's say your med school for
example you consolidate you're able to say that you made you have no current taxable income because
that's a true statement right so that's why most everybody gets a zero dollar a month payment
coming out of their school because you know that's a true statement. Now if you're in between
residency and being attending for example where you have this huge income increase and let's say
your due date for recertifying your income is in August and your income is dramatically higher
what you want to do is just use tax returns because it's easier and it doesn't raise any
questions and so what I mean by that is okay if your recertification date is in August well if
you use your prior year tax return it's actually reflecting a resident income already and you don't
have to do anything you know at all untoward or not truthful to just use your tax return and have
that income be lower and also let's say that you've had a you know a higher income for a while
but you know maybe the year before this past year you had a lot lower income than you had the prior
year and so then there's a opportunity potentially to legally file a tax extension on your tax
return because that would make your taxes due in October instead of August and then you would most
likely be able to use your tax return that's the most recent available which in this case you know
would be if we look and think about you know recording this in late 2024 so prior your tax
return is 2023 if you had a recertification date in August of 2024 but you followed your 2023
extension then you'd potentially be able to use your 2022 tax return instead of your 2023 return
and get a much lower income based payment for a longer period of time so this is something that
will it always work i cannot promise that no but does it work right now does it work in our
experience yes and so what one of the things that people are not aware of is the servicers are
allowed to ask for clarification the servicers are allowed to say well i'd like to get a little bit of
extra information on your income they are allowed to ask that and you know if they do ask that you
just have to see very carefully what they're asking for right are they asking for a current pay stub
what exactly are they asking you know you don't necessarily have to comply with that it just sort
of depends on what they ask right so ultimately you have to comply with it if they kick you off
your ibr plan onto a standard plan or something like that but i've frankly i've never seen that
yet so who knows what will happen with the next four years right because the servicers could be
instructed to be more aggressive on recertifying income and that could be something that happens
so let's take another question hi travis thanks so much for your podcast really appreciate
giving all this confusion right now so i have a question for those of us who applied for
consolidation and for save but never actually entered into it due to the court injunction
so specifically in my situation in april 24 as part of that temporary idr waiver i consolidated
my undergraduate and graduate loans to get the higher pslf eligible account applied
to the consolidated loan after that i was put on a standard repayment plan and was waiting for
the recalculation under the save plan but then on july 18th the court injunction hit putting all
that processing on hold and since then i have been accruing interest on my loans now this is
different from the save administrative forbearance because i've technically not been enrolled in
save at this time so for those of us in this situation does this time period count as
self-eligible for loan forgiveness thanks so much for your time appreciate it so unfortunately i do
not think that any of this period will count for pslf regardless uh for people in the save
forbearance or people who consolidated and were waiting to get approved for save i think that
there is a chance that you could get pslf buyback if you're you know going to get total to 120
payments sometime in early 2025 because i don't think they will have had time to repeal that pslf
buyback rule yet but beyond that i'm quite uncertain about this so that's why i would say
you know for most people they need to get onto the ibr plan because that's definitely a plan
that people have access to if you need to get pslf so let's take another question so i had a question
and wanted to see if you were able to help with this um thank you so much by the way for all of
the useful information and the videos apparently i missed a big video three months ago but like i
saw in the video nobody was really talking about the pay plan ending so it's gone away and it went
away to simplify things to get everyone on the safe plan which i'm on the safe plan so i'm in that
forbearance and kind of limbo place right now i am also seeking plsf and i wanted to know do you
think the pay plan may come back now that the save plan looks like it's not gonna be
approved and can we do anything about it like the lack of information sent out by student
studentaid.gov nobody notified us i see you guys did several videos on it i must have missed those
but i'm kind of irritated now that the only plan that i can apply for is in the ibr and my
my payments are going to be really really expensive with just that plan just wondering
your thoughts do you think um if save is completely thrown out will the pay plan come back
or should i just suck it up apply for ibr so i can at least continue to get some credit
for the month for my plsf let me know your thoughts thanks so there's a chance that the
biden administration in its last few weeks will reopen the pay and the icr repayment plans to
borrowers again because they know they're going to lose in the safe plan they know that that's
toast and the idea is yeah they do want to try to create as many affordable repayment options
as possible they were trying to accomplish simplification of the student loan program
through you know executive action and that's clearly not going to work so i think their
priority is to give people the lowest possible repayment number and they were the ones that
blocked the pay in the icr plans and phased them out for new borrowers and they have the power to
unphase them out and i think they also want to try to signal that the pre-covid status quo is is okay
and that would honestly be a big win for borrowers if we just went back to the pre-covid rules for
and others so i think that hopefully we'll see them reopen the pay plan but we can't count on
it we just have to wait and see so let's take another question hi i'm at 113 qualifying
payments toward the 120 that i need for uh student loan forgiveness i'm on an icr plan
not with the safe program and i'm with mojila which is the servicer for my loans and my question
is from may to november of this year will be the seven months that i need to
reach the 120 qualifying payments however in june and july of this year mojila put all loans
in administrative forbearance because of the transition that they were doing to the new
platform so will i still get credit for those two months um and would that count toward the
seven months that i need toward the 120 that i need for student loan forgiveness so i need
just clarification on that because it's so confusing with what's going on with um the
block with the same program so i don't know whether i'm safe with that because i really want
to go ahead and get this done as soon as possible so that i can get out from under this before you
know anything else crazy happens if you could answer that question for me i would appreciate
it um like i said i'm on the icr program and i was wondering whether those two months um of
administrative forbearance that mojila put us in because of the transition would that still count
toward um the qualifying payment being that i'm in an icr and not the same program thank you
so this is a tough one because the answer is yes you're supposed to be able to get credit for it
but with the you know backlog at department of education how ineffective this department of ed
has been and actually doing its job i do not necessarily have confidence unfortunately for
this listener that they will process everything correctly before the new administration comes in
so administrative forbearance that's not you know that's done to you versus something that you ask
for is supposed to be something that counts for pslf and certainly a transition to the mojila
platform theoretically should count so i would go ahead and have the the belief that it counts
and i would apply as if it counts and then i would either you know advocate for getting it
forgiven because it should count or i would offer to do a pslf buyback kind of scenario if
you needed to to get it over with as fast as possible because this person if they have seven
months left you know they would be on track to getting full forgiveness sometime in maybe april
or so that might be soon enough for pslf buyback might still work so that would be my my suggestion
is you know take your chances there's nothing to lose by advocating for yourself and saying that
you believe it should count because you know under technically the rules that by administration put
theoretically it should so let's do another question hey travis my question is about the 10
year standard repayment plan i'm a dental specialist and owe around seventy five thousand
dollars in federal loans at 4.75 interest i enrolled in the state program using my residency
income and currently have a very low monthly payment my recent vacation date is in february
and now that my income has jumped if i recertified with save my monthly payments would be around a
thousand dollars a month i feel like i have better uses for my money than rapidly paying down
my 4.75 student loans so does it make sense for me to get on the 10 year standard repayment plan
if so what is the best way to go about doing this i've had a terrible experience with mojila and
don't really trust them to switch me over so i had considered just not filing my recertification
and letting the system kick me back to the standard plan is that a terrible idea any advice
or insights you can offer are much appreciated thank you so for this one this is a really
interesting question because you would want to know how the student loan program works with
picking payment amounts you can pick a really low payment amount a lot of people are not aware of
this so if you consolidated a balance over sixty thousand dollars the standard repayment plan
changes from the standard 10 year to a standard 30 year so if this person really believed that
4.75 is very low for them that they would like to use their money for other things what she could do
is just consolidate and get them to the standard plan and then you have a standard 30 year plan
and so for a 75k balance that 30 year payment would probably be like 400 or 450 a month instead
of a thousand a month so that would be a way to get a low payment i would only do that until the
you know i would wait until that zero percent interest period is expired however long that lasts
probably at least until january 20th when the new administration comes into power
and the only thing that i would push back on about the 4.75 is 4.75 first year loans would be
after tax meaning it's not tax deductible so a lot of times you want to make sure that you
look at your entire financial portfolio and think about well what does 4.75 really mean right because
if you look at your mortgage interest you might be deducting that and so you might have a five
percent mortgage but after you deduct it maybe it's only a three percent mortgage in terms of
in which case a lot of people might be paying extra on their mortgage when really they should
be paying extra on their student loans because the 4.75 is not tax deductible versus the mortgage
interest you know could be tax deductible and the other thing to think about too is you know
how is your portfolio invested so for example do you have a lot of money in brokerage accounts
if so then you have you know a pre-tax yield on a on a bond right now is something like four point
whatever percent 4.3 let's say and that's pre-tax after tax you're really taking home maybe 2.5 or
something so a 4.75 on your student loan might actually be pretty expensive so what i'll say is
you know in general whenever you have a really high price earnings ratio in the stock market or
at least an elevated one it's not a bad idea to deleverage if you have some extra cash lying
around now that comes after having a rock solid emergency fund putting good amount in retirement
having a brokerage account set up and being funded at some level but just keep in mind when
we're thinking about interest rates you know a lot of times you got to be thinking about after
tax equivalent interest rates and what the comparison is for your finances so let's do
one last question hey travis thanks so much for taking my call um i was wondering what you thought
was going to happen with parent plus loan borrowers in the near future we're going to be
done borrowing by july 2025 meaning they're going to be locked out of the double consolidation
loophole um a lot of borrowers in that instance they may be okay with just being on icr and they
may have sent their kids through college um thinking that they could pay back the parent
plus loans using income contingent repayment however now because of the eighth circuit
court of appeals judge leaning towards him saying that icr forgiveness may not even be legal
how do you think that's going to impact parent plus loan borrowers who never heard of the double
consolidation loophole or who may not be done borrowing by the time the loophole closes and
otherwise only borrowed because they thought they could get income contingent repayment
thanks so much i appreciate it so for this one every bad thing that could happen to student
loans can't be true at once so what i mean by that is if courts rule that icr forgiveness is not even
allowed at all then frankly like they'll probably strike down the idea of weighted average
consolidation too and so if i was going to really gain the system in that situation i would take
all the icr eligible parent plus loans i could i would pay for 25 years until i'm 75 or 80 and
then i would go take a uh you know you know european history uh of art class or something
like that and get five thousand dollar loan i'd reconsolidate everything back together
and then i would pay for another 25 years and my plan would be to die with the debt
so that would be if a bunch of terrible things happened which wouldn't happen long term because
everybody in dc knows the parent plus loan system is really broken but the political
imperatives and pressure from universities keep that unbar uncapped borrowing uh in place because
it's just more painful for congress to cap it than to you know uh it's more painful for congress
you know to leave it to cap it than to keep it uncapped basically is what i'm trying to say
so i think that the icr forgiveness route for parent plus borrowers is actually a tremendous
route that is very underutilized people are very unaware of most people in america have either
themselves or their spouse earning most of their retirement income in the form of social security
that's the majority of what they're earning for a lot of people right and then the other spouse
might be earning a little bit more they might have some pension income they might have a higher
social security payout they might have some ira distributions in retirement but if you really
plan carefully you could very much be in a situation where you know even if your only
option is the icr plan you could still have a fantastic retirement if you're you know a
moderately frugal person and for the double consolidation um you know wait you know loophole
ending in mid july of uh july of 2025 we have to wait and see on that because that rule is embedded
into the save plan rule and if that save plan rule falls the ending of the double consolidation
might go away too so this is just another example of why we have to wait and see on a lot of these
policy things to just be able to tell what's going to happen so those are all the questions
for today i'm interested it's interesting that we haven't yet got questions about what's going
to happen to student loans you know in trump's second term uh you know obviously we'd like to
just keep it focused on the impact on student loans because that's just the only thing i'm
really qualified to talk about i guess but you know so if you want to ask a question about your
student loans about any concerns that you have um if you are wondering if it changes your strategy
if you're wondering what will happen with the idr waiver count payment uh that they're supposed
to update you know whatever your questions are you can ask them at studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail just go there press the record button on your phone read off a quick minute
question and we'll feature it on a future pod episode if you do that and if you need a student
loan consult we are having a lot of people book you know what now consults is what i'll call them
and you can do that at studentloanplanner.com book and we are actually modeling a new proposal
for income driven repayment i'm calling it the house gop proposal that you know interestingly
enough in terms of the present value the cost in today's dollars has a similar potential benefit
as the safe plan of all things basically the house gop's proposal is to do sort of payment matching
so if you're making payments based on your income they would match those payments until you got to
a certain level of payment relative to your uh your loan amount and it's quite interesting it
would result in a full payoff of the loans for people and you wouldn't have to worry about the
tax bomb anymore because you're actively paying down the loan but i think they also drastically
underestimated how expensive this was going to be when they were writing the bill so i don't think
they'll actually put it forward but it's still really interesting to see the 2017 house gop
proposal was very very strict and traditional small government let's cut everything and the
2024 house gop proposal is sort of like let's spend a bunch of money let's do a bunch of like
let's make a new government 401k matching style program for people's student loans and it's a very
different like way of thinking about student loans coming from the republicans than i've ever seen
before and it's a lot more frankly you know whether you want to call it liberal or progressive way of
thinking on student loans it's definitely a big spending kind of way of thinking about student
loans compared to things that they've done in the past so we'll be following all of the breaking news
about you know who does trump put into place the department of ed we're going to be looking at you
know these proposals coming out of the republican caucus on student loans there's rumors that
there's you know bill language being circulated about what they could accomplish through the 50
senate vote threshold through budget reconciliation on student loans so we'll give you updates on that
so that you'll be in the know and so that you can keep your anxiety levels low and so that you can
feel confident in your plan for your student loans knowing that it's not going to impact your
finances in a negative way so that's that's our goal that's why we do this podcast that's why we
hit that record button each week thank you so much for listening if you have any questions reach out
to us if you need a consult you know where to go if you have want to record a quick question
have a wonderful rest of your week
