Will SpaceX be able to deliver Starship in time for Artemis? Will Elon and Donald cancel SLS and replace it with Falcon Heavy? Is there any chance for real competition with SpaceX? How serious is the space race with China? Finding out the answers in this interview.
00:00 Intro 01:12 Reentry and the rise of SpaceX 10:24 What happens to SLS 20:17 The state of Starship 30:45 Blue Origin and other competition 35:29 Space race with China 42:11 Questions from the Patreon Community 53:22 Current obsessions 55:11 Final thoughts
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
we live in a very confusing time for the
state of space exploration in theory
NASA is going to be sending humans to
the moon in the next couple of years
we're seeing the construction but the
concerns about the space launch system
we're going to see more and more tests
of Starship and yet Starship is one of
the parts of the Artemis mission is it
going to hold up the mission what's
going on with blue origin uh what about
the Chinese what's the state of the
International Space Station like I said
there's a lot going on and so I was
really fortunate to be able to bring on
one of the if not the best space
journalist in the industry and that is
Eric burer from RS Technica Eric writes
so much and has deep inside knowledge
and connections to everybody at all of
the space agencies and Rocket companies
and does just excellent reporting and he
recently came out with a new book called
re-entry which is all about spacex's
design and development of reusability
with the Falcon 9 rocket I read his book
it was terrific and now I had a chance
to ask Eric some questions about the
book but mostly about the state of space
exploration in this very strange and
turbulent times all right enjoy the
interview with Eric berer Eric it's good
to see you again hey it's great to be
back Frasier thanks so much so before we
get into the conversation because it is
a very H Dynamic unfolding uh situation
that's going on across all of both human
and robotic space flight I want to just
it tell you how much I loved your book
which is which is why you're
here that's very generous thank you very
much yeah so for those of you who are
watching um you know your new book
re-entry is really all about
spacex's plan approach to
accomplish powered return reusable
spacecraft moving towards Starship it's
a phenomenal book 400 pages I don't know
how big the final version is and level
of detail I just I don't
know how you did
it so well I just talk to all the really
smart engineers and technicians who over
the last 15 years took um the Falcon 9
rocket and through its teething pains
early on and then really understanding
how they managed to you know land the
rocket um refly it and then fly it
frequently and then also oh by the way
they also had to to build the cargo
version and then the crew version of the
Dragon spacecraft so it just basically
tells the story of the development of
Falcon n and dragon uh up through about
2020 when you when they had the first
successful crew mission and what's
really interesting for me like you
having reported on all of this stuff but
I reported on it one level removed with
the you know seeing the announcements
from NASA and seeing the press releases
and in some cases talking to people but
not that that level of and it was
amazing to see from the other side
seeing the internal struggle seeing the
stories um how much they had to sort of
lower costs uh to be able to accomplish
some of the tasks that they did the
closest I got was I was at
Nasa after they had the uh the explosion
on the pad and we sort of took a tour
right past the rocket and I saw the
burned out Gantry and it was uh it was
yeah but but still like just to be able
to hear the stories was was absolutely
incredible so thank you for writing this
book and I and yet it's already out of
date so well the idea the idea really
was two things first of all to take
readers behind the scenes so as you say
you know we all sort of watch this
unfold from the outside from the
perspective n nassa or from what we were
hear from SpaceX or from Elon Musk or
from Gwen Shotwell and really to kind of
go behind the scenes and talk to the
people who are making it happen and kind
of put you beside them in the factory in
the control room um wherever they were
sort of making all of the hard work um
you know to accomplish this and so it's
it was to bring their stories forward to
to tell the story of the rise of SpaceX
and the Falcon 9 and really the other
idea was to set the stage for the
Starship ARA right you look at all the
lessons that SpaceX learned with reusing
Rockets with the Falcon 9 and then all
of the lessons they learned from human
space flight with dragon and you you
take all like like for example with
Dragons um you know originally it was
suppos It was supposed to be propulsive
landing right it was supposed to land
under the power of its super Draco
thrusters and that spacecraft just got
so complex that with that propellant
management system that they had to
Scuttle um propulsive landing and so
they took all of that and pushed it
Forward into Starship but they had all
these lessons learned about complexity
and they just had to be simplify things
for um for Starship and so yeah it was
it was to to kind of bring readers up to
the modern say okay here's how the
company got to this point that they're
able to do these pretty crazy things
with Starship yeah yeah I mean that part
was quite interesting that I think the
managers on the team you say kind of
regretted pushing the team so hard to
get that that reusability into dragon
and then it ended up not needing the
propulsive landing although I guess you
know it's theoretically uh available
again in an emergency situation so so
who knows but yeah it was not the
managers Elon Musk who pushed the team
hard and then in a moment of regret in
the fall of 2019 confided to me that
well yeah maybe maybe I did push him a
little too hard and believe me they felt
they felt pushed very hard yeah well and
and I think the story that you see
throughout the book and I think this is
a larger conversation is that all of
these incredible people are pushed to
their limit and and in many cases to the
end of their limit and then they resign
and that seems to be the story over and
over again is that people did their best
work and yet it was it was too much for
them every time yeah that's really a key
theme um that I tried to get at is you
tell this the the story of of these
people through kind of their rise at
SpaceX these amazing things they did and
then almost all of them at the end were
burnt out or had had enough um and so it
was really to kind of to bring forward
also what it was like to be inside the
fire of working as SpaceX I mean it's an
incredibly unique opportunity you're
literally working on The Cutting Edge of
Science and fiction um you're bringing
things into the world that did not exist
and that really do Advance Humanity's
you know entry into the solar system and
beyond I mean SpaceX is absolutely
pushing the envelope on this it's no
longer NASA it's it's it's SpaceX that's
kind of at the frontier of this stuff
and but at the same time you know you're
working in inedibly hard the expectation
is that you'll work 60 or 80 hours a
week kind of at a minimum and then it
goes up from there when they're a crunch
time with with major projects and it you
know it can be a demanding work
environment especially if you're a a
senior manager or director or vice
president and you have an interface with
Elon it's it's it can be pretty brutal
at times yeah yeah and I think so and I
think Elon has become quite a polarizing
figure and I think for a lot of people
they don't want to hear anything that is
associated with him and yet I think you
know you read this book and you get the
Nuance you get the Shades of Gray the on
the one hand the the Bold risk-taking
this and on the other hand the sort of
meat grinder of of what it's like to to
work with them and I think you know in
the end you have some uh you have some
words you have some recommendations you
have some concerns about the direction
that things are are taking so I think no
matter where you fall if you're like
super into space flight and you think
this is the best I think you're get a
ton out of the book and if you're
concerned about this I think you'll also
get a lot of because because it's 12,000
Engineers who are working their hardest
to advance space flight beyond anything
we could even have imagined 10 years ago
20 years ago yeah I really struggled
with that you know um I was in the
process of really getting into reporting
for the book back around the time that
that Elon bought Twitter
and went through that whole process
which
was you know it was it was a challenging
time right he was attacking journalists
I'm a journalist um he was attacking you
know lots of different people and
increasingly being you know much more
conservative and and and that's fine his
politics or his politics but he's
clearly going down some
conspiracy whole theories um and yeah I
I really struggled with sort
of how do you write a book about SpaceX
which which is you know this Ultra
successful company and at the same time
contextualize it or help people
understand how this can be happening
with SpaceX when the kind of opposite is
happening with Twitter right they're
losing advertisers hand over fist
they're losing users and and financially
they're really struggling um and I sort
of got through that Al ultimately by you
know focusing more on the engineers
themselves who did the work I mean Elon
is still a very important part of the
book I mean SpaceX is Elon Elon is
SpaceX they're they're really
Inseparable and you know you see people
try to say well he just bought SpaceX or
he just it was all the engineers that
did the work and and like look you know
the guy has serious flaws but he built
SpaceX from day one with his vision he
hired these people he gave them the
goals and then he has kept pushing and
pushing and pushing and pushing for more
than two decades I mean
you cannot separate the success of
SpaceX from Elon Musk and so that was
that I I really struggled with sort of
framing all of that um but yeah the idea
was was to give readers a Nuance sense
of what it was really like to work at
SpaceX and and why they were so
successful yeah yeah and so I think no
matter where you how you feel about this
situation as it continues to unfold
you're going to get a ton out of the
book so again uh congratulations I
thought it was so good um so so let's
shift gears then and and talk about all
of the stuff that we've all been madly
reporting on as as things are really
unfolding rapidly and so you know like I
said I've got this laundry list we'll
try to get through as many of them as as
we can and so I think the elephant in
the room is the state of emis and the
continued funding of the space launch
system even if it wasn't Trump and
musk leading the government um moving
into
2025 um what is your understanding of
where things stand right now so it's all
in flux um I do think there was going to
be a major rethink of emis regardless of
who won the election um like if KLA had
won the election I think there would
have been a decent chance that you would
have seen a situation where they looked
pretty hard at SLS and maybe cancel the
upgrade so block 1B upgrade um and then
potentially Gateway as well to more
refocus on the lunar surface um I I
think that would have been under active
consideration at least um um I think
with um with with Trump winning and Elon
being involved um in space policy at
least in an advisory capacity although
he's not he's not up there writing space
policy right he's not he's not writing
in the name of an next to NASA
administrator um he is certainly in
Trump's here however we just found out
that he's gonna that Trump is actually
going to be at the six Starship launch
on Tuesday so um my sense is that much
more drastic changes are on the table um
a couple people I talked to who I have
have a pretty good sense of things tell
me there's a good chance that the SLS
rocket is just cancelled um that that
the government you know looks at this
and says why are we paying 4 billion a
launch for basically to get four people
to lunar orbit when there are ways to do
this far cheaper you know you could do
it probably not with Starship but you
could certainly do it with Falcon heavy
and a Vulcan rocket right to get Ayan
out to the Moon um so I think that
that's I think that that's under active
consideration um and it's not going to
happen soon it will be not it will be
months not weeks before that decision
ultimately made but you know let's face
it these programs the Orion and SLS have
been running for 15 and 20 years almost
respectively and we haven't even
launched crew yet um and they're costing
an exorbitant amount of money they are
the opposite of efficient um and you
know Boeing and lock and NASA just have
not executed you know these these
systems were originally supposed to
launch in 2015 then 2017 then 2019
ultimately finally launched in 2022 and
and here we are 3 years later or two
years later and we haven't seen a second
launch yet you know the Starship vehicle
is going to have launched what a dozen
times or more before between SLS
launches so it's it's just if you're
looking at government efficiency in the
space program that's kind of where you
start but I always describe it as this
this really difficult limbo be that you
that that the whole
situation is stuck in like on the one
hand you've got this unsustainable
rocket development $4 billion per launch
uh completely you know no part of is
reusable uh with large infrastructure
that's going to be able to support it
it's going to move you towards that
partially
reusable architecture that gets you down
to the surface of the Moon and yet your
other option is to go okay let's just
scrap all that and let's
live live in fomo land right where you
were like okay maybe SpaceX is going to
be able to deliver with Starship and be
able to meet all those needs or maybe
it's going to go take a lot longer and
the engineering problems are going to be
more complicated and all of the people
that you laid off across all of the NASA
centers are going to be grumpy about
this I think I think what you're missing
is the Starship is already on the
critical path like for for NASA to land
on the moon this decade Starship has to
work so if You' got a functional emis
program you have a functional Starship
vehicle now some people may say well
blue origin is another human Landing
system contractor yes they absolutely
are but they are not Landing humans on
the moon with this in this decade and
potentially not until the mid 2030s
we'll see it's going to be a while like
the Starship is the only viable path to
the moon in the 2020s in terms of a
lunar lander at this point for NASA um
so it's got to work and and I'm saying
that like you don't need Starship to get
Orion to the Moon you could do that you
know this is what Jim brightenstein
talked about back in 2019 when he went
for Congress and then got got called on
the carpet by Senator Richard Shelby you
know he was talking about launching um
launching a centaur upper
stage uh on a on it at the time was
Delta 4 heavy and then it was launching
crew um and the rocket wasn't specified
but it could have been a falcon heavy
launched it gets Orion into orbit and
then um Orion docks with Centaur goes to
the moon and it does the same mission is
as aremis 3 and aremis 2 and and you
know if you you add up the cost of a
Vulcan a falcon heavy and some kind of
docking
mechanism you know what is that for the
first launch maybe a billion dollars and
then you could cost could come down
quite a bit so I mean it's it's we have
the tools to replace the SLS right now
um so I think that that that you're
going to have some people in the White
House who say why why don't we make this
change and there will be deal struck
with Congress whereby you find other
things from Marshall space flight Center
Huntsville Alabama to do that they're
losing out with h with with getting rid
of the SLS rocket and and I think what
you're suggesting isn't a very
complicated switch if with even a little
more creativity as you said you bring in
Falcon heavy maybe there's a way to
adapt crew Dragon to do lunar operations
a larger trunk who knows you know if you
can invest in that pathway then other
think goes away right away I think Orion
sticks around um I suspect that you
would like to have locked Martin's
lobbying
power not fighting against this I think
Boeing you know is is a little bit less
interested in its Space Program than it
was a few years ago um and so you might
get less resistance from Boeing than you
would locked um and so or and Orion
let's face it they've got to test the
heat shield but my understanding is the
modifications for Dragon to make that a
lunar vehicle would be really
significant and quite frankly I don't
think SpaceX wants to in Elon Musk in
particular wants to take the time to
modify Dragon for lunar operations so
frankly he views dragon as a dead end
technology we saw that last Friday when
Gwen Shotwell was speaking at this Baron
Capital event in New York City she said
we expect to fly Falcon and dragon for
six to eight more years now think about
that that's incredible the Falcon 9 is
the best rocket in the
world no questions right in terms of
reliability you can launch three of them
a week the price you know the internal
price for SpaceX is 20 million or less
um it's the only still the after 9 years
is still the only reusable rocket and
the president of the company's like yeah
we don't need the best rocket in the
world you know in six or eight years
we're moving on um right so that's how
they with crew Dragon that's how they
that's especially how they view crew
Dragon yeah crew they view crew dragon
as a dead end technology even though
it's it's the only operational us human
space light vehicle
SpaceX is like n we don't need it right
right because we're going to go to
Starship yeah and and and and I think
there are big FS about whether or not
you want to put human beings into
Starship and have them reenter the
Earth's atmosphere especially on a on
the 50% higher velocity you're going to
be looking at when they're coming back
from the Moon like there's so much that
would be much more complicated with
Starship I agree and I think I you know
for all the talk about humans to Mars
and Starship and and so forth I think we
still quite a long ways away from
putting humans on Starship um now it's
going to happen sooner than I thought um
because you know let's face it the
regulatory environment for SpaceX is
going to be more favorable yes very very
soon um and so they're going to go like
Gang Busters and and really for the
first time since I've been writing about
SpaceX you know they they are not
Capital constrained right they if you
look at what they're doing in South
Texas in terms of building up the
capacity to launch these Rockets they
are putting in lots and lots of money um
and they've never really been in a
position before the last couple years
where they could just spend all the
money that they needed to Elon had
always kept you know things very tightly
um the budget was were always very tight
for is this due to funding from starlink
or is this due to funding from from NASA
um it's not really due so much to
funding from NASA I mean they paid him
$2.9 billion over the lifetime the hls
contract which is nice but that's not
life-changing money I think it's
revenues from starlink you know you know
from
2015 to 2023 like they were investing
very they were they were developing two
Capital intensive projects right right
they're developing starlink and Starship
and now starlink is profitable so like I
don't think they're going to be raking
in the cash from starlink for any time
but it's not going to be costing like
they're not going to have to put in a
billion dollars every year in
development so you can take those funds
and put them into Starship it's
basically has never had TR trouble going
to the capital markets um they just did
a private valuation last week I think it
was like a 255 billion dollar company um
so they can raise money at will and so
they
they they see the goal line ahead of
them and and they're going for
it so this sort of bleeds into the next
topic that I wanted to to talk about and
that is sort of the state of of Starship
um you know we're recording this on
Monday the sixth flight of Starship is
due to happen it was supposed to happen
before we talked which would have been
fun but it's going to be happening
tomorrow um they're going to do some
more additional tests but really the
question is when do we see full
reusability of the entire stack when
does Starship itself come in and get
caught by The Loving Embrace of
mechazilla
so I don't know I would guess I would
guess certainly not next year um you
know know before the election I was
pretty concerned about the regulatory
matter of you know Starship coming back
to South Texas it's going to be flying
over Mexico right Northern Mexico on a
trajectory to come back to be caught by
maxilla um and let's face that's that's
like internationally that's you know
that that's that's that's that would
have been some really serious
negotiations I think between the fa
state department and so forth and I
think now um
that will be much less of an issue
because those people will be told to
Greenlight this and so they will you
know they will make that happen um I
still think though you know SpaceX I
don't think is going to refly this
booster that that they're flying
tomorrow or the one that they caught
last month I think they're going to wait
till the upgraded boosters come back and
and see how they are and so I think
you'll see first stage flying first
honestly I think that we're ways away
from seeing a second stage fly again um
but I I mean would certainly wouldn't
rule it out in 2026 to get full stack
reusability the reality is you don't
really need it um because the first I
mean certainly right now because the
first stage is where all the engines are
right you know that you throwing away
three dozen engines if you lose a first
stage and and there's only six on the
Starships you know we don't know the
unit cost of building those but you know
the engines are probably three or four
million dollar um the machine is pro I
mean you could probably guess that
they're building those for 15 or $20
million at most and so yeah it sucks to
lose them but you know if you need to
fly 10 of those for a lunar Mission you
know it's it's still like $200 million
and that's that's money it's real money
but in the in the scope of what SpaceX
is
spending those are not those aren't
going to break them those costs so like
using Starship to refuel the hls using
not trying to go for reusability the on
the Starships just making new ones and
having them deliver their I think
they're going for full
reusability absolutely I just think
they're going to have to go through
quite a few of them before they actually
get it all right and are comfortable
enough in that Hardware to fight again I
could be totally wrong but I I think
they'll maybe have like I'd be I'd be
surprised it was for like fight 50 when
they did full stack
reusability right yeah um and and then
you know back to what we talked about at
the beginning that hls is on the
critical path for emis and I think for a
while there it was it was you know
Artemis was the was the part that was
slowing things down but it does look
like the timeline of emis could easily
slip due to
hls absolutely I mean hls has clearly
been the reason why um you know that
that it's they're not going to make
20125 or excuse me
2026 um and and it may may not be dealt
till 2028 or later um but you got to
remember you know the the first SLS
contracts were let in
2011 and it was a pretty straightforward
rocket build from shuttle components and
the first um first hls contracts from
NASA were not let until the end of
2021 so you know the Starship the L
lunar Landers is more complex piece of
this um and you know SLS is as they been
funded by NASA for a decade longer so
you know yes Starship is is going to
hold them up but I mean let's be real
the other the other components Ryan and
stship or excuse me SOS had a much
bigger Head Start um but you know we'll
see like like the really big test the
really thing that I'm looking out for
Frasier in 2025 is this one or more of
these refueling tests in orbit where
you're going to see a Starship launch
from one Tower in South Texas and then
shortly after another one launches and
they they dock in low earth orbit and
then one of the vehicles transfers a lot
of propellant to the other vehicles and
they enter the atmosphere now from a
physics standpoint point that should be
fairly straightforward right but it's
still really complex to to dock two huge
ships and then you know do this
relatively delicate process of
transferring prop pellant um
and you know they they'll probably do
that more than once and so you know if
they get that done in the first quarter
of 2025 then it's Off to the Races but
it could take you know quite a bit
longer if they run into problems or
challenges and demonstrating the test of
transfering propellant is not the same
as demonstrating that you can maintain
your cryogenic Propel propellants in
space under those kind of conditions for
long periods of time like that's just
running the clock forward see if that
worked no that's just the next step then
you've got to do then you've got to you
know have a like a Starship Depot or
whatever that that is your kind of
orbital Starship that's probably got
more insulation on it I don't know I'm
not an engineer but sort of something to
prevent boil off of your liquid oxygen
and methane um and
then you know then you've got to do a
long duration test where you send a
Starship out to the Moon where it has to
loiter for like be able to loiter for
like 270 days or something like that um
for the you know the for the emis
guidelines or requirements so yeah
they've got they've got a ton of work
ahead of them yeah yeah you had a great
article that came out a couple of weeks
ago where you just laid out the to-do
list that that SpaceX has to be able to
work through to to fulfill their
obligations to NASA as well as s to meet
some of their larger aspirations and
it's enormous like it it just it goes it
went on and on and on and you could see
that there's just a lot riding on this
it feels like the progress is fast and
yet the that's be partly because the
list of too items still stretches off
into the distance I mean that's frankly
you know regardless of your politics you
know that's why the the Trump presidency
is going to be significant win for
SpaceX um because almost certainly
you're going to see an FAA or if not an
FAA Department of Commerce whatever
ultimately ends up regulating launch
licenses be much more business
friendly um and that if you want to see
SpaceX go fast that really is like the
number one thing that's now holding the
company back because to accomplish all
these objectives the thing you've got to
do is fly Starship frequently right so
you got to go from once a month
to once every you know every two weeks
to once a week I mean probably
by this time next year they'll be
launching Starships you know two or
three a month if not every other every
week you know a lot of people have been
not critical I guess but they're sort of
wondering when the whole Mars component
when do we get that City on Mars do you
think that the reality of space flight
has pushed that as the big audacious
goal sort of into the I don't know like
it's just considered less important
these days well I think it's very
important El on musk and then it's going
to be there therefore very important to
the overall us space flight Community
because you know SpaceX is so critical
to all of those functions but I do think
I do what my sense and I don't know this
for sure this is just Eric Burger
speculating is that the official US
Government Position will be we're
focusing on the moon with arem
but there will
be a more supportive atmosphere for a
human Mission to Mars with NASA and
SpaceX working together right so on one
hand SpaceX is going to be over here
doing their Artemis government work but
on the other hand they're going to be
you know sort of building up some of the
components and Technologies for Mars and
I think once you see a couple of
Starships land safely on Mars I don't
know if that's 2028 I don't know if
that's 2030
um but but once you start to see some
some missions landing on Mars then
you'll start to see more NASA payloads
going to Mars every two years and that
will build up some kind of reservoir for
NASA and government support for Mars
missions but I think it's really
still SpaceX still has to go out and do
it you have to you have to be able to do
the propellant transfers you have to do
how many other you know Starship
launches you need to support propellant
for a Mars Landing I don't know if it's
10 12 16 we're not going to find that
out until you see how efficient propell
and transfer is till you see how much
boil off concerns you have um but once
SpaceX starts landing on Mars then it
becomes real um think about you know
think about back to 2020 right before
the demo 2 mission there were still lots
of people in the US government who are
kind of skeptical about SpaceX it's kind
of this company of
jackasses um um they really didn't
prioritize safety and can we really
trust them and then they put Bob and
Duck in Space on the space station they
bring him back safely and that really
changed I think the perception of Falcon
9 dragon and SpaceX to don't wait a
minute we can rely on these guys and I
think the same thing there'll be that
same the similar CA change in opinion
when you sort of get Starship landing on
Mars who knows if they'll have cameras
out videoing it they probably will
though cuz they're crazy but but then
you know you sort of get down to Mars
and you take video and like you see the
surface of Mars from like 200 ft up it's
going to be super cool um I just think
that those kind of imagery will really
open a lot of eyes in the government to
to what is possible right um uh all
right so I need to shift gears again I
got we got a schedule here um and so you
know we saw blue origin finally roll out
their first stage of new Glenn on a big
long drive through the streets to arrive
at their pad um but we've already seen a
delay from Blue origin for launching uh
it's the NASA Mars mission into 2025 so
you know when do we think that we'll be
able to see a first even a hot fire of
new Glenn not to mention like an actual
first test flight hot fire hopefully
within weeks um the company is still
pushing very very hard to launch this
year um that was the Mandate when when
when Jeff Bas was hired Dave limp to be
the new CEO of blue origin just a little
more than a year ago I mean his he told
him I want you to launch new Glenn in
2024 and so they have been pushing
pushing
pushing um but the clock is ticking
right it's November 18th today and you
you have cutouts for the holidays in
December um where you can't launch um so
they're you know they're running out of
time you know I think
if they get out to the pad soon and do a
hot fire before the end of the month or
even early December they have
potentially a pathway to launching this
year I think it's going to be really
close though yeah yeah um and and then
there are other companies that are you
know sort of in the wings as well so I
mean but like United lunch Alliance is
on the
blocks uh the Europeans are way behind
Ed with Aron 6 which is still just in
the the same stage as AR you know a
disposable rocket so is like is the
entire planet except for maybe China but
is everyone just seeding the rocket
Market to
SpaceX yes I would say so um I mean
let's let's be let's be real um you'd be
kind of a fool to want to compete
against SpaceX unless you were a
billionaire right who could underwrite I
mean Jeff basos is putting about $2
billion into blue origin every year in
an attempt to catch up to SpaceX and
Vulcan appears to be a fine rocket um
and you know they had the problem with
the nozzle on their last test flight and
so I think they're they're they're going
to get back to flight and they'll
probably launch maybe eight to 10 times
next year which is great um and there's
lots of demand for that vehicle but but
you know I don't think they're ever
going to reuse be 4 engines despite
talking about it um and the reality is
they have been on the Block for almost
two years now they've been up for sale I
first reported that others have reported
that as well um Jeff Bezos and and blue
origin kicked to tires and decided the
price was too high Sierra space kicked
the tires more recently decided the
price was too high it just wasn't worth
it um and so yeah locky Martin and and
Boeing want to get um more money out of
a sale and I think is pretty clear about
its interest in exiting parts of the
space business so Ula just isn't worth
that much to buyers um and so that and
that's because I think it's future is
constrained right on one side they're
competing against SpaceX and they've
lost right that that's no question the
Falcon 9 handily defeated the the atlas
and V the atlas and Delta rockets and so
they came up with Vulcan but Vulcan is
not as cheap as Falcon 9 and it's it's
certainly not going to be cost
competitive or payload competitive with
Starship and on the other side you've
got blue origin right which makes the
engines you're using bringing new Glen
to Market New Glen is a bigger more
powerful rocket and quite frankly blue
origin can sell those at a loss um and
and we've seen that kind of business
practice from Jeff basos before so it
would not Shock me to see them pricing
new Glenn lower than uh than Vulcan um
and so over time you know you're going
to have two two very large Rockets
subsidized by billionaires essentially
that that
will push Vulcan to the side I mean
Vulcan fills an important Niche right
now because the Department of Defense
needs a second provider and they are
that provider but but you know five or
10 years from now the outlook for for
Vulcan is is a little more dim I think
yeah and and I mean then there are a
handful of smaller companies we see
tests of course there's rocket lab which
is doing a great job um setting up
facility in the US they launching on New
Zealand so so there are some interesting
options what about the Chinese they you
know I think people are a lot less
familiar with what they're working on
and what their schedules are both on
their their Science Program their human
space exploration program as well as
their their rocket system what's your
perspective on that so yeah just before
we get to the Chinese just a few words
about the US launch competitors I think
there's really three companies you have
to watch in the United States Beyond
SpaceX blue origin Ula and that that
would be rocket lab which you mentioned
um have a lot of admiration for what
Peter Beck has done um and he's pushing
hard to get Neutron to the pad and that
is a nice vehicle up to 16 tons we'll
see how many pains they go through in
terms of Landing it I mean if anyone who
read re-entry should know how damned
hard it is to build a medium lift rocket
with a reusable first stage it's it's
very challenging but I they've got a
great team um and and and I like their
management uh Firefly you have to admire
what they done with um against sort of
in the one ton rocket Wars with uh with
relativity space and a they have clearly
emerged as the winner and so fireflies
building a medium lift rocket with uh
with North which I'm not sure there' be
a huge market for that but we'll see and
then the other company is Stoke right
they're building a fully reusable
rocket um called Nova um great team
pretty great engineering a different
approach for for second stage reuse than
SpaceX is doing so I I think they're
going to be a lot of fun to watch but
beyond that uh there's not too much to
be excited about um so then you go over
to
China um and about seven or eight years
ago the government decided the
government saw what NASA was doing with
the commercial cargo and Commercial crew
program and saw that how that was
generating this this commercial space
industry and
said we want some of that right that's
like that's like that's the way to go
and so China has the most most vibrant
commercial space industry outside the
United States um and what they did is
they basically started licensing their
government technology to private
companies and investors and so initially
they were sort of initially what you saw
was those companies taking the
government's solid rockets and taking
some of their liquid engines and and
trying you know building new launch
systems with those and then SpaceX
started having success Landing Falcon
9es and reusing Falcon 9es and so you
saw a whole whole big pivot it's like
almost every week you see like a new
rendering of from China of a rocket that
looks exactly like the Falcon 9 or looks
exactly now like Starship right they're
like they're essentially I mean I hate
to say it but it's true They're copying
what SpaceX is doing and frankly that's
the smart thing to do right like SpaceX
has shown the pathway so don't try to be
creative and build like a system that
doesn't look like Falcon 9 because you
don't like Elon Musk or SpaceX or
whatever like they're the winners like
copy what they're doing and so you're
seeing lots of companies with pretty
good PowerPoints but we're also starting
to see some Hardware right there have
been some Al high altitude tests with
some Landing some successful some not
but they are that is where the most
activity is so I think like the first
reusable rocket was the Falcon 9 second
was Starship the third was new Glenn and
then we may have three or four Chinese
Rockets before we start to see um
Neutron Neutron Lan so there's lots of
activity in China on the commercial side
then also like the lunar program like
that is the competition that is a race
right NASA and Artemis are racing
against China in the international lunar
research station you know some people
say well it's not really a competition
but it's absolutely a competition you
know you you know this like at the at
the South Pole of moon there's a limited
amount of resource re real estate where
you have ready access to the the
permanently shadowed regions of lunar
craters that you're interested in right
where the ice is but you can also where
you can also generate consistent solar
energy so there's going to be
competition whoever gets there first is
going to get the prime real estate so
it's a totally competition and you know
the plans for China like normally
they're quite secretive about what
they're working on and we don't really
get a sense of what they did until after
they did it but their plans for lunar
exploration have been right out there in
plain sight and they're following their
Milestones to a te I mean from the very
first tyona who launched to the building
of their various space stations to their
missions to the Moon their sample
returns to missions to the Moon their
their missions to Mars and now they're
planing sampler for Mission from Mars
and then leading up to them sending
humans I mean all the pieces are in
place in this very cogent plan that also
has this long-term strategy when they
say they're going to set humans on the
moon around
2030 I believe them I think so um I
think there's a couple wild cards first
of all they could have setbacks right
they could have accidents like the
Apollo on fire or you know some kind of
crew crew accidents I mean let's be
honest their their their lunar program
has been phenomenally successful like
they've hit every one of their missions
has been a success and they've done some
really technically challenging things
with returning samples from The Far Side
of the Moon so you have to give them
credit but they're they could definitely
you know have setbacks right um and then
also you know the financial situation in
China is not great and the government's
got a lot of um a lot of irons in the
fire um with the with the housing you
know Market um and just lots of other
issues and they could decide that their
financial priorities are elsewhere in
the next five to seven years but I agree
with you I I think that by and large
they're on track to put humans on the
South Pole of the Moon by around 2030
now the key difference and I do think
this is important look geopolitically if
China beats NASA back to the Moon um and
puts a T canots down on the South Pole
first that's a kind of a big deal but
the really important thing is like
putting the infrastructure there and so
the initial Chinese Lander is a lot like
the lunar module big surprise right but
it's basically like the lunar module and
I think my understanding is that the the
tyut will be on the surface for several
hours right not very long so it's kind
of a touch andgo Mission and so if you
if you're NASA coming along with SpaceX
and you're starting to churn Starships
out there and you know Starship can
bring hundreds 100 tons or more to lunar
surface you can really start to build up
infrastructure quickly so China may win
like the race but the the NASA could
ultimately win the competition I guess
what I'm trying to say yeah yeah um I've
got a couple questions from the the
audience I let my uh my Patron Community
know that I was going to talk to you um
Sean Patterson asks are there any groups
who are seriously looking at a Mars
cycler in a practical way or is still
theoretical it's all theoretical from
time to time you would hear NASA talk
about the lunar Gateway as a test bed
for the Technologies of a of a ship that
could you know go to Mars like the idea
that you'd T some modules on Gateway in
the d space environment for 10 or 15
years you could get some really s you
could get some good sense of what life
support Technologies would work um in
that environment but I think that was
just lip service like like I I still
think like the chance that we ever see a
lunar Gateway fly in any kind of
semblance is like less than 50% um and
um even though the hardware is being
built I mean the hardware has begun
construction they've been building that
hardware for years man um okay all right
and we're still years away from launch
and if you're the if you're the incoming
Administration you look at the lunar
Gateway you say does this help me get to
the surface of the Moon no it makes it
more difficult okay does this help me
get to Mars no because it's not an
optimal place for refueling station
actually for refueling missions to Mars
right the place to do that not the Moon
is it's low earth orbit
so I mean it's just it's it's
not it's not really advancing your goals
it's the being perfectly honest the
lunar Gateway exists for two reasons
number one aescent Orion could not get
to the lunar surface didn't have the
Delta V excuse me couldn't Orion
couldn't get to low lunar orbits they
had to put something in a higher orbit
around the Moon and R and the other
reason is Johnson Space Center a few
miles down the road from me um wanted to
keep a space station going after the
International Space Station so that's
the lunar Gateway and it's been that
that was the original reason really it
was created and so I think that that
anyway I don't think lunar gate will
happen and even if it does I don't think
it's a great test bed for a Mars cycler
so at this point it's Starship or bust
um cuz NASA is not working on any
hardware at all that could be cred
described as a spaceship that could take
humans from Earth to Mars and
back but but that's we're back into the
you're just sort of putting all your
eggs in the in the SpaceX basket
which we'll see how it all plays out
that that is but but Fraser that is the
only deep space that is the only company
building deep space Hardware there's no
government building it yeah I I don't
there's no NASA funding for a Mars
spaceship NASA doesn't have the funding
to to even to to build lunar Rovers at
this point I mean there's no funding for
it so yeah while SpaceX
is obsessed to an almost cultish level
with sending humans to Mar think think
about it this way think about it this
way right like I don't I I I
fundamentally absolutely agree that
putting all your eggs in a SpaceX
basket is not something you want to do
right like like you don't want them to
have the majority of the contracts but
think about let's let's think about the
Orion spacecraft right pretty simple
vehicle it's a
capsule four people inside of it for up
to 21 days goes to the moon and
back can it's and it's it's it's only
got limited capacity the astronauts are
coming back I bring like 50 kilograms of
rocks that's all they can fit inside
Orion um and we started development of
Orion in
2005 so it's been 20 years so do you
think a human space script that can go
to Mars and back is more complicated
than Orion of course it's much bigger
much more expensive so if you were to
let contracts tomorrow Frasier Fraser
crane congratulation you're the you're
the next administrator of NASA um and
you're like we're going to build a mar
spacecraft
um I mean it's going to take at least 20
years right so that gets us to 20 so if
you want to do this in our
lifetimes there's one vehicle that's
going to be able to do it
so if you don't like Starship and you
don't like SpaceX then that's fine
you're just not going to Mars in our
lifetimes right that's I think simple as
that yeah I mean you are looking at how
many
administrations three administrations
probably they're going to have to be
willing to keep their eyes directed at
Mars one after the other and you know
hand over the baton one after the other
with the same level of enthusiasm and we
you know we know that it didn't happen
we saw the the target go we're going to
go to the moon no we're going to go to
Mars no we're going to go to an asteroid
no we're going back to the Moon are we
though you know that's the that's the
sort of the journey that that goal takes
and yet you then talk to SpaceX people
and they just say and we're going to be
living on Mars and we're all going to go
to Mars and Mars Mars Mars and so it's
really hard to find I don't think
fundamentally NASA has ever been serious
about sending humans to Mars like it's
just
even during the Journey to Mars years
with Charlie Balton in the mid-2010s it
never was real like no one was ever
working on any
hardware and that's just that's like if
the government were to do that that's a
half a trillion dollar program at least
um
and just no one is going to fund that
right there's no there's no impetus for
the government to do it and so for
humans to actually go to Mars and and
look there are so many challenges right
I read a city on Mars by the wiener
Smith right it's great book um there's
so many challenges to overcome and and
the transportation piece is just really
the first significant challenge but it's
the most important one because if you
don't solve that then you don't do any
of the rest of them um you need a
forcing function and so if you actually
if you all of a sudden have a
transportation vehicle that's
theoretically capable of this then you
can start to talk realistically about a
Mars mission otherwise you're just
writing P technical papers and
architectures that are going to sit
around in drawers and in 30 years people
look back at them you know for research
purposes I don't know we're not going to
Mars absent of forcing function the only
forcing function right now is is the
availability of Starship right and maybe
the aspirations of the Chinese
maybe I mean maybe yeah that would be
that would be a forcing function but
again like if you look out at their
program through 2050 I don't think they
had humans to Mars on their road map did
they mhm yeah when when did they say it
when when were uh late 2030s their their
recent plan was you know humans on the
moon 2030 build starting to build the
infrastructure and then starting to you
know use the successes gained from the
Mars sample as a as a way to lead to to
humans to Mars so I think I mean I don't
think we would see even Chinese boots on
the ground in until the 2040s yes right
right yeah yeah because I mean they're
talking about like using the Long March
9 rocket which now looks like a Starship
copycat um to build up the lunar Colony
settlement um in the 2030s and so the
idea that we would then turn that around
and go to
Mars very quickly it
just or even launch from Mar yeah no I
mean obviously I think you're exactly
right but I think
the but you're right China is the other
potential forcing function that just
that the I think just has some problems
with it yeah well I I think you know
Zack and Kelly with their book they
really nailed it which is that there is
no one has come up with a with a
reasonable argument on why anybody
should go to Mars Beyond a couple of
boots on the ground to explore the place
and come home and and say we did it you
know humanity is the best but to
actually like go there because we need
to get our eggs out of you know into
another basket that argument doesn't
hold that there's money to be made that
argument doesn't hold like there's a ton
of Reason like there's no good reason to
do it there's one good reason from it's
awesome no no there's one good reason
yeah I and where I just agree with him I
think the one good reason to go is to
literally make human a space fairing
species like if we are going to live on
other worlds we have to start somewhere
and
Mars as inhospitable as it is and it's
very very very deadly world that is the
best place to start so I I think I think
you got to start somewhere with with
with space settlement and and Marge is
the place to start and so that that is
the only good reason like yeah no I I I
think an even more kind of boil down
version of that is because it's awesome
and I think you know I talked to them
and interviewed them as well and I think
that was the gist is like just that you
know back to Kennedy we go to space not
because it's easy we do it because it's
hard why do you climb a mountain you
climb a mountain because it's there why
do we go to space because that's what's
next and if you're going to try to
shroud your reasons for going in any
other thing than when those clearly
aren't going to carry the day then
you're left without a really good
rationale for being able to do this
thing but if we can all agree that the
reason we want to go to space is we all
want to go to space then it's really
hard to talk us out of going to space
because we still want to go to space i i
i f i absolutely agree and I would just
I would say that like if you were going
to Mars because it's awesome you would
do a flags and Footprints mission right
you would go and come back or if you
have more scientific questions like
again but you know you're not going
because well if you're a scientist
you're probably like I don't want humans
on Mars messing up pristine laboratory
possibly um but I I
think I think there is
um the
the I think the settlement issue is the
important issue and no government is
going to do that right like across
Decades of history no government has has
has paid for settlement in space and
probably will the the question the real
Challenge and you hit on this with Mars
is if you look back at historical
analoges like like why did um did did we
settle North America right it was
economics right first they were looking
for a trade route to India and then you
know you had people coming to S up the
Virginia Company for for tobacco and
other trading purposes then you had
religious escaping religious persecution
um in New England like none of those
analoges hold for Mars right we're not
going there for economic gain I can't
think of any resource you would produce
on Mars and bring back to Earth is there
any I don't think there is right no so
we're not going there for economic
purposes even though there probably
would come some over time um so the only
reason to go is is like literally to
establish human settlements there yeah
yeah in in the same way that we live in
Antarctica that we have people in
Antarctica like we're not there because
it's economically viable we're there
because it's a science station and
because it's important to to check out
every single part of planet Earth and
well we can we do um so Eric what are
you obsessed with right now oh man um
one of the things I'm really interested
in is commercial space stations um these
are the follow on to the International
Space Station I've been spending a lot
of time understanding the companies that
are involved in this um and it's just
it's part of this whole trend of NASA
has gone from building spaceships and
Rockets to buying services and there are
some going to be some hits and misses
along the way in that journey and uh and
so I'm just really trying to understand
where we are sort of at this stage of
commercial space and what NASA can do to
be successful with these programs going
forward yeah yeah
it's I mean we're seeing difficulty in
even those
companies that was hoping to be
commercial companies and to be able to
provide this these services at the same
time that NASA is getting out of the
space station business and so you're not
seeing a really obvious successor I mean
uh Sierra space has got some really
exciting stuff with they Inflatables
you're seeing other companies but we
don't I don't know who I don't either
don't that's the that's the fun that's
the fun I look at all the I look at all
the perspective space station operators
and and they all have strengths and
weaknesses and none of them are clear to
me that that is going to be the company
that that sort of steps up and puts up a
station that replaces the ISS but ISS is
coming down and so there will there will
be a day six years from now when only
the Chinese have a space station I mean
that could be the that could be the
reality maybe yeah yeah yeah well Eric
thank you so much uh enjoy the flight
tomorrow I guess when people see this it
will have already happened if or or
delayed and and good luck navigating
this these next four years you too
Fraser thanks so much for the time all
right all right take care I hope you
enjoyed that interview with Eric burer
now I passed along a question from the
patreon community about the state of
space journalism and we then had a
fairly lengthy conversation about sort
of how good space journalism is how are
people dealing with the behavior of Elon
Musk and sort of what does the future
look like for space journalism and so uh
we're going to have that available
completely for free over on our patreon
just go to patreon.com Universe today
and follow us there it's totally free
and then you can watch all of that
additional content now I want to give
you some of my thoughts but first I'd
like to thank our patrons thanks to Abe
Kingston Adam Schaefer andream gross
Barry Lake Roofing David Gilton and
David matz Dennis alberty Dustin cable
James Clark jery murn Jim Burke Jordan
young Josh Schultz Paul robox Science
World rec.org spiders swap. Steven kraki
Steven Fowler Munley and Vlad shipin who
support us at the master of the universe
level and all of our other supporters on
patreon hopefully at the time that you
are watching this we will know what
happened with the sixth flight of
Starship now I've been able to get
together with Scott Manley and Marcus
house and do an analysis of each of the
former rocket launches I don't know if
we're going to do the sixth one we'll
find out but if you want to kind of go
back and really see the progress of
SpaceX as they develop their starship
through each one of those iterations
definitely go and check out those videos
all right we will see you next time