Switched Reluctance Motor vs Synchronous Reluctance Motor, SRM vs SYNRM, Know which is better. .

Terrific Physics
38 followers
Welcome back to the Reine Tech. In today's video, we will know the difference between
Switched Reluctance Motor and Synchronous Reluctance Motor. If you are a new to this
channel, don't forget to hit the like button and subscribe button. Also press the bell icon so
that you don't miss any latest information on engineering and technology. Before discussing
the difference between the Switched Reluctance Motor versus Synchronous Reluctance Motor.
Let's first understand that both motors are very similar in many things.
Both motors are superior to the induction motor in efficiency and performance.
Both have magnetless as well as copperless rotors. Both Switched Reluctance Motor and
Synchronous Reluctance Motor work primarily on the same principle of variable reluctance.
Which means rotors made up of ferromagnetic material take position on the minimum reluctance
path when stator coils are being energized. Despite so many similarities, there is a
difference between two motors in operation, design and application. Let's compare the SRM
and SYNRM side by side. Here are some of the differences between the Switched Reluctance
Motor versus Synchronous Reluctance Motor which further called SRM and SYNRM.
1. Working Principle. Stator of the SRM has concentrated windings and each phase produces
the salient pole. Whereas, the stator of the SYNRM has a distributed winding like induction motor
which produces the rotating magnetic field. In the SRM, phase switching is done to change the
location of the stator poles with rotor position to produce the rotation of the rotor. In SYNRM,
rotating poles are generated due to the rotating magnetic field and the rotor of the SYNRM rotates
with the same speed but slightly lag behind the RMF with some angle. SRM required a position
sensors to switch the phase energization with rotor position to maintain the continuous rotation.
While position sensors are required to maintain the rotor angle to avoid loss of synchronism in
SYNRM. 2. Rotor Design. The Switched Reluctance Motor has a highly segmented rotor salient pole
that is made up of magnetic poles and flux concentrators. In contrast, the Synchronous
Reluctance Motor, the rotor has a smooth surface and it is made up of laminations.
3. Control Mechanism. The Synchronous Reluctance Motor requires a complex control mechanism
including a feedback sensor to operate effectively. On the other hand, the Switched
Reluctance Motor can operate without a feedback sensor making it less complex.
4. Efficiency. The Synchronous Reluctance Motor is highly efficient which can be designed for
an efficiency of up to 98%. In contrast, the Switched Reluctance Motor has a lower efficiency
typically between 80% and 90%. 5. Power Factor. The Synchronous Reluctance
Motor has a high power factor which is beneficial for the power system. The Switched Reluctance
Motor has a low power factor which may cause power quality issues.
6. Torque Ripple. The Switched Reluctance Motor has a higher torque ripple compared to the
Synchronous Reluctance Motor making it less suitable for applications where a smooth torque
output is required. 7. Speed Control. The Synchronous Reluctance Motor has better
speed control making it suitable for applications where precise speed control is required.
In contrast, the Switched Reluctance Motor has limited but simple and cost-effective
speed control solutions. Conclusion. Overall, while both Synchronous Reluctance Motors and
Switched Reluctance Motors have their advantages and disadvantages, their differences in working
principle, rotor design, control mechanism, efficiency, power factor, torque ripple,
and speed control make them suitable for different applications. In further note, SRM is the oldest
electric motor developed in 1838 with mechanical phase switching arrangements.
Whereas Synchronous Reluctance Motor is the recent development. The first Synchronous
Reluctance Motor was developed in 1923. Thank you for watching this video.
See you in the next video. Good day.
