Richard Meier - The Neugebauer House (24_36)

Honor Art
11 followers
7 Video Views·Nov 20, 2024
I think that, you know, as I look back, it probably began with the Smith House and then went to the Douglas House, you know, somewhat later but which was a different expression because of the nature of the site.
I think that, as I look back, it probably
began with the Smith House, and then went to the Douglas House
somewhat later, which was a different expression because
of the nature of the site, looking down to Lake Michigan
on the steep slope, where you enter from the roof,
not in the middle of the house.
And this desire to create an articulation, a separation,
a reading, as it were, of the difference
between public and private space,
difference in the architectural expression.
And therefore, the private spaces
were closed and contained and cellular,
and the public spaces were open and transparent
and interrelated to one another.
And I think it was this kind of desire
to just have the architecture talk
about the difference between public and private space that
was, in a sense, something which I would like to think
continues to this day.
It may be very different, for instance,
in the house in Florida, the Neugebauer House.
There is public and private space,
and they are differentiated, but maybe not in the same way.
But there, the difference is that the public side, which
is the entry side, is really the closed-down side.
And the private side, which is the transparent side,
is the water side that looks out to the water.
And the light really comes down and animates
that circulation space between the wall,
separating the outside, and the cellular spaces
that open out to the water.
And that differs from, say, some of the earlier houses
in that it doesn't have a kind of vertical movement system.
It's really concentrating on a horizontal movement system,
and therefore has a different kind of organization
and an idea behind it.
But it's animated, it seems to me, by the requirement.
When I first was approached by the Neugebauers,
they told me that they were about to purchase
the site in a gated community in Florida.
Sounds like trouble, but I said, do they
have any requirements in this gated community
in terms of what you can build?
They said, oh, no, no, don't worry about it.
It's going to be fine.
I told them that I was going to select you as the architect,
and they were thrilled.
I'm sure whatever you want to do is going to be all right.
I said, well, I wouldn't be so sure.
Do they have any regulations?
So I said, I think they have a little pamphlet.
I said, well, why don't you get it and send it to me,
and let me see what it says.
So he sends me his pamphlet put out by the Naples Homeowners
Association.
And one of the things it says is that all the roofs of all
the houses had to be slope roofs with a 1 in 12 slope.
So I said, you know, I don't think this is.
I don't know how to do a slope roof house.
I don't think this is for me.
He said, oh, no, no, I'm sure it's going to be fine.
Don't worry.
I said, yeah, but I can't do a slope roof house.
So he said, oh, no, no.
So we said, oh, we'll give it a try.
So we worked on it where we worked on it.
We said, OK, let's take the slope roof
and do this with it with a priority of direction
towards the water and a lower roof on the entry side.
And then light comes in from both the east and west
as well as through the skylight that separates the two.
And we had to present it to the building committee.
And we took a model down and we showed them the design.
And they said, no, no, you don't understand.
It needs a slope roof that's like this.
I said, no, but it says 1 in 12.
This is a 1 in 12 slope.
No, no, it's like this.
So we went back another time.
No, no, you don't understand this.
I said, but it doesn't say that.
It just says 1 in 12.
So they had no real way to refuse it.
Of course, afterwards, they rewrote the code
to say that it had to have an apex in the center.
But otherwise, we would never have done that house.
