DEWALT XR Power Detect 20V Reciprocating Saw DCS368 Vs Flexvolt 60v DCS389 Vs Milwaukee Fuel 2721-20

Gadgets Tools
5 followers
Hey guys, Brian from WorkshopAddict.com and we're going to take a look at DeWalt's new
PowerDetect 20 volt recip saw. It's model number DCS368 and we're going to take a look at this
saw, some of the marketing specs that they put on this saw, some of the marketing specs that they
compare the new PowerDetect saw to the FlexVolt saw, and we're also going to bring in the Milwaukee
Fuel. With that said, I want to quickly say that we're not testing blades here. We're going to try
to do a lot of things that are similar and I'm not going to do much editing, if any, to the video
so you can see what we're dealing with, how we're going through it, and everything else. But first,
let's come in and take a look at this saw. The new DeWalt FlexVolt and the new DeWalt PowerDetect
are very, very similar in construction. In fact, if you just set the two next to each other,
there are very few differences in what separates them. In fact, their specs are very similar in
that the new PowerDetect has zero to 3,000 strokes per minute and an inch and an eighth stroke.
Both these saws come in at about 7.8 pounds and the differences are very subtle. A little bit
with this rear casing and how the 20 volt tapers back where the FlexVolt is a little bit square.
You do have a PowerDetect sticker and indentation in the case that definitely sets it apart from
the FlexVolt that does not have that. A little bit more beef up on top, but other than that,
they share most of the same items. As far as not having an adjustable shoe, you do have a
simple way of attaching the blade that can go either up or down. Now this looks like
you could put it in sideways, but that does not happen and cannot happen. Variable speed trigger,
you do have a lock up top to put it in a bag and use it. Now this kit, if you were to get it,
which is going to end in W1, is going to come with the 8.0 amp hour battery in the DCV118
fast charger. I want to get into some of the marketing that DeWalt has on some of their boxes
on these. Quickly, the FlexVolt box says that it is two times more powerful than the XR.
If you actually look in here, they say that the XR is the DCS368 model, which is the PowerDetect,
but they made it with a DCB205 battery. So they say it's a five amp hour battery that they're
comparing it to with the new saw. Now this PowerDetect saw is 44% more powerful than the
model it replaces with a 5.0 amp hour battery. What's that mean? Let's get into some testing.
So all blades are not created equal. We have a lightly used Diablo blade in here. Clamps on the
wood, like we did in the FlexVolt test, I'm going to use this same blade with all the other tools
that we have. We have the PowerDetect with the fully charged eight amp hour battery.
That bounce was me hitting one of the clamps. Tighten the clamps up. Seems very similar.
Tighten the clamps again. So what did we take from that? At least what did I feel?
As I'm getting in, obviously the pressure is a little bit less. The Milwaukee seemed a bit
smoother, no doubt. Not much of a difference between the FlexVolt and the PowerDetect,
although the PowerDetect is probably going to take most of the pressure here. Let's keep testing.
So before we get into our big test, let's take the same two by eight,
same blade. I'm going to put my foot on the bottom of the jaw horse, try to hold it into place,
and let's look for vibration differences that we might see, and also the speed of cut.
So there, the Milwaukee seems smoother to me, but it seems slower and you can hear,
in my opinion, a little bit of the motor bogging down more than you do with either of the DeWalts.
But there's no doubt that there's less vibration coming from this Milwaukee. With this six by six,
we're going to be looking for speed of cut. We again have a used carbide blade here. I think
that's the best situation so that one does not have an advantage over the other from having
a non-used blade. But this is going to be interesting because we're going to look at,
again, vibration and speed of cut between all of them. Starting out with the PowerDetect.
Quite a bit of vibration there as we dumped FlexVolt off the stand. Blade is pretty warm.
That's going to be the one difference between all of them. The last guy, cutting, is going to have
a very warm blade. A little bit less vibration here, and you can see the sawdust coming out of
these holes in the wood. Testing on a six by six, I think that's a big issue because you might have
an inch and a stroke, but you're trapping a lot of that sawdust right in the center. So still good.
It seemed like it did have a little bit more power. Let's see how it compares to the Milwaukee Fuel.
And I want to note, I didn't say this earlier, but this is not the super sawzall. It's a very
comparable saw with the weight that we're going through. So huge difference in that cut. We can see
here we have another hole that came through, so that would have made this saw faster. And there's
no doubt that by the time you get through to these holes down here, the saw is cutting a lot faster
and spinning a lot more of that sawdust out. Due to this inconsistency, I'm going to shoot one more.
While we're at it, let's take the power detect and take a look at the difference between the
eight, six, five, and four amp hour batteries. I don't really feel any difference between the
eight and six. I feel like putting a little more pressure on, I can slow the saw with the five.
So there is a big difference between the five, eight, and six. And even more when you drop down to
the four. This test should stand out even more when we put a six by six in here. And we're also
going to really lean into this to try to stop this blade, see what happens. Not the best cutting while
you're leaning into it, no doubt, but you're not stopping this. Similar to the flex bolt.
Drop down to a five from the eight. We have a hole cut here. I'm going to go with it just to
see if I can stop it with the difference. Still can't stop this guy with the five.
Let's try the Milwaukee. So we have a fully charged eight amp hour battery on here,
high output, same as the DeWalt. Let's see how it does. There's no stopping this guy either.
So why this testing and why in this way? First, I want to show the difference between the power
detect tool and the flex bolt tool. To me, it's absolutely amazing how close the power detect
tools are to the flex bolt tools. That's a huge thing for me. Now, Milwaukee is the king of sawzalls.
In fact, Milwaukee is the sawzall, the rest of them are recip saws. And the vibration level has always
been great with the Milwaukee. And I think that's something to bring in here. This is not the super
sawzall. They make a much heavier, much more powerful version than this. But I think it was
great to see the time differences, even though they might not be absolutely perfect because the
wood is different. The blade is hot. There's a lot of differences going through here, but
you know what? New blades aren't all the same either. So we're just doing the best we can
testing in the environment that we're in. Now, the environment that we're in is our big virus
season that we have here, and we're in a stay at home order. So by staying at home means we're not
working with multiple people around us. So I can't have Jeff on the other side and us going at it and
then switching saws back and forth, switching blades like we normally would. So this is an
improvision to say, here's what it does. And most of you guys out here watching this are going to
either already be a Milwaukee guy or Dewalt guy and say, okay, now what am I going to buy? Is this
going to change your decision? Or you might just be interested in how this all plays out. Either
way, I want to hear some of these comments below because I really like talking with you guys. But
realistically here, asking my opinion, what would I purchase between the Flexvolt
and the Power Detect? Man, it's tough. It really is. The Power Detect has given me some crazy
battery life, and it's amazing to see the power that comes out of the tool, but the amount of
battery that's in there. And it will last longer than the Flexvolt. Why, I can't tell you, but
they're so similar. But there is definitely a power advantage to the Flexvolt. So if you need
all the power in the world, the Flexvolt's still where it's at. If you need most of that power,
but more runtime, this new Power Detect line is really hard to beat. And when you take the
technology and put it up against this Milwaukee, which is a fairly new model, the Milwaukee does
have a couple benefits, like a nice hanger, and it does have some different speeds. So if you're
cutting through metal, it's nice to just slow it down a little bit. But with that said, I really
think the Power Detect had more torque availability to keep the RPMs higher. Now, did that translate
into a faster cut? I can't tell you that yet. I'll try to put some times down in the screen,
so you might already know that answer. But it felt like there was more power. Is that actually
translating into more power or more speed? I don't know, because as we can talk about the specs and
some of these tools in the marketing that's used, this one's more than this tool, but with this
battery and with that, and that's great. There's a slice of marketing there that everybody wants
to see that, oh, this is more powerful, and I'm spending my money to get more. And you are,
you're getting more, just maybe not exactly the more that they're putting out there. So
it's interesting. It's fun to go through. I'm sorry this is a longer video than it would be.
I'm trying to leave a lot of the editing out. I don't want to cut in and out. I want to show
you guys what's happening. You can surmise different cuts, different pieces of wood,
different things, different knots, all that in the bottom. I'd love to hear your opinions on that.
I'm not trying to knock any other tool reviewer out there, because we're all trying to do
the best we can with the hand that we're given. An oscillation on either one of these DeWalt's
or the Milwaukee in wood would have sped it up a ton. It would have helped to get some of that
sawdust out and let the blades do a little more cutting. It would have helped in not rocking the
tool. That would be a game changer for either one of these, but there has to be a reason
why it's not in here. And that leads me down the fact of more things that move could mean
more things that break or could mean more things that wear out faster. I don't know.
I do know in using some of the models that oscillate that even when they're off they still
oscillate just slightly depending on how you're using them, which could cause them to cut slightly
faster. Hard to say. I do not have the rigid octane in a shape that's available to put up in
a test, nor do I have the super sawzall that's in a shape that I want to put up in a test and say,
yeah, I really respect those results because those two tools that I have are absolutely
beaten down. I'm going to put all the links from all this stuff that we've gone over in different
videos in the description. Check them out. It'll help you in seeing where we came from and where
we're going. And I think that that will kind of get you to surmise what you're seeing out there
and put it all together how it might have come to shape and how things might be going. No way
about it though, the Dewalt Power Detect tools are where it's at and they are just pouring them out
these days along with some of the new FlexVolt. And because of these are the new tools they've
kind of taken over our channel and I think it's great. It's been a blast to test them and I hope
you like it too guys. Give us a like in this video, subscribe to the channel if you haven't already,
and as always, thanks for your time and have a great day.
