How Did the Baltimore Bridge Collapse - Animated

Hightech Road Bridge
22 followers
59 Video Views·Nov 16, 2024
On the morning of March 26th, 2024, a large container ship called Dali departed from the
port of Baltimore, starting its 27-day journey to Sri Lanka, carrying nearly 4,700 containers.
A few minutes from leaving the port, it clashed with one of the main supports of the Francis
Scott Key Bridge, leading to a catastrophic collapse of the bridge and the tragic loss of
six lives. So what really happened? How can an impact like this cause destruction of a main
Why did the ship lose power a few minutes after leaving the port?
Hi, this is Joseph and you're watching The Young Hero Engineer, and in this video,
we're going to dive deeper into the reasons that led to the collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge
and the shutdown of one of the biggest ports in the US.
Danish shipping giant MESC has hired Dali for a planned trip from Baltimore to Sri Lanka,
carrying almost 4,700 containers. It was about one o'clock in the morning when the Dali departed
from the port of Baltimore. Two tugboats were helping to steer and maneuver the ship out of
the port. After the tugboats had left, the ship speeds up to 8 knots, roughly 9 miles per hour or
15 kilometers an hour, approaching the Francis Scott Key Bridge. Suddenly at 1.24 a.m., the
ship loses power, drifting off its main course, getting closer and closer to the bridge's main
pier. The ship drops anchor, and at 1.26, the pilot calls for help from nearby tugboats. At 1.27,
the ship gains power again. At that time, a Maryland Transportation Authority police officer
calls for traffic to be halted on either side of the bridge. After desperate attempts to stop the
ship, there was not enough headway, and at 1.28, the ship hits the pier head-on, leading to a
catastrophic collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge. Unfortunately, six construction workers
who were filling the potholes on the bridge did not have enough time to leave the bridge before
the collision and lost their lives. And this is what happened. But let's reconstruct the events
that led to the collapse of this bridge. First, let's talk about the Francis Key Bridge. Built in
1977, this continuous truss bridge with an arch form is primarily made of steel with a suspended
concrete deck, spanning 8,636 feet or 2.6 kilometers across the river, with the longest span
being 1,200 feet or 366 meters, with a vertical clearance of 185 feet or 56 meters. The bridge
was a major traffic and transportation hub for the U.S. East Coast and the entry point to the
Port of Baltimore, carrying 11.3 million vehicles a year. The main truss section of the bridge rests
on four supports on each side of the navigable waterways. The design was commonly used to span
large distances due to its lightweight and efficient use of materials. However, this type
of bridge was not designed to redistribute loads in the event of damage to one of its main peers.
This type of bridge is known as a fracture-critical bridge, meaning if one section sustains enough
damage, the entire structure will collapse. This is because the bridge is made of rigidly connected
truss members. This is evident when DALI collides with the bridge. The weight of the collapsing
members of the central span lifted the far end of the truss system, eventually pulling the entire
section to the ground. This is not the same for the non-truss section of the bridge. The girders
are simply supported by piers, which does not allow for damage to propagate to the other section
of the bridge. Of the roughly 615,000 bridges in the U.S., around 17,000 are fracture-critical
bridges that are quite similar to the Francis Scott Key Bridge. On the other hand, the two main
bridge piers that support the truss section were now built to handle crashes with ship containers
of the same size as DALI. DALI is a big container ship that weighs 95,000 tons when empty,
and it is 984 feet or 300 meters in length that would reach the top of the Eiffel Tower
if it stood upright. The ship has a capacity of 10,020 foot equivalent units, or TU for short.
At the time of the accident, the ship had nearly 4,700 containers. Although it is not the largest
ship in the world, it is still more than what the bridge can actually take. In fact, container ships
back in the construction of the Francis Scott Key Bridge were not as big as the DALI ship.
Container ships back in the construction of the bridge can only hold 2,000 to 3,020 foot
equivalent units. This is significantly smaller than the capacity of the DALI. A ship of that
mass and size requires a lot of power to come to a stop. The DALI was moving at about 8 knots or
just over 9 miles per hour. Given the size and momentum of the ship, it can take up to a mile
to come to a complete stop. This may have been 150,000 tons in motion, the equivalent of 15,000
buses traveling at around 9 miles per hour. During the design of the Francis Key Bridge,
the probability of a supersized container ship like DALI hitting one of the bridge's main
supports was nearly zero. Engineers do not design structures such as bridges to withstand impact to
more than what the bridge actually needs. A ship with a weight of 150,000 tons hitting the bridge
pier was never considered in the design of the bridge. However, incidents of bridge collapses
like this have happened in the past. The Sunshine Scour Bridge in Tampa Bay, Florida,
collapsed in May 1980 after a 600-mile-foot freighter rammed into one of the bridge's
supports, killing 35 people. The bridge lacked a protection system from such collisions. Because
of this incident, the Federal Highway Administration issued new standards requiring bridges being built
to have an adequate protection system to protect them from such collisions. The new Sunshine Scour
Bridge has 36 cylindrical concrete dolphins, along with two rock islands that surround the
main supports. Fenders are structures that wrap around the support columns to protect them from
damage, much more like fenders in a car. Dolphins are independent structures typically made of
concrete that are designed to stop ships from colliding with the supports, or at least reduce
the impact. Unfortunately, the Key Bridge lacks a robust protection system. The bridge dolphins
are placed well in front of the piers, leaving ample room for ships to maneuver around them.
The Key Bridge dolphins can probably stop a small boat, but not a container ship like Dolly.
This means that the current bridge protection system is outdated, and Maryland has not updated
the bridge to keep up with the current size and weight of container ships. The preferred method
for building bridges these days is to allow for redundancy. The Key Bridge did not have any
redundancy. In my city, Melbourne, Australia, the Westgate Bridge has a main span length of 1,102 feet,
or 336 meters. One of its main piers has an artificial island that wraps around the pier
to protect it from large container ships. This type of redundancy protects the bridge from such
collisions. The cost of repairing such a protection system is far less than critical damage to one of
its structural elements. A bridge such as the Francis Scott Key Bridge has a very small window
for ships to pass through, which would require tugboats to guide the ship out of the port.
Tugs can maneuver and escort vessels in dangerous and coastal waterways. The escort tug is required
to assist with the steering and stopping of large ships. If the tugboat has stuck with the ship
longer escorting through the bridge, it would have been able to keep the ship in line and prevent it
from drifting. Unfortunately, such extended tug escorts are required or mandated in Baltimore
and many other U.S. ports, mostly because of the cost they add to shipping. Each individual port
makes its own tugboat rules, resulting in a patchwork across the nation. And because of the
competition between ports for business, it has lowered the cost for extended tugboat escorts,
which can add tons of thousands of dollars for every transit. Baltimore ports operated by the
states of Maryland usually uses tugboats to help maneuver ships out of the docks and doesn't require
extended tugboat escorts into the port, unless ordered by local harbor pilots or U.S. coastguards
over safety concerns tied to weather, traffic, cargo or mechanical issues. The supply of tugboats
is also limited. Tugs are a big upfront cost for shippers and a lot of companies do not want to
pay for it. And if Baltimore start mandating the use of longer tugboat escorts, we will probably
see a reduction in their business, as ships will go to other ports wherever is cheapest.
Ship pilots in an ideal world would like to have extra tugs with them at all time,
until the ship gets to the ocean. But shipping companies don't want to pay for those tugs.
However, with the increasing size of cargo ships and the threat they pose on bridges and other
critical infrastructure, maybe they should be mandated for long escorts across the U.S.
In the end, there is still so much we don't know. The mystery of the power outage of the ship is
still under investigation. Allegations from the city of Baltimore has acclaimed that the owner
and operators of the container ship Dali were aware of the vessel was unseaworthy before it
left port. According to court documents filled by the city that Dali has experienced power
supply problems hours before departure, which was not adequately addressed. And this will likely
take a while before we know what actually happened. Incidents like this are always tragic,
but the lessons learned from them will help make future bridges better and stronger,
and improve safety protocols for ships entering and exiting ports.
Maintaining or adding bridge protection systems such as fenders or dolphins is relatively a cheap
endeavor compared to the construction of a newer bridge. It is too early to say how long it will
take to open the ports of Baltimore or replace the destroyed bridge. However, it probably won't
take any less than two years to replace the bridge. Thanks for watching. If you're here
for the first time, I make videos about bridges. You can check those videos here.
Also, consider subscribing for future videos. See you in the next one. Cheers!
