(Ep. 207) Student Loan Cancellation Is Blocked. Now What?
#A Texas judge blocked student loan cancellation, effectively stopping it in its tracks. Plus, the midterm elections will have an enormous impact on student loans going forward. Between these two events, you could feel the effects even if you wouldn’t benefit from cancellation specifically. I’m diving into the student loan lawsuits, the temporary pause on student loan cancellation, and what will happen when student loan payments resume.
Welcome to another episode of the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
This is your host, Travis Hornsby.
Today, we're going to talk about what happened with midterms
and what it means for student loans going forward.
And we're also going to talk about student loan cancellation.
And specifically, we're going to talk about the court case
that's blocking student loan cancellation
and what does that mean next for everyone's student loans.
You know, I think it has really big implications,
even if you wouldn't benefit from cancellation that much,
because it's going to certainly impact student loan policy writ large.
And it's going to be a big deal no matter what.
Let's talk first about the blocking of student loan cancellation
with that lawsuit in Texas.
And what does that mean for student loans?
For those of you that haven't been following this particularly closely,
the student loan cancellation program that President Biden put forward in August
is now blocked and suspended, eliminated, temporarily pending appeal.
A separate court case was filed in Texas.
Everyone was focused on the one that is currently in the 8th Circuit right now.
That case started out in the Eastern District of Missouri,
and the judge basically dismissed it and said nobody had standing.
And the argument in that case, you know, that was filed by six Republican
led states and mostly in the Midwest.
Those states essentially argued, hey, we're going to be negatively impacted
with our tax revenues.
We're going to also Mojito is going to be negatively impacted,
which is an arm of the state of Missouri, and therefore Missouri can sue
on behalf of Mojito.
So the argument was that nobody had standing on the government side
and no one was harmed, basically, because Mojito would have had to sue on their own.
And Representative Cori Bush, who represents St.
Lewis, got a letter out of Mojito basically saying that they did not intend
to be a part of the lawsuit.
They were not involved in it in any way.
And so that case was at least wobbling a little bit.
But the judges on that court did decide to issue a sort of an administrative
stay, which is like a pause.
They can't cancel any debt until they rule on whether or not
there's going to be an injunction.
So that was the status of the Eighth Circuit Court case.
And everybody was focused on that one because that was perhaps the most organized.
Perhaps you could say the best funded, the best resourced.
That was the primary case that was drawing people's attention.
So I have to admit that I even missed this.
I would like to maybe play some of the blame on the chaos in my personal life
with trying to figure out the logistics of bringing a baby home,
possibly on oxygen from the hospital.
So I'm not as deep into texting all the other student loan experts
I know trying to get their thoughts, like as I maybe normally am.
And so I definitely missed this in the last newsletter update
because I thought after the midterms being a little bit more
better for Democrats than was anticipated, you know, that would maybe mean
the cancellation would be a little safer, actually.
But I did not see this Texas lawsuit coming out of left field.
And that's what happens with student loans sometimes.
You can really have a really good understanding of the rules
and then something very unexpected pops you in the face.
So what exactly happened with this?
The Job Creators Network is a right leaning organization
that had said that they were going to try to block student loan
cancellation from the start.
So this is an organization that is funded by the co-founder of Home Depot.
They are big financial backers of sort of right leaning causes.
And they waited to file their lawsuit until later in the process
compared to some of the ones that were filed.
So if you recall, there was one filed by Pacific Legal Foundation
that was basically put up by a borrower that was Indiana
who was going to have to pay state income taxes.
And the administration responded quickly to say, well, actually,
people can opt out of this.
And so you won't get taxes on cancellation and therefore you don't have standing.
And so that case got blocked because of that.
And then another case in Wisconsin was basically saying, hey,
giving cancellation, they seized on some remarks
by the White House press secretary that said this is going to help
close the racial wealth gap.
And this Wisconsin taxpayer group sued, stating that that was a violation
of the 14th Amendment that guarantees equal protection under the law,
regardless of race or ethnic background.
And the courts found that that didn't have standing,
that that wasn't a legitimate argument.
And so those were two cases that were shot down.
Those were, we thought, less serious than the, you know,
the Republican attorney's general lawsuit,
just because that they had that Mohilla part of their argument, which was,
you know, you could make a good argument that Mohilla is not part of the state
of Missouri, that it's a separate entity,
that Missouri would not have the authority to sue on behalf of Mohilla,
that Mohilla would have to decide to sue independently.
But that is a big question.
And, you know, a right leaning court might decide
that they do have the power to sue on behalf of Mohilla.
And that would certainly be an impacted organization financially
by suit alone cancellation.
And there was a lot weaker arguments in this case that those states had about,
you know, having negative impacts from state tax revenue that they wouldn't get.
Like if the loans were canceled later than after the American Rescue Plan expires,
it makes due unforgiveness tax free on a federal level,
that they would have 1099s issued to borrowers
and the states would be able to collect taxes on that.
So those were less strong arguments.
Another argument they made,
which was actually key in the success of this Texas lawsuit,
is they made an argument that Nebraska invested in some FFEL loans
and basically stated that by giving an incentive to consolidate
that the state of Nebraska's pension funds would lose money in their investments
because these bonds were trading, you know, I think above par probably,
which means that they would be marked down when they would be consolidated.
Now, Department of Education actually offered to pay above par,
from what I understand, on those FFEL loans to try to ward off lawsuits.
I'm not sure exactly how they did that because that's, you know,
I would assume that that would require some sort of appropriation.
Somebody who knows more about this than I do said that
some departments have large amounts of discretionary funds
that they're able to allocate in a way that the secretary sees fit.
And so that was kind of what they were doing with that.
But of course, Nebraska wasn't interested in receiving back
the market value of the investment.
They were using this to try to block the student loan cancellation.
And what the Department of Ed did very intelligently and necessarily,
is they said, okay, well, anybody who consolidates
after September 29, 2022 is not going to be included in this cancellation plan
because we cannot provide an ongoing incentive to consolidate.
And that was really the thing that ended up being key in this judge
who was appointed by George W. Bush,
shooting down the lawsuit at that Eastern District of Missouri level.
So basically the judge said, hey, I agree with the government here that
since there's no ongoing incentive to consolidate
because you took the commercially held FFEL loans issued before 2010
out of this student debt relief program,
that means that the plaintiffs don't have an argument
because he found that Mohilla had to sue on its own if they wanted to sue,
that Mohilla didn't have, or Missouri didn't have the right to sue
on behalf of Mohilla.
He found the arguments about state tax revenue losses to be weak.
And he found that since there was no ongoing incentive to consolidate
that nobody had standing to block it.
Of course, the people in that lawsuit immediately appealed it to the 8th Circuit.
The 8th Circuit is one of the most conservative courts in the whole country.
If you think about the composition,
I believe there's only one justice on the 8th Circuit of Appeals
that's appointed by a Democratic president.
And so they issued a temporary pause on this actual bringing of relief.
Really the theory that pretty much everybody, I think,
pro and against student loan cancellation has
is once it starts going out the door,
there's no stopping it and there's no reversing it.
That's what happened.
They issued a pause on student loan cancellation.
And notably, they actually didn't make any ruling
on a more permanent injunction until after the election,
which is really interesting.
I think that if you tend to be left-leaning,
I think you would argue that was very intentional
to not hurt Republican candidates.
If you are more right-leaning,
you might say that they needed an appropriate amount of time
to decide this case or something.
I don't know.
I mean, to me, it certainly does feel like the goal
that the 8th Circuit had was to not give either side
sort of a win before the election.
I think you could make a reasonable argument
that it certainly seems to be in line
with a right-leaning bent on the way they would rule on that.
Now, in terms of the decision from that court,
what that did is that gummed up cancellation
and stopped it from happening
and gave time for the court in Texas
to make their own ruling independently
of what this case was being decided in the 8th Circuit.
So let's talk about this Texas case.
Remember earlier I said that this lawsuit down in Texas
was funded by this conservative right-leaning group
and they found two key borrowers
that were impacted in a negative way.
And why did I go down that rabbit hole?
So remember that the administration
had to stop people with commercially held debt
that didn't consolidate by September 29th.
They blocked them from getting cancellation
under the program.
So what they did is this conservative group
found someone who had commercially held FFEL debt
that would have qualified for the program
if they had consolidated before September 29th.
And since they didn't consolidate,
they were left out of the program.
The group brought forward this challenger who said,
hey, I didn't get my cancellation.
This is a violation because I was harmed economically
by not getting cancellation
because of this arbitrary decision
by the Department of Ed.
They found somebody else who also sued
based off of being a non-Pell Grant borrower.
They also said, hey, I only got 10,000 cancellation.
I should be getting 20 like everyone else
because this program was arbitrarily decided.
If we think about what is going on here,
clearly you would not agree
to have your name used in a lawsuit
to try to stop student loan cancellation
unless you were very personally imposed to it, right?
They had to find two people
that were very opposed to student loan cancellation
that did not mind putting their names forward
as plaintiffs to try to stop it.
Because these two individuals were definitely harmed
by the Department of Education's design of the program,
that gave an opening for a Trump-appointed judge in Texas
in a federal court there, a lower level of federal court,
to say, hey, look,
these two individuals were harmed economically
and so now I can proceed to the merits of the case.
I think if you're more of a democratic-leaning nature,
you would say that's a ridiculous interpretation of standing.
If somebody can say,
hey, I was harmed by an agency decision economically,
then basically every single agency decision
around the country could be challenged this way.
I'm not gonna make a definitive statement on standing
because I'm not a lawyer, you know?
I mean, certainly I talked to a lot of friends that are lawyers
and they think that the standing argument is ridiculous.
I don't see that many conservative-leaning people
saying that the standing argument is great,
but I'll say that they got over that hurdle,
this particular judge got over that hurdle of,
hey, can anybody legitimately challenge this
by saying that they were economically harmed?
And they identified these two borrowers,
so then the judge basically went straight
to the merits of the case and said,
hey, because I'm able to rule on the merits of the case
because I found these two people that were harmed,
because there's this prior court case
that says individuals that are harmed
by an agency's action can bring a lawsuit
so I can look at the merits of the case.
That was basically what the problem
with the Eastern Court of Missouri,
they basically said, well,
yeah, this program from the merits of the case
might not be super legal,
but I can't make a ruling on that
because I need to have standing,
somebody needs to have standing
for me to make a ruling on that.
So this judge kind of made the different decision of,
hey, yeah, I have their standing
of these two borrowers that were harmed,
and then I'm gonna rule on the merits.
And so what they said on the merits of the case
is that suit alone cancellation,
in this judge's view,
does not line up with what the HEROES Act allows.
So the HEROES Act, you know,
you don't have to go through
the normal rulemaking process to make rules.
What this judge says is,
no, this is not a fair use of the HEROES Act.
And therefore, if the administration
wanted to do this,
they would have had to go through
the public comment period.
And since they didn't go through
the public comment period,
they're in violation of
the Administrative Procedures Act.
And because of that,
and because of the major questions doctrine,
which basically says that judges
can have judicial review over items
of great economic and political significance.
That's been something that was looked at
with an EPA case, some other cases as well.
And so basically this judge found that
because the merits of the case were,
in this judge's words,
a major abuse of legislative authority
by the executive branch,
that the whole program was null and void
and the program was suspended and over.
So this was not even an injunction.
The judge basically said,
suit alone cancellation is over.
It's not legal, move on.
Of course, the Biden administration
immediately appealed this ruling
to the Fifth Circuit.
So now we have two cases
on suit alone cancellation,
the Eighth Circuit and the Fifth Circuit.
Now the Fifth Circuit is one of the other
most conservative appeals courts
in the country.
So there's only a handful of folks appointed
or judges appointed by Democratic presidents
on this court of appeals.
That means that you're going to probably
see this get appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Fifth Circuit and the Eighth Circuit
both have two different legal arguments
that they can use to stop
suit alone cancellation.
This is something that conservative legal minds
are very, very opposed to.
I mean, it kind of makes sense
why a conservative-leaning judge
would be opposed to this,
just because of separation of powers,
Congress has power of the purse.
This is spending four, five,
$600 billion without Congress.
And a conservative-leaning judge
wouldn't like that.
And what I would expect to happen next
is the Eighth Circuit or the Fifth Circuit
is going to say,
hey, this suit alone program is not legal.
We could very much see a split ruling.
The Eighth Circuit might say,
hey, there's no standing here.
We're dismissing the challenge
and the Fifth Circuit could say,
hey, we find that these two borrowers
were injured and we're upholding
the lower court ruling.
So you would get conflicting rulings.
But even if you didn't get conflicting rulings,
even if the Eighth Circuit
and the Fifth Circuit
did not decide in favor of the government,
it's going to get appealed.
It's going to get appealed
no matter what, basically, right?
If these appeals courts find in favor
of the plaintiffs
and say the suit alone program is illegal,
you know, then it's going to get appealed.
And then if the lower courts
find that the program is legal,
then opponents of the program
are going to appeal it.
What's really obvious to me now
is suit alone lawsuits
are all going to end up
at the Supreme Court at some point.
And with the composition of the court
that obviously was willing
to overturn Roe v. Wade,
I would be pretty surprised
if the Supreme Court
upheld suit alone cancellation now.
So the big question was,
is anybody going to find standing
to challenge suit alone cancellation?
You have to have a plaintiff
that was economically harmed
to bring a lawsuit that's successful, period.
And that's why everybody was assuming
that maybe this cancellation
is actually going to happen.
But now that there's at least one court
that's found, yes, they're standing,
and yes, this program is unconstitutional,
I would be very surprised now
if it happens the way
that it was expected to happen.
I kind of missed the mark on this.
I just want to admit that,
like, because in a newsletter update
I gave last week, I said,
hey, you know, Democrats did much better
in the midterms
if they do end up holding the House
or coming very close to holding the House.
You know, you might have a House GOP
that's a little chastened
and not willing to challenge
suit alone cancellation in court.
And if nobody can prove
that they have standing,
then maybe this cancellation is upheld
and it happens.
And certainly industry groups
want this to happen
because what's going to come next
is going to be real chaotic.
And so I'll tell you
why I think groups like a SoFi
or Nelnet haven't sued, right?
Because those are corporate entities
that are negatively harmed
by suit alone cancellation
and a lot of the different
suit alone relief actions
taken by the Biden administration.
So you can,
if you're looking for somebody
with economic injury,
there's definitely private entities out there
that originate private loans,
refinance student loans,
you know, service student loans
that could all make an argument
they were economically harmed
and sue to block
any of these different measures.
But why have they not done that?
And the reason is because
you've essentially have this political
just nightmare
if you're a Democratic president
where, now you might say
maybe it's not as much
of a nightmare anymore
because any kind of argument
that student loan cancellation
is a political albatross
might not really hold water anymore.
If you really look
at the midterm elections,
you might have even helped
the Democrats, right?
You might not care as much anymore.
Like you might have pre-midterms
in terms of, you know,
is student loan cancellation
in a big scale
a good idea politically, right?
But if you're a Democratic president
with Biden, I mean,
Biden was going to start student loans again
in January of 2022, right?
He was going to start them up.
He said, this is the final pause.
And then what happened?
Build Back Better fell apart.
It was a signature legislation.
Progressives were furious over this.
The mainstream Democrats
were also furious over this,
and they wanted action
on something the president could control.
And the student loan pause
was something that he could control.
And so therefore he changed his mind
and extended the student loan pause
and then extended it again.
And what is clear, right,
is Joe Biden wants
to run again for president.
And so what do you need
to run again for president?
Support.
And if he had been wiped out,
if his party had been
wiped out in the midterms,
you know, it'd be pretty hard
to make an argument
for him being the nominee in 2024.
But because his party did really well
for any compared
to any other Democratic
president in recent memory
in the past 50 years,
he's got a decent argument
of being renominated, right?
And so his restarting
of student loan payments
was really contingent
upon canceling all this debt
so that they could get rid
of the spike in defaults
that everybody knows
is going to happen,
because if you take away
a bill for a month,
what do people do?
Well, you get some relief
and then you know
the bill's coming back.
And so you keep that in your budget.
If you pause the bill for a year,
what do you do?
Well, you're still
getting some relief.
Maybe you go out and you buy
some like temporary items
and big ticket items
like a car, a vacation,
you know, some sort of
more moderate expense, right?
Like a new bike or something
or a new place
that for your kids,
depending on how much
student loans you have.
But if you have a pause
that goes on for multiple years,
which is what we've had,
you start like adjusting your budget.
You start saying, you know what?
I don't really think
this bill's going to come back.
Particularly if you have,
I would say less awareness
of what's going on
in the student loan kind of world,
which graduate degree holders,
professional degree holders
tend to have the most awareness
of what's going on
in the student loan world,
just because of virtue
of being more educated, right?
Being more privileged
than folks with less education
and lower income levels.
What a lot of people have done,
what millions of people have done
is they have written off
student loans in their mind
from their budgets.
And so we know that defaults
are going to spike
whenever they do turn on
student loans again.
The question is,
is how much will it spike?
And so the Biden administration
definitely wanted to avoid
this economic pain
and avoid this negative headline,
especially given the polarization
of education levels
across the different parties, right?
Because, you know,
if you look at
college educated voters,
there's greater polarization
between the parties now
than ever before,
where college educated voters
are more likely to be Democrats
and non-college educated voters
are more likely to be Republicans.
So this is a group of voters
that is super important
to the Democratic Party.
Also tends to be younger voters,
borrowers of color,
disproportionately
that would be impacted by this.
So the administration
needs to take care
of this group of borrowers.
This is a way
that they can get out
of the trap they were in,
where nobody wants
to start repayments again.
The only reward they're going to get
from starting repayments again
is just a lower budget deficit
and possibly very slightly
lower inflation.
And some people argue
that that's not the case.
There wouldn't even be
that much inflation
if they didn't restart payments.
There's not a big reward
for being the,
let's turn on student loans again,
kind of person, right?
And so this was the way
where the Biden administration
could get out of the tough spot
they're in
of turning on payments again
while also not having
these default spike
and also being able to claim,
hey, we're not giving this benefit
to high income people.
This is for working people
because we're limiting it
to only 10 or 20,000.
We're going to give it
to only people
that make below 125,000 a year.
We're going to give more
to people that had Pell Grants
because they were lower income people
who needed more.
This whole thing was very crafted
to try to fit within the parameters
of what they thought
that they could do politically.
And I think that people
before the midterms too
thought that this
was a losing proposition.
I think people looked
at cancellation and they thought,
hey, Democrats were struggling
with working class voters.
A bad idea is to look
even more pro highly educated voters
if we're trying to win over
this group of people.
There was a lot of skepticism.
If you look at people like Tim Ryan,
like Maggie Hassan,
I believe Cortez Masto in Nevada,
people that were in these sort
of swing states,
those folks in general
opposed student loan cancellation.
They didn't support it publicly,
which is telling
because they believed
that it was a losing issue.
Otherwise, they would have supported it.
Most likely.
Let's talk about the midterms a little bit.
And while this blocking
of student loan cancellation
might result in people
that are going for forgiveness
to get basically,
I would say more money saved
than if you might have gotten
direct cancellation,
depending on how they end up doing it.
So let's talk about that.
The midterm elections,
Democrats did much better than expected.
Why is that?
If you look at the pundits
and I am not a political analyst,
but I like to read
a lot of this stuff for fun.
And so I'm just going to parrot
what people have said.
If you look at states
where, you know,
abortion rights and democracy
were not as much at risk,
like New York and Florida,
Republicans performed
very much in line
with what you would expect
in a midterm.
That's happening
when there's the other party in power.
So Republicans beat
expectations in Florida,
beat expectations in New York
in terms of their vote share.
And in those kind of states,
there wasn't a risk of,
you know, abortion getting curtailed.
What's interesting is
if you look at DeSantis,
who really outperformed expectations,
would not be perhaps
what media would describe
as a outright election denier.
And also he was not willing
to go more intense
on abortion restrictions
than 15 weeks
compared to some other governors
that were willing to go
more restrictive than that.
This is what pundits have said, right?
Is that if you look at these states
where Republicans did better,
it's these states
where abortion and democracy
were not key issues.
But if you look at states
where they were key issues,
Republicans really underperformed.
Those were kind of the big key issues
in the midterms,
what people are saying is,
you know, abortion and democracy.
And secondarily,
people noticed that there was
not abysmal young voter turnout.
And a lot of people are saying
that this is due to a couple things.
They're not saying it's just one issue,
but they're saying climate action,
and they're saying
student loan cancellation
are kind of the big things
that people are saying
as to why young voters
turned out in decent enough numbers
to prevent this from being
a red wave election.
What that's kind of suggesting
is that student loan cancellation
is a winning issue
because Democrats,
at a minimum,
they were not punished for it.
And you can make an argument
that they were rewarded for it
because young voters showed up,
not in massive numbers,
but, you know, in good enough numbers
for a midterm
that it wasn't a bad election for them.
And so if you're, you know,
Biden looking at this
and you get blocked
from your signature
student loan relief
via the cancellation plan,
you're going to look for
what other avenues you've got.
He might go the Higher Education Act
Compromise and Settle Authority path
where he tries to do cancellation
via a rulemaking process.
He might try to do that.
I would assume that a court
would find the same path
that he can't do that
if they're blocking it
based on the HEROES Act.
I would assume they would block it
based on the Higher Education Act, too.
So if he can't go through that path
to get relief for people,
then what I might expect
is he might go through
the Income Driven Repayment Plan
and the Public Service
Loan Forgiveness Regulations
and try to go that route instead.
And so there's probably
an internal discussion of
how hard do you go?
How intense do you go on these programs?
Because the folks
on the Negotiated Rulemaking Committee,
you know, asked for some
super aggressive stuff.
They wanted 400% of the poverty line
for borrowers to, you know,
before you had to make a payment.
They were definitely interested
in shorter time frames
to forgiveness, right?
Like seven years, ten years.
They were interested in
cancellation every year
through the IDR programs.
And they were interested
in lowering payments for people.
And they were also interested
in making sure that this new IDR plan,
in every single case imaginable,
would be the best plan.
And also in removing any barriers
to borrowers switching out of old plans
into this new plan
so that the simplification
of the student loan system
could be accomplished
by making one new plan
that is so generous
that every single person in the world
would switch to it.
And every single person
who just checks that box,
hey, put me on the plan
with the lowest payment,
would switch into that plan.
Because, you know,
there's now no interest capitalization
unless you're leaving the IBR program
or consolidating after July of 2023.
And so that was the goal
of negotiated rulemaking.
And there's probably
some moderate Democrats
and career staffers
in the Department of Education
that might've pushed back
on that a little bit
and said, well, hey,
like let's take this half step
of a Biden IDR plan
that is going to be 5%
of income for undergrads,
10% for grad students.
It's going to be 20 years.
It's going to be 10 years
till forgiveness
if you're basically having
very small amounts of debt.
And we're also going to expand
the definition of public service
loan forgiveness.
And there's some different options
that they're looking at.
And here's kind of
an interesting stat for you.
I like to follow
some of the different
consumer advocate groups on Twitter.
This picture is coming
from Ben Kaufman.
I think it works
for the Student Borrower
Protection Center, I believe.
Apologies, Ben, if I misstated that.
But he's showing some different
percentages of borrowers
that could get PSLF
and with the different rules
the Biden administration
is considering.
And they estimate that borrowers
that borrowed
for graduate degree holders
before 2010,
only 0.4% of them
would have qualified for PSLF.
That's because very few
graduate borrowers
would have only direct loans.
Now, people that borrowed
between 2011, 2015,
about 13% of graduate degree holders
could qualify.
2016 to 2020, about 22%
would qualify.
2021 and later, about 31%
would qualify.
Now, with the new regulations
that they're looking at,
one option is
instead of 30%
of graduate degree holders
going forward,
about 34% would qualify for PSLF.
So this is doing things like
expanding the type of employers
that could qualify, right?
Like Kaiser Permanente,
making certain kinds
of adjunct faculty
able to get this, right?
Now, they're considering
alternative scenarios too
where instead of 34%
of graduate degree holders
getting PSLF,
38% would get PSLF.
What I'm trying to explain
is that the administration
can take a lot of little tweak,
you know, tweaking of the rules
to back the truck up
and try to get people
as much forgiveness as possible
without coming under fire
as directly by all these lawsuits.
Because here's something
that's pretty obvious to me.
The IDR waiver provides
an ongoing incentive to consolidate.
Absolutely, right?
If you would say that
the cancellation of 10 or 20,000
provides an incentive to consolidate,
which, you know,
the Department of Ed
felt the need to rush
to say if you consolidate
on or after the state,
you don't qualify, right?
If you're looking at your portfolio
of FFEL loans,
getting 10 or 20K
canceled if you consolidate
certainly is a reason
why somebody would do it.
But the idea that you would get
15 years out of 20 years
applied to your IBR plan
or get your balance
canceled completely,
there's like $211 billion of loans
that could be canceled
with the IDR waiver, we estimate.
And so that's probably
at least half of the FFEL loan portfolio.
And so that definitely provides
an incentive to consolidate,
but none of the Nebraska pension funds
have sued over that.
That's probably partly
because they're focused
on this cancellation thing first,
and maybe partly because the rules
of the IDR waiver
haven't been published yet.
But I think it's also
because people want
the glory of the headlines.
You know, stopping the IDR waiver
is kind of a niche kind of thing.
It's not going to get you glory
in conservative circles
like stopping Biden's
student loan cancellation might.
I think that's just my take.
And so if the Biden administration
goes super aggressive
with regulations,
with getting more people
to qualify for PSLF,
being more aggressive
on how generous the IDR plan is,
that stuff is probably
not quite as subject
to legal challenges
and probably isn't as exciting
for conservative groups to challenge.
And so that's kind of
the path forward, I think,
for the administration
that we might see.
And it might be why
we didn't see the rules
for the IDR plan released
like we were anticipating
by November of 2022.
I think that possibly
what the goal was
is to wait and see
with this cancellation lawsuit
barrage that they were getting,
see how that shaked out.
If I had to guess,
this is a very speculative guess,
so I apologize that
this ends up being incorrect.
But if I was the Biden administration,
I would probably extend the pause
on student loans
until July of 2023.
Why?
It's because you could argue,
well, that's because
all these lawsuits,
we needed this to let borrowers
that are struggling
be able to have a better success
of entering repayment
by getting rid of the 10
and 20K balances
that struggling borrowers
are battling with the most.
And so we want to get rid
of this kind of balance.
Then we can have people
start repayments
and we'll eventually give them
a bit more generous IDR plan.
But since you were not
punished electorally
from all the student loan relief
that you were trying to do
as the administration,
ultimately, I don't think
the administration cares
about getting an extra
20 to 50 billion
of student loan payment
revenue back in the treasury, right?
It's a fairly small amount of money
compared to the other initiatives.
Why wouldn't you
just extend it to July?
I'm not saying that it will be.
One of the issues is,
you know, the story of,
what is it, Chicken Little
or the Boy Who Cried Wolf
or something like that, right?
If you say something once,
people will believe you
and then it doesn't happen.
And then you might say it again
and people might come out
and say, OK, let's, you know, help.
And then if, so in other words,
if you say something twice
and you don't do it,
people are really not going
to believe you the third time.
And if the administration
does start payments in January,
like they've said they will,
I think that that's probably
going to be the reason
why they do it
is because they know
that if they don't restart payments
and tell people that it's
not going to happen a second time,
you know, then nobody's
going to believe them
when they say that payments
actually do end up starting again.
I don't know.
It's hard to really estimate this stuff,
but that's one path
that could take extending
the pause until July 2023.
I mean, obviously we'll know for sure
if they do start payments
on January or sorry,
if they start interest on January 1st,
they won't start payments
until about January 30th,
but they would start
interest January 1st.
And so when that happens,
we know for sure that,
you know, payments definitely
are starting up again, right?
The first day of interest
being charged is the time
that we know it's going to be the case.
And then the other thing
that we're looking for
is the draft release
of the IDR plan rules.
Now, they've already come out
and said what the parameters
are going to be,
but they haven't released
the proposed language yet,
which means that they could respond
to this lawsuit,
you know, against cancellation
by saying, well, we have no choice
because of what these Republicans
are trying to do to harm borrowers
than to come out
with an even more generous program
through the existing IDR authority
that we have in Department of Ed
to go even bigger and provide
even more relief directly for borrowers
through the income
based repayment programs.
And if you have a very small
Republican majority in Congress
or even a Democratic majority
in Congress in the House,
then probably there's nothing
they can really do to stop that.
Perhaps that pandemic
health emergency doesn't get suspended
now for a while longer.
And so you might be able
to move things around,
make rules a lot more aggressive.
Who knows?
So I do think that the new IDR plan,
regardless, is going to be available
sometime at the earliest
in December 2023
because they did not publish the rules
by November 1st of 2022.
So they might use
some bureaucratic maneuvering
to get it released early
like they did with the repay program.
Generally, you're supposed to have
the language released and finished
up by November 1st of the prior year
to have it taken to effect
July of the following year.
And so for that reason,
I don't think we would necessarily see
that Biden plan by until
maybe the end of 2023
or maybe at worst until July of 2024.
And that's another reason
why if there was a Republican
takeover in 2024 of the White House,
you know, if they did
the negotiated rulemaking
and they got all the language together
by November 2025,
the very earliest
you could take away the Biden plan
would be July of 2026.
And most likely,
they couldn't get everything
put together by then.
So that means July 2027.
And if that were to happen
with the new rules on giving,
you know, weighted average credit
after a consolidation
that are coming after July of 2023,
it might actually be a smart idea
to consolidate again
and get that new Biden IDR plan
in your promissory note,
just in case, you know,
Republican administration
comes down the line
and takes that program away.
Remember, what we think
is if it's in your promissory note,
you've got it
and they can't take it away.
That's what we think.
And if you look at the repay
and then pay programs,
anybody who's done a consolidation
or borrowed loans since 2016
has that language
in their promissory notes.
Anybody who's borrowed since 2014
has got the new IVR plan
in their promissory note.
And that's a vote,
a program that would require
60 votes in the Senate to overturn.
So the new IVR program,
if you've borrowed
for the first time after July 2014,
you're set no matter
what anybody does in the future,
because there's no way
that they would repeal new IVR
unless they had a supermajority
in the Senate
and the White House,
Republicans did.
And this obviously doesn't seem
like that's going to happen
anytime soon.
So there's a lot going on
with Student Loans right now.
We might have some of the other
team members on the pod
because I'm going to be
deep in handling dad duties here
for the next couple to several months.
We've got baby coming over
from the NICU.
So I'm going to be pretty
going to have my hands full.
And we will do our very best
to come out with
the latest breaking updates
on Student Loan stuff
so that you know.
If you have any questions
about any of this,
we'd love to hear from our listeners.
You just go to
studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail.
You can do this on a phone.
You just go to type it in
studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail.
If you type it into your browser,
it's going to take you to a spot
where you can press that record button
and ask your question.
I'm going to not always
get things right.
So I just want to say that
I do not have a perfect hit rate.
I don't think anybody
that is involved in something
that's very uncertain
can have a perfect hit rate.
Again, sorry that I missed
on the Texas lawsuit.
That kind of came out of left field.
Everybody was looking at the 8th Circuit.
Pretty much nobody anticipated
that the 5th Circuit
was going to be important
in this student loan
cancellation battle.
And regardless of what happens,
I think for the rest of the year,
we're going to see battles over this.
It's going to get appealed
to the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court says,
hey, this is not something
that you can do.
Then I think we will see
the Biden administration
that is not chastened
from a bad midterm result, right,
is going to continue to go big
in the relief
they're providing borrowers
through executive action.
And the reason why
that's kind of important
is because they're doing it
through executive action.
It's going to be more complicated.
It's going to be more involved.
The rules are going
to be more confusing.
And ultimately the rules
in some cases could be taken away,
depending on if somebody else
takes over the White House
in 2024 or 2028.
So one of the things
that we're going to be doing
in our consults
is just looking at,
hey, this is what
the Biden plan looks like.
This is what the existing
plans look like.
And if you had sort of an effort
to remove all of the executive
student loan relief actions,
what would you qualify for
that's just based on the statute,
which is generally old IBR
or new IBR?
We're going to be trying
to stay nimble
and look at all this for you.
Hope folks ask questions
via the voicemail line.
And then if you have any need
for a consult right now,
specifically people that have
any of these older types of loans,
lots of forbearances or deferments,
we're telling people to consolidate
with the IDR waiver.
There's some cases
where you would not consolidate,
but you should definitely get help
with the IDR waiver.
This is people that have long-term
deferments or forbearances,
people that have loans
they've borrowed over
very different numbers of years,
people that have got loans
that were not paused
during the pandemic,
and people that just in general
want to understand
what this IDR waiver means for them.
If you could save money,
if you could save money,
it's like generally 100 times
our consult fee.
So it's sort of like
if somebody could show up
to look at your plumbing
and prevent maybe a 75, 80% chance
that they're going to find a mistake
about your plumbing
that's $50,000 plus in savings.
And worst case scenario,
they come out for a few hundred bucks
and they don't find anything
that you need to change,
in which case you get peace of mind
knowing that there's nothing
that's going to burst and go wrong.
I mean, that's how we model things.
You know, if you think about
some attorneys,
they do contingency fees
and you take a percent of the savings.
If we did that,
a whole lot of our fees
would be in the thousands of dollars
for people,
and that's not a good
consumer-friendly model,
in my opinion,
when we're doing things
the way we do them.
That's why we charge
the way we charge.
Some people prefer a contingency fee,
but like, again,
we think that if you're going
to be charging people
a percent of the savings or something,
that's just not a
consumer-friendly model,
in my opinion.
So if you need to help,
steelloanplanner.com slash book.
Our team is doing lots of consults right now,
specifically around the IDR waiver.
And also, you know,
if you wanted to look at
what the Biden IDR plan
would mean for your loan payments
when they start up
and how much you might be able
to save through that,
if that could be a better alternative
than paying back your loans,
we're also doing a lot of that as well.
So any questions,
leave a question on the voicemail line.
Thank you much for listening
to the Student Loan Planner Podcast.

