What Should We Do With A Gifted Whole Life Policy?

The Ramsey Show Highlights
1.8K followers
124 Video Views·Nov 10, 2024
[Music]
brought to you by the every dollar app
start budgeting for free today okay so
um I will exercise brevity here I have
extremely generous and thoughtful
in-laws um they do very well though they
are not you know ramsy principal people
and with that being said a couple years
ago they opened uh Whole Life policies
for all four of their children that they
pay for and technically own but when
they gifted it at Christmas they said
you know we opened these policies but
they're yours if you want to cash it out
if you want to add to it if you want to
just let it sit that's totally up to you
okay Flash Forward three years later now
that we're married because they gifted
the policy when we were dating oh W um I
would like to cash out the policy
because my husband and I both have term
insurance so we're covered there on our
own I would like to cash it out and put
it in a high yield which the interest
would probably cover what contributing
every month anyway which is $65 yeah but
my husband doesn't want to be ungrateful
or um have a difficult conversation and
I don't know if my mindset should be
like you know what technically brass tax
they own the policy it's their money
should it be out of side out of mind or
should I push for this because it's what
we follow in our marriage I mean they
said you could cash it out right they
did who are the policies for right now
you said there's four of them they have
four children and they open Whole Life
policies on all four children but they
own the parents still own all the
policies and they're listed as the
beneficiaries not the wi oh that's
interesting so the policy's on him like
it's we're talking about one policy and
how much do they pay per month for this
policy
$65 okay and what's the like what's the
cash value after the surrender charge it
would be about 11,400 at this point okay
and you're saying hey we put that in a
high yield we're going to make the 5
back and we don't need this policy what
if and it would be something if it
wasn't a high yield that I would
contribute to where I'm not going to
throw money into a whole life policy
into a terrible product with a terrible
return absolutely well what is their
intent at this point paying for a grown
man's whole life policy well I think I
was trying to Rack my brain about that
too and the only thing that crossed my
mind is are they trying to just set this
up as a savings plan so all of their
kids have money to pay inheritance tax
when they go you know like so if there
are expenses based on their inheritance
they already know that they've helped
put aside money to cover that how
wealthy are these people inheritance tax
not going to kick in unless we're
talking like $20
million yeah they're very wealthy okay I
don't know if I'd touch this I don't
know that 65 bucks a month is gonna also
pay for any meaningful taxes if we're
going to be honest right right right
there's there's part of me um just
listening to you talk I don't know if I
touch this because this was in kind of
in it was in place a before you guys
were married um it's their money that
they're spending that and the fact that
you are not the beneficiary kind of lets
me know that this is just something that
they're doing it doesn't really make
sense to me but who cares it's
not I I would tend to not try to control
this it's almost like like my
mother-in-law has a 529 setup um for the
kids and that was something she did I'm
happy she did it and she put some in it
and we some in it too I could try to be
like oh no I want to do this dates 529
and I want to change it but I'm like
this is something nice she's doing and
she did it for the State of Florida cuz
that's the state you're in and that's
fine um I'm just grateful for it and
it's still some money that I wouldn't
have had before so I'm like okay great
and and I'm not going to touch it cuz if
I think that it's going to stir up a
hornets nest which in this case for me
it probably wouldn't but if you sense
that at all or seriously it sounds like
your husband maybe does I'd be like okay
great thank you for the thank you and
just probably move on so most more so
the first like out of sight out of mind
like pretend it's not even a thing I
mean that's me I don't know George would
you be different it's not it's not
hurting you right now obviously there's
you feel like there's a better use of
this
money and your husband is going hey
they're just doing a generous thing
we're not having to pay for this they're
not taking debt out in our name they're
this is just one way they want to give
to the kids they are free to do that and
so I don't think this is on fire fire if
this if you never see this money you're
going to be okay so whether they put it
here I mean you could talk to your
husband and say Hey what if they put
that 65 in a investment account that one
day we then get to use as an inheritance
to pay the taxes whatever are there
better ways to go about this from a
wealth strategy perspective yes yes it's
hard to tell people how to give to you
especially with this relationship where
it's like it's in your husband's name
and it's a thing his parents did and now
you're trying to get in the middle of it
I feel like there's more harm than good
the only reason it crossed my mind is
because of in the way it was given you
guys can do what you want with this you
know so I was like do we want to do what
we want are they the type of people to
get upset if you did cash it out I don't
think so I think that they may not agree
but I don't think that they're going to
be upset listen I would not want to be
the one it'd be different if you're
listen there's a lady in the audience
right now she's going don't do it don't
mess with the in-law over 65 bucks a
month that you're not be one thing if if
your husband was like dude I was just
looking at this whole life policy are my
parents have on me like this is whack
I'm going to go tell them you know d d
and then you could be like yes honey you
go do that but the fact that even he is
like I don't want to come across
ungrateful that for me tells an
underlying Dynamic that even maybe you
don't fully know is there yeah which is
yeah don't touch it I get it though yeah
and Thanksgiving dinner is coming up we
don't want that yes ma'am oh my gosh
yeah it's like don't mess with the whole
life policy don't mess with the Macon
but I am proud of you guys for getting
term life in place and having a much
better policy in place there I'm I think
that was the move to do and if you were
in a different situation I'd say hey get
term life and then go ahead and cancel
the whole life pay this another charge
and cash it out all right well I'll stop
stressing about this thanks guys yeah I
think it's it's not worth your peace of
mind over 65 bucks a month that you're
not paying as long as they have the
right Insurance in place for them this
is just something that someone did
especially at their level of wealth
their in-laws clearly aren't broke
they're not spending money they don't
have to fund this thing sure sure it's
like my in-laws buying me a biscuit even
though I'm gluten-free and I go hey
thanks for the biscuit I actually don't
eat gluten and they go no we want to buy
you a biscuit and then when you're not
looking they're not looking you kind of
put it you give it to the dog feed it to
the dogs my little French Bulldog is
very overweight she doesn't need that oh
yeah that trying to Slumber down sorry
that's a good uh message though for all
of you out there who don't have term
life in place let this be your wakeup
call you need it 10 to 12 times your
annual income on the policy and you can
get a 15-year term 20-year term 25e term
here's why you don't need insurance for
your whole life once you follow the
Ramsey plan for 15 or 20 years you're
going to be what's called self-insured
you have a paid for home you have
sizable nest egg that will cover your
family in case something happened to you
to replace your income not to mention
you don't need an insurance policy
that's going to quote invest for you you
can do your own investing yes combining
investing and insurance is a terrible
terrible idea with terrible returns and
all it does is line the pockets of these
whole life insurance salesmen that they
pose as wealth strategists cuz they go
well this is actually an investment
strategy the wealth they use don't buy
it so if you want to get term life in
place the only one we've ever
recommended at Ramsey go to zander.com
our friends there would take care of you
they've taken care of my family for
years J family you can also go uh call
800 356 4282 to get that plan in place
and man the peace of mind is worth it
the policy is a fraction of the cost of
whole life and you'll sleep better for
it create your free every dollar budget
today the simplest way to budget for
your life
