Critique and Review of My Early Oil Paintings

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
All right, so let's take a look at some of my early work.
All right, so I was messing around in the studio
and I started digging around in a box
with my old eight by 10s.
These are oil paintings from probably the first three years
of me being a painter.
And so there's a lot of, yeah,
there's a lot of experimentation.
I was surprised though,
there are actually some things that kind of work,
but I thought it could just be fun to share
some of these paintings with you guys.
So let's just take a look.
This was done from a photograph.
This one is in Burlingame.
I'd done a bit of plein air painting,
but I can tell already, this, like I said, was a photograph.
This shadow, there's not a lot of color in that.
In real life, you know,
there's a lot more light in the shadows
and camera will make it look sort of dark like that,
dark blue.
So that's something I would do differently.
There's not, there's also not, you know, it's all cool.
It's like a purplish color.
Usually I look for, you know,
warms and cools in the shadows.
I don't mind the composition.
It's kind of interesting, I guess.
And then this train, the top of the train is a little sloppy.
I'd probably clean that up a bit.
Oh, this tire, it seems really tiny, actually,
really small out of proportion with the rest of the car.
I was definitely influenced by Tim Horne.
You can kind of tell this looks like a Tim Horne painting.
All right, this one here is from Half Moon Bay.
This was also done from a photograph.
I do remember that I was trying to work
on atmospheric perspective.
So artificially lightened the mountains in the background
to kind of push them back.
One thing that I noticed is that the,
my signature is just so dark and let's see,
compositionally, I mean, it's not terrible,
but it's not super interesting either.
I was just going for a convincing feeling of light early on.
That's, that was like the thing
that was most interesting to me
was trying to create a feeling of light.
I did, I do notice that I got some warmth
under the eaves here.
I think in 2006, around then,
I just started looking for more reflected light.
So even though this was a studio painting,
I was starting to incorporate some of the things
that I saw when I was out plein air painting.
Okay, this is the Carlos Club down in San Carlos.
This was done in plein air.
And I remember, actually, it was kind of a rough day
because I was painting at the Southern Pacific Train Depot
across the street, looking at the Carlos Club,
which is an old bar with this marquee here.
I just thought this was kind of,
this old Spanish building on the corner was really neat.
I had a couple of cops come up to me
and threatened to impound my equipment
and, you know, and charge me like a $75 fee
to get my easel back and all that.
And this went on for like five minutes until,
and I was, I kept saying, you've gotta be kidding me.
You've gotta be kidding me.
And he was like, no, I'm sorry.
And he had sunglasses on.
Nope, sorry, I gotta impound your stuff, blah, blah, blah.
And then finally he let up and was like,
oh, I'm just messing with you, so not cool.
Anyway, I don't know if that affected
the outcome of the painting,
but yeah, what would I do differently here?
I don't know.
There doesn't seem to be a place for the eye to go.
Usually, like, I try to,
instead of just doing storefronts or whatever,
I like to be able to have, like, a view down a street.
So I wouldn't compose like this.
You know, I just wouldn't do that.
Again, I was attracted to the light I saw in the buildings
and so that was what I was trying to do.
And also I was, in those early days,
I would just drive around
and I would get desperate to paint something
and I'd say, all right, that'll do.
And I think this was one of those days.
All right, this is another view from the neighborhood.
I was trying to do stuff, you know,
that I saw walking my daughter to school
or, yeah, just things in my neighborhood.
You know, little scenes that appealed to me.
Painting cars was always a challenge.
I'm not even sure what model of car this is.
And this, like I said, was 2006, so that's 14 years ago.
I've not seen this car around in a long time.
But anyway, I felt like it was a good challenge
to paint old cars.
And definitely, again, the Tim Horne influence.
I think that's gonna be a theme
running through these paintings.
And I really did like his, you know,
the way he painted old cars in light.
This tree trunk here is a little bit wacky.
I kinda like the composition.
Yeah, I do like the fact that you can see up the street
into the distance here and you get a sense of,
yeah, a sense that it's a hill
and, you know, there's these cars going off in the distance.
All right, so I can see this building,
this old Victorian, as I walk out my front door.
And I've always liked the late afternoon light
on the building.
I did simplify this composition
by removing buildings that were in the background
behind the trees.
I was mostly interested in the light.
And then also, you know, it was an exercise
in painting something fairly complicated
and trying to simplify it.
I think there was another car as well.
So I removed the other car and just kept it to one car.
I remember liking it a lot at the time.
I felt like it was a successful painting.
I really did like it.
Again, that super dark signature down below.
All right, so this was a plein air painting.
And again, I remember the day and I was driving around
and I was just not finding anything.
And then I saw this little red building,
which almost looks like an outhouse,
but it's out in Palo Alto, out by the bay.
And I thought, all right, I gotta do it.
Gotta go for it.
So I did.
And yeah, it's not very interesting.
But you know, there are those days where it's like
better to paint than not to paint.
I do remember around this time I was, you know,
I liked on a road or something to have
maybe a portion of it be in shadow
and I could see my shadows are lightening up.
That's kind of cool.
It's nice to be able to see into the shadows
and see some variation.
I probably would have signed it now.
I'd probably sign it on the other side
so that the path didn't have this big dark signature in it.
I don't know.
I might remove some of these posts.
Like, these are okay in here.
These are kind of interesting, I guess,
but I don't know.
I don't know.
Yeah, I might've removed the ones
that are blocking the path.
That might've improved it a little bit,
but it's still kind of awkward.
Actually, I did get some good atmospheric perspective
on the mountains.
They do seem to be pushed back.
Also, too, there wasn't a strong light and dark
on this building, as you can see.
This side was getting a little bit more light
than this side.
You can see a little bit of a cast shadow right here
from the eaves,
but not a really dramatic light and shadow pattern
on that building.
And that's something that I tried to look for
even back in 2006.
Okay, this one is a plein air painting,
and this was done in Potrero Hill.
And I actually met with Tim Horn,
and we did some painting in Potrero Hill.
I had taken a workshop from him in 2004
when I first started,
and we became friends,
and we painted together occasionally in San Francisco.
This was one of those days.
And I do remember walking around
trying to find a composition,
and I hadn't done much painting in the city before.
I was sort of overwhelmed.
This is like one of the first city plein airs
I've ever done.
And I like the idea of like a hill.
You know, the hill is suggested
because this road goes over,
and obviously the houses are going down.
And I thought I'd try to capture that.
This is really awkward,
this telephone pole right on the edge of this building.
I don't know how I overlooked that.
That's kind of weird.
This is sort of undefined in this area.
But I do think there's good atmosphere
on the trees in the background,
that sort of blue-green of eucalyptus trees.
I think if these buildings are the most interesting
or if they're what I was attracted to most,
somehow this building detracts from that.
If it were darker,
or maybe if it had been cropped differently
so there was less of it,
then these buildings, you know,
these buildings here might be more prominent.
I do remember actually,
I think Tim did a really nice painting, I'm sure.
He had done a lot of plein air in that area
and he had years of experience
and I really liked his work.
And I remember just feeling like this painting was terrible.
It could be kind of discouraging to paint with a good painter
especially when you're beginning.
Okay, this is another painting
that was done from a photograph.
And this one,
this is a view that I always appreciated
when I was walking back
from dropping off my daughter from school.
We would walk to school every morning.
She went to a small neighborhood school,
which was really great
because it was always such a joy to walk her to school.
And that was when she was like in, you know,
all the way up to fourth grade, I think.
On the way back, I would always notice this view
and thought, wow, that could make a nice painting.
And I actually liked this painting.
I remember at the time thinking it didn't really work
but maybe it's because it was a view
that brings back memories, but I actually like it.
Yeah, I think the composite,
actually the car, this car is kind of in the center
but that doesn't really bother me.
I guess because the tree is sort of a prominent feature
and that's on a third.
A nice little bit of color in that chimney
and also light as well.
And in the distance I can see Mount Diablo
over in the East Bay.
All right, so this is another one
that's done from a photograph that I took
when I was walking Emma to school.
And I actually did an eight by eight version
of this first, which sold.
And then I decided to do a little bit bigger of a version.
And this is like all these paintings, it's an eight by 10.
I do remember liking this tree,
you know, how there's like a lot of soft edges on there,
just sort of suggesting all these little fine branches.
I remember liking that.
And I do also like, you know,
I remember liking the sense of light.
The only thing that really jumps out at me
is this bright orange, which is a brick staircase.
That seems like maybe overly saturated.
I might kind of play that down a little bit,
but I like the perspective and the shapes are interesting.
Good saturation too, so overall not too bad.
And again, good memories attached to this painting
because it reminds me of those walks to school with Emma.
All right, and this final painting
is another one from the neighborhood here.
I would take a walk up this hill by my house for exercise.
And I always walked past this house
and it reminded me of some of the Hopper paintings
from Gloucester.
And I thought, oh, I got to, you know,
I've got to do a painting of this.
And so there were no cell phones at the time.
So I just had a little point and shoot camera,
took a picture and then later painted it.
Yeah, it does kind of a feel like
one of those Hopper Gloucester paintings,
although not as good.
This telephone pole and this wire just jump out at me
as being really dark.
Some of the lines on the roof are a little bit wonky,
but I do feel like there's a feeling of light
in this painting.
The pattern of shadows is sort of awkward too,
but like I said, it brings back good memories.
So, you know, that's kind of a nice thing.
I don't know what this is.
If this is like a street light or a street lamp
or something that's kind of, yeah, that's kind of awkward.
I probably would take out,
like a lot of times I don't even paint in the lines.
If I'm going to paint in, you know, posts
or telephone poles or whatever,
I always kind of de-emphasize them.
I, you know, lighten the value of them.
So they're still there, but they're not as obvious.
That's something I would probably do.
And I'd probably eliminate this one altogether.
But in those days I was still being, I was very literal.
I would just copy exactly what I saw
and I'd walk around until I found a composition
that I felt worked.
I hadn't yet discovered the, you know,
the idea that I could just, I could change anything.
I could change things and move it around at will.
All right, so it's really fun for me
to look through these paintings.
And the one thing that I did notice is,
as I mentioned, there's a really strong
Tim Horn influence in these.
Also, you may notice like a Hopper influence.
I think when I first started painting,
I didn't know anything about art at all.
I've mentioned this before.
I started painting in 2003
with no previous art experience at all.
You know, I was mostly played music.
I was in construction.
And so I didn't have, I didn't,
I didn't really know where to look.
There was no internet at that point, 2003,
or if there was, I didn't know how to use it.
I wasn't connected to it.
And I don't know that artists had websites at that point.
Maybe they did, I'm not sure.
I guess maybe they were starting to,
I can't really remember.
Cause I do think, cause I did find Tim Horn's work online.
So there must've been websites, you know,
for galleries and stuff like that at some point.
Yeah, around 2003, I would imagine.
But I, like I said, I can't remember.
Anyway, the point is, I was definitely heavily influenced.
And at a certain point, I do remember
finding an image in my collection of, you know, images.
And I, for a second, I thought it was like,
did Tim Horn, is that a Tim Horn or is that one of mine?
And I was like, okay, I've got to find my own voice here.
You know, I cannot, I can't be imitating him
or any other painter.
But there was a lot that I learned
by closely studying, you know,
painters like Hopper, Tim Horn, and who else.
I think I used to look at Ken Oster.
I used to look at his work too.
But then it, like I said, at a certain point,
I thought, you know what, I got to stop with that
and kind of look at other artists
and then just develop my own voice.
And that became something that was really important to me.
And so I feel like I've done that now, you know,
and then continue to do it.
It's something that never, hopefully never ends.
You just continue to develop and grow.
So anyway, I hope you guys enjoyed looking
at some of these older paintings
and let me know what you think in the comments.
Also, if you'd like to help support the channel,
there's a Patreon link down below.
It's Patreon videos that, or the Patreon support
that keeps me making these videos.
And I have a bunch of extra videos on there
talking about, like say, instinct versus intellect,
how to develop your instinct in painting.
Those are the two latest new ones.
Check them out.
Link in the description.
Thanks for hanging out, guys.
I'll see you in the next video.
