DJI Osmo Action 5 Pro vs GoPro HERO13 Black [Video + Audio Comparison]

Learn Film Photography
93 followers
This video is going to be a comparison of the DJI Osmo Action 5 Pro and the GoPro Hero 13 Black.
I'll give you an in-depth side-by-side view of the video
and the audio quality of both cameras, so let's just go ahead and jump right into it.
Okay, now I want to talk about the different color modes that you have with both of these cameras.
Right now you're seeing standard color. This is standard on the Action 5
and this is standard on the GoPro 13. Standard is what you want to choose if you don't want
to do any grading in post. You just want to shoot it, edit, and then upload.
And this is the basic color with no grading applied that you'll get out of each camera.
And now here's standard color in the shade instead of the sun,
just so you can see a different sort of lighting environment.
Excuse my sweat, it's a little bit hot outside right now,
but this is how both of the cameras auto-expose to adjust for a shady environment.
And you can also see the white wall behind me, so that gives you an idea of how they
deal with the dynamic range of the situation in standard mode.
So it's really bright back there and really dark here where I'm standing.
Okay, now we're in HLG or HDR mode, so this is going to give you more dynamic range overall.
The brights are going to be brighter.
So this is perfect for if you don't want to do color grading in post
and you want to post it on social media in HDR,
because Instagram and YouTube can both support HDR video.
However, you will only see the difference if you're viewing on an HDR compatible screen,
of course, like a new iPhone or a TV that can show HDR.
Now we're seeing both cameras in LOG mode.
LOG on the Action 5 and LOG on the GoPro.
So LOG is a flat color mode and in order to make the color look normal again,
you do have to apply a LUT in post.
DJI has their own custom LUT and GoPro also has their own custom LUT.
Here's a little dynamic range test.
I've got the sun in the frame behind me and I am under a tree in foreground.
So I am much darker than the sky and the sun.
So let's see which camera automatically compensates for this high dynamic range scenario better.
Right now I'm standing under a tree and there's a white wall behind me
and this is basically a dynamic range nightmare.
Super dark where I am and it's super bright right behind me.
So I'm testing to see how both cameras deal with this in auto exposure mode.
So you can see that they both decided to brighten me up
in order to expose my face without completely blowing out the background behind me.
The last mode I want to talk about here is flat mode on the GoPro
and that's what you're seeing right now.
The DJI Action 5 for comparison is still in log mode.
So flat mode on the GoPro is basically a fake log
where it takes the natural color and just dials down the contrast.
And this used to be my favorite color mode before the GoPro could shoot log.
I would just put it in flat, shoot 8-bit color and it came out looking pretty nice.
So I just wanted to do another direct comparison here.
Log on the Action 5 in 10-bit and flat on the GoPro also 10-bit
with a little bit of color recovery in post done manually.
I want to make a little side note here about the GoPro,
something that was actually kind of annoying as I was doing these tests.
Each time I changed the color mode, it reset all my other image quality settings.
So for instance, the frame rate, the sharpness,
the noise reduction, they all got reset back to default
each time I changed from standard color to HLG to log, etc.
So if you plan on switching your color modes a lot when you're shooting with a GoPro,
you're going to want to save presets and go to those presets
instead of just changing that one color setting.
Otherwise, you'll find it constantly resetting to factory defaults each time you change your color.
So that's just one little note that was annoying to me
that I thought I should pass along to you to save you the grief.
There's barrel distortion on the edges of the frame in both cameras now
because we are using the wide-angle lens setting.
You can see the field of view on the Action 5 is a bit wider than the GoPro.
So you do get more in your shot.
But the GoPro has a higher overall resolution,
which means that you're able to crop in more if you want.
So here's the Action 5 with lens correction in post.
And here's the GoPro 13 with lens correction in post.
The other option is to do lens correction in camera.
So here's the Action 5 with lens correction applied in camera.
This is the standard de-warp setting.
And here's the GoPro 13 with the lens correction applied in camera.
This is linear mode.
Both the DJI Osmo Action 5 and the GoPro Hero 13 have a sort of open gate mode.
And that's where you can use the entire surface of the sensor to record video.
So on the Osmo Action 5, you have a 4x3 open gate.
So it's sort of a squarish looking image.
And then on the GoPro, you have an 8x7 sensor area.
So that means that it's basically a vertical image.
So the difference in the shape of the frame that you're seeing right now
is due to the different shapes of the sensors in each of these cameras.
So you can see the relative field of view that you get
when you're recording in this mode with both cameras.
And of course, you can take this and crop it in to a standard 16x9 or 9x16,
depending on if you're posting horizontally or vertically.
Now in terms of the frame rates,
when you're recording in open gate on the Osmo Action 5,
you have up to 120 frames a second.
Whereas with the GoPro in 8x7 mode, you only can shoot up to 30 frames per second.
Now I'm testing out the built-in microphone in a nice quiet environment.
I'm walking through a peaceful temple area
and there's not really much competing noise.
There's no traffic in the background.
It's not windy. It's a very calm day.
So this should be basically an ideal sort of environment
to record audio with an action cam.
So I should sound pretty good on both the Action 5 and on the GoPro.
Now I'm holding the action cameras a little further away.
I'm not speaking directly into the mic. I'm facing forward.
So this is what off-axis sound would sound like in a quiet environment
when you're using both these action cameras.
Okay, now this is going to be a test of the internal mics in a noisy environment.
As you can see, this is a road with a lot of cars passing around me
and I have the action cameras both at arm's length,
talking straight to them.
We just have the default audio settings on both cameras.
So this is just going to give you an idea of how it might sound
if you're out vlogging on the street and you don't use an external microphone.
So this is the Action 5 Pro audio.
And this is the GoPro 13 audio.
Now I'm standing by a very busy road
because I want to test out the voice mode on the GoPro Hero 13.
So this is a mode that's supposed to isolate my voice digitally from the background
and the Action 5 Pro does not have this mode.
So this is the audio from the built-in mic of the Osmo Action 5 Pro
versus voice mode on the GoPro Hero 13.
One feature of the Osmo Action 5 that is not shared by the GoPro
is compatibility with the DJI Mic 2.
So the audio that you're hearing right now is being recorded from the Mic 2
which is clipped outside my shirt on my chest
and I'm just going to walk back here and test out the range a little bit
and we'll see if there's any audio dropouts here.
And then I'm going to go behind a concrete shrine here
and let's see if that causes any
and just walking back straight toward you.
So the audio quality should get better and better as I get closer
or hopefully it never got bad in the first place and it's just staying the same.
But yeah, this is the DJI Mic 2.
If you want to use it for your vlogging as you shoot with the Osmo Action 5
this will give you much better audio when you're further away from your subject.
Okay, let's go ahead and try out some slow motion.
Both the Action 5 and the GoPro can shoot 4k 120
and here I'm at a spot with a lot of pigeons flying around.
So that's a good subject to film.
Let's go ahead and see how it looks.
Randomly wandered into a Muay Thai gym so I'm gonna try to catch some b-roll here.
Now I'm at this amazing silver temple
and I'm gonna try out a special stabilization mode
that's available on both the Action 5 and the GoPro.
This is the horizon leveling mode.
So no matter how I angle the cameras it will keep the horizon steady
which is great if you want to make it look like you were using a gimbal
but you don't have a gimbal.
So as I walk around you can see that it's keeping my horizon steady
no matter which direction I go
and as I'm holding it I'm not keeping it perfectly level.
I am actually rocking the horizon in my hands as I walk.
So this will give you an idea of how well the horizon balancing works
and if it will improve your vlogs.
So next up I'm gonna put my action cameras on the selfie stick
and then I'm gonna extend it way up
and then walk around using it basically as a long extension pole
to get drone-like shots.
So I do this a lot with 360 cameras.
I do it with gimbals on monopods
but the fun thing about doing it with an action camera is
I don't need a gimbal and it keeps the horizon level for me.
Okay now we're doing low-light tests at a bar.
Cheers!
The GoPro is recording 5.3k 24p in log mode
and the Osmo Action 5 is 4k 24p also in log mode.
Both cameras have the stabilization turned off.
I'm using the wide lenses because that packs the most image area.
So basically the shot is not cropped and zoomed at all
for stabilization or anything.
So that should mean that we are getting the most pixels in the frame
and therefore the sharpest image and the least noise.
So I tried my best to match up the image quality between these two cameras
and you can be the judge which one looks the best in a tripod scenario like this.
All right one more angle just for fun while we're at it.
Just so you can see the street out in the background.
You can see how the highlights are retained by each of the cameras
and also the shadow detail here.
Yeah so I'll let you be the judge.
Cheers again!
Okay now I'm going for a little walk downtown.
Checking out some lights right now.
This is the mid-autumn festival I guess
and yeah it's pretty nicely lit up here.
Not too dark.
The GoPro has the stabilization turned on
and the Osmo Action 5 also has the stabilization turned on.
So you can see how well that performs in this kind of lighting.
All right there's one more low-light trick I wanted to try out here.
That is the high dynamic low-light imaging on the Osmo Action 5.
And on the GoPro I've just turned up the noise reduction
because the GoPro doesn't have a specific low-light mode
but now the noise reduction is at the high setting.
So we're comparing the special night mode on the Action 5
high dynamic night imaging with the regular image from the GoPro
but the noise reduction has been turned up to high.
So as I walk around you can get an idea for how the dynamic range holds up on both cameras.
Can you see detail in the highlights behind me?
Does the color look natural?
Are you seeing any weird artifacting as I walk around because of camera shake?
These are all things to look out for as you look at this comparison.
And actually just to test that a little bit more
I'm gonna shake the cameras in my hand intentionally pretty harshly here.
Let's try it out.
Okay now I'm shaking the cameras as I walk.
Let's see which one holds up better stabilization-wise.
And now for the ultimate low-light test I am walking into a very dark and shadowy alley
because I want to test out the Osmo Action 5's high dynamic low-light mode night mode
against the GoPro 13 when I remove basically all of the ISO limitations.
So now the GoPro is going to use any ISO it deems necessary and auto exposure up to 51,200.
I think that's the max ISO.
And the Osmo Action 5 is auto exposing in high dynamic low-light night mode.
So I'm walking into this shadowy area.
It's very very dark here and I'm standing against a black window.
This is about as bad as the low-light situation you'll ever find
when you're shooting with an action camera.
So let's take a look at how the Osmo Action 5 handles it.
And the GoPro 13.
Now a little tuk-tuk ride.
We're still in super night mode on the Osmo Action 5
and the GoPro Hero 13 just has the noise reduction turned up.
