Regional Direct Air Capture (DAC) Hubs Program Notice of Intent Informational Webinar 2024

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Nov 5, 2024
Video recording of the Regional Direct Air Capture (DAC) Notice of Intent Informational Webinar, featuring an overview of DAC at the Department, the program, and next steps, held on October 10, 2024. Visit http://www.energy.gov/oced/dachubs to learn more.
[Music]
good morning everyone thank you for
joining us today to learn more about the
regional direct air capture hubs program
and the recently announced notice of
intent for the next round of direct air
capture hubs funding my name is Kelly
cumins and I'm the acting director at
the office of clean energy
demonstrations commonly referred to as
osid and we are so pleased to be
speaking with you today about the direct
air capture Hub program's latest funding
opportunity and in this webinar we'll
provide an overview of the Dak hub's
program we'll provide key information on
this funding opportunity uh what the
next steps are and resources and with
that I will pass it off to my colleague
Beth weed the direct air capture hub's
stakeholder engagement lead to go over a
few of the webinar Logistics and give a
brief overview of what you'll be seeing
today thank you so
much great thank you Kelly and thank you
to all participants who are here joining
us today before we begin the session I
want to go over a few webinar Logistics
you can turn on live captions by
clicking on the captions in your control
panel to turn on Spanish or ASL
interpretation please click the
interpretation button also in the
control panel you will be able to find
recordings of this webinar in both
English and Spanish as well as a copy of
the presentation on our website within
the next week many attendees submitted
questions ahead of time time and while
we will not be able to address these as
part of a Q&A session today we will
compile a list of questions we've
received and post a Q&A to make
available any answers we're able to
provide based on information that is
public at this
time first please note that this webinar
will only include publicly available
information provided from the notice of
intent or noi attending the webinar and
watching the recording are completely
voluntary and will not impact the future
application process in case of any
inconsistencies between the noi and
what's discussed in this webinar the noi
document is the controlling
document so today we'll be covering
first a high level overview of the
direct air capture work at the
department of energy across nettle fecm
and osed we'll get into uh outcomes from
the request for information or RFI that
osen issued in February on the role of D
funding for midscale commercial
facilities um and then that ties nicely
into how that then informed details of
this current noi so we'll go through
this dhub off this stub's opportunity
including project eligibility key
application requirements and then
finally we'll end the session by
covering next steps and resources
information uh to help Orient you to
Future touch points with osed and other
resources available to everyone on this
call so with that I'll hand it over to
my colleague
Grant hi everyone hey I'm uh Grant faor
I'm the director air capture hubs
program manager working on the carbon
dioxide removal team uh the office of
fossil energy and carbon management uh
yeah thank you all very much for being
here today so um yeah in my role at uh H
energy and C management I oversee our
offices work on the 19 topic areas one
and two direct air capture hubs that I
will speak a little bit more about
momentarily and I work on a variety of
our other DC and carbon removal related
projects so to kick off here I just want
to you know acknowledge that we'll be
talking about uh some some higher TRL D
work today and in demonstration scale
funding uh Doe's work on Direct D
capture actually spans all developmental
levels from new materials development to
integrated bench scale testing uh all
the way through pilot plants engineering
scale uh or engineering studies and
large scale demonstrations as I noted
we'll talk a little bit more about today
and underlying all of this work is uh
you know robust cost modeling life cycle
assessment uh Community benefits
planning Workforce Development and and
really everything that's necessary to
enable a holistic uh buildout of of
director captures as a technology and as
an industry and and broader industrial
ecosystem in the United States but today
I'm going to be giving a little bit uh
more background on the direct air
capture hubs program in particular to
provide some context for our
discussion so yeah on the next slide um
just wanted to provide yeah just just
some uh background information about
deck hubs so uh these were originally
funded by the bipartisan infrastructure
law which provided $3.5 billion to
establish at least four Megaton scale
direct air capture hubs in locations
around the country so each of these hubs
is is uh meant to include a network of
uh the the actual like capture the
actual direct air capture project uh
potential carbon dioxide utilization or
conversion processes which may involve
CO2 conversion into low carbon fuels and
chemicals or perhaps building materials
like concrete uh as as well as CO2
transport and storage infrastructure
that uh is is uh generally necessary for
long-term removal of that captured CO2
so to write a little bit of context yeah
each Hub is expected to you know
ultimately achieve at least this million
metric tons of CO2 uh from the
atmosphere per your per your capture
capacity and for just a little bit of um
grounding on that point a million tons
of CO2 per year is about equivalent to
the emissions from
250,000 passenger vehicles so while the
direct impact like the direct climate
impact of one particular Hub is not
necessarily uh super significant or
groundbreaking necessarily on its own um
it's these hubs will still be
tremendously important for establishing
that foundation for the direct capture
ecosystem United States and subsequent
scalability so on the bottom here I've
outlined two just a few of the
attributes that were initially
identified in the bipar infrastructure
law that uh these hubs should ideally
satisfy so you can see here there's a
focus on uh scalability on uh high
potential for CO2 uh utilization or or
storage which uh makes sense but also
there's a focus on citing these hubs in
economically distressed areas and areas
where there's a lot of employment
potential uh as as well so yeah this in
in this sense the hubs may be able to be
used to uh preserve some level of jobs
in regions where uh oil and gas may be
being phased out and uh where where
there's perhaps a desire to leverage
some of the existing infrastructure and
and maintain some some of those jobs so
Dak these these stubs may be able to
help help serve that purpose so yeah on
the next slide you know we just want to
give a little bit of um uh an update on
the progress of the first round of of
the direct air capture hubs program to
date so in August of
2023 21 back Hub projects were selected
uh for funding uh to dat as of today 18
of those have been awarded with the
remaining three still under negotiation
and you can see here the topic areas
from the first round of the daubs had
range here the first one being
feasibility studies and just trying to
find an appropriate site topic area two
focused on feed or front-end engineering
design studies that try to um say
engineer and actually have a better
vision for a larger percentage of what
that Hub is actually going to look like
and how it may actually operate and tap
into energy resources transport and
storage and so forth and then finally
topic area three uh was actual project
development and permitting and moving on
perhaps to construction and operation
funding pending successful down
selection there so these topic areas at
the time were uh drafted more or less to
uh to reflect and and um be suited for
the existing like technological maturity
of of the Dak industry and uh as we'll
discuss a little bit later that same
principle uh under was it underlied some
of the thinking that went into uh the
topic areas outlined in the Nota 710 so
um yeah on the next slide and my final
slide here I just wanted to
provide a map and just showing the
distribution of uh these topic areas 1
through three direct a capture hubs uh
as well as some previously funded pref
feed and feed studies that were funded
by my office F energy and carbon
management I wanted to show this map uh
for a couple of reasons uh the first one
is to point out that there is actually
interestingly already been an emergent
degree of of clustering of some of these
Hub projects so you can see that in
Southern California along the Gulf Coast
maybe a little bit in the Midwest and
along the Front Range as well we're
seeing some clustering of these initial
uh dhub and and other kinds of d
projects which uh may just you know be
reflective of existing CO2 transport and
storage resources in those areas uh
perhaps access uh or perhaps clean
energy resources present in those
regions as well um but uh you know
something I want to point out is that
you know we're definitely open to
considering Dak anywhere uh there's
there's CO2 everywhere I mean it's it's
pretty uh evenly distributed in the
atmosphere and that's something that's
interesting and special about director
captures that it can really be cited
anywhere technically which gives us a
degree of flexibility when when thinking
about citing and thinking about how to
do this in the most optimal way to bring
jobs economic opportunities
environmental benefits and other kinds
of co- benefits from these facilities to
uh people all over the country and and
perhaps even the world so uh yeah with
that thank you very much for listening
and I will now pass to uh Dan to uh to
talk about the mscale RFI response and
notice of intent and some other topics
so Dan take it away thank
you thank you grant hello everybody
thanks for taking time to join us today
uh I'm Dan yawitz I am Ed's uh strategy
lead for carbon dioxide removal uh and
I'm going to be talking us through two
topics today first is uh the request for
information on midscale direct air
capture and then into the details of the
new notice of intent so uh if we could
go to the next slide please um I wanted
to start with the midscale RFI uh
because it does really set up a lot of
the um the newer elements that we've
integrated into the program that we'll
see in the notice of inent so just a few
facts about about the midscale RFI uh it
was released in late February um we got
a great response and I should just say I
know many of you uh listening today were
probably among the group of respondents
thank you for taking the time to do that
uh we know it's a lot of work but it is
incredibly helpful to have those
detailed responses on paper for us to
for us to work with um we we got almost
50 responses in total uh 20 over 20 from
actual DAC developers technology and or
project developers um um all all the
relevant industry groups I'd say that
cover even uh a broader a broader swath
of those of those DAC developers uh
other CDR Developers
uh labor groups think tanks and and
other kind of stakeholders in the
industry so um the the midscale RFI
really asked a question to Industry of
what is the role of what we what we
termed midscale direct air capture uh
which we which we Quantified as being
kind of in the low thousands of tons of
capture up into say the 10 or up to I
think 25,000 ton per year capture
capacity what are what is the role of
those facilities in um in
drisking uh larger call them Hub scale
facilities and how how does that act as
a step in daak scaling and uh the
response was was pretty clear really
that that that first commercial step uh
is critical for for not all but many DAC
Technologies it's really the first the
first step where they mooved from a
pilot uh that has drisk the technology
and they're working uh with a facility
where the business model also needs to
work so so they've taken the technology
um at Pilot scale where maybe they were
catching and releasing the CO2 and now
they they are deploying a facility that
has to generate revenue or is capable of
generating Revenue so at that point the
uh the type of energy that you're using
matters for your life cycle analysis uh
the storage or utilization of the CO2 is
critical to enable um whatever that
business model may be say sale of carbon
removal credits so the industry really
confirmed that that is indeed an
important step for many DAC uh DAC
technologies that that step is often
critical to reach larger scale and that
there are a lot of unique kind of
challenges uh where Federal funding
would be would be very catalytic so that
was really useful feedback
another piece of feedback we got in the
RFI is the doe should not in any way
take its eye off the ball of larger Hub
projects and larger facilities as really
delivering the capacity that's going to
get us to HUB scale uh these the goal of
the million ton the four million ton
hubs and of course Beyond uh to to more
climate climate relevant scale as as
Grant alluded to so uh takeaways where
we should we should explore ways to
support midscale we should not take our
eye off the ball of the large scale
facilities that are going to be the the
main Hub uh capacity U drivers I'd say
and that flexibility at midscale is key
flexibility in sighting uh flexibility
in how we Define midscale flexibility in
operational life and so on so uh those
were really great lessons and as you'll
see we've worked uh we've worked most of
these into the the new program we could
go to the next slide
please okay now onto the notice of
intent before we get into these details
uh I should just uh reiterate the the
caveat that uh this is only a notice of
intent and as I'm sure you all read in
the in the fine print um there there
very well uh can and may be things that
change when the eventual noo is released
of course the noo is going to be a much
more detailed and expansive document so
by its nature it's going to have a lot
of the answers to the questions you all
may have uh but there are things that
can and may change between now and then
so just bear that in mind as I walk
through the details next slide
please this slide gives a snapshot of uh
the new the new programs funding and how
it's allocated uh we don't actually have
the Topline number on the slide here but
the notice of intent uh indicates up to
1.8 billion will be made available for
for uh this new program it's worth
mentioning that 1.8 billion does reflect
the remaining amount of funding in the
provision available for new programs so
when you factor in the 1.8 with the
amount offered in the first foa that
that is the total amount available for
new programs so how will that 1.8
billion be distributed across the topic
areas I'm going to actually start on the
right side here because that's where the
largest dollar amounts are this topic
area three uh this is the this is
similar in many ways to the first boas
topic area three in the sense that this
is funding the what we now call large
scale commercial DAC facilities this is
where the majority of the funding is
intended to go and um these will be the
facilities that will either uh establish
a new Hub or add capacity to an existing
Hub in the middle we have topic area two
uh which as as I was just referring to
these midscale commercial DAC facilities
uh less funding uh obviously these are
going to be smaller facilities and we'll
get into those details but uh but for
the facilities at that size we think
this will be a really important uh way
to support those those midscale
commercial facilities and then topic
area one we get into the detail of all
of these uh in a minute but these the
these are platforms where those midscale
and other early commercial D facilities
can go to build and operate their
facility we're calling those
infrastructure scaling
platforms next slide
please okay drilling down on some of the
details here for the topic Area 3 the
large scale commercial facilities these
will uh need to be proposed uh with a
capture capacity of at least 25,000 tons
per year you're welcome to propose a
larger facility of course uh that's
great you're also welcome to propose
reaching a larger capacity total in
stages as long as no single stage is
smaller than that
25,000 uh ton per year minimum we will
also be asking you to show us your
vision for how this technology will
scale to 10x Beyond this uh not as part
of this project but just the Future
Vision vision for deployment of this
technology um we will as with the first
foa we will be uh requiring robust uh
life cycle analysis and mrv
plans uh we know that a a key question
for a lot of you is the Readiness
requirements uh so I'm going to I'm
going to touch on a few of the key
points around what we will expect uh at
the time of of application we will want
to see that you for this large scale
commercial topic area we will want to
see that you're basically scaling up uh
a a technology that you've deployed at
smaller scale commercially already so we
will want to see what we call a
reference facility at
trl7 six months of operational data and
we would want that reference facility to
be no smaller than 125th so the quick
math on that is is you would need a, ton
per year uh facility ton per year to be
proposing the minimum of 25,000 and then
scaling up from there um and then just
to emphasize the U the fact that we're
really looking for commercial
applications here not catch and release
so we would expect to see uh the
relevant energy inputs and carbon uh
infrastructure uh to to um to make it a
commercial
facility next slide
please okay topic area two uh looks
similar with a few of the key key uh
numbers changed um these midscale
commercial facilities uh are envisioned
at being between 2,000 and 25,000 tons
per year so that kind of creates the
step right before the large scale
facilities here we'd like to see uh the
vision for after this project how you
will you will be deploying or
demonstrating I'd say squarely in the
large scale range so we'd like to see
your plans after midscale to get into
the 100,000 ton or above uh just to know
really where where this technology is
going and how it can be more relevant to
uh to Hubs scale large scale facilities
going forward again robust LCA and mrv
are going to be required as far as the
reference facility here here we are
expecting these may be the first True
commercial facility so your reference
facility could be a trl6 facility we'd
like to see certain number of hours of
operations again a similar scaling
factor of 125th so if I'm not doing my
math wrong here that would be an 80 ton
perear facility to be proposing the
minimum of a 2,000 ton Pere uh midscale
facility and again a commercial facility
here not a u not a catch and release
pilot
project next slide
please okay topic area one the
infrastructure scaling platforms uh This
Is A New Concept what we are hoping to
find and fund here are locations where
those midscale projects or other small
or midscale commercial Dack project
projects can go to site their facility
without needing to develop a site from
scratch so uh this is something that was
identified in our RFI as really a key
bottleneck that we want to help unlock
again supporting these early early stage
commercial I should say smaller scale
commercial uh facilities on their way to
larger Hub scale the challenge is here
that the RFI uh helped educate us on
really are that um finding a site
developing a site and uh getting access
to the clean energy that's required for
the LCA and the carbon management
infrastructure um are are critical
challenges at this stage which really
are not core to the tech itself um so
the idea behind these platforms really
is to create host sites where uh small
and medium commercial DAC facilities can
go to access these clean energy and and
uh carbon infrastructure resources um
maybe maybe just to uh emphasize the
access point here um what what we hope
to find really are sites where those
resources are already being developed
and a host site for DC could be really
just added on to that so it's not to say
that um we wouldn't allow funding to go
directly towards um the the development
of new energy or carbon infrastructure
assets but our hope and we think the
better use of funding would be to find
places where those resources are already
developed or are already being developed
as part of another project and say hey
could you make some room for these
smaller DAC facilities to take to take
part in that and not have to develop
their own if we can find one or two or
three of these we think this would be
really catalytic for both both those
first commercial uh facilities and the
larger scale facilities that they'll go
on to do afterwards uh so we will want
to see uh what is in place or in
development as far as those energy and
offtake resources what the business plan
would be and who a potential list of of
Dak tenants could
be next slide
please okay this is my favorite slide uh
because it is uh it is the encapsulation
I think of of what we've what we've
changed uh to compared to the first foa
to make the remaining funding more
flexible and and um more supportive of
the daak industry on its way towards
these these four million ton hubs so I'm
going to go through each one of these uh
one by one um in in the first row we're
highlighting here that um we have added
more flexibility across time um in in
the sense that we're envisioning
recurring uh likely annual openings for
this uh for this funding so um we hope
that will really meet the quickly
scaling DAC industry where it is through
these through these recurring openings
um that's a that's a feature we're
really excited about the flexible
funding ranges if you notice that the
different topic areas have ranges of
funding that's a that's an important
flexibility ility element because as um
it will let us really allocate the
funding across those topic areas as
we're seeing the most impactful
projects on the second line uh we have
the minimum facility size we lowered
that modestly but we think importantly
from a minimum of 50,000 tons in the
first foa to 25,000 tons uh going
forward again that only applies to the
large scale topic Area 3 there's a
different minimum for the mid
scale the third line uh is the Hub
composition in the first pH we we really
envisioned and expected that uh at least
for the ta3 and really across the topic
areas that applicants would bring doe um
unified Hub projects uh we still love
unified Hub projects and we are eager to
see those but we now have broadened
somewhat the uh the type of projects
that we will that we will um that we'll
potentially select as as comprising a
hub so we will still welcome unified Hub
projects but we're also open to large
scale projects that can help uh either
expand the capacity of a hub of an
existing Hub or um
independently U establish a hub in an in
a new region U so that sort of
independent project selection and the
idea of um you know we may we may see
individual or sorry unified Hub projects
we may also see uh great independent
large scale facilities in a region that
can comprise a hub and as Grant alluded
to earlier we're already seeing some
natural clustering across different
projects there so we hope this will let
us support uh more projects over time
the Readiness requirements as I
mentioned the initial foa had a 10x
maximum to enter the construction phase
uh I know uh many people took notice of
the the Thousand ton requirement to
enter the project development phase but
then there was subsequently a 10x
maximum scaling to enter uh the
construction phase we've now expanded
that to 25x um so that's that's more
expansive and we do intend uh to do in
addition to that um quantitative screen
we'll also be doing a qualitative risk
assessment of Readiness because because
every DC technology is a little
different and scaling means different
things so uh there will be sort of a
dual pronged approach there uh I won't
dwell much on the next two since we've
already covered them but we think the
additions of a a minority of the funding
uh going towards midscale DAC and the
infrastructure platforms to support them
is is really going to be critical for
success for these hubs going
forward and then just a maybe a
procedural point but an important one
one uh the first FAA uh went straight to
full applications um the process we're
expecting going forward is going to be a
little different where we will ask for
either pre-applications for one topic
area or concept papers uh for others and
that has worked really well in other
osed programs as an interim step I'd say
it lets it lets you as the applicant uh
provide us with a view of your project
earlier on before going through the
effort of of creating the full
application it lets us respond to that
um and give a give an early sense of of
uh what we call encourage or discourage
um prior to entering into the full
application review process so that
interim step has worked really well in
other osed programs we pulled it over
here because we thought that would
really help uh help both sides
before we move on to the next
slide I will just make one note as well
um or two notes rather one uh that we do
welcome of course uh uh applicants uh
that may be projects or individual
Partners from our current uh our current
fo1 portfolio uh those projects would
have no advantage or disadvantage
compared to other applicants um and then
I will briefly mention the the um the
RFI uh that we um mentioned in the
notice of intent if you caught it it was
fairly far down in the document uh but
we are eager to uh again Ask the DAC
industry and other stakeholders some
questions around how funding for DC that
does not focus on subsidizing the capex
but may be more focused on subsidizing
the operational phase uh or the revenue
model of DAC could be could be
complimentary so I'll just say preview
of coming attractions uh keep an eye out
for uh for that RFI um and with that I
am going to wrap up my section say thank
you again to everybody for joining I'm
going to turn it over to my colleague
Chris
Anderson great thanks a lot Dan um as as
Dan mentioned my name is Chris Anderson
and I am the uh notice of funding
opportunity manager here at
OED uh next
slide I want to walk through the
anticipated timeline for the noo and
first before I do that I want to drive
just the point that even this very
general timeline is just an estimate and
there could be potential although
unlikely uh changes in the process that
we've outlined here um the timing
uncertainty in particular uh obviously
increases as we move further out so uh
with that said um we are currently
targeting a noo release this
winter uh we're then likely to require
concept papers uh as Dan was talking
about for topic areas two and three and
pre-application submissions for topic
areas one sometime during the Spring of
next year we're expecting uh the
deadline for full applications to be in
the summer um and then doe would like to
make selections sometime during winter
of
2526 uh so you might be curious why why
are we expecting a roughly six-month gap
between applications and selections um
so variety of things that Doe has to do
we have to conduct various compliance
reviews uh we obviously have to do a
merit review uh potentially we'll be
exchanging comments back and forth with
applicants uh we have to engage a
federal consensus panel uh do security
vetting om approval Etc um and the
purpose of of sort of underlying all of
those processes is to ensure fairness in
selections and ensure that the selected
projects meet uh program mission
objectives and DOE security
standards so next I'll pass it to uh to
my colleague Beth to discuss an exciting
opportunity that's coming up next
slide great thank you Chris uh so
returning to the present day our next
opportunity for engagement is the
upcoming carbon management industry day
this is a completely optional event that
aims to further inform potential
applicants about the program's
priorities details on the solicitation
process and then we'll also provide a
really good forum for networking and
teaming among potential applicants so
this is an in-person event it'll be held
on November 13th in Washington DC some
of you may already have submitted the
interest form I do want to highlight
date change from November 19th which was
originally listed it will be on the 13th
in DC if you'd like to attend please
fill out the form uh the link will be
posted in the chat and also please
utilize the DC engagement page to stay
connected and up toate with future
opportunities on this slide there's more
details about the regional daubs program
and then also links to a few of the
resources that we mentioned during the
webinar today so those links will also
be going into the chat please don't
hesitate to reach out with questions and
concerns to the DC Ed email address
listed here um and then sign up for for
our newsletter and stay informed about
ongoing opportunities within osed so on
behalf of all of our speakers Kelly Dan
Grant Chris and myself we really
appreciate you all taking the time to
join us and learn more about this
exciting notice of intent so with that
thank you and have a great rest of your
day
[Music]
