Trust Business Structure Australia - Pros & Cons

Startup Sphere
22 followers
1 Video View·Nov 6, 2024
Hi, Danny from The Field Group.
In today's topic we're going to be talking about trusts.
So trusts are an obligation imposed on a person, in this case a trustee, to hold property or
assets for benefit of others, being beneficiaries.
Trust is formed, the solicitor draws up a trustee, which is a document that sort of
sets out the rules and how the trust will be administered.
And it becomes the law as to how the trust is going to run.
There's two types of trusts.
There's a discretionary trust, which by the word itself means that the trustee has discretion
as to who receives the capital and income within the family group.
And the second type is a unit trust, which has a lockdown fixed percentage of units held,
which determines the percentage of capital and income.
So if you own 50% of the units, you would get 50% of the income.
So a trust can hold assets.
They might be shares, it could be cash, it could be property.
They also can be used as a legal vehicle to shift profits from one trading entity, maybe
away to another entity to protect it.
It can help with asset protection.
And obviously that can also run a business.
So we often have difficulties explaining to clients the relationship of the trust and
the trustee.
A trust, unlike a company, is not a separate legal entity.
It's the trustee that is the legal entity.
So it's the trustee that owns the assets and enters into all contracts, whether it be by
property or get finance or whatever it be, on behalf of the trust.
So it's the trustee that can be sued.
And if it is sued, the trustee can use the trust assets to pay any debt.
And if the trust hasn't got enough assets, it's then the trustee that would have to use
their own assets to pay the balance.
And that's where we quite often put a trustee company in place, because then that would
limit that liability away from the individual.
So why would we use a trust?
So as just mentioned, the reduced liability where a trustee company is in place is one
main reason.
Another reason is that we can protect the assets that are in the trust away from the
individuals. If the individuals have got risk in their lives, those assets in the trust
are protected. The main reason I feel for trust is the flexibility of asset and income
distribution. So where you're running a business, it's mum and dad, and you want to
have variations in the way the income is distributed to be able to pick and choose, trust
perfect. So it might be that mum or dad might be earning variable amounts in other
jobs. And the trust allows us to maximise the tax position by giving one of mum or dad
more income than the other to keep them even.
Might be that mum stops work for family reasons to have some kids, and therefore we can
direct a lot more income to mum during that period and keep dad's income down.
Also beneficial where you've got adult children who might be studying, you can use them
as a beneficiary, save some tax, and similarly self-funded retiree parents who don't
have any reliance on income tests for government pensions and the like, they can be used
as a beneficiary. So a trustee can pay tax, but it's very uncommon, we don't see it very
often. In most instances, the trustee will distribute all the income of the trust each
year to all to the beneficiaries, and it's the beneficiaries that pay the tax.
Where we have two or more independent people or families involved in a business, it would
be uncommon and not appropriate to use a discretionary trust, as the trustee has no fixed instructions
as to who's to receive the income, it's all discretionary, and therefore one family
might benefit more than the other. So in that instance, that's where a unit trust would
be more appropriate, as that sets out the percentage of units held, and therefore gives
the trustee more guidelines as to how that is to be split.
Some of the disadvantages of a trust are the initial, they're expensive to set up and complex
to administer, can't distribute losses from a trust, so they're trapped in there until
such time that you can either get some other distributions into it, or the business starts
making profits and can use them then.
Another one is financial institutions. So quite often, and especially in recent times
on the back of some of the changes in the banking world recently, we're finding it's
getting more and more difficult for the banks to understand how trusts work and the flow
of income. So if you're buying assets within the trust, or maybe it's personally, but you're
getting your income from the trust, it's harder for them to understand the flow of money where
it's discretionary, and we're seeing clients find it a bit more difficult to borrow money
as a result.
Retained profits, so unlike a company that can retain profits and pay tax on those profits,
while a trustee can do that, it's very rare, and therefore we find that we don't set up
businesses in trusts that are going to retain a lot of money, so they might have high profits.
It's more for lower end profits where the individuals can pay all the tax, but we do
have those situations where a client might get a tax bill and feel they haven't got the
income from the trust to justify that bill, and that's because the trust assets have tied
up some of that money, and because the trust has to distribute all the income, the cash
might not follow that income, and therefore it can feel like the beneficiaries pay more
tax than maybe they feel they should.
Another little intricacy with trusts is the 80-year vesting period, so when a trust's
set up with that deed, it'll have a vestment date, which means that it needs to cease.
It's 80 years, so it seems like a long time, but we are starting to see some dates creep
up that were set up, the trust was set up quite a while ago, so we've got to get some
guidelines around that because it's going to cause some issues.
Some of the requirements when you're setting up a trust is the trustee wouldn't need to
go and get a tax file number for the trust, and then lodge an annual tax return every
year.
One other tip would be if you are setting up a unit trust, we'd recommend a unit holders
agreement that can set out some of the terms and the rules of the trust, and if someone
wants to exit, how that's going to work.
We hope this helps you understand a little bit about trusts and why they're a popular
vehicle, especially with the flexibility of assets and income distribution for those smaller
businesses that would benefit from that.
Thanks.
