Pal(a)eoPERCS Special Fieldwork Seminar - Ian Castro

Discovered in China
13 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 1, 2025
Special Pal(a)eoPERCS Seminar initiative on Inclusive Fieldwork
"Disability Critical Race Theory (DisCrit) in Geoscience Field Research: A Call to Action for new frameworks to Assess Accessibility and Inclusion for Field Settings"
Ian Castro - University Cincinnati (USA)
Weekly Feedback Form:
https://forms.gle/KP2zJojeqgfQnimd8
For more, visit our website: https://paleopercs.com/
All right. Good morning. Good morning. Good afternoon. Good evening.
Depends on where you are, I suppose. Welcome to this week's edition of Paleo Perks.
My name is Elizabeth Seibert. I'm one of the committee members who puts this seminar on every
week. And this week, it is my great pleasure to introduce Ian Castro, who's going to be giving a
talk called Disability Critical Race Theory, Discret and Geoscience Field Research,
Call to Action for New Frameworks to Assess Accessibility and Inclusion for Field Settings.
This seminar is the first of a series that Paleo Perks is running this summer on accessible and
inclusive field work. And so we're really, really excited to have Ian kick off this special series.
And we hope that you'll stick around throughout the summer to hear more different perspectives
on inclusive field work and ways that we can make our field and the outside more inclusive
and accessible to folks interested in paleosciences and in general. All right.
So for those of you who have not yet been to a Paleo Perks seminar, welcome. Just a quick note
of how this typically goes is that we have welcome and announcements that last somewhere around two
to three minutes. That's what's going on now. It'll be followed by Ian's talk, and then we'll
have a moderated Q&A period. Following the moderated Q&A period, there will be a little
bit of a quick break, and then we have an after tea time, which Ian has agreed to stick around
with. So he'll be available for us to chat for about 30 minutes after the talk to have a more
informal discussion. For those of you who have questions as this is going or want to discuss
more, you can send your questions via the chat feature on Zoom to the questions at Paleo Perks
hosts. That is Natasha this week. Thanks, Natasha. And we will read those out for you during the end
of the talk. Just a little bit of housekeeping is that Paleo Perks values the participation of all
folks interested in paleosciences. So we ask that you please remember to abide by our Code of
Conduct during today's seminar. You should have read and agreed to the Code of Conduct in order
to get on the email list to be able to get this Zoom link. But just in case you didn't, please
navigate to our website and check out the Code of Conduct and just make sure that you
abide by it during the seminar. We ask that you please remain muted during the duration of the
talk, and you shouldn't be able to unmute, but if you find yourself unmuted, please just go ahead
and mute yourself, and we'll let you unmute later. And again, you can ask questions at any time by
chatting to the questions at Paleo Perks hosts. And at the end of the talk, you can either submit
questions via the chat or by using the raise hand button on Zoom, and we'll call on you and allow
you to unmute. We have closed captions built into Zoom these days. You can use the CC button to show
or hide them. And at this point, we'd like to also note that you can nominate any outstanding early
career scientists to give talks in our seminar. We strongly encourage nominations, especially from
folks from underrepresented or historically excluded groups in STEM. So we'll drop the
nomination form in the chat momentarily. And then the last thing on our little housekeeping is that
we have a weekly feedback form that we encourage you to fill out if you are willing that is
anonymous and just lets us collect a little bit of demographic data to get a sense of who is coming
to these seminars and allows you to leave us some feedback so that we can continue to improve this
series and better serve the community. That should also be in the chat. All righty, so enough about
perks. Let's talk about Ian. So our speaker today is Ian Castro. Ian got his Bachelor's in
Geology from the University of Cincinnati and then went on to do a Master's in Geology from
Miami University. And he is currently a PhD candidate in Geoscience Education at the University
of Cincinnati and is also an Executive Counselor in the International Association for Geosciences
Diversity. And so Ian, at this point, we'd love to hear from you. So go ahead and take over your
screen share. Thank you so much. Give me one moment, please, as I switch over. All right,
we can get started. Thank you, everybody, for inviting me to be here. Again, my name is Ian
Castro. Today I'm going to be sharing a framework called Disability Critical Race Theory or DCCRT
and how it can help us address some of the issues of accessibility and inclusion that we have in
science spaces. So I want to talk about briefly about kind of the purpose of this talk. I want
to start things off with some of the current state of field experiences for underrepresented
or marginalized individuals. And then I want to transition into assessing Disability Critical
Race Theory or DCCRT into that space and how we utilize it as a research framework.
Then I want to talk a little bit about how that applies to geoscience fieldwork. And lastly,
I want to touch on areas of how do we push this forward? Where can this grow? How can we facilitate
this further? So let's talk briefly about just geoscience field experiences. So as we all know,
field experiences are often regarded as one of the main reasons to enter the geosciences.
They're normally seen as a really integral part of being a geoscientist. And I've listed a couple
of key examples of, you know, what field experiences can look like. Oftentimes,
institutions will have a field camp or a six to eight week field course that's normally a
requirement for undergraduate students. We also see field trips advertised through conferences.
We see field trips encouraged in classrooms. We see entire institutes that are focused on
field research that collaborate with universities. We see these as great opportunities for research
at all professional levels from undergrad onward. And a lot of people often cite that field
experiences are a great way to heighten engagement for students to build community and aspects like
that. However, I want to stress that this is not always the case. And I want to dig into
that thought process a little bit. So when we think about field experiences,
field experiences bring a lot of really unique challenges to the way that we conduct our
research. One of the main ones that comes up is that there is a lack of familiarity regarding
what the rules of conduct are. And if there's an infringement of that rule of conduct,
how do we report it? How do we act on it? How do we ensure that proper action is taken?
There is a reduced independence for access to resources. This ranges everywhere from
transportation, food and water, field tools, whatever the work requires and based on how
long you're going to be involved in that work. There's an increased distance from support
networks that can cause a lot of mental and emotional strain on participants. There's an
unfamiliar culture that's often ascribed to field experiences that can vary depending on the
experience or the subdiscipline. Various factors can play a role in that. There's the physical
exhaustion of just long days in the field doing primarily very physical work. And lastly, there's
of course the natural environmental risks or hazards that come into play when we involve
ourselves in field work. Beyond each of these things, though, there are other problems that
directly affect those of us that are from more underrepresented or historically excluded
communities. And I want to bring some special attention to those. So we've seen some work that
has looked into issues of harassment or bullying or discrimination or all of the above that can
sometimes be present in field settings. There's also issues with things such as sexual harassment.
There have been issues with validating identity-based experiences. There have been
microaggressions and just a general feeling of a lack of safety. I've highlighted a couple
articles that have come out recently that have addressed this for different marginalized groups.
You can see the one on the bottom left focusing specifically on issues and risks that are posed
to people of the LGBTQ plus community in the field and ways to help protect your Black, Indigenous,
People of Color, or BIPOC students in field work. So more recently, there has been a more open
conversation about, you know, a lot of these marginalized people don't necessarily feel
that community and that safety that we often associate with field environments, but rather
that some other issues exist in those spaces as well. And in many of these cases, it's not
obvious or it's not physically present. I want to highlight a quote from a paper from Stokes
et al. 2012 that I think highlights a lot of the themes that I'm going to be addressing in this
talk. And I'm going to revisit this slide later on in the talk to really emphasize a major point.
And it's this idea that practitioners need to think beyond the boundaries of their beliefs
and experiences. A lot of times when we think about field experiences and how important they
are and aspects like that, we often are very limited to our own experiences, either on
running field programs or in participating in field experiences. But oftentimes in those spaces,
we don't reflect enough or think about how these experiences could be met very differently by
people of different backgrounds and of different lived experiences. So it's essential that we
leave this narrow view behind and try to expand our understanding of what the impact of these
experiences can be to a larger audience. I want to highlight another recent example that's
explored some of the social problems in geoscience, more specifically looking at racial
representation. This is from Bernard and Cooperdock in 2018. I want to bring special attention to the
central diagram here that looks at the number of PhDs earned in geoscience fields
based on, separated by racial identity. So we see racial and ethnicity, race and ethnicity, I apologize.
If you look here, you'll notice that the topmost line, going horizontally, represents white,
non-Hispanic, and you can see it has a similar trend to the total PhDs earned over time
on the leftmost graph. However, when we compare that to other underrepresented groups from
Native Americans to Asian, Black, Hispanic, or Latino, we see that there's much less growth,
there's much less change here. And over this 40-year period, it seems to stress that the ways
in which we've attempted to approach accessibility, inclusion, diversity in earth science spaces
is not being properly met, and that the ways that we need to do things has to be different. We need
to change our outlook on how do we approach these kinds of problems. This is also a big issue, even
outside of race, for example, we can also see this with aspects of disability. This is from a work
by Atchison and Labarkin in 2016, which looked at the perceptions of geoscience professionals
and assessing how likely they were to think that a person with a specific disability would be
successful in earth science. And while many geoscientists at the time spoke that
hearing was not a super crucial skill in earth science spaces, as more and more disabilities
were brought up, whether they be physical or visual or learning-based, the belief that
those individuals would succeed in the space drastically reduces. So as we're looking at these,
when we think about specifically for field experiences, it's important that we understand
that there are these invisible barriers that are keeping these marginalized people
out of earth science spaces and that are limiting opportunities to participate,
limiting engagement, and that these are all aspects that need to be focused on in order
to address these problems moving forward. I've also highlighted this in a quote from the Atchison
and Labarkin paper that summarizes their findings, saying, limited awareness and perceived
barriers for people with disabilities in the geosciences may result in continued marginalization
of geoscientists with disabilities and further inhibit participation in community-based
scholarship and engagement. I've chosen to highlight this specifically because this idea of
we think about a lot of the underrepresentation we think of in geoscience, we tend to focus
specifically on its current state, but it's also important to realize how we've gotten to this
point and what continues to feed this continued marginalization, this continued underrepresentation,
not just for people with disabilities, but for all underrepresented groups in earth science spaces.
I would argue that this is tied very closely to the culture of the geosciences,
so I want to explore that a little bit further. When we look at geoscience culture,
there has been a more open discussion about some of the foundations of geoscience and what that
history has involved, especially from the negative lens, and how we can try to grow and push forward
from this negative connotation. We've seen most recent discussions about colonialism
or colonization, the idea of conquest culture, this is especially prevalent for communities
with disabilities, the idea of needing to visit and explore these extreme environments.
We've seen issues involving racism, ableism, sexism, and various other forms of oppression
and marginalization. It's these foundational pieces of earth science that have helped fuel
the underrepresentation and marginalization that we see. This is emphasized by some recent
literature. Here's an example here by Max LeBoyron, which focuses on the idea of decolonizing earth
science as more than just equity and inclusion benefits. There needs to be more work and
acknowledgment on this history of earth science in order to address its problems and attempt to push
forward. For the purposes of this audience, I've included a recent example of this kind of discourse
through a recent paleontological debate. This was within the last few years,
where a dinosaur who was originally discovered in Brazil was brought over to a Western institution,
and there's been a big push to bring that specimen back to the people where this was
originally found, the institutions where this was originally, that are directly associated with
this. There's been a fair amount of pushback against that. I've included some artwork that's
focused on this effort for the organism, I think it's pronounced Ubirahara. I might have butchered
that, and I apologize if I did. This has been a significant public outcry from both the public
and the geoscience community to try to bring this organism back that has essentially
been at the forefront of a colonization or colonialism discussion in this space,
for it to be back in Brazil where it can be further investigated by those individuals in
that science community. I bring this up as an example of how these problems continue to pop up
in the modern. This is not just a historical issue, this is a problem that continues to happen
into the modern day and that needs to have this attention and conversation focused around it
for our field to continue to develop and grow. As we talk about the ideas of addressing
field experience, I've brought up all these problems and all this discussion, how do we deal
with them? There needs to be work to address this culture of marginalization that exists
in the geosciences. As I've discussed from these foundational pieces, we need to
address those as best we can. We need to present new ways of better meeting the needs of marginalized
individuals. For the purposes of this talk, I'm going to focus primarily on people of color and
disabilities. We need to look at more efforts to explore misperceptions about marginalized
individuals. Again, I'm focusing on race and ability here. What I argue is the way to do that
is through intersectionality-based approaches. In particular, I'm going to be sharing about
disability-critical race theory. Again, I'm brought back to that Stokes quote.
Practitioners need to think beyond the boundaries of their beliefs and experiences.
As we look at the problems that we face in the geosciences, we need new approaches to address
those problems. We need new ways of thinking about these social problems in order to address them.
While a lot of what I'm going to be discussing may be new to most of you, I want you to keep an open
mind as we explore them. Use this to reflect back on your own experiences in the field,
your own experiences in the geosciences, and how we can push forward and grow from there.
Now I can introduce disability-critical race theory, or for short, DISCRIT. I will be referring
to it as DISCRIT for a majority of this talk, although I may bounce back and forth a little
bit just as the conversation flows. What DISCRIT is, this is essentially just a research framework
that focuses on the intersection between racial and ability barriers. I've included an image here
from Connor et al., which is a foundational text for this framework. If you'd like to
explore it further or maybe read some more foundational pieces from this work,
this is a great resource for that. Essentially, the origins of this approach
stemmed from these early interactions, or more so the lack thereof, between racial issues and
special education. We see this with the massive over-representation of people of color in special
education. We see this in a variety of different spaces. There was very little interaction between
the idea of supporting people through racial issues and through supporting people through
disability. By not having those connected, we miss out on these interactions. Along with this,
we're exploring issues of ableism and racism as they exist in both societal and educational
structures. Where this comes from, I think a lot of people, especially lately, have heard
about critical race theory, or CRT, as it has become a very politically charged term
in the last couple years. I want to emphasize that CRT is an origin of a theoretical foundation
for disability critical race theory, as is intersectionality. Intersectionality,
like disability critical race theory, stems directly off of foundational literature and
thought behind CRT. All of this comes together to work with disability theory in order to bridge
this disconnect between racial discussion and ability discussion in order to support individuals,
for example, such as people of color with disabilities. I've included this graphic
on intersectionality to help emphasize the point here of when we think about things through an
intersectional lens, we need to understand that identity is not just a singular aspect.
The aspects that make us who we are are a combination of different identifiers, either
that we have applied to ourselves or that have applied to us by others. Understanding how these
different aspects connect together, both uniquely and compoundingly, helps us to better support
these individuals, as opposed to trying to just support one aspect of them.
So, I'm going to quickly summarize some of the main principles of disability critical race theory.
I think this is really important because, especially when we're looking at something
that's so tied to an aspect like CRT, it's important that we understand what it is this
work is doing, what does this work value, and what the goals of it are. This is not just some
hot-button topic. This is not just piggybacking off of a popular term. This is a legitimate
research framework that we need to understand if we're actually going to use it.
So, summarizing what this framework does or what its main principles are, it focuses on the often
invisible ways that racism and ableism are present in society. It values the intersection of
marginalized identity. It emphasizes how race and ability are socially constructed, while also
acknowledging that both race and ability, those labels associated with them, have a direct impact
on individuals. This framework brings the voices of marginalized individuals forward, privileges
those voices. It looks at the legal and historical aspects of how race and disability have been used
to deny rights to individuals. We look at how whiteness and ability both exist as property,
and how improvements that have been made on these fronts have mostly been made due to converging
interests with white individuals. And lastly, that in this work, activism is a requirement.
Action is a key component for this work. So, this is not just digging through the theoretical.
There is an expectation and a drive for positive action and change that comes with this framework.
So, discussing how we use DISCRIT as a framework. Primarily, DISCRIT has been used in educational
and legal spaces, and thus it's relatively unexplored in STEM, not just in the geosciences,
but STEM as a whole. And thus, there has been a lack of emphasis on DISCRIT approaches for
something like a field experience. I do have these brief examples, this brief example that's
cited by both Chiarella and Burrow and Masscoll and Stokes, which essentially focuses around the
idea of a learning activity. Planning a field activity, we need to consider the students,
the environment, and the outcomes. So, when we're looking at the students, figure out their prior
experiences, their disability, skill sets. When we think about the environment, understanding the
cultural context, the physical environment, the resources that can be available to assist in that
environment. And of course, the outcomes. How do we assess knowledge and how it's gained? How do we
encourage it? How do we motivate it? And how do we help students progress forward? So, as we think
about research through this mindset, especially field research, we can really rethink the way
that we approach field programs. Looking more specifically in the geosciences, I think I would
argue that DISCRIT applications could help us address some of the issues in geoscience culture.
I think they can help us provide new research approaches to addressing inequity and inequality.
It can help bring forward the voices of marginalized individuals and more specifically
the voices of people of color with disabilities. And I think the most important thing of this work
is this sets up a foundation of intersectional work in the geosciences and how this type of
research can really help us to explore marginalization as a whole. So, now I want to highlight a couple
studies that have, while not directly used disability critical race theory, have applied
similar thought process or framework in their specific research. So, the first thing I want
to highlight is Stokes et al. in 2019. This was focused around the idea of designing accessible
geoscience field trips and field work experiences, specifically for individuals with disabilities.
And the reason I've decided to use this as an example of how DISCRIT could be
addressed is that this work was really focused on the collaboration with individuals with
disabilities, what were their issues with the field, what are their concerns, their complications,
and how to work directly with them to address those concerns. And that's a really fundamental
piece of DISCRIT as we attempt to assess the needs of these individuals, working directly with them
to bring those voices and experiences forward. Another paper I'd like to cite in this example
would be Kingsbury et al. in 2020, which used a community-based participatory research or CVPR
process in order to help bridge this connection between autistic community members and academic
research members in the construction of a typical research project for autistic geoscientists
and how to best support them through these endeavors. So this really brings forward a
foundational piece of disability studies, which is this idea of nothing about us without us. And
this is so integral that it was made part of the title of this particular paper. And essentially
what that is referring to is this idea of we cannot create long-term, sustainable, significant
change for marginalized individuals without them present. We need those voices, we need those
lived experiences for any of this to actually be resolved and for the real issues to be identified
and worked on. So while both Kingsbury and Stokes don't directly focus on race, these foundational
approaches set up similar guidelines and emphases that we would see in a disability critical race
study, just with the added push that this would also add that perspective based on race alongside
disability. So there's a lot of work to be grown through here, through these mindsets, and I think
papers like these are really important for setting that up early on and for helping build the floor
of what this kind of work can look like. So like I said, as we work to apply discrete to broadening
participation, we need to work directly with those who are most affected. So if you're attempting
to address something like a discrete approach, you need to be working with people of color,
you need to be working with people with disabilities, ideally individuals who have
both, who are people of color with disabilities, in order to understand how all these issues come
together and what can be done about it. The other aspect is that this needs to be planned collaboratively.
We need these individuals throughout the research process. They don't exist
just as participants. They are the experts in this space. For example, while I'm here talking
to you about this work, I am not an expert on the lived experiences of people with disabilities.
I don't have, I'm an able-bodied person and thus don't have these disabilities. I need these voices
in order to share what these experiences are like. And in the same way for race, I can speak of my
own experiences, but I cannot speak for broader racial interactions as a whole. Those voices are
essential for throughout the research process. Also, as we work on broadening participation
through a discrete lens, it's important to emphasize opportunities. So looking at ways
to collaborate and communicate efficiently, ways to better go about with data collection and
interpretation that's in a more accessible way. Integrating technology in various ways in the
field in order to make sure access is available. Working together to solve problems as they come up
and understanding that there are ways to get around things. So the idea, a lot of these ideas
come from the work of Dr. Christopher Atchison and his work on accessibility, but the idea of
full participation as we worked abroad, it doesn't necessarily mean 100% access to everything, but rather
it's emphasizing how we reassess the way that we look at field experiences. So instead of worrying,
well, how do I get these students with mobility issues up this cliffside? Is there a way we
can show that science either with technology or through another locality that can better express
these issues? So keeping that in mind can really help alter the way that we go about this process.
I decided to include a couple pictures from a previous field trip from the International
Association of Geoscience Diversity. Most of these are from the trip during the Phoenix, Arizona GSA.
I've chosen to highlight these images because I think they do a good job summarizing some of
the points that I have brought up so far. So in this image, this is at Petrified Forest National Park
and what is happening here is we're seeing a joining of two research teams where we had a
group that had mobility issues that met together alongside more able-bodied individuals
that were able to directly explore the outcrop in the background, and we were able to work
together using technology to map out and attempt to understand the stratigraphy of this area,
and then we are all coming together to share experiences, share our understandings and
observations, and alongside that for the more racial aspect of the more the other component
beyond disability, we also have Dr. Stephen Semkin present with us who's giving more information about
the cultural context of the region, who's discussing issues involving the indigenous
people who are surrounding these areas and bridging all of these different knowledge spaces together.
This is a really fundamental part of how we could integrate discrete approaches in fieldwork and how
we can reassess fieldwork through this new lens. We can see similar approaches here. We can see
at a stop at this canyon setting, we're seeing a way to accessibly reach this location. Again,
we're bridging this knowledge from both cultural, racial, historical, and accessible knowledge
together in one space in order to better connect all these different areas of geology and bring
this knowledge to anyone who wanted to engage with it. So this is really opening up the doors for
accessibility and trying to bring similar ideas that discrete champions bringing those forward.
And lastly, you know, I think I like this image primarily because I think this is a good
representation of the goal that this work is really after. We're thinking about disability
critical race theory. We're trying to essentially create a space where everyone can engage in this
work regardless of racial background, ability, or any other combination of marginalized identifiers.
And I think when we see something like this, we can really see how all these aspects come together
and can produce some very high quality discussion and thought about the earth, how it functions,
and how we can continue to address the problems that concern it. So I'm really excited about this
work and I think there's a lot of potential in here for the geosciences to grow as a whole.
So starting to wrap up, thinking about where do we go from here, I think important aspects are to
begin educating both students and professionals more about the social issues that exist in our
field. I think this has definitely gone up in recent years, especially through efforts like
URGE and the recent anti-racism pushes that we've seen in earth science, but I think making a more
active effort to educate ourselves about these problems and how they can be addressed is really
important. I think recontextualizing some social science frameworks like disability critical race
theory into geoscience work can also be really valuable. I see a lot of the time we almost feel
like we're reinventing the wheel when instead this work exists. This work is already out there,
we just need to be open to exploring it. And lastly, as I mentioned earlier, I think this can
really expand the future of intersectional research approaches in earth science to address other
issues of marginalization and beyond just race and ability. And most importantly, we're getting
the active involvement of marginalized individuals like we've seen in Stokes, like we saw in Kingsbury
et al. Bringing these voices forward is the meat of this and that's where the most important findings
are going to come from. I've also highlighted support organizations that have worked with
underrepresented groups in a variety of ways. We have Black in Geoscience, the Geoscience Alliance,
GeoLatinas, the IAGD. These are all examples of groups that have done great work to support
marginalized individuals, but I would say that the next big step would be for groups like these to
interact more with each other, share more ideas, and share these lived experiences in order to
better address those intersections as they come up. So we've seen that DISCRIT has a really notable
history of exploring these intersections of race and ability. There is a need for more research
involving DISCRIT and other intersectional frameworks in order to better understand
how this intersection affects individuals in our space and how we can better support them in the
field. Collaboration is essential as we meet not only individualistic needs, but also as we attempt
to address larger scale issues in the geosciences. Through all this work, I think we can
create a more inclusive and diverse field space that is better equipped to address the
concerns and issues that geoscientists are currently addressing. That's all I have for today.
Thank you so much for listening and thank you again to PaleoPerks for inviting me here.
I've included my email here if you wanted to get a hold of me to talk about any of these points
further, and I'm really glad that you guys gave me your time. Thank you so much.
Thank you, Ian, so much for that really, really interesting talk. I think there's an enormous
amount of really good information in there and lots of food for thought. So before we open it
up for questions, I just want to reiterate what Natasha has already put in the chat, which is that
if you have questions, please either send them in the chat to Natasha, who has questions at PaleoPerks
today, and I will read them out for you. Or if you would like to, you can raise your hand and we
will unmute you. So to get us going, we have a question from Sender who asks, and actually just
so everyone knows, we'll be putting the questions also in the chat. So this question asks, how has
virtual reality simulations and other related online solutions to express geoscience notions
helped differently abled people as an alternative field trip? That's a great question. So there has
been a lot of research into virtual reality simulators or virtual field trips as a whole.
We've especially seen this come to fruition through the recent rush for COVID-19 as a lot
of field programs were shut down. There has been a lot of great work in this regard to help provide
opportunities for differently abled individuals. My only concerns for these aspects is that
often these experiences are not always available, either because of technology issues or resource
issues. And also, you know, there's an inherent learning curve as we work to design
virtual field experiences. But I think that there's a great space for integrating a lot of
the ideas that I've brought up with DISCRIT and how we go about designing virtual reality
experiences. So as we work to develop these things, bringing people with disabilities to the table and
people of color to the table, it's like, how can we make this more work for you?
How can we design a field course that better captures your concerns or the issues that you
experience in order to make these experiences not only more meaningful, but also that bridge
these gaps between the people who are planning in-person field experiences and those who are
focused specifically on just virtual spaces. I think there's a great conversation space there
for combining these ideas and making very meaningful field experiences.
Excellent. Thank you for that. So our next question says, thanks for a great talk.
You make a really compelling case for considering intersectional identities when planning educational
field work. But in the case of both disability and race, it is not necessarily obvious what
someone might need to be comfortable and effective in the field. What are ways to go about getting
people the support that they need without making assumptions or asking folks to do a lot of
additional labor? Honestly, that's a great question. And I think a big aspect of it is just
instead of focusing on the idea of doing all this additional labor, it's just inviting these
individuals to be at the table to share their experiences and like, what makes you feel safe
in a field environment? What doesn't? Or like, if you're proposing, you know, bringing them on from
the get-go as opposed to the goal of this is not that marginalized people are serving you as like
a stamp of approval, but rather that you're working collaboratively from the get-go in the designing
of these aspects. So we don't want to make assumptions. We want to work with these specific
individuals on how to address some of these problems. How do we improve? What are areas
for growth? I can use an example of this with the IAGD when they do accessible field trips.
There's constant check-ins with individuals on the trip. Check-ins, if there are things
that need to change on the fly, we work on them as best we can. If people bring up concerns that
even after consultation maybe weren't thought of or maybe weren't approved, we bring those forward
and discuss them further in a way that involves everyone involved. So I think there's this concern
that, you know, we don't want to overtax individuals who are already marginalized and
already just trying to do their own work. But I think the encouragement they would receive from
being invited to collaborate on this is really encouraging and is really empowering. So I think
opening that opportunity and starting that conversation to help build trust with these
communities and to help, you know, show an honest effort of improvement is going to be
really, really important moving forward. I think your point about building something
collaboratively from the beginning instead of trying to put a band-aid on it at the end
seems like a really, really valuable one. So I have another question in. This one is from
Roy Slotnick. He says, great talk. Can you say something in this context about issues
surrounding neurodiversity and also about participation in scientific conference?
Yeah, I can try to speak on that. So as we're looking at issues of neurodiversity, you know,
it's important that as we look at issues of disability, disability varies tremendously.
Everything from physical to the neurodiverse, whatever you want to emphasize on, it's really
important to have, I'm going to sound a bit like a broken record, but as we work to produce these
experiences for things like whether that be for the field or for a classroom or for whatever
geoscience experience you're trying to build, it's reaching out to this community, to these
individuals, figuring out how can I best support you? And more importantly, if you know that your
experience has an individual who is neurodiverse, even reaching out to them specifically, how can I
support you on an individual level? What are things that we can do to help make sure this is
as accessible to you as possible? How can we make sure that this is, you know, best suited for your
specific needs? And when we branch that out to conferences, there has been a bigger push for this
more recently. If you've noticed that some of the recent GSA, and I think occasionally at AGU,
there have been discussions of, hey, if you have a concern about either diversity, disability, or
whatever, share that with us. We want to talk about those spaces. And I think those conversations
are so valuable. Because as we gain more and more of these perspectives, we're seeing
more and more of how we can improve things, how we can make these spaces better for everyone.
So I think as we go about this, I think there's a lot of area for growth. And I think there's a
lot of area for more efforts to engage in these kinds of conversations and maybe reassessing how
we do not just geoscience work, but also as we plan science conferences.
Excellent. Thank you. So we have one question currently in the queue. And if you have any
other questions you'd like to get in now is the time. Otherwise, I think we might end with this
one. So the question is, DISCRIT is a great framework. Thank you for highlighting it.
Could you talk a little bit about how to incorporate the framework in field camps
that are aimed at geoscience undergraduate students?
Yeah, that's a great question. Honestly, this is something that could be dug into for,
you know, one, if not multiple research papers. But I would argue when constructing a field course
that's designed for undergraduate students, I think the first thing to do is to as you figure
out what are the important aspects you want to cover in your field course, whether that be
mapping or stratigraphy or whatever it is you want to focus on,
trying to learn about how these aspects can be made accessible, how these aspects can acknowledge
issues of safety or lack thereof, how they can acknowledge the cultural or racial histories of
an area. And that honestly comes from collaboration. And I don't mean just with the
undergraduate students, but also as you reach out and explore these areas, working with some
of the support organizations I highlighted, like GeoLatinas or Black in Geoscience,
the Geoscience Alliance, the IAGD, talking to these groups can really help point out some of
the things that we don't initially think about. You know, no one is going to be an expert at all
aspects of identity and how to properly support them. But by opening that door and sharing
experiences and talking with others, we can really try to make a foundation that is
accessible as we work to design a field course. So the unfortunate news is there's not like an easy
like 10-step process to doing this, but just active involvement through the creation of the field
course is going to be an essential first aspect, I would argue. The other thing is as you are, not
only as you're planning the field course, but also as it's running, be open to feedback. So as
students go, hey, like this was really challenging for me because of ABC, or hey, like I had a lot
of issues, I didn't feel safe in X environment because of ABC. Being really open to that and
receptive to that is essential. It helps build trust with the students, it helps build community,
and it also helps us show a genuine effort in making these programs better. So I think
through that frame, through that idea, we can really see how things like DisCrit could be
applied to the ways that we design field experiences from the get-go, as opposed to,
all right, well, I have a program, how do I make this more quote-unquote DisCrit approved?
Sometimes it involves a much more drastic tear-down and rebuilding with that foundational
core. Excellent. All right. So I think that that is the end of our list of questions. So
we'd love to thank you all for joining us and thank Ian for the really excellent talk and
discussion afterwards. I think this is a really important topic and one that I think we can all
think more about. So with that, I'd like to thank everyone for joining us for this week's seminar
and encourage you to fill out our weekly demographic survey, if you are willing to,
in the chat. And sorry, and that will be in the chat momentarily, as well as our nomination form
for folks. Please nominate your early career researcher friends, and we'd love to hear from
you. Speaking of hearing from other folks, next week we'll actually be hearing from Michael Kipp
of Caltech, who will be giving a talk titled, The Evolution of Nitrogen Fixing Symbioses in
SciCADs, an Isotopic Perspective. Now, you may remember that we have tea time with our speaker
coming up next. And actually, so if you'd like to stick around for that, we will go ahead and
take a little two-minute break, and you can use this time to get up, walk around, come back,
and then we can chat a little bit more with Ian about these kinds of questions and challenges,
and honestly triumphs when doing good work in field spaces. So I'm just going to go ahead
and start this two-minute timer, and hopefully we'll see some of you back after the break.
And again, thank you, Ian, for a really excellent talk. Thank you all.
