How is LA's Mansion Tax Impacting Housing Development? | Mott Smith

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
77 Video Views·Jul 3, 2025
Voters thought Los Angeles’ mansion tax would target luxury home sales to help fund solutions for homelessness. In practice, it’s affecting a much wider range of properties, including apartment buildings and commercial spaces. Developer and urban policy expert Mott Smith explains how this is changing the real estate landscape in LA and what adjustments could help restore balance while still supporting public goals.
The city of Los Angeles has a new tax called the mansion tax. When people were voting for this,
they were assuming that this will apply only to really big properties,
mansions, but it includes all sorts of properties including affordable housing and commercial real
estate. Our guest today is Mats Bitt, professor at USC and a developer who's been studying the
impact of this mansion tax on the city of Los Angeles. He's been comparing the data between
the city of LA and the county of LA where this tax does not apply. He's here to tell us how this
tax is impacting the city of Los Angeles. The city, which has you know tons of budget money
and tons of power, could be doing a lot more itself and developers could really just become
builders who build the housing that we need and aren't expected to solve our school problem,
our road problem, our everything problem. I'm Siamat Karami. Welcome to California Insider.
Mats, it's great to have you back on. Welcome back. I'm so happy to be here,
Siamat. We want to talk to you about mansion tax. You are a professor and developer as well. You've
been studying this situation with mansion tax in LA. You have put some data together. Can you tell
us what's happening with it? Absolutely. So in November of 2022 a law called Measure ULA
was on the ballot in Los Angeles and it passed by more than 50 percent but less than two-thirds
and it was popularly known as the mansion tax and this was very effective branding. It turned out it
was a 29-page law that voters were expected to opine on and it created a transfer tax, a real
estate transfer tax on properties above five million dollars, which to the average person
might sound like a mansion, you know something more than five million dollars, but what was not
discussed publicly is that most of the properties in Los Angeles that are over five million dollars
are not houses. They're apartment buildings. They're retail centers. They're industrial
centers, manufacturing centers, sound stages, things like this. And so really what Measure ULA
did was put a very high tax, one of the highest in the nation, on the sale or transfer of high-value
properties and then programmed the use of the money that was generated or would be generated
for homelessness relief and supporting low-income households, which are very good causes that it's
hard not to support. And how much is this transfer tax? So do people pay it when they sell the
property? Exactly right. So if you have, at the time that it got enacted, it became effective
in April of 2023. It was voted on in 2022. It hit the streets in 2023. If you sold a
five-million-dollar house or a five-million-dollar apartment building, let's say,
on April 1, 2023, you would actually have a very small transfer tax just to cover the recording
in the county. But if you sold it for five million, one dollar, you'd now be looking at a
$200,000 additional tax on that sale. And if you sold it for ten million and one dollar, you'd be
looking at a $550,000 tax. And it doesn't matter if you make money or lose money on the sale.
It doesn't matter if you are a bank who is selling a property that you foreclosed at auction.
You're paying that tax. And you mentioned it doesn't matter making and losing money.
Can you explain that? Sure. So the tax is, it's a very blunt, the way Measure ULA is designed,
I would say it is not a well-designed tax, unfortunately. Despite being 29 pages of
detailed legal language, it doesn't seem to have learned the lessons of other transfer taxes in
other areas about what works and what doesn't work. And it's based purely on the price. So,
for example, if you, there was just in the news an office building in downtown Minneapolis that
sold for, I think, $6 a square foot. So it was like this massive office building that sold,
$6 per square foot. I think it sold for about $10 million or something like this. And let's say it
cost them $100 million to build it. And so now the economy has crashed. The owners of the building are
probably approaching bankruptcy, if not already bankrupt. And they need to sell this building.
And so they've lost $90 million on the building. They managed to get $10 million on the market.
But if that building were in Los Angeles, they wouldn't even get to keep that $10 million.
They would have to pay $550,000 to the city because of the transfer tax. So it's, as I say,
it's very blunt. It doesn't consider whether you're making or losing money. It just looks
at the price and that's it. How is it impacting the real estate space in LA?
Okay, great question. And when the tax was first put forward, the advocates were claiming that
really wouldn't be a big deal for real estate in Los Angeles. Because first of all,
mansions above $5 million are a very, it's a tiny share of the market. And it's consumer real
estate in a sense, because if you're buying a mansion and you're going to pay $10 million for
it, maybe you'll pay $10,500,000. And it won't matter to you if you're the sort of person who
buys that kind of real estate, which may or may not be true, but okay. They also claimed that it
would not affect apartment developers or commercial developers because people who build
buildings like that, the advocates of the law claimed, build and they hold properties. And so
the fact that there might be a theoretical tax at, if they sold, wouldn't matter because they don't
build in order to sell, they build in order to own. And they rent them out, right?
And it turns out this is a wildly unsophisticated view of the real estate market. It's clear that
they didn't speak to any actual builders or any bankers or others, because the typical builder
of a large apartment complex, a hundred unit, 200 unit apartment complex,
is what we call a merchant builder. So there's somebody who gets investment to build a building,
get it leased up, and then they sell to another class of investor who's a landlord basically.
And so that'll happen within three to five years usually of the start of construction on the
building. So the builders don't hold on to the real estate in most cases. In many cases they do
not. Some do, but in many cases they don't. And so what Measure ULA has done is by charging this,
for buildings at that scale, 5.5% tax, that's often half the profit of a project like that.
Literally half the profit. And so people who before Measure ULA could make deals work
no longer can. And the effect of that has been to significantly depress transactions and development
activity in LA specifically. And that's something that we researched at UCLA.
What have you seen in terms of the data and the numbers?
Sure. So I wrote a paper with my colleague Mike Manville at UCLA and was published by the UCLA
Lewis Center called The Unintended Consequences of Measure ULA. And what we did is we looked at
five years of transaction data in LA County, including the city of Los Angeles. And we graphed
out the number of sales per quarter basically, starting in 2020 and ending at the end of 2024.
And what you could see is we looked at sales below $5 million. And the graph basically is
inverse of interest rates and the city and the county are moving in lockstep from 2020 through
the end of 2024. Because the county doesn't have this law, right? This is just the city of LA.
That's correct. Not only does the county not have the law, but the city of LA didn't have it before
April of 2023. So we're able to see before it took effect, city and county moving in lockstep.
After April of 2023, we see that there was a massive divergence between the city and the county
for properties above $5 million. If you look at the paper, you see we graph sales of properties
below $5 million that are not subject to the tax, either in the city or the county. And LA city and
LA county stay in lockstep. Sales over $5 million, there is about a 50% drop in Los Angeles city
versus Los Angeles county, meaning that people have found ways to not sell. They've chosen not
to sell. It's basically seriously depressed transaction volume, meaning that properties
are not trading the way they once were. And that's a problem for a variety of reasons,
which we can get into. Why did you compare the city and county? Is it because the same
investors could go to the county or it's right there, right? Well, it's because if I wanted to
design a social science experiment on the impact of taxes, I couldn't have done a better job than
what they did with Measure ULA because they took two markets, LA county and LA city,
which are basically, again, the same market from a practical perspective. And they imposed a very
punishing tax on one subset of the market, just LA city. And so it enabled us to isolate the
effects of the transfer tax specifically, as opposed to the general macroeconomic conditions,
which affected everything. So the transactions you said is half compared to the county.
Correct. And what does that mean for LA? So it means a couple of different things. I mean, one
is people have complained for a long time about the impact of Proposition 13 on making property
ownership sticky. So people hold onto properties longer than maybe they should in a place like Los
Angeles. And so there aren't as many properties available for development as there would be in
other markets, because if I've owned a property for 50 years and my property tax is $100 a year,
and if I were to sell it and buy a new property, my property tax would go up by 100 times or
something like this. It's a reason for me to hold on to the property that I've got.
So one of the things that Measure ULA did is made it even less attractive to sell. So it means that
more people will decide just to keep holding their properties longer and fewer properties
will be open for development. The second thing that it means is that specifically for people
who care about jobs and housing production, the raw materials for jobs and housing are basically
properties, development properties in the city. It means that there are far fewer of those
available than there were before. And so we should expect to see less development of industrial
and commercial properties, less development of multifamily housing, including affordable housing,
because the properties just aren't trading. And in fact, some other colleagues at UCLA and the
Rand Corporation released a paper showing exactly that that has been in effect. And then the third
issue with that is that the primary means of property tax growth in L.A. County is property
sales and development. Because Prop 13 caps property tax growth at 2 percent a year max,
the main way we get the growth in the 5 or 6 percent range, which is what we need in order
to uphold our services and safety net, is because people are selling properties and they're getting
reassessed at sale or they're building on their properties and they're getting reassessed when
properties are built. Because Measure ULA has seriously depressed both of those activities,
property tax growth is basically stunted. And that's a big problem for the future.
So when people come and buy these buildings or when people exit, the new buyers come in,
they have to pay property tax at a much higher rate because it's a new transaction, right?
Absolutely. So, you know, because, again, real estate values are growing much faster than 2
percent a year, but property taxes can only grow by 2 percent a year as long as you're
holding a property and not building on it. Typically, when a property sells in L.A.,
the assessment of that property, the amount of money going from you and property taxes to the
about doubles. So every sale basically doubles how much that property is worth to the county.
And then it would be that amount doubled every year, right? Because the taxes...
Every time the property trades or every time somebody builds on it. In other words,
you buy an old car wash, let's just say, that's valued at $3 million and you decide...
Well, first of all, you buy it and chances are that the county was taxing it at a rate
valuing it at about $1.5 million. Because you bought it at maybe at a million
10 years ago or something. The seller bought it at a million 10 years ago. And so just the
very fact of you buying that from a seller who's owned it for five or 10 years means that it's
worth twice as much to the county in terms of property tax revenue. Now, if you were going to
build an apartment building on it, it might be worth 30 or $40 million when you're done.
And so that building activity is going to increase the value of that property to the county by a
factor of 10. And in order to support our schools, our community colleges, our social safety net,
we need that property tax growth and Measure ULA, as well-intentioned as it is,
appears to be seriously depressing that. The city is getting a lot of revenue from the
mansion tax. How does it compare to the loss of taxes? So a couple of things on that. First,
when the transfer taxes put on the ballot, it included an estimate that it would generate
somewhere between $600 million and a billion dollars a year of money for these important
services. And the reality is it's generated about half of the low estimate, about $330 million a
year. So still a lot of money, but a lot less than was anticipated. Now, the amount of money
that it's costing the city and the county and the state, frankly, in property taxes today is,
we estimated it could be as low as $25 million a year. A working paper, I should say, coming out
of UC Irvine shortly is going to peg that estimate at about four times as much, maybe about $100
million a year. And the thing is, when we talk about $25 or $100 million of slower property tax
growth, we have to think about that as a compounding and cumulative number. So take my
low estimate of $25 million a year of slowed growth. This year, the city, county, state,
schools, etc., aren't getting $25 million a year that they would have gotten but for Measure ULA.
Meanwhile, the city's collecting $330 million. That sounds like a good deal.
Next year, that $25 million of slower growth stays there, and then there's an additional
$25 million of slower growth that the county, city, state, schools, etc., aren't getting. So
it's $50 million. In 10 years, it's $250 million per year that are being offset by this. If the
that happens much sooner, $100 million of slowed growth a year, in two years, the city, county,
state, schools will be losing more money than the city's making on Measure ULA.
Because the transfer tax is a one-time thing, right? So then it's on transactions, and you get
whatever you get every year, and you have to start over. But the property tax, it adds up, right?
Exactly right. The property tax is something you pay every year, like it or not. The transfer tax
only happens when you sell. It's a one-time thing. So you mentioned that for developers to come and
build, this transfer tax is a big deal. It's half of their profit. Can you explain to us how does
it work? Why don't they add five more percent to the price? For sure. Okay. So the way the
business of building works is it's just like any other productive enterprise. There are raw
materials and inputs. You kind of put them together in a way, and then you sell what you've created
on the market. And a typical development, if I'm building a small apartment building, let's say
it's going to be a $30 million apartment building, that's probably enough for, call it, 50 units or
so. And the city of LA has an incredible shortage of housing right now, and we need all of the
production of housing we can get. And so even a 50-unit project matters. It's material. We need
that housing. So the way I make my money as a builder, if I buy, say, a car wash property for
$5 million as my land, and then I'm going to spend $25 million, give or take, in construction costs,
fees, all kinds of other things, I'll be invested to about $30 million in the whole project.
Now, I'm going to want to sell the project for about $36 million, about a 20% margin,
which for my four to five years of work that I'll have to put it in a place like Los Angeles
is good enough. It's not great, but it's good enough. Even though I want to sell it for $36
million, I'm only going to be able to sell it for what the market will bear, what people will
pay me for it. And my project will still be considered marginally successful if I'm able
to sell it for a 12% to 15% margin. So at these prices, we're talking about somewhere in the $33
to $36 million range. And Measure ULA would force me to pay somewhere between a $1.5 million to
$2 million tax on my sale price. And again, it's not a tax on how much money I make. In theory,
I could lose money on the deal and still pay a Measure ULA tax. But that $1.5 to $2 million
could easily be half of what I end up making in profit if I sell the property for $33 or $34
million. And so that would be a failure to most builders. If I'm only making less than 10% profit
on the deal for five years of work, my investors would not be happy. I would have trouble paying
my bills. And because of that math, a lot of builders and investors and lenders have effectively
said Los Angeles is not a place that we're willing to do business right now. And what is the impact
of that? Why should we care about building not happening as much as it was happening before in
LA? We should care deeply for several reasons. One is we have a massive housing shortage that
has been quantified in the hundreds of thousands of units. And what a lot of people will say
sort of ideologically is I don't care if people are building market rate units because the real
need is affordable units. We need low-income units because those are the ones that people
would otherwise be homeless, would live in. This has turned out to be disproven by study after
study that the way the housing market works is like a game of musical chairs where every so
often you get a job, you get married, you have kids, you change schools, you are an empty nester.
You sort of get up in the game and you start looking for a new place to live. And unlike
musical chairs where when the music stops, it's whoever's closest to a chair gets to sit down and
everybody else loses. In housing, it's whoever has the most money gets a seat. And the people
who don't have money, no matter where they are, they get pushed out of the system. And so if we're
not building housing for people who can afford it, for people who can pay the cost of housing,
for middle income and up, those people are going to take units effectively from lower-income
families who can't pay as much. And those lower-income families are going to get pushed
out the bottom and they're either going to leave Los Angeles, which has happened in great numbers,
or they're going to end up on the streets, which has also happened way too much. And so we need
all of the housing we can to keep that from happening, to make sure there's enough
places for people to live. Another reason we should care is because of jobs. I mean,
building is great work. It's high-paying, hands-on work for a huge portion of the workforce. And if
we're not building, then people aren't working. And I've heard people sort of joke grimly in the
building industry that the carpenters union chiefs say that I don't want to be the highest-paid
unemployed carpenter in America. You know, we need there to be projects in order for people to
get work and keep the economy going. Now, you are involved with the builders in LA. You see the
numbers of transactions. Do you think developers and builders are giving up in LA? Sadly, I do.
I mean, the conversation among the builder community is that LA is not a place to do
business. And it's both because it has just become so unmanageable to make it through the bureaucracy
and also because the sentiment among some on the city council and other agencies
has become sort of anti-builder, we think, where rather than the city taking responsibility for
providing safety net services or for, you know, doing something as simple as improving a sewer
system in a neighborhood, everything is put on builders to accomplish sort of on behalf
of the city. And there's a degree to which that's manageable and a degree past which
it becomes unmanageable. And we're really in the unmanageable stage of that. You mentioned the
sentiment is kind of negative among some city leaders. What's the sentiment like
from what you guys are seeing? Well, taking a step back, if I may,
I think that what we're living with is a consequence of two big trends. One of them
is something that started in the 1920s. And I think we've maybe even talked about this before
when Herbert Hoover, as Secretary of Commerce, kind of popularized the way we do planning right
now, which is to, it's all centered around turning farms into subdivisions. And the
financial model of that is you have a developer come along and he or she says, I'm going to turn
this farm into a whole community, kind of like happened in Irvine, for example. And part of that
is paying for the infrastructure, paying for the roads and paying for the schools and paying for
all those things. And the developer would usually take responsibility for all of that stuff because
there's really nothing there. And the upside of transforming agricultural land into residential
land can be enormous. I mean, four or five, six, 7,000 percent upside if you do something like
that, which is why it can make sense if you're turning a farm into a subdivision to have that
sort of a model where the developer takes responsibility for everything. In that sort
of suburban development paradigm, there's nothing there before the developer. And there's a lot of
margin because you guys got farmland and you're turning into housing and you make a lot of money.
Pennies on the dollar. Exactly. Meanwhile, those of us who are in the infill world, which means
builders who are building in existing cities and often much more incremental projects, 50 units,
100 units, something like that. It doesn't make sense to have us build the roads and the schools
and the sewers. But that's still the structure of how the city regulates. And so that culture
of having the developer do everything is still very, very much part of the planning and
engineering culture of most cities, including Los Angeles. So when I show up, I'm expected
to take care of all of that stuff. And when you drive through L.A. and you see, you know, an old
kind of 1930s street with beautiful buildings on it, and then there's a new apartment building,
and the street widens suddenly for just the width of that apartment building,
that's what you're seeing. You're seeing a city that says the developer must build the streets.
And so they make you build, you know, 30 feet of a street, which is ridiculous. But that's
what happens. The second issue with the city is that there's a great sense of disempowerment
among public officials. I think it's something that's happened in our civic culture over the
past 50 years, where people in government don't feel like they have the tools to directly do
very much anymore. And they see their primary power as being able to find a private actor,
a developer, or a business person, or somebody who can do what needs to get done.
So instead of the city building public housing, they say, let's create a system where private
developers can build public housing for the city. Or instead of the city saying, let's build the
roads that we want, they wait for developers to come along and say, okay, you build us 30
feet of that road that we want. And so you end up with this really kind of disjointed public realm
and public safety net, frankly, because it's crafted bit by bit opportunistically when a
developer shows up. And so there is way too much attention being paid to individual projects to
kind of solve all of the problems of our city, when what really should happen is the city,
which has, you know, tons of budget money and tons of power, could be doing a lot more itself.
And developers could really just become builders who build the housing that we need and aren't
expected to solve our school problem, our road problem, our everything problem.
Now, based on what you're seeing, you've done extensive studies of Measure ULA and the mansion
tax, and you've seen the transactions are going down. What do you recommend? What should the city
do? In our report, The Unintended Consequences of Measure ULA, we actually made a few recommendations.
One of them would be to turn Measure ULA into actually what it was sold as. It was sold as a
mansion tax, and we could make it actually a mansion tax, and not tax apartments, not tax
commercial centers, industrial centers, et cetera. That would preserve about 60 percent of the
revenue to Measure ULA and turn the real estate market back on for these very important components
of the market. Another thing that we recommend is to make ULA marginal. I hinted at this earlier
in the conversation, but didn't go into detail. It kicks in abruptly when you cross the threshold. So
when it first came into effect, a $5 million transaction was not subject to the tax at all.
A $5.1 million transaction is subject to a 4 percent tax entirely. So suddenly, with $1 of
additional value, you've got $200,000 of additional cost, and that creates a lot of very
strange behavior. Income taxes are marginal, as we say. So if you go into a new tax bracket because
you get a raise, your whole salary isn't taxed at that new level. It's just the portion in that new
bracket that's taxed at the level. We think Measure ULA should be marginal, so only the amount over
the threshold is taxed at the tax rate. We also recommend short of those two things that we create
a waiver for new construction projects. So if you build a new commercial building, if you build a
new multifamily building, the first 15 years after it's put in service, you should be exempt from the
transfer tax. That way, the way most building happens, where a builder builds and then sells
to an owner, and then that owner, maybe after 10 years or so, will sell to another owner who's
going to renovate it again. That 15 years should be enough in many of those cases to preserve the
economics of those projects and not dissuade people from investing in Los Angeles.
If you like California Insider and the topics and the interviews we conduct,
chances are you really like the Epoch Times newspaper. We are part of the editorial team
of Epoch Times. This is not just a newspaper, it's a news platform with hundreds of articles a day.
We interview different sides of stories on different topics. We cover state-level issues
to national to international. We have a unique coverage on China as well and a lot of other
topics that the mainstream media may not cover. We have a story in this week's edition about the
tariffs and their impacts on the activity at the ports. Shippings and truckers are really feeling
the impact of the tariffs at the ports, and our reporters are giving you a perspective on the
ground of what's happening. Make sure to check out the newspaper. We have a special deal for you
where you can get the digital or the print for a dollar a week for the first month. Now let's go
back to the interview. Does the politics of LA get in the middle of all of this? It really does,
because privately many many people across the political spectrum are acknowledging that Measure
ULA isn't working as they hoped it would, and so they would like to change it. You know, the
union workers aren't working, the affordable housing people are getting pummeled by some
strange financing requirements in Measure ULA, the market rate builders of housing and commercial
aren't able to work anymore. And so everybody knows that it's not working, but politically it
hasn't become safe to say that publicly yet, and I'm hoping that the Overton window is moving a
little bit and people will be able to speak out a little bit more. Because at the state level,
Assemblymember Buffy Wicks from Berkeley has put forward something called AB698. It's a
what we call a study bill, which would require future transfer taxes to do economic analyses
before they're put before voters. And that bill, which made it out of the Assembly unanimously
recently, could be amended to make some of the important fixes we need in Measure ULA.
And I'm hoping that as it becomes safer to discuss its shortcomings, that we can craft
some solutions that will preserve what's good about it, which is to the extent that it can
generate hundreds of millions of dollars a year to pay for low-income households to have more
stable housing and even create more housing for them, we should do that. And I'd like to see AB698
be a vehicle for that. So Measure ULA was put forward when it was because of a couple of recent
court cases which essentially poked a hole in Proposition 13. Proposition 13 says that a
special tax, and Measure ULA is a special tax, needs a two-thirds vote of the people.
These two court cases basically said that that is only the case, you only need a two-thirds vote
of the people if the special tax is put before voters by a legislative body, either a city
council or the state legislature or something like this. But if the people proposing the tax
are the people, this is what the court case has determined, then it only needs a 51 percent
threshold. And so the backers of Measure ULA kind of raced to get it on the ballot
before that loophole in Proposition 13 was closed. It's still open, by the way.
And the result of that is, you know, if the legislature had proposed this transfer tax,
or if the city council had proposed this transfer tax, it would have gone through countless
committees, economic analyses, it would have been studied, and people, you know,
from the builder community, the banking community would have had a chance to look at it and say,
you know, I think it's a good idea, but change paragraph number seven. Instead what happened
is version 1.0 of this very complex measure, a 29-page measure that voters were asked to
vote yes or no on, made it into law. And it contains lots of idiosyncrasies that,
had the backers spoken with bankers, had they spoken with builders, could have been fixed.
Things like provisions in Measure ULA that make the money incompatible with Fannie Mae and Freddie
Mac loans. So it's become nearly impossible to place it in service and development projects
because it's incompatible to financing those affordable housing projects have.
It has resale restrictions that prevent projects that got ULA money from being able to sell
to anybody but a nonprofit. And the number of nonprofit buyers in the market is tiny compared
to the number of regular for-profit companies that buy and sell affordable housing. So that's
created massive problems. You know, we believe that the changes that we're proposing, which would be
the 15-year waiver for new construction, if bundled with things like fixing some of the
financing provisions of Measure ULA, would preserve the vast majority of the revenues.
It would preserve 87% of the revenues. It would actually make Measure ULA much, much easier to
put on the street and benefit people. Developers somehow don't have the best reputation.
Yeah. Can you tell us about that? Sure. Well, so it's actually interesting. So an organization that
I am a part of called the Council of Infill Builders, we chose our name builders very
intentionally because that is what we do. We create physical places and cities for people
to live and do business and things like that. Development has this reputation of somehow
gaming the system, of somehow finding a backdoor, you know, to do something that other people aren't
allowed to do, to change the zoning, to change the plans and all of this. And I think a lot of
people perceive development as that, as kind of breaking a community's idea of itself and...
Gentrifying areas.
Gentrifying, changing the character. There's an exploitive valence that some people assign to
the word developer, which I don't think is often deserved. But this is why I like the word builder,
because every house that we live in was built by a builder, often by a developer. Every apartment
building we live in was built by a builder, often a developer. And so I think the reputation of
development is undeserved, but it's real. It's there. People have that perception. And I think
we need to change it. We need people to start thinking of those of us who are creating physical,
you know, the physical spaces where people can live and work and play and do business,
we need to think of them as the builders, which is what we are.
Now, what's the value you guys bring to the table for the community?
Building is a skill. And it's sort of like producing a movie. You know, you need to
know how to be able to finance stuff. You need to know how to get government approvals to do
things the right way. You need to know how to hire the right team of designers and contractors
and others. And you also need to have a vision for what you're doing. You know, we all know that
the world is changing. And we all know that the world needs to change that, you know, when you've
got more people in Los Angeles than we have homes, for example, somebody needs to come in and find
solutions for this. And developers slash builders are people who have kind of self-selected to be
the protagonists in change. I mean, it's our job to say, you know, something needs to happen and
I'm going to do it. I want to create a space for more small businesses on this main street,
or I want to create a space where more families can live. And a lot of people will
go to planning meetings and talk about zoning changes and stuff like this, which is good and
fine, but no zoning ordinance, no urban plan has ever actually created anything.
In order to create, you need to go out there and get your hands dirty and deal with all the moral
complexity of it, because it is a morally complex thing when you're introducing change into a
neighborhood. And builders are people who've said, I'm willing to bear that burden and I'm willing
to do it. And that's, that's who we are.
Matt Smith, professor at USC and developer. It was great to have you in California Insider.
So great to be here. Thanks, CMAC.
Let us know what your thoughts are on this mansion tax. Do you think it should be reformed
or do you think it should stay as is? You can always email us at cmacatcaliforniansider.com
or comment. We read all of your emails and comments. I'm CMAC Kourami,
this is California Insider, and we'll see you next time.
