We try to educate people with these videos by just sharing a small part of the original material and not wishing to bring down any market value of the content; we try to increase the market value of the content by making it known to new people.
there's a huge literature on the
supposed utility of positive allusions
and then there's also the associated
sort of terror management hypothesis
which is that the purpose of your belief
systems is to protect you from the
anxiety of death which is sort of a
variant of the Freudian idea that
religion was a childish delusion
designed to protect people from terror
of their own mortality very powerful
critique of religion although it's one
that I happen to think is wrong I mean
one of the problems with Freud's
formulation is that it fails to deal
with you know concepts like the
underworld and Hell I mean if you're
gonna just whip up a belief system to
protect yourself against the fear of
death why in the world would you
envision something like an eternity of
suffering worse than death if you ever
step out of line it's very hard to
understand how that's a defense
mechanism now a cynic would say well the
only reason that say Christians invented
hell even though they didn't it's a very
old idea is so that they had somewhere
convenient to put people who didn't
agree with them but you have to be
unbelievably cynical to assume that
that's the only reason I I don't think
there's any historical support for the
idea that that's the only reason now I'm
going to tell you some I'm going to tell
you some stories or so that some of the
most famous existentialist sin history
told their their ideas and quotations
and and I the existentialist that I've
read are often the most powerful of
writers so Dostoyevsky is an
existentialist and Solzhenitsyn is an
existentialist and so is Viktor Frankl
who survived the concentration camps and
Kierkegaard very weird collection of
people I mean their their fundamental
belief systems were often very much at
odds with one another some of them are
atheists and some of them are Orthodox
Christians especially you know because a
lot of the literary existentialist were
Russian so you can come out
existentialism from a variety of origin
points but what they have in common is
is what I kind of outlined is that the
first idea is the essential
preconditions of life are sufficiently
tragic to render the normative state of
humanity pathological and and health
something as something and health and
wholeness is something very difficult to
to aspire to or accomplish and that and
that the road to that health is the
reduction of deceit and so that's a
thing that's also very interesting about
the existentialist because they make a
very straightforward moral claim which
is that lies make people sick and I'll
tell you in my experience as a
psychotherapist I mean you know I can
tell you some of the things that make
people sick a lot of them have nothing
to do with the psyche the things that
make people sick are well they get
unemployed
it's like unemployment just lays people
out especially if they're conscientious
they just devour themselves and it's so
stressful right because if you're
unemployed well yeah your finances
become shaky almost right away plus you
don't have any routine plus you're not
involved in anything meaningful in
relationship to society you know and
then you start to eat yourself up with
doubts and and and you know
self-criticism especially if you're a
conscientious person or especially if
you're a conscientious person who's high
a negative emotion it's like
unemployment will just flatten you and
then the death or illness of yourself or
a close relative that's really hard on
people and there and there were
situations at work that are difficult so
people are bullied maybe they have a
terrible supervisor or there or they're
in in a pathological social structure so
that you know they're basically being
bullied and oppressed with every step
they take or they're in a very
horrendous relationship but but then
things start to turn a bit so okay so
you can lose your job and you can be ill
or dying and and so can people around
you and that'll lay you low a lot of the
time and no wonder right it's it's
logical and when people come to me with
those sorts of problems the first thing
I often note is they're not
psychological I tell the people that
that's not a psychological problem
you're unemployed that's an actual
problem and it's really useful to
distinguish those right so so for
example and this is something that
psychiatric diagnosis does very very
badly if someone comes to me and and
they're depressed
so they're not sleeping properly they
feel terrible in the morning you know
they they they don't have a lot of
energy
they're having a hard time experiencing
any positive emotion it's difficult for
them to move and they have a lot of
negative thoughts about the past and the
present in the future I do an analysis
of their life first to say well you know
do you have a job that's you know
alright that you know that if at least
isn't horrifying you know is it okay for
you to go to work in the morning
do you have an intimate relationship
that's basically functional do you have
some friends you know are your
relationships with your family members
okay
are you reasonably healthy apart apart
from the depression and do you have
useful and interesting things to do that
aren't related to your career and if the
person says yes to all of those and
they're still feeling terrible then I
think okay this person is depressed
right because they don't have a problem
they're just depressed and in my
experience those are the people who
respond quite well to antidepressants
you know because their nervous system
isn't calibrating its analysis of their
situation to the reality of the
situation it's as if their lower status
according to their status comparator
which is a very primordial thing since
even lobsters have it their status
comparator isn't paying attention to
their actual status and maybe that's
because they're you know temperamental
'high a negative emotion or maybe it's
because they had been traumatized
earlier in their life and so they're
much more sensitive to any signs of
failure it's easy it is it's easier to
knock them down but then you have other
people who are well they don't have a
job and they have they never have and
maybe they're 30 or 35 no real stable
employment history no real educational
history it's pretty patchy one or more
illnesses and then family members who
are just out for their absolute
destruction like families can be
unbelievably pathological so there amesh
to the familial situation where for one
reason or another as soon as they get up
off the ground a little bit someone
knocks them back down and so and then
maybe they have a drug or alcohol
problem to go along with that or they
have a relationship with someone who has
a drug and alcohol problem or a mental
illness and sometimes you see people who
have like all five of those things going
on at the same time
it's like that's not precisely mental
illness now a lot of that's associated
with deceit you know they're entangled
in relationships and in relationships
with themselves that are pathologically
untrue so I've seen people for example
who I've seen people who are in families
where probably nothing they were ever
told was true like it was never just
true it was always twisted and bent in
some way by whoever was talking to them
for the purposes of that person power or
domination or or positive illusion or
delusion or something like it all the
communication within the family was
motivated and so there it's so awful to
grow up in an environment like that
because you can't get a grip on what's
real and then you know it can get worse
than that in that the person will tell
you that they love you and they'll act
all sweet but every time you do anything
that's even vaguely productive and
useful they'll just criticize you to
death
and all the while telling you that they
love you it's really horrible and that's
all tangled up with deception and lies
and it's a weird thing because if you
look at the Freudian hypotheses you'll
notice that Freud attributed an awful
lot of psychopathology to repression
right but I think the distinction
between repression and self-deception or
deceit is very permeable it's like
what's the difference between repressing
something and lying to yourself about it
well Freud would say often that
repression occurs unconsciously but I
really wonder about that I think that
what happens is that something happened
or you did something that you don't like
and it's bothering you and you could
think it through but you just decide not
to you just don't think it through so
it's left vague and uncertain and you
know it's fairly emotionally salient but
you just refuse to think it through and
you practice doing that until you've
built up a habit of not thinking that
through and then you forget that you've
built up the habit and then it's like
it's being repressed unconscious
but I think that you know or at least
you knew when you first did it and so
you know when you meet people who are
acting in a twisted and peculiar way and
you ask yourself oh they're very
manipulative say you ask yourself well
do they know what they're doing the
answer to that could be well no but
another answer could be
yeah but they knew once they knew when
they made the decision to start acting
like that but after they did it a
hundred times or so and made it into an
automatic routine well then they forgot
its origin and now it runs autonomously
and so now they don't know but they did
know