Commercial Real Estate Loans - 4 Things To Know BEFORE Financing a Deal

Investor Insights
1 follower
5 Video Views·Nov 4, 2024
"To make sure you have the foundations covered, especially in the midst of all the uncertainty in the market we’re seeing today, in this video, we'll cover four things you need to know about commercial real estate loans before getting into the game, and how each of these things can impact a commercial real estate deal.
🕒 Timestamps 🕒
0:00 Introduction
0:55 The 2-Part Formula For Interest Rates
2:21 Beware of Prepayment Penalties
4:22 Amortization vs. Term
6:39 How Lenders Determine Proceeds
9:39 How To Learn More About CRE Loans"
If you're coming into commercial real estate
from the residential sector
or from a different industry altogether,
the financing of commercial properties
and the terms associated with commercial real estate loans
can feel pretty complex.
The way these loans are structured,
how payments are made on commercial real estate debt,
and even the fees and penalties to look out for
when financing these deals are all pretty unique,
but these are also really important things to consider
when you're trying to value commercial properties
So to make sure you understand
some of the most important pieces
of commercial real estate debt,
especially in the midst of all the uncertainty
we're seeing in the market right now,
in this video we'll cover four things
that you need to know about commercial real estate loans
before getting into the game
and how each of these things can impact
a commercial real estate deal.
So the first thing I wanna highlight here
is directly related to interest rates
and how these are determined
by commercial real estate lenders.
And this is that on commercial property loans,
interest rates are made up of two different components,
an index rate and a spread.
And the index rate is generally going to be
the equivalent term risk-free rate in the market
that represents bond yields
with the same maturity date as the loan
and an assumed 0% default risk
by commercial real estate lenders.
For fixed rate loans or loans with an interest rate
that doesn't change throughout the loan term,
the index that's generally going to be used
is the equivalent term U.S. Treasury yield,
meaning that for a loan with a five-year term,
the index on that loan
would be the five-year U.S. Treasury rate
at the time the rate was locked.
But the index rate is only one piece of the equation
when calculating the all-in interest
that a lender is going to charge
and the spread on the loan also needs to be factored in.
And this spread is going to be based
on the assumed level of risk the lender's taking on
and the volatility levels in the markets.
So when interest rate movements
and the risks associated with a given deal are low,
commercial real estate loan spreads
will also usually be low.
And when interest rate environments are more volatile
and the risks associated with a given deal are high,
commercial real estate loan spreads
will also usually be elevated.
Now, interest payments aren't the only cost to borrowers
on commercial real estate loans
and penalties and fees can also be substantial.
And point number two on this list
is related to this directly.
And this is that when commercial real estate loans
are paid off early,
there can be substantial penalties
that are associated with this.
Unlike mortgages on owner-occupied single-family homes
that can typically be paid off early
without any sort of prepayment fees,
if a commercial real estate loan
is paid off before the end of the loan term,
whether an investor wants to refinance a deal
or sell a property outright,
it's usually not going to be cheap to make that happen.
This is especially true in situations
where interest rates have dropped
since the initial loan proceeds were funded
since commercial real estate lenders
need to maintain their yields.
And if a borrower pays off a loan early,
now that lender needs to go back out into the market
with additional capital to deploy
just to earn that same return.
Prepayment penalty calculations
can sometimes be as simple
as a percentage of the outstanding loan balance
at the time the loan is paid off,
but these can also sometimes be more nuanced formulas
in the case of yield maintenance,
which calculates the present value
of the remaining loan payments
that the lender would have received
if the loan wasn't prepaid,
or in the case of defeasance,
which essentially requires a borrower
to replace the lender's yield with government-backed bonds
that can replicate the cash flows
of the remaining monthly payments.
It's also important to note
that commercial real estate loans
might include what's referred to as a lockout period
or a portion of the loan term
in which the loan actually can't be prepaid at all,
meaning that even if a borrower was willing to pay a penalty
to refinance a loan at a better interest rate
or to sell a property with an offer on the table
they just couldn't refuse,
they may not be able to make those things happen
even if they are in the best interest of the investor.
Now, the next thing that often trips people up
about commercial real estate loans,
especially those that are coming from the residential sector
is that the amortization period
of a commercial real estate loan
is often significantly different than the loan term.
On residential single-family home loans,
you'll usually see 30-year loan terms
with loan payments that are also calculated
based on a 30-year payback schedule
with the goal to have that loan paid off in full
by the borrower at the end of that term
through fixed monthly payments.
But on commercial real estate loans,
to mitigate their risk,
lenders usually won't offer loan terms
of more than about 10 years in length
with three, five, and seven-year terms also being common.
And with that condensed loan term timeframe
in order to keep debt service payments
manageable for investors,
commercial real estate loans will still often include
a 25 or 30-year amortization period
that's used to calculate monthly payments on the loan
regardless of the length of the actual loan term itself.
This creates what's referred to
as a balloon payment requirement
when that entire outstanding loan balance
needs to be paid off in full at the end of the loan term.
And this is part of the reason
why there's so much concern right now
about commercial real estate loan maturities
since in many markets and product types across the country,
property values have actually decreased
over the last few years
and with interest rates significantly higher
than they were in 2019, 2020, and 2021,
this could create a lot of issues for borrowers
that don't have access to new loan proceeds
that can fully cover a required payoff.
Many commercial real estate loans
also include an interest-only component
where the outstanding principal balance
isn't being paid down at all on a monthly basis
and when values have dropped by 15 to 20% or more
in some markets and interest rates have increased
by 250 to 400 basis points on some loan products,
this is going to create a significant gap in financing
requiring equity investors
to infuse additional capital into deals
just to prevent having to sell a distressed property pricing
and directly related to this process of refinancing
in the amount of loan proceeds
that a lender is going to provide,
the last point I wanna make in this video
is that unlike most single family home loans,
commercial real estate loan funding
is generally going to be based
not only on the property's value,
but also the income the property can generate.
Right now, commercial real estate lenders
are looking very closely
at a property's debt service coverage ratio
or DSCR for short,
which measures the amount of times over
a property's net operating income
or operating revenue minus operating expenses
can cover annual debt service
that would be owed on a loan.
And usually, lenders are going to wanna see
this DSCR figure fall somewhere between about 1.25X
and 1.4X depending on the product type
and the risk associated with the deal,
but if the NOI of a property decreases
or debt service payments increase
due to interest rate increases,
the amount of loan proceeds
that a lender is going to be willing to issue today
is going to be substantially lower
than what that amount would have been
with those same DSCR requirements
just two to three years ago.
Even for product types like multifamily and industrial
that have seen massive increases
in net operating incomes over the last few years,
the massive run-up in interest rates
we've also seen during this time
may still end up causing issues
when these deals need to be refinanced.
And to run through an example of what this might look like,
if an investor took out an acquisition loan
of $10 million financed at 3% interest back in 2020,
assuming an amortization period of 30 years,
the annual debt service on the loan would be $505,925.
But if that original acquisition loan
was now set to mature this year in 2023
and had to be refinanced
in today's interest rate environment,
if we assume a 6% interest rate on the new loan proceeds,
keeping all other variables constant,
a $10 million loan would now require
annual debt service payments of $719,461.
And what this means is that
if debt service coverage ratio requirements
stayed the same on this deal,
this would now require the property
to have seen a net operating income increase of over 42%
during this three-year period,
just to get back to that same $10 million loan value.
And this isn't even factoring in
any sort of loan origination fees
that would likely be associated with a refinance.
Now, obviously every commercial real estate loan product
is going to be a little bit different,
but with current market conditions as they stand today,
these are four things
that are definitely worth paying attention to.
And some of the most important components
of commercial real estate loans
that are going to have huge implications for investors
over the next 12 to 24 months.
And if you want to learn more
about commercial real estate financing
and how to model commercial real estate loans
when analyzing potential investment opportunities,
as always, make sure to check out
our all-in-one membership training platform,
Breaking the CRE Academy.
A membership to the Academy will give you instant access
to over 120 hours of video training
on real estate financial modeling and analysis.
You'll get access to hundreds
of practice Excel interview exam questions,
sample acquisition case studies,
and you'll also get access
to the Breaking the CRE Analyst Certification Exam,
which covers topics like real estate pro forma
and development modeling,
commercial real estate lease modeling,
equity waterfall modeling,
and many other real estate financial analysis concepts
that will help you prove to employers
that you have what it takes to tackle the responsibilities
of an analyst or associate at a top real estate firm.
And if you like this video
and want to see more content on this channel
on commercial real estate loans
and the debt side of the industry in general,
make sure to hit the like button and let me know,
and let me know in the comments
any other debt-related topics
that you'd like to see covered
in a future video on the channel.
As always, thanks so much for watching, guys.
I hope you found this helpful.
Subscribe to the channel if you haven't already
to see more videos like this every single week,
and I'll see you in the next video.
