Principles of Justice | VCE Legal Studies 3&4

General Principles of Law
24 followers
7 Video Views·Nov 1, 2024
Beautiful, so we'll begin with the actual content now. First having a look at the principles of
justice. These are really important because in Unit 3, both in the civil and criminal justice
system, you will constantly have to link things and concepts back to the principles of justice.
And in answering extended response and even potentially 10 markers as well, the principles
of justice may come up. So you need to have a really solid understanding of each and a really
solid definition. So fairness means having impartial, which means no bias, and just
treatment without any discrimination or favoritism in the system overall. And there will be different
processes that help to achieve each of the principles of justice.
Equality means that all people should be the same before the law. Try not to use the same
word in your definitions as the actual thing you need to define. So I recommend saying
equality means all people should be the same before the law and have the same opportunities
as anyone else. Access means everyone should be able to access the justice system and information
so they should all have equal opportunity to have information on the legal system
and be able to use it. And we'll go into more detail on each so you can really get a good grasp.
So fairness refers to things like fair processes and a fair hearing for the accused person, for
example, or for the defendant and the plaintiff in a civil case. So this includes lots of things.
How can we ensure processes are fair? How can we ensure there's a fair hearing in court?
This means everyone needs to be able to understand and comprehend court processes
and procedures, especially those formal procedures that they have to be a part of.
As you can imagine, a big part of that would be having legal representation. Without legal
representation, we might be hindering our ability to achieve fairness. We might not be able to
understand these court processes and procedures. Processes and procedures should be completed in a
timely fashion. There shouldn't be unreasonable delays or an accused person waiting for their
criminal trial in custody, in jail, for an abnormal amount of time. So it should be completed in a
timely fashion with adequate legal representation. We need legal representation in order to be able
to present our case in its best light and have the highest chances of success, essentially.
Everyone also has the opportunity to present an individual defence. This goes for the criminal
justice system in particular. An accused should be able to raise a defence. Maybe you've heard of
things like insanity defence, for example. Everyone should know what evidence is being
brought against them so parties actually share the evidence that they're going to use against
each other before trial so they can prepare for that evidence to appear to court, how they're
going to make it lose credibility or defend against it or bring up other evidence that shows,
that discredits that piece of evidence. So evidence sharing, whatever the prosecution submits in a
criminal trial and whatever the accused and the accused person's legal rep are planning to use,
it's disclosed to the trial and all parties that are part of the trial then have access to
that evidence so they can prepare for it to appear in trial. Similarly, in a civil case, the plaintiff
who has brought the claim to court and the defendant who is the party that the case is against,
they also have to share evidence with one another. With fairness, everyone also has
the opportunity to disprove the respective counsel's case so maybe cross-examination
comes to mind when some evidence is presented by the prosecution, for example. The accused
person's legal representation will afterwards cross-examine and question the witness that
the prosecution has been using to try to discredit them. And everyone should have the opportunity to
try to appeal or review a decision if only their grounds to do so, to have a case reviewed
by a higher court. Now equality is more self-explanatory. Everyone should be treated
evenly before the law with the same opportunities to present their case. This means everyone really
needs to be having an equal opportunity to present their case. There should be no bias or prejudice
in any of our processes. This happens more so in fairness. Fairness is all about having no bias.
But everyone should have the same rights. Everyone should have the same entitlements
that they are entitled to. No one should be treated at a disadvantage.
That's what equality is all about. So don't confuse the two. Remember fairness is a lot about
no bias, impartial decisions, impartial judge, impartial processes, giving everyone a fair go.
And equality is everything should be the same essentially for everyone. So I've got a little
bit of a comparison table to try to show you how the points that you could use, and you could even
use something like this in questions, how they would differ for fairness and equality.
So for fairness we see severe penalties should be given for severe crimes and vice versa. That
shows that unbiased treatment. If you've committed a severe crime of course you should get a severe
punishment. The same would happen for a minor offending. It would be a minor penalty slash sanction.
Can present their case with strict adherence to rules of evidence and procedures. So fairness
means everyone needs to be subject to the same strict rules of evidence and procedure that are
in court, including the language, the strict deadlines. Everyone has to
follow those because that's fair. And if people are treated differently it should be from
application of the law, not because of their personal characteristics. So that is fairness.
Equality instead means being deemed equal in status, rights and opportunities. We all have the
same rights in the court system, in an ideal world. So when you give a weakness for how a process does
not achieve equality, you look at how it fails to make everyone equal as part of that system or
process. And which people would not have equality in that instance. But the assumption that
equality makes is that everyone who comes before the law is treated the same. As you can imagine
that doesn't really happen. And laws should be applied equally to everyone and not provide
exceptions or discriminate individuals based on any of their personal attributes. So all of these
things should not be a factor and should not be posing any kind of threat or disadvantage to you.
Lastly, looking at access. Remember it's all about understanding. Understanding legal rights
and the court system and pursuing claims in the legal system. So if I want to initiate a case
against someone that has caused me some kind of harm or loss, first of all, if I had access, I
would be able to understand that I have a right to initiate a claim against them and how. And then I
would also be able to pursue that claim to actually go have the finances and the information and the
opportunity to go and try to sue that person, for example, by initiating the case. So we've
everyone should be understanding of their legal rights in society. That includes what laws there
are and how they can pursue anything if there's been some kind of wrongdoing against them.
Everyone should also be able to pursue their case through avenues not beyond their reach.
So courts are expensive. As you will learn and as we'll look at in this lecture, there are a few
other bodies that offer low cost or even free resolution. They aim to enhance access the most
within these criminal and civil justice systems, because they try to make it affordable for
everyone who couldn't access the courts otherwise. They couldn't afford it. Access also implies that
everyone should be able to access courts, education, information, assistance, bodies
and institutions regarding a legal process and just to seek advice. And everyone should receive
materials pertaining to criminal cases, processes and outcomes. So everyone is able to access
information and bodies to pursue their claims. So looking at the principles of justice, this is a
bit of a summary table. Don't expect this to make everything clear for you yet, but this is giving
you some examples that are really good to discuss for each principle of justice across the justice
system overall. So we said because fairness is all about bias and not having bias, an impartial
judge and jury are beneficial for the attainment of fairness, having an open and public hearing so
everyone can see that it is fair. People can actually go to court and watch and see that there
is no discrimination happening. The court for Indigenous and Torres Strait Islander peoples
is giving them an unbiased process that they can access for sentencing. Equality, all individuals
are able to use the justice system, all of them have the same rights. So we're just about to start
looking at the rights of the accused and the rights of victims and this helps to uphold
equality because all individuals get the same rights. With regards to the criminal justice
system, access, all those bodies and organisations that I mentioned help to provide access to more
people to pursue claims because it's more affordable, it's quicker etc. They also share
their own information about the court system and how everything works and what the law is etc.
So you should have tables like this in your notes. For most of Unit 3 you will be making tables or
dot point notes just like this pretty much every single time in Unit 3, both in criminal and civil
when you learn a concept or a process you will be writing points for how that process does achieve
the principles of justice and how it doesn't achieve and you will need to remember a lot of
points. So it becomes a difficult subject in that sense but what I would like to say is
you shouldn't be memorising everything but you should just be making sense of all information
that you cover in the subject until you can just understand it. There shouldn't be any need for you
to memorise, maybe at first you will need to memorise these ideas but then you'll notice
that how each principle of justice is achieved or isn't achieved, the points start to get very
repetitive and you'll just be able to think of points for each topic as long as you understand
it. So this is great because I like this meme, when you use access in every question
where you have to link to the principles of justice, it ain't much but it's honest work
because access is so easy to use. If it's all about understanding costs and time
being minimised or not being minimised thus achieving or not achieving access it becomes
so easy and a lot of students do that and it's just a little bit of a life hack.
So now these are our overarching concepts for everything in unit three, the principle of justice.
