Treaties and Third Parties | International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 1, 2024
Welcome back everybody to our studies in Public International Law. We are continuing in this
video talking about the sources of international law, specifically the sources of treaties,
and we'll talk about the effect and impact that a treaty may have on a third party. Now,
this is obviously in reference to the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. We'll
be citing the convention in multiple different stages in this video, and we'll just explore
the nature of treaties in this regard. The previous lesson we talked about treaty reservations
as a key element of the treaty itself, and we asked the question of whether or not the
concept of the reservation, or the right of reservation, is something that was universal
across all different treaties within public international law, citing famously the advisory
opinion from the International Court of Justice on the question of reservations to the 1948
Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. So, the implications
and limitations of reservations were discussed in the previous lesson. This lesson we're
going to talk about the impact on third states that a treaty may potentially have. Now, the
general rule when we talk about how treaties affect that of other states that are not party
to the treaty is that of Article 34 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
Article 34 says that, quote, a treaty does not create either obligations or rights for
a third state without its consent. That's fundamentally where it begins and ends when
we talk about the relationship between treaties and third states. They do not create obligations,
nor do they do not create duties and things that essentially the third state has to do,
nor do they create any kind of rights that a third state may privilege from. It should
be noted, however, that this is a general rule of international law. This is the general
rule. This is not the absolute rule. There are other exceptions to this rule that we
have to think about. Well, first of all, there is a general exception found within Article
34. Read it again. A treaty does not create either obligations or rights for third states
without its consent. This is the first exception that we can really highlight here. The idea
of it being done without their consent. If what if it's a situation where a third state
or a third party does consent to have rights or obligations imposed upon it while not being
expressly part of the treaty? Well, the Vienna Convention on the Law of the Treaty seems
to make it very clear. If it has consented, then the idea of the treaty having a right
or an obligation applied to it is something that therefore means that it would affect
a third state. So, there are notable exceptions to this rule. We can also find further exceptions
in the Vienna Convention itself. Take, for example, Article 35. Article 35 says, quote,
an obligation arises for a third state from a provision of a treaty if the parties to
that treaty intend the provision to be the means of establishing the obligation and the
third state expressly accepts that obligation in writing. This is carrying on from Article
34. So, it fundamentally takes Article 34 and it says, well, if a treaty exists and
it is signed between two states and there is a third state that's sitting in the corner
that is not a party to the treaty, unless that third state consents themselves to being
bound to the obligations or having the rights of the treaty, then this treaty has no impact
on them. And then it goes on and it says here that the obligation for a third state from
a provision will arise for a third state. It will arise out of a treaty if the parties
to the treaty had intended the provision to be a means of establishing the obligation.
So, there has to be first an intention on the part of the people who are making the
treaty that this provision in question will have an obligation on the third state and
the third state has to expressly accept this obligation in writing. Again, this all dates
back to and formulates this quite theoretical conception of international law being something
that is done with the consent of parties. It is consent that is required for the majority
of obligations to be bound onto states. States, at least under this conception, are the primary
and principal components of public international law and so they do so with their own recognition
of sovereignty, their own recognition of state sovereignty, which means that there has to
be consent to be bound to obligations from treaties. This being treaties that they sign
onto, so if they are not third states, but also provisions that establish obligations
onto third states as per both Article 34 and Article 35 of the Vienna Convention on the
Law of Treaties. Article 36 goes on to say the following. They say, quote,
"...a right arises for a third state from a provision of a treaty if the parties to
the treaty intend the provision to accord that right, either to the third state or to
a group of states to which it belongs, or to all states, and the third state assents
thereto. Its assent shall be presumed so long as the contrary is not indicated unless the
treaty otherwise provides. A state exercising a right in accordance with paragraph 1 shall
comply with the conditions for its exercise provided for in the treaty or established
in conformity with the treaty." What does this tell us? Well, this is just talking about
the next part of basically unpacking Article 34, but for rights, not just obligations.
So the Vienna Convention seems to be delineating between rights and obligations in Article
35 and Article 36. What it's essentially saying is that if there is an obligation
that is being intended by the people making the treaty, then it is required for the third
state to consent to that obligation. But if it is a right, okay, we still have to have
the intention, there has to be an intention on the part of the person creating the treaty,
this is going to confer a right onto either a third state, a group of states, or all states.
But then we also have the fact that the assent of the third state to that right, the requirement
of that right, the acceptance of that right, is presumed. It is a presumption of acceptance
so long as the contrary is not indicated. So if the third state says, well, we don't
want this right, then therefore it would be within the remit of Article 36.1 that the
contrary is indicated. However, for the most part, where rights are conferred, if there
is an intent on the part of the parties to confer this right, then the right is assumed
to exist between the third state and the people who created the treaty. In order to exercise
that right, okay, so we have the presumption of the right existing in Article 36.1. Article
36.2 tells us that in order to exercise this right, if you're a third state, you have to
comply with the conditions for its exercise, which is done for the treaty or is established
in conformity with the treaty. So you have to do so in conformity with the conditions
that are required for you to actually be able to exercise the right in accordance with the
particular treaty itself. So all of these things highlight a continuing element of public
international law that we've been really touching upon back and forth throughout these
series of lessons, which is this idea of consent being of paramount importance for states in
public international law. So it should be noted very clearly that even though these
can be considered to be rights and obligations which are placed on third states, which are
placed on state third parties that are not party to the treaty itself, the idea of consent
for these third parties are placed front and center of the conversation. Fundamentally,
what this is suggesting, therefore, is that public international law should not be in
the business of rejecting the ability for third states to have some kind of relationship
with the treaty so long as consent exists for that to be the case. Therefore, it suggests
therefore it therefore suggests that consent is the point of paramount importance for us
as international lawyers understanding the relationship between states and their third parties.
