Cobra Kai Cafeteria Fight | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 26, 2024
in our most recent episode movie karate
we talked about all sorts of different
tips and techniques that filmmakers and
editors use to make movie fight scenes
so much cooler than they have any
business being and to highlight this
concept we're gonna take one scene from
cobra kai from season one
and it's the school lunchroom scene and
we're going to take a look at the
cinematics versus the realism at play
now it goes without saying this is gonna
have some spoiler alerts if you have not
watched cobra kai on either youtube
premium or on netflix
yet pause this episode go watch the show
a thousand times because it's that
awesome and then come back and join the
discussion
because we will be giving away some some
minor plot elements so if you don't want
to be spoiled then please go check it
now if you don't care
then let's move on i thought that this
was a really good scene to start with
mainly because even though it's halfway
through the first season
it's a pivotal moment you know this is a
moment that kind of cements
and sets the dynamic for these
characters going forward so i thought
this was the appropriate place to start
now we're assuming you know who
characters are if you've continued
watching this
but up at this point we've seen our main
character miguel
be impacted by the bullies a couple
times in the first episode he's getting
his butt kicked by them in the parking
lot
johnny comes to the rescue and saves him
later at the halloween dance we see
miguel
has learned just enough karate to get
himself into trouble and he faces off
with kyler again
delivers a beautiful front kick and it
works but then he realizes very quickly
he's in over his head
and then the whole scenario does not end
very well for him so at this point of
the show we're halfway through the show
and kyler keeps getting the best of
miguel and this goes back to our most
recent episode
we talked about the different hierarchy
in the movie scene when it comes to a
fight
where the realism itself the actual
realistic nature of the fighting
is actually on the bottom totem of the
priority list
number one is the narrative setting you
know this is a
narrative piece they're telling the
story so every scene has to move the
story forward so there's some sort of
storytelling
some sort of character development the
story has to move forward that's number
one priority
two then we have the choreography which
is the actual fight that they choose you
know it's gotta look cool it has to be
engaging
and it's gotta be creative it's gotta be
different enough so that's the
choreography that goes into it to make
it more of a spectacle
then there's the presentation and
intended effect and that means
what do the filmmakers want the viewers
to feel after watching the scene
do they want to feel triumphant do they
want the viewers to be angry
upset happy you know terrified suspense
you know
that's that comes into play too so
you've got your
narrative structure so moving the drama
forward you have the choreography and
making it creative and look good
you've got your presentation and the
effect you want on the audience
once you've met those then it's about
making it as realistic as possible
within those confines
and that's usually the priority of how
things are set in an action film
and all of that plays into this scene
right here this lunchroom scene we're
halfway through season one
this is a milestone scene that how this
plays out
affects the path of the show from this
point forward so you have your narrative
structure right there
we also see some choreography we're
gonna get back to that part in a minute
but we're gonna see some moves that
we saw miguel training so that
choreography is in place
as far as the intention this is
definitely a root for the underdog
moment
this is definitely we want to feel
triumphant and that is what that's our
takeaway when we walk away from the
scene
after that the realism is actually
pretty low but nobody cares because the
scene itself was just
cool enough and it actually impacted
enough to move the show forward
so what's interesting though is when the
scene starts it actually appears like
it's going to be a samantha versus kylie
moment
we know samantha has training we know
she can take her they already kind of
show us a glimpse that she knows how to
handle him
kyler's pushing her buttons and actually
samantha takes a stance it looks like
she's about to unleash so it's like
okay this is gonna be satisfying we're
gonna watch samantha kick the crap out
of him
until miguel steps in then we realize oh
this is his moment
is he going to succeed so i thought it
was interesting how they shifted the
tone from one they quickly switched it
over to miguel
this is miguel's defining moment this is
where i feel is the most realistic of
the scene
the shoves and the intimidation is real
miguel's kind of getting his bearing you
know he's had no success up to this
point
and then kyla throws a punch and miguel
immediately does a defensive tactic and
captures it
and of course if he pauses and delivers
the cool line saying it's not lame mass
karate it's cobra kai
then delivers the counter strike okay
total hollywood right there
you don't stop in the little fight the
bad guy's not going to stand there and
let you give a catchphrase something
like that
that's pretty unrealistic it was pretty
badass in the moment
but right off the bat that's not a
realistic part of a real fight
but what happens from that point on i
really like this is my favorite part of
the fight
kyle's reaction is rage he's bewildered
for a second
grabs miguel and just starts throwing
them around the tables and for anyone
who's seen a real high school fight in a
lunch room
that's pretty much what it is you know
wild swings grabbing and choking
throwing each other into tables
and it's frantic and miguel looks
panicked and for the moment you can
relate if you've ever been into a fight
you've got that moment of okay this is
on this is happening
you try to find your first bearing and
you see the moment it clicks
when kyle pulls him off the table the
second time and puts him in that choke
hold
miguel immediately recognizes his
position because we've had some
foreshadowing of johnny teaching them
different techniques
he recognizes this position and he goes
right into action and actually
you know delivers another blow to kyler
which is extremely satisfying to watch
and what i find realistic about it is
again that panic and that franticness it
feels raw
that is authentic and even his his
counter attack and the kick and the way
collar falls off the side
it's a little sloppy kind of awkward but
again also realistic it's not
movie-esque you know he's not doing a
chuck norris move
it's a gangly teenager you know trying
to defend himself having just learned
after a couple weeks now he has to
succeed because failure is going to be
worse this time
and then we're cheering along with them
especially when alicia stands up she
goes no mercy
it's on we're excited we are now
automatically rooting for the underdog
and here's where it gets a little silly
here's where the
hollywood hollywood doe comes in first
he exhibits a spidey sense with that
punch coming in
he drops down and we're gonna call him
the big dumb guy because that's what
johnny called him
big dumb guy comes in for punch and
miguel drops and sweeps and takes him
right down
a couple minor problems with this and
these are very nitpicky problems is
continuity if you go frame by frame if
you're a geek like i am and you went
frame by frame
you can see that when the big dumb one
comes in for a swing he's already a
mid-swing in the close-up shot
but when you cut to the lower shot you
see both of his hands are down so he's
not in swing position
and his lead leg is different okay it's
an editing continuity
error but it's very very minor then
miguel does a sweep and
in my opinion that sweep was just way
too easy a big guy like that
really wasn't off balance enough to have
his legs flail out from underneath him
that way
especially considering miguel never
actually touched him
we talked about this in the previous
episode about how you
frame camera shots so that they look
like this connection happening where
you know a foot or a hand just has to
pass in front of an object to make it
look like they're connecting
if you look closely you see miguel's
foot actually sweeps the floor in front
of big dumb ones legs and there's no
contact made
but the reaction and the falling down
i think helps sell it so yes i am
nitpicking here when you go frame by
frame when you play it back
it's good enough you get by with it it
still adds to the scene in the moment
but nitpicking you can see there's a
couple little movie magic tidbits
happening in there
and here's where they kind of dip into
briefly the whole well you're going to
attack and you're going to attack
the whole one at a time multiple
attackers that you see a lot of movies
it's not that realistic
it's only brief here i'm willing to
forgive it but um he gets attacked from
behind he goes to that chokehold
he delivers a hammer fist to the guy's
groin okay good buys himself a couple
seconds
that could legitimately be a technique
and he delivers a solid front kick to
the next guy and we've already seen him
deliver a front kick so if he were to
land that
totally believable that kid will fly
back and maybe buy himself a few more
seconds
and then he turns spins as that
beautiful crescent kick knocking the
next guy out
the other thing though is again camera
angles because later in the show
you see an alternate angle from a cell
phone when miguel
did the turn spin kick he was nowhere
near landing that strike so that's that
part
i was talking about where certain camera
angles can help sell strikes better than
others
that you have to frame things in a
certain way to make it look like things
connect so that was a little sloppy
later they showed the other angle
but it's actually kind of fun to see the
difference in the two
how much of a difference a slight angle
change can make now i do feel that the
scene has a pretty good use of
environmental space
and if you go back to the karate kid
movies most of the fights are in big
open areas and
with some exceptions but most times
they're on a big open mat in a
tournament or they're in a big open room
cobra kai there's a lot more
environmental usage you know they fight
in the bar they fight
in a school hallway they fight in an
apartment they fight in the school
lunchroom
you see a lot of different environments
in which the actors are playing off of
and there's a good example of that here
miguel is using the tables he is putting
obstacles between himself and his
attackers and he's using his space as
part of the fight and that really makes
the fight that much more interesting
because the moves themselves aren't that
impressive but it's this whole
the way he's reading the situation that
we're invested in and the way he's
trying to scramble to get away and
protect himself is what we're invested
in
and using the environment in such a way
i think was very effective way to do
that
i'm not a fan of the chair knocking the
guy down um
at best you know pushing a chair like
that is is a good quick delay but i
don't think anyone's gonna go craning
over it
like that my pet peeve of the scene
honestly
is that stupid food tray miguel picks up
the food
tray plastic food tray not very
aerodynamic
not very heavy and he's knocking guys
out with it he's hitting people he's
blocking with it he's striking with it
i understand what they're going with
that he's grabbing a tool that's at his
disposal i just wish they would have
chose something better like a book or a
bag something with more substance
because you're not gonna do a whole lot
of damage with that tray
maybe if you used it once but it was
like his primary weapon and he's like
mean guys and knocking him out over the
head
i have a hard time believing he's going
to knock somebody out or even knocks me
down
hit him with that kind of a tray that's
just my opinion
i kind of was kind of like when they did
that but
it did highlight ingenuity and just kind
of the
you know cement in the fact is that when
you are in a self-defense situation
that you really should be aware of your
environment and that anything around you
can be used to defend yourself so i
think it succeeded in highlighting that
i just my nitpick is in the choice of
object i just don't think that was as
effective and that kind of pulled me out
a little bit
so after knocking the guys around a
little bit miguel's wrapping it up he's
trying to escape he sees kyle getting up
jumps on big dumb guy jumps on the table
and delivers a nice little you know
sweeping back kick to the kyler knocking
it backwards
no problem with that i mean yes you know
legitimately speaking he could have
gotten enough torque enough energy to do
some damage
but then he resorts back to that trey
again but ultimately though
as far as the story goes he's now
vanquished his bullies
he's taken all four of them out he is
lunch from hero he stands up and there's
this triumphant moment
he has now gained new respect in the
school he has now attracted the eye of
the girl that he likes
his friends who doubted him are now
seeing the value of self defense and
karate so
this was a pretty big moment for miguel
the fighting was kind of weak in itself
if you break down individual moves it
was pretty weak
but the overall presentation the way
they framed the angles
the way they edited the timing his use
of space the music pumps you up the
character's excitement
all wrapped up adds up to a scene that's
pretty pivotal
and it's a tentpole scene and a very
important scene in the in the series
because
it really affects a lot of things going
forward and i also like that it
stretches far enough to the point where
it vindicates johnny a little bit
because we saw johnny
working with miguel on a variety of
techniques and one of them was at
chokehold so when we see it being
applied in real life here
it kind of is like okay you know it kind
of cements the bond between him and
johnny johnny taught him well
and we see that and when you see a
little bit of a foreshadow like that and
have it paid off later
i find that very satisfying and it
happened the original karate kid film
too
in the tournament between daniel and
johnny uh daniel's
moves are pretty basic he's pretty much
you know punched front kick round kick
for the most part
but there's that one moment where he
pulls out that nice leglock takedown and
there's that backfisted johnny's head
for a sweet point
it seems pretty advanced for daniel way
more advanced than the other stuff he's
done
but we got to see the moment where
daniel saw that was first exposed to it
when he was goofing around with miyagi
and miyagi did it to him
it was such a subtle little moment
earlier that when we see him breaking
out later
dramatically speaking and his audience
engagement it's that much more
satisfying so i like to see that cobra
kai is doing little things like that
they drop little hints and they pay off
later so the whole position recognition
of miguel
in that chokehold and slithering out and
doing that counter-strike was
beautifully done i think it was a very
impactful moment in the series
so that was just one fun example to show
how there's little tricks that you can
do to make action scenes much better
because
you don't always have the greatest
martial arts or actors that have martial
arts skills so sometimes you have to
cheat a little bit
and i find it impressive different
tactics that you can use
to make actors and make the scenes look
better and come across better than they
would have in real life
and that's part of the fun of movie
magic and if you guys like this episode
if you kind of like this concept of
breaking down movie scenes
please by all means suggest more below
because maybe we can do more of these if
there's specific scenes
that you either want to break down you
want to hear explain or you don't know
how
something was done and you wanted to be
discussion you know i
i value all your input so please leave
those comments down below and also be
sure to check out our past episode where
we talked about movie crote if you
haven't already
where we go a little bit more in depth
of the different camera work and a
different editing work that can help
amplify these scenes so this is kind of
a partner companion piece with that
so if you haven't checked it out already
please go take a look
and thank you so much for watching i
look forward to your feedback and we'll
see you next week
you
