Can You Skip Karate Belt Ranks?

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
344 Video Views·Jun 12, 2024
can you skip karate belt ranks the quick
answer is of course you can it happens
all the time the better question is
should you and that's other quick answer
no now I'm not usually this definitive
but I think I can be on this one in a
few minutes I'm going to tell you about
my unearned rank story and I'll share
something that only up to this point our
patreon and private members
know today's topic was actually inspired
by a recent viewer question and I want
to apologize to that viewer if my answer
seemed inflexible it triggered a little
nerv and I realize of all the belt
topics on this channel this was one we
haven't hit upon yet skipping or jumping
belt ranks and this isn't just for a
Kate but for any Milestone equivalent in
any art the question was if my child
gets hurt and is not able to practice do
they still have a chance to catch up
with their class after the injury a few
months later if I understand correctly
you're asking about accelerating rank to
catch up and not necessarily skipping
ranks but honestly my an is the same for
both so I'm just grouping both scenarios
together so there's three primary
reasons why somebody would even skip
rank to begin with OR accelerate at a
faster speed number one is trying to
catch up to lost time you know we all
have our struggles we all have our
timeouts injuries or life gets in the
way it's easy to slip and fall back and
you know wanting to catch up is
understandable two knowing Advanced
material going ahead and looking ahead
to material and being the head of where
you are and three having good optics for
the school or a status symbol
unfortunately I know a lot of schools
who have promoted students faster or
skip ranks so that it look better on the
school to have higher ranks But to
answer the question directly no I don't
believe you can make up for Los time
because it's quite literally lost time
you know if you were out for months it's
not like you can just cram for a week
and suddenly be where you were you know
3 months ago four months ago however
long it was there is physical
conditioning and growth that comes with
the time it's not just memorizing the
material and if you've been out for a
while it might actually take you longer
because unless you've been constantly
refreshing your material you're going to
you're going to forget things and you're
going to have to take time to refresh
and I understand you know the child's
going to want to catch up to their
classmates but it's also it's not fair
to the classmates who were there to
train and they put in that work and
finally it's not fair to your child
because it doesn't teach him how to
handle setbacks and this reminds me of a
story when I used to teach at the local
school I was a part-time instructor we
had a child who was red belt um two two
belts away from their junior black belt
and his parents decided they left the
country for a year they took him with
them when they came back a year later
they said you know what we feel it's
been long enough he's been in class long
enough we want him to test was black
belt now and there was a black belt test
coming up and we were like um but you
understand he hasn't been here so in
their mind that clock kept ticking even
though he wasn't in class they felt that
that time counted towards his training
and they were pushing really hard and
ultimately we decided no that we're not
going to do that and I even said I'm not
going to be part of that testing board
if this kid is allowed to jump two ranks
after being gone for a year the parents
didn't take it very well but eventually
they they submitted they said okay but
the reason was um he wasn't there and
he'd forgotten half of his material like
when we actually tried to assess him
where he was at he couldn't remember
half of what he tested for already so
right then he was already behind second
we had other students we had two other
kids who were on the verge of qualifying
for testing and they themselves opted to
wait for the next test 6 months later
because they wanted to be extra ready
what kind of message would we have sent
them if we allow this kid to jump two
ranks no that wasn't going to happen I
understand there's a social friction in
place where kids want to be with their
classmates and that they fall behind
it's uncomfortable and it's awkward but
imagine the friction if your child
suddenly matching them without putting
in the same work it's going to be worse
and that ties into skipping ranks you
don't just get ranked for just knowing
the material and you don't just get
ranked just for putting in the time they
go together you put in the time to know
the material and I unfortunately have
known people who have read ahead or
watch the head and memorize the future
material and flat out asked us to skip
ranks honestly unless that person is an
absolute Prodigy and I'm not saying
they're not I've actually met a couple
then simply looking ahead is not the
same as being at that level why not okay
a few reasons incomplete skill
development each rank represents a set
of skills and techniques skipping can
lead to gaps in knowledge and abilities
making the student less proficient and
potentially more prone to mistakes next
the lack of foundation you know training
is cumulative with each level building
upon the previous one so skipping ranks
can result in a weak Foundation as a
student might miss critical fundamental
skills that are necessary for the
Advanced Techniques safety is a big one
you know the martial arts involve a lot
of physical physical activity that can
be dangerous if not performed correctly
without the proper progression a student
might not learn Essential Safety
protocols or have even developed the
right control yet psychological impact
achieving rank is a milestone that
provides a sense of accomplishment and
boost confidence skipping can deprive
students of these motivational
Milestones potentially leading to
decreased morale and commitments and
this actually relates to the story I'm
going to tell you in a few minutes next
peer discrepancies you know in a Dojo
students are usually grouped by rank
which ensures that they train with
others at the similar level now student
who skips ranks might find themselves
out of sync with their peers leading to
frustration and even additional social
friction within the dojo and bad Optics
you know we talked about the good Optics
if a student wears a rank that they
aren't ready for it actually reflects
poorly on the school now some people
think that having a room full of black
belts looks good for the school but if
they're moving like yellow belts you're
actually creating a negative impression
I have actually one more point to add to
this but I want to elaborate on that
first one first the incomplete skills
development you know accelerating train
can happen but it requires dedication
and daily hours of work but just
promoting people because it looks good
it does not help your school and there
was actually family the last year my my
former instructor when he had the school
open the last year he was open he
actually had a family that was training
with us it was a father and their two
teenage kids and within a year within
one year they went from white belts to
brown belts that's seven ranks normally
there's 3 to six months for each rank if
they went through the proper channels
but but he was kind of burnt out and he
was he was decreasing and watering down
the curriculum and just pass them um
they did not move very well they looked
like novices and when I saw that that
really kind of put a damper on my view
at the school because it looked bad
people think the Optics might look good
but the Optics can actually work against
you in that case so I'm going to segue
into my personal story from here back in
2015 I was in training for my 503 black
belts and I had had a long talk with my
instructor because I had seen the ranks
that he was giv away and how fast they
were and I was working a different
curriculum he was re retooling stuff he
was stripping things down but he let me
stay on the traditional full curriculum
because that's what I wanted to learn I
wanted to see everything and I pulled
them aside and I had to talk with him I
said look I said when it comes time for
me to test I want to make sure it's
because i' I've been through the whole
curriculum not just because it was a
matter of time or whatever and he agreed
he's like yeah sure no problem he
actually recorded for me all the lessons
going forward so I had the material but
I you know I still wanted to go through
it so about you know a month or so later
he calls me up and he's like hey I'm
just going to let you know you're going
to get your fifth degree next week and
I'm like wait I'm still quite a bit away
from learning the material he goes yeah
I know but he goes I'm going to move
soon and it's now or never and besides
uh he goes you've already passed all the
requirements of the class of our school
and there's nothing less for me to show
you and that didn't sit well with me
because one we had talked about it and
two I felt like he was doing the same
thing with me that he did with everyone
else he was just giving rank away and
this really kind of put me in a tough
spot cuz I'm like do I have a falling
out with him and turn him down and
embarrass him in front of the school um
I did some soul searching and I wrestled
with it and what I the conclusion I came
to was I accepted the rank on his behalf
like I accepted the fact that he
accepted me but to myself I still had
something to prove so you know I did go
into class next week and he gave me the
promotion and he gave me certificate in
the belt Rank and I've got you know I've
got the belt but I didn't wear it for 6
months because I still had my
requirements I had met his approval I
had not yet met mine so I spent 6 months
hardcore studying that material going
through everything by the end of those
six months I knew that entire curriculum
I finally felt good enough I had
accomplished what I wanted to accomplish
I had his approval so I accepted the
belt but the thing though is for the
past nine years it's always bugged me in
the back of my mind you know I've got
this stigma against myself now sometimes
I feel like I haven't earned it and I
know I put that work in I know I put
that work in I put 22 work 20 2 years
into earning that belt and it's been
nine cents um but you know life gotten
away you know I fell out of training my
father got sick and passed away you know
I had to work so there were times where
I didn't train as hard and I've
forgotten some material and I've been
working my way back into it I've been
reviewing because I've put myself in a
bit of an academic probation so I've
been wearing just a traditional regular
plain black belt most of the time um
I'll wear I'll wear the the official one
for like testing and seminars and such
but even though I know I earned it and I
know I put that time in that that doubt
is in the back of my head because his
reason his reason bothered me I do hope
to train for you know and get sixth
degree one day but I don't want it until
I've earned it my point to is don't do
that to yourself don't do that to your
students and certainly don't do that to
your children let them earn their ranks
naturally make it worth something to
them if there's a loss of time there's a
loss of time unfortunately setbacks
happen teaching your child to deal with
that adversity and still struggle and
push through is far more respectable
than jumping to catch up so I want to
take that back to the last point of the
reasons why you shouldn't skip rank
there's a loss of tradition and
integrity karate is so deeply rooted in
Tradition and the ranking system is a
big part of that Heritage when you skip
it can be seen as a disregard for that
system and those traditions and
potentially it damages the Integrity of
the art that you're trying to represent
yes it's just a piece of fabric but yes
there's also tradition attached to it so
whether you want to just toss on the
floor and forget about it or spend all
your time harping about belt etiquette
in the end what's important is the
quality of your training so with that
being said should you skip ranks I still
say no because if you feel it's more
than a piece of cloth and if you feel it
represents something greater then you
should respect that value and if you're
from the other camp and you think it's
just a piece of cloth and nothing else
then why are you worrying about rank
anyway just focus on your training
besides there really is only one belt
that actually matters and probably not
in the way you think
