Cobra Kai and the Truth About Karate | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
1 Video View·Oct 25, 2024
for those of you familiar with this
channel you know how much we love the
karate kid and the kobokai tv series
and one of our primary focuses has been
trying to determine what type of karate
is miyagido
and cobra kai now with the release of
season three
we now have a definitive answer so we're
gonna look at that real quick but also
the season also brings to attention
another very important aspect of the
martial arts that i don't think gets
enough attention and that enough people
are talking about so we're gonna dig
into that
right now
[Music]
so i have to up front say spoiler alert
we're going to be talking about events
of season three and the cobra kai tv
series
if you have not yet watched cobra kai
season 3 pause the video go watch this
if you have not yet seen cobra kai pause
this video go watch the series and come
back
if you have not seen the karate kid
movies then that's just like a crank
to the face guys i mean come on
so with that out of the way going
forward our previous assessments of
miyagidou and cobra kai we're not going
to go into too deeply now because we've
already done a few episodes on that
but we had determined that miyagi dough
is a version of
gojiru and okinawa style of karate and
that cobra kai was actually a variant of
tonksudo
because of the different korean art
elements that we have had peppered into
the movies and the series
now if you want to see a full breakdown
of how we came to these conclusions you
can check on the link below we have some
of those episodes there
but basically that's what we came up
with go guru
and tang tsudo now of course you know
we're talking about what's canon what's
actually in the narrative structure of
the story we know
that there are different people who are
stunt doubles and and other uh
coordinators and choreographers that
brought their influences of other arts
and
of course on screen we see a lot of
mixture of different arts and stunt work
i'm talking about the narrative arts you
know what in the story are the styles
supposed to be
and this season cover kai sees three
came right out and confirmed it
cobra kai is in fact tongue tsudo so
that was actually really interesting
that they actually just
came right out and said it they
confirmed the instructor that terry
silver mentioned kim sung young so he
was actually telling the truth
and we are told up front that chris's
instructor was taught tungsto and he's
going to teach him the same art
so there we have it narratively speaking
canon
cobra kai is tonksudo or at least some
version of it
now with miyagi doe we determine gojiru
from a variety of factors based you know
just
ranging from you know miyagi's name to
the village she's from and then there's
for style and the kata is used um the
screenwriter practiced gojiru and he
based a lot of it off himself
in karate kid2 um sato's nephew chosen
actually wears a gojiroo or the goju kai
patch right here on his ghee
so some of you might be saying okay so
what that's chosen not daniel well let's
not forget that
joseph's instructor sato trained under
mr miyagi's father they trained together
they were basically brothers so miyagi's
father
trained both of them and they each had
their respective student which was
daniel and
and chosen and we broke this down in the
previous episode but what's interesting
is cobra kai season 3
pretty much came out and gave almost the
exact same explanation you know
chosen takes daniel to his home dojo and
daniel's looking through the scrolls and
he realizes
that this is actually miyagi do karate
and they come right out and say it
and then he says we're basically karate
cousins because they explain the lineage
so we have to assume they are the same
art gojiru because
it's confirmed by wearing the patch or
at least sato school was
registered with the gojukai and i know
jesse encamped the karate nerd actually
issued his own
theory about what kind of art the miyagi
miyagi dosa is
and it's actually a really good watch
and that's in the link in the
description below as well
the thing that was his theory is
different than mine however they
can coexist because his theory actually
really more explains the background
of miyagido's family lineage versus what
i'm talking about what we see in the
films and what's supposed to be in the
story going forward
so all that aside we now have
confirmation that miyagi del crate is
gojiru and that cobra kai is tonks
trudeau so
that was awesome and i love the
discussion we had so many people out
there have proposed so many different
ideas and it was a really fun
debate and discussion to see what
perspectives people were coming from
and there were a lot of great points
made but as fun as that is
i think the show actually brought to the
surface a much more important
issue that i don't think enough people
are talking about the whole premise of
corporate is talking about the ultimate
rivalry
daniel versus johnny we see them as
polar opposites we're like you know
here's an example of politics here's an
example of opposites here's an example
of how different styles can diverge and
all that
the thing though is i don't believe that
daniel and johnny defines that duality
of karate and the division in the split
i believe that that distinction goes to
daniel and chosen
daniel and chosen show a much deeper
opposition to each other than daniel and
johnny
even as ali brought up in season three
she said to them she goes with this
rivalry that
they see a lot of each themselves in
each other and they might not like what
they see
and if you look at the conflict the the
problems between daniel and johnny
are personal it was over a girl it was
high school drama it wasn't over the
martial arts the martial arts were just
a tool that they used but their actual
personal conflict
was petty issues and when they put them
aside
they actually get along together pretty
well and we've seen that a few times
where they do work together and they
work together well
when their egos allow it with chosen and
daniel the problems go a little bit
deeper and it's more about
honor even though some of their their
conflicts were superficial as well
but i think that the dynamic here shows
us
the grand scheme of the martial arts one
of the biggest problems we have in the
martial arts today
is the division the politics the splits
the show was showing us
how easily the martial arts can splinter
look at
for example mr miyagi's father and in
this case we're going to refer to him as
the grandmaster because he's the one who
kind of started this particular lineage
that we're following
mr miyagi's father tat miyagi and sato
look how drastically different their
teaching methods are and look at daniel
chosen how different
they are we're talking two generations
right off the bat you can see
you know gojiru means hard soft miyagi
is the soft side of the martial arts
sato is the hard side it's very evident
sato is very very bold very strong very
powerful
miyagi is always on the defensive and
he's always doing the more software
techniques
and they pass those values down and
that's what happens in the martial arts
when a teacher
learns something they take their lessons
they take the instructions they pull out
the values that mean something to them
and they go with that and they cultivate
that and many times they'll leave out
stuff that they don't like
or they don't find valuable or they'll
mix in other influences and it doesn't
take long for the art to look
different than what it was just one
generation back so in season three
chosen is enlightening daniel that
there's more to miyagido than he knew
because daniel's like this doesn't look
like miyagi dough when they start
sparring
it's because miyagi didn't teach him
this part of the art he must have
learned it
but he chose not to pass it on why is
that was it because it was more
aggressive we know that mr miyagi was a
much more
passive individual so did he find these
techniques too brutal and aggressive
um or did he feel like daniel couldn't
handle it daniel was a hothead he had a
temper
if you recall in the first movie when mr
miyagi asked daniel why he wanted to
learn the very first thing out of his
mouth was revenge
daniel's a hot head we all know that
miyagi knows that
he might have thought that might not
have been appropriate to teach daniel or
maybe he just didn't believe in it
we don't know but the bottom line though
is chosen has
part of the system that daniel never
learned and daniel
after all this time just realized he
didn't know everything there's more to
it
and i think that shows a massive split
we saw the reverse of that in karate kid
part two
if you recall you know in their many
conflicts with each other there were
moments where
daniel was employing the softer side of
the art that chosen to not recognize
for example the icebreaking scene in the
bar when chosen forces daniel to do the
ice-breaking competition
miyagi has daniel stop breathe focus and
chosen's laughing and joking the whole
time but we see over across the room we
see that sato recognizes it so that was
part of the training that sato
was part of too but he didn't pass that
down so chosen didn't understand that
part chosen was definitely strength and
power
and aggressiveness you know so chosen a
little bit blown away when that works
we see that later in the end of the film
too with the drum technique again
obviously salto knew it because the
second miyagi pulled that drum out sato
followed
started doing it chosen once again was
perplexed
baffle he didn't know what this was
right there sato and miyagi cultivated
their own
different opinions and values of the art
and they pass it on to their students
and there was some interesting overlap
too the crane kick
you know giant know what the crane kick
was he walked right into it even though
it was horribly telegraphed and he
should have seen that coming
but he wasn't familiar with it chosen
was if you go back and watch the end of
karate co2 when they're doing the final
fight
chosen recognizes the crank kick daniel
takes the stance he knows what's coming
we see this in season three he's got the
scroll right there chosen knew it all
along
and that's why he does if you watch
closely he does a faint
and triggers daniel to act early and
then chosen is able to deflect it
so there is definitely some overlap
there and that again just reinforces
that daniel
and jose are the same art but they've
gone to down to different paths
and that's why i think this really is a
little nugget
of an example of how the martial arts
works and this is where a lot of
problems in the martial arts comes from
is this division this split miyagi and
sato took what they chose and passed
that on
that's not unlike ki jin finikoshi he
learned okinawan karate he went to go
establish shotokan but he took the
values that he liked that he believed in
some of it was too aggressive for him he
left that out he stripped a lot of it
down and he made the system that he felt
was appropriate for what he wanted to
teach his own son gigo
had different ideas he wanted higher
kicks he wanted more competitiveness he
wanted more aggressiveness so just right
there is a perfect real world example of
the miyagi-sato dynamic
and that's what happens now take these
arts and you do this over generations
over hundreds of years
and then we can start to understand why
there are so many splinters
and why we have exactly 4782 types of
kenpo
and numerous martial arts out there
because each student
takes what they learn and they pass it
on or they pass on the values that they
feel
and as fun as the karate kid is and as
fun as the cobra kai series is
i absolutely love them but i think
besides if you look past entertainment
there's some real
actual values there and i think that
this is one of the most realistic
lessons that they've brought forth
is that they're showing us right off the
bat the kind of politics and splits that
can happen in the martial arts
yes it's just a movie yes it's just a tv
show and yes it's fun to break it down
but it yes ultimately is made for
entertainment purposes and the actual
fighting is not always realistic it's
made for on-screen drama
but i think that sometimes the lessons
that the show portrays
um are a little bit more on the nose
than we realize and i also want to give
a great big kudos to the show
for showing real life consequences you
know my favorite things about the movies
were
okay the moves might not have been
realistic but the reactions were like
there were consequences
to being struck daniel looked hurt these
kicks these punches actually injured
their opponents so it's just like a
wooden real world
it's not like in the movie you know a
chuck norris film or a van damme film
where they take 20 hits with a weapon
and they just brush it off no
danny got kicked in the face he bruised
it hurt him it
impeded his ability to fight so i
thought the movies really did that well
cobra kai i think goes really well
showing the consequence of the story in
action
we see a lot of fallout of these
characters choices and that's what makes
the show
so darn good is these are these people
start to feel real to us they're rounded
out they're more
filled in and more multi-dimensional now
but there is real
consequence and weight to their actions
and it carries the show forward and i
think it makes it much more dynamic so a
great big kudos to show
showrunners for keeping that integrity
intact
so i think the biggest takeaway here is
we don't all learn the same
you know we all have our different
methods of training and teaching we find
our own values and ethics our own
techniques our own
strategies that we that mesh with
ourselves
and i think sometimes we tend to lock
out other ideas either due to ego or
whatever or seclusion
but it's worth opening your mind up
listen to others perspectives because in
the best case scenario you both walk
away learning something new
so i'd like to hear what you guys think
about with the cobra kai series please
leave comments down below but if you do
make sure to put spoiler tags if you're
going to reveal any story details
and um also if there's any other topics
of with cobra kyr or karate kid you'd
like us to cover
leave those comments below as well now
stay tuned for our next cobra kai video
which we might have found
a storytelling mistake so click that
subscribe button click on the bell so
that way you get notified when it drops
and we'll have fun with that one next
thanks for watching
[Music]
bye
you
