Traditional Shotokan Karate | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
1 Video View·Oct 25, 2024
[Music]
on today's episode we have a very
special guest yusuke nagano a karate
coach in tokyo and sensei of the karate
dojo waku youtube channel is with us to
talk about the practices of teaching
traditional shotokan karate in japan
[Music]
so for the viewers who might not be
familiar with your teaching your channel
you teach shotakon in tokyo can you tell
us a little bit about the historical
significance of the school
sure um the
school that i coach at is called ke o
mita karatekai i think in english would
be keo mita karate club or something
like that
it was the the first um i guess the
karate school in mainland japan uh i
think a lot of you guys might know about
guichene funko she has brought shurite
from okinawa to tokyo in the 1920s and
he started teaching to the elites first
so ko is a university in japan and it's
one of the
the good schools um in tokyo so
he started um teaching karate in
ko university and it's been going on
since
1925. i forgot the exact year but it has
a pretty long history and um
there's a university at the top and then
there are high schools and middle
schools that are connected
and i am from a high school
from that or or from that school system
so i you know as a
i guess a
somebody who has finished his uh or
finished oreos graduated the high school
i go back there once in a while to
teach them karate i go i usually go back
once once a week depending on my
schedule and i teach karate there
excellent that's fantastic i love the
history that's attached to that i mean
you're talking about school that's been
there since the beginning pretty much
with shuttlecock right
right it's awesome so if i understand
correctly so the school is working to
preserve the original works and
teachings of funakoshi how do you guys
do like what efforts do you put in to
preserve his original art and his
teachings and how does it differ to the
show to come we see today
right um i wouldn't say there is a like
a huge difference um maybe
in percentages it would be like 10 or 15
the the differences aren't so fast and
um
uh what we do or what the the it's not
something i do personally what the
teachers
the old you know the masters do
is um they would hold weekly um
practices they're in their like 70s 60s
but they come together i think it was
every thursday
and they practiced the katas they
discussed the bunkais like maybe is this
this that and there is a
ko version or i guess the masters call
it the original version of the shotokan
katas so the stances are higher which is
something that are seen across other
universities as well because shotokan
the stances are getting lower and lower
so the stances are higher in the ko um
way of doing shotokan
some of the the motions
for
qatar's are different as well but
they're very minor differences if you do
shotokan you can pick it up but if you
don't do it i don't think you can pick
up the differences
it's interesting you said about the
stances because it was um funikoshi's
son that started introduced to lower
stances isn't it
right so this is his work do they try to
preserve his work as well or is it
mainly uh
works that's a hard question i think
it's more of kiching funakoshi's
teachings simply because
there are still
direct students that um
she taught that are still alive in ko so
since those masters are still there
i think that the younger ones that um
started to practice at a
at a later stage you know doesn't have
like a huge
authority over what the uh komida club
is going to do so
right now it's kitchen financial but
maybe later um you know in the future it
might change so i want i thought there
was something really fun that you have
on your website about your school and
that you offer classes to tourists
so like people traveling the people
traveling to japan and tokyo if they get
to take a class with you can you tell us
a little bit about that experience and
kind of like the experience that you
offer
sure sure um
i
did that before i started this youtube
channel actually um
i used to it was it was in 2019 when
kovate wasn't here yet so
um
i would teach kalate for beginners and
more experienced people for the
experienced people um i would
like it's
it wasn't a lifetime experience you know
coming all the way to tokyo it's pretty
far from other countries so i wanted um
them to you know
have a very good experience so i would
make everything tailor made so i will
listen to them you know listen to the
problems what their background is and
you know make a full i think it was a 90
or a 2 minute hour lesson to
cover up anything that they like so
that's something i did before you know
after the pandemic when everything
settles down um i hope to restart it
because so many people are like i'm
gonna go to japan and see you so
i would like to provide something um for
everybody in the comments that's such a
great experience to be able to travel to
japan and train at a dojo even if it's
for one day at a place like they meet
the dojo i mean that's just so they're
not only getting the lesson they're
getting a great historical significance
along with it
right right i think the atmosphere is a
lot different from dojos abroad and the
the etiquette part and i guess
uh what i mean this japanese society is
built upon like respect and our
way of thinking so just feeling that i
think is a great experience and i travel
a lot so i really appreciate um
you know doing something very local so
yeah i hope to you know continue doing
something like this
have you ever had any weird requests
from any from tourists about what they
wanted to learn
weird requests
um
weird requests there have been people
that wanted to take photos mainly
like enough wasn't
i mean
i guess it's okay i mean they're coming
for vacation so i mean i would take
photos for them
and
but mainly for the experienced class i
mean for the um people that already know
karate
they were looking for the skills and the
actual you know i guess they said the
karate at their country is a lot
different so they want something more
authentic so i mean i would just you
know teach what i do normally and i it
seems like they had a great time so i'll
just continue it
that sounds fantastic that really does
from what i understand with the cultural
difference with japan and say like the
west and the usa there's a great
emphasis place on respect for the elders
so if you are in a class from my
understanding is uh students really
shouldn't question the material or ask
the instructor a lot of questions if
there's a student who does have a
question about what they're learning
what's the most respectful way for them
to kind of voice that opinion or try to
seek that information i think
uh first of all
it really it really depends on the
person it really depends on
the sensei
and maybe like 50 years ago
that might have been the the common case
where you just cannot ask any questions
but
it's 20 21 and things are
and things have changed um i would say
uh the
uh what we think in terms of questioning
somebody is
have you put enough work
that you
have a question i think i think that's a
if that makes sense like if
if the student just goes into class and
starts asking questions right away
the
um teachers would or the older teachers
would commonly say
how have you practiced at all because if
you haven't
done repetitions at all
then
i think the questions you ask are going
to be very
like light and not deep enough
so they
um
ask you or i think i guess they expect
you to
work on something that's in front of you
and give your 100 100 or 200 percent
onto something let's say you do the
keyhole do the keyhole
like
go get everything out put your focus
there
and then ask the question i think that's
a common way of thinking in the japanese
so
um
if you yeah
there's a comment i'm not sure if it's a
common saying but some people say
it's a very forceful way of saying it
but it says shut up and just do it
um
i think
i i think in the back of our heads uh a
lot of people think that way
and i think they're both pros and cons
you know the pros are you're gonna do
the work the cons are
people cannot ask a question like if
they're not used to asking questions
they just keep on doing something
without any doubt and they'll end up
going somewhere far away
like away from the core but yeah i think
that's the common uh way of
thinking when it comes to questioning
here and you can does that stay true if
they're on the map versus off the mat
like outside the school is it still the
same kind of process
um
i think i think so um the older teachers
or again depends on the teacher but um
the relationship on the mat and off the
mat or i guess in the dojo out of the
dojo doesn't really change much
and in the in for the older um
uh teachers it's not like they become
casual right away
you you still have that respect
when you're out of the dojo as well so i
i think that's how it is now as far as
like boomkai like in okinawa and karate
especially gojiru there's a heavy focus
based on bunkai how is that approach to
traditional shotokan
um the the very good schools the very
traditional schools um practice the
benkai's
but it's also a reality that like the
olympics are on right now
a lot of the dojos are
going into competitions more
and i think you know if
as a kid if you don't have competitions
i think
it's hard to keep up the motivation as
well i think that's uh that's also the
reality so um the teachers the teachers
know the bunkai but they spent
more time on teaching the the
competition aspect of karate
so i think
you know again depends on the teacher
but from what i feel
i think most
schools in mainland japan i'm not sure
about okinawa but mainland japan focuses
on um khattas and kumite more experience
rather than bunkai but again the the
older
sensei still practice the bungkai so
when a student
let's say they finish high school they
finish college and they start you know
getting interested in the the martial
art aspect of karate then they start
getting interested in those aspects but
they they have been training so much
that they can just go right into the
bunkai without any question
because the second nature at that point
right right
so since um the metadojo that you're
working with there's that effort to
preserve traditional shotokan how
prevalent are funukoshi's 20 precepts is
that something that's still as prevalent
today as it was uh years back is that
are there any that are have more focus
than others in particular
i think it's a lot more emphasized
in the western countries i don't know
why but
um
in japan
you
i don't think a lot of people know all
20. like i think they've heard of it
they know the existence of it but
they wouldn't uh you know know deeply
about it to be honest i never knew about
it since i started this youtube channel
because it's not something we
read or we learn in the dojo there are
dojo kuns or
like teachings it's not something so
strict as dojokin it's just a teaching
as a human being in an indonesia like to
be respectful or to put in the work
but i i it's not something that's
verbally said out loud um in japan but
uh from from my own perspective
is a very um
i guess well-known phrase there's no
first attack in karate i think that's
the one in english
and um
yeah i think that most um karate ka
would know that phrase and
has it in his mind right right that's
what well the whole importance on it so
you're saying that's interesting that
more importance on it you're saying is
more in the western countries so you
think it's a matter of the ideas being
romanticized more than what it actually
was
i slightly feel that yes
interesting that's that's actually the
romanticized aspect
i think is pretty that's what i feel as
a japanese and i think
it's it's meant to be like that because
it's a new way of thinking for other
countries but for us it's something that
it's not so special it's not something
we just have in the in karate is
something that we have while living in
this country
so there's i don't think there's a huge
need for it to be like emphasized so
much within just the dojo like our
parents would tell us something similar
so
i think that's
one of the reasons yeah so it's more of
a lot more of a lifestyle just a way to
live and be respectful and that's
awesome right that makes that makes a
lot of sense actually are there any
particular behaviors or unspoken rules
that instructors like to see their teeth
are steelers students do well
first
being disrespectful to anybody in a dojo
would be one
maybe the definition of being respectful
is different between countries too
but um
unspoken rules right within the dojo in
the dojo or out of the dojo within
within like any behaviors that i guess
let me rephrase this are there any
specific initiatives or behaviors that
teachers like to see their students do
without being told like any taking the
action or say anything or maybe go over
and help another student is there
anything that's not necessarily taught
or instructed to you that instructors
like to see
i guess
simple things like saying hello to your
friend saying hello to the instructor
when you're coming to the dojo or saying
goodbye you know
don't just come in without saying
anything those simple things like as a
human being
and
i guess for your belongings too um if
you let's say
you you come in with a backpack and you
have your doggies and you have your
equipments in there
um a lot of people or i guess the normal
japanese it's not just karate japanese
people expect you to
put it nicely
onto a wall or you know you don't just
want to
throw it on the floor you want it to be
nicely placed so and that's something
um
we think about as a as i think i think
as a japanese and so that's something
that sensei would expect you to do
without telling you to do but maybe for
elementary school kids
the sensei would instruct you on that
point but i feel like a high school
student
i wouldn't want to make my point out on
those points because i mean i expect
them to do it now i noticed that you
released a video today about watching
the karate olympics uh you did a live
stream which was pretty cool
what is the overall um attitude right
now like in japan like is there a lot of
pride that that describes
or is there any people who don't like it
like what's the overall attitude and
feeling is having karachi represented in
the olympics in japan um to be honest
the
the general audience doesn't know much
about karate so i don't think they care
they don't have any opinions on it so
they don't care
um but i think
i mean it started and you know seeing
some some people on twitter they seem to
like it so i guess the general japanese
audience do
are enjoying karate
and for the the karate practitioners i
think a lot of people
um do like
what's happening and they do have the
pride to see in the olympics
and i
and i've seen you know i'm in my like i
have my half of myself in the
international martial arts world and
then half myself in japan so i i can
sense the differences and it's funny
that um i think there are a lot more
negative comments or negative thoughts
or not thoughts about negative um
perspective towards olympic karate
and i guess maybe the states or in
english speaking countries compared to
japan and i think that's because um
the okinawan uh influence or the orig
the original karate
way of thinking is more
deeply um
i guess
intertwined between
countries abroad and not japan
in mainland japan
there are there aren't a lot of people
doing okinawan karate and most schools
are
mainland japan kind of like childhood
toxin
is big too
but um i can see
um you know people especially in the
states like in the early 1950s you know
people started going from okinawa to the
states hawaii california doing shorting
you showing you isn't so big in japan
but a lot of people i think do shorten
you um in the states so that's something
that's very surprising for me
so
having said that um since
more people
i'm not sure if it's more i don't know
the absolute number but since
i feel like more people um in
english-speaking countries knows about
okinawan karate
they can make a comparison and i think
thus they have some people you know have
a negative you know comment about
olympic art if someone is looking for a
good show to come school uh can you give
any recommendations or signs or things
that they should ask that they might not
know to ask for if you can see the
sensei doing a kata or kumite
i think that's the best indication
um to how far you can go within that
school
if if the sensei doesn't um or if it
doesn't have to your full kata within
the lesson
if you can see the sensei move full
speed um i think that's the best way to
um
to see if he has a good school or not
i guess maybe if he even if he is good
at um delivering or explaining
things if he can't show it um with his
own body then
it's going to be very hard to imagine
what he's talking about so
i would say that's one aspect and if and
if you don't have any cut out experience
to
to you know to evaluate if his movements
are good or not
then i would say
if they allow you to take a video
i don't know maybe that's a sensitive
thing if they allow you to take a video
take it back home
there are tons of videos on youtube so
just compare
and see if you like it or not that would
be my answer and that's what i would do
if i were to start any other martial
arts so what is your favorite thing
about teaching karate and do you have
any particular goals that you're
striving to achieve
uh
well in japan
since i coach at a middle school and
high school
um it's different from teaching at a
karate school in karate school your role
your main role is to teach karate
but in i teach at a school so it's like
half education half karate
so my goal is
within the three years or six years
middle school and high school
i hope to
[Music]
have the kids grow up that so that when
they graduate
they know about themselves like they can
they know about their own character they
understand what they like what they
don't like
and that's something that they
understand throughout having those
difficulties uh doing karate and working
with the teammates
aiming for that one tournament
you know those those kind of things so
that's
what i feel as an instructor um in japan
and as a
karate content creator and
someone that somebody that teaches
people abroad
my goal is to um have people
understand the white aspect of karate
there are both you know the okinawan
side the japanese side and recently i
never knew karate
like
branched out so much
across the world so i'm starting to
become interested in those
and yeah i just hope to
since i cannot you know have them face
to face i can't really deliver the
skills
well um
i can't deliver the skills as much
as you know if i were to see them every
day in japan
so the education side or i guess not the
education but the knowledge side
is uh as bigger i think for the
international audience so there's two
sides of me
that's fantastic well so far you've done
a fantastic job big fan of your channel
you've been putting out a lot of great
videos and i definitely appreciate your
efforts to spread the knowledge you know
there's just so many channels out there
that that they talk bad about the
martial arts but i like the positive
energy that you put out and i like the
exploration and i just want to say thank
you so much for taking part today and
sharing your experience with us it's
been an honor to have you on today
thank you so much for having me
i want to extend an extreme thank you
sensei for spending the time to talk
with us and sharing your perspectives of
karate that many of us don't get to see
be sure to check out use case channel as
further discussion we talked about
comparing american kenpo to traditional
karate and you can find those episodes
on his channel he also has a lot of
phenomenal content exploring the martial
arts and he will be returning next week
to talk about this exploration and his
experience with karate around the world
so click on that bell notification and
set your reminders to come back and
check that out
as an exclusive episode for our patreon
subscribers and youtube memberships i
talked with sensei in a special
off-the-mat interview
that's a very funny question
it's so weird to be talking about this
but visit us on patreon or click the
join button below for access
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
you
