Former Fed Governor Kevin Warsh: The Fed doesn't seem to have a serious theory of inflation

Thrifty Thinkers
9 followers
1 Video View·Oct 25, 2024
Kevin Warsh, Hoover Institution distinguished visiting fellow and former Federal Reserve Governor, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss the Fed's inflation fight, state of the economy, rate path outlook, and more.
We are just a few weeks away from the Fed's next meeting and our next guest says that he was puzzled by the Central Bank's
50 basis point cut because he thinks it contradicts everything they've previously said about their policy.
Joining us right now is former Federal Reserve Board governor Kevin Warsh. He's a distinguished visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution.
So distinguished. It's like hard to say distinguished enough. Yeah, Greeks have distinguished. He's wearing a tie.
I just arrived and the sniping has already begun.
You shouldn't take things
Very distinguished. We are very happy to have you here. Call him chairman. Why don't you just explain what you mean chairman elect?
Why don't you explain what you mean by saying this goes against what the Fed had been saying up to this point with their policy?
So they've had different theories Becky about
Cause of the inflation the measures they use and people in financial markets and media have tried to follow those
They said for a long time. You'll recall a few years ago. They were for flexible average inflation targeting
So inflation when it was at one seven, they said we'll get it a little higher and we'll try to balance around two
They seem to have gotten rid of that idea without replacing it. So they don't have a broad new strategy
Then they said for a long time. What really matters is core PC. That's what we should focus
But it's now running at around 2.7 percent nowhere near their 2% range
About a year ago. They said well the best measure of inflation is now what they create a new category and they said it was
core-services X housing. Well, that's in the fours
Previously Janet Yellen and embedded in the Fed model said what really matters is wages
And so we need wages to run at 3% which is consistent with inflation running around to wages are running around for
so all of this isn't to say that that there's a all this is to say they don't seem to have a
serious theory of inflation
That's theoretical and empirical
It's not obvious that they acknowledge what their role is in prices
Said it has something to do with wars and pandemics
I think in a world this dangerous an economic policy that where fiscal policy is
Irresponsible the central bank needs to be very clear about its reaction function be clear about its goals and not look like it's lurching
That's what put us in the mess. We have I
Understand your point. I will say I can
Understand their perspective if they're saying look it was inflation inflation has been coming down now
Maybe we need to pay attention to our other mandate, which is the jobs market
However, the jobs numbers have been better than anticipated to over this time
I can understand moving around and saying there are things that are more important at different points in time
What what do you think about the dissent that there was at the last meeting and do you think there will be more at this
Meeting. Yeah, so it's a it's it's a fair point. So what you're really saying is
They've claimed that their data dependent right and when times change they should change. Well, of course, that's right, right?
I can't argue with that the data since early part of the summer. It's gotten better. The economy's gotten stronger
The broad sense of the data is the economy's in better shape stock market
Well, the stock market is in better shape. So if that's all true, then maybe they're not data dependent
I do not want to be the person accusing them of politics. That is not the central bank
I know the members of the FOMC that I know they don't play politics
But when you don't have a theory of the case, you don't follow it
It is easy to get that accusation and it's harder for people like me to defend them
Did you see Esther George yesterday?
I've had a running argument with Steve Leesman about whether the Fed should push back on Congress about funding some of the
That some of the the oversized spending that we saw Steve says they work at the you know
Whatever Congress does they need to enable the Congress that that's what their job is. They work for
For Congress Esther George said they definitely should push back
So I guess I'm asking I don't think politics should influence the Fed
But can the Fed influence the politicians or should they and how complicated is that when the other ones who are given oversight?
So let me try to get into that riddle when they kept interest rates near zero
for a decade and
Did quantitative easing where the central bank are buying the bonds of the Treasury Department in crises?
And they decided to make that more or less a permanent feature
It is the Fed that wandered into politics on a permanent basis and in a period of free money
What was the clear sign to Congress you can spend all the money you want and so they did
You don't have to do much to get a bunch of members of the Congress to want to spend money and they said come at
It because it's free and it'll be free forever
Remember secular stagnation and zero rates and zero lower bound. So they encouraged this spending boom
Over the course the last few years
Congress at a time of relatively full employment added five trillion dollars in deficits
Cumulatively and this put the country in a much more dangerous place
This level of debt is dangerous for our economy and it's a terrible sign to the world because we're all talking about economics
Kevin that economic policy provokes our adversaries to take us on so that makes the country less
Prosperous and less peace. Have you seen the calculation that big banks have been almost given this windfall of
Profits because the Fed paid them to hold on to reserves rather than giving it out in loans
And as a result, they've gotten paid more than
Then normal businesses would have been paid and it just padded their profits
I saw a number of like a trillion a trillion dollars. Have you looked at that? Is that so I have looked at it
It's shocking to believe that the banks would take advantage of an arbitrage and they did and they did
I don't blame the banks for taking advantage of the arbitrage. I blame the Central Bank for allowing the arbitrage to happen
What was the reason they do it?
Yeah
the rationale for that and the rationale for keeping rates at zero if the Fed was wrong and doing these things and allowed Congress and
The banks to take advantage of the situation. Why were they doing?
I think the reason why it happened is in the old days think about the Greenspan Fed
We had a Fed funds rate. That was the rate that mattered
It was the rate the Central Bank communicated and it was the relevant rate for financial markets
There are a proliferation of rates now that the Central Bank hits
The interest on excess reserves rate the Fed funds rate and a host of others
There's a series of risk-free assets that are now competing with the Treasury. They come from Fannie and Freddie
They come from the home loan banks
they come from government guarantees of all sorts of things the Fed now has many different rates that they're trying to juggle at the
same time because they've moved from a
Relatively simple way to manage the Central Bank and the balance sheet to a very complicated. Is that is that a
reflux and after effect of what happened in the Great Recession and the financial crisis and the moves the
Extraordinary moves that were taken to try and normalize and stabilize things. I think it comes from two things
It's one the Central Bank playing a much more permanent role in the financial markets and wanting to
Not just in crisis times where I have some sympathy
but for all seasons and all reasons and it also comes from the fact that they have a
Framework that is unanchored that they are pursuing different objectives that are often in cross purposes one simple example
They're now seeming to loosen the policy rate to provide more
Accommodation at the same time. What are they doing with the balance sheet?
They're still in some modest quantitative tightening, which is tightening financial conditions
It's like having a foot on brake and the gas at the same working at cross purposes. So what rest of the world is watching?
