Fed's Kashkari on Inflation, Housing, Jobs Market

Financial Freedom
10 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 14, 2024
Minneapolis Federal Reserve President Neel Kashkari says inflation is heading in the right direction. But he says it's too soon to say if the Fed will continue on its rate cutting cycle. He also talks about housing, the labor market, and uncertainty about what policies President-elect Donald Trump will enact. Kashkari speaks on "Bloomberg Surveillance."
I saw some comments from you yesterday, and for our audience that might have missed them,
I'll share them with our audience now, we can pick up on them, that have to be a surprise
on the inflation front to change the outlook so dramatically.
If we saw inflation surprises to the upside between now and then, that might give us pause
for December.
It'd be hard to imagine the labor market really heats up between now and December.
That's just not that much time.
Inflation data out just moments ago, anything in that to disrupt this easing bias that seems
to have gripped the Fed over the last few months?
Well, first of all, it's very fresh data, so I haven't had time to go through it in
a lot of detail.
But at least on the headline level, it seems to be confirming the path that we're on.
We've made a lot of progress in the last year or so bringing inflation down.
I need to go through the component of that release, which I have not done yet.
But generally speaking, goods inflation is back down to where we want it to be, where
it was pre-pandemic.
Services inflation, which is tied to wages, is gently trending down.
And then finally, housing inflation we know is a lagging indicator.
We know that it takes a couple of years for the new leases to turn over, and the new leases
are showing that we're headed in the right direction.
So right now, I think that inflation is headed in the right direction.
I've got confidence about that, but we need to wait.
We've got another month or six weeks of data to analyze before we make any decisions.
One of the things that has been very noticeable over the last week is the change in investors'
views about where you're going to end up.
If you're looking at SOFR futures right now, they only price in about 75 basis point cuts
between now and the end of 2025.
Are we entering a period, because we don't know what Donald Trump's policies are actually
going to be, where the dot plot, the summary of economic projections are kind of off the
table, can't really put a lot of faith in them, and that maybe you're in the Lael Brainard
attenuation phase, where you slow down everything, and people should expect not a lot of guidance
from the Fed?
Well, you know, the dot plot is something that I, at times, I'm glad we have it, and
at times it's more of a frustration that we have to fill it out because there's so much
uncertainty about the economic outlook.
Over the past year or two, I've been surprised at the resilience of the U.S. economy in the
face of seemingly quite high policy rates.
Yet, the labor market has stayed strong, and the economic growth continues to surprise us.
So, for me, I've been asking questions about where's the neutral rate for the last year or two.
That's not about the election.
That's just about how the economy has been performing over the past year or two.
And so, you know, for example, there's been revisions that suggest that productivity is
now higher than it had been in prior years.
If that higher productivity environment is maintained, that would tell me we're probably
in a somewhat higher neutral rate environment.
Again, that's not about the election.
That's just about how the economy has actually been performing.
And so, for me, as a policymaker, that's what's leading to my own uncertainty about where
is our ultimate destination.
And I think that people are raising questions about what is the new administration going
to do?
What is the new Congress going to do?
I think that's also adding uncertainty about, ultimately, what's the growth trajectory of
the U.S. economy.
Well, Tom Barkin said yesterday, your colleague from the Richmond Fed, that right now there's
no way to know.
So, one has to just kind of assume that things are going to be maybe stuck.
Inflation's stuck above 2%.
Would you join in that sentiment?
I'm not sure that I'm ready to say that inflation is stuck above 2%.
I think it's right now running in the mid-2s on a PCE basis.
And as I said earlier, goods inflation is back down.
Services inflation is tied to wages.
And wages are gently trending down.
And housing inflation, we know, is going to take a couple of years before the new leases
roll all the way through the housing inflation.
So, I have confidence that inflation is headed in the right direction.
Is it headed there fast enough?
Do we want it to get there more quickly?
We will see.
But ultimately, that and the labor market are going to guide our policy decisions.
Well, back in September on the labor market, you said that the balance of risk had shifted
towards a more weakening labor market.
Do you think we've backed off that risk?
Is it not as acute as it was since we've had the data since September?
We had seen some data piling up, up until that September meeting, which was pretty much
pointed in one direction, which was a softening labor market.
We then had a surprise on the other way.
The labor market looked stronger.
But then a reversal in the subsequent job report.
And so, I still think the labor market is softening.
A 4.1% unemployment rate is a good unemployment rate.
It's a good labor market.
It's not as tight as it was a year ago or two years ago.
So, it's unquestioned that it has been softening.
And right now, we're at a good place in the labor market, and we want to keep it there.
You know, I do a lot of outreach to businesses, large and small, around my region,
as well as labor unions around my region.
Generally, what I hear is cautious optimism.
People feel good about the outlook.
But there are some trends that it's slowly softening.
And we just want to watch that carefully.
Neil, the election.
We've got to talk about the election.
And I know it's a difficult moment for the Federal Reserve.
I think it's a difficult moment for monetary policymakers worldwide, for that matter.
The chairman dealt with it in the news conference and was pretty clear.
We don't speculate.
We can't make assumptions.
But you're in the risk management business.
And you've been in the risk management business for a long time.
It predates your experience at the Federal Reserve.
Do you think we've introduced two-way risk in 2025?
And when you think about the balance of risk, does that call for a slower approach
to any move in monetary policy, one way or the other?
Well, two-way risk, I think we've already had two-way risk.
So, we've got risks of the labor market continuing to soften and over-softening.
And then we've got risks of inflation potentially getting stuck.
I'm not seeing a lot of upside risk yet.
We don't know what's going to get enacted.
I'm not seeing a lot of upside risk that inflation is going to take off from here.
The bigger risk that I'd be concerned about in the inflation front is just if we're landing
at around the 2.5% level instead of back down to 2% level.
I think that those risks existed before the election.
And I think that there continues to be uncertainty now.
And we need to just take our time, let the data come to us, and let that guide us.
Ultimately, for me, this goes back to the discussion we had a moment ago about where's
the neutral rate.
There's tremendous uncertainty in my mind about where the neutral rate is.
And the longer the economy continues to exceed expectations, the more signal I take that
we must not be as restrictive as I would have assumed.
Fed staff analyzed, though, during the first iteration of Trump, the impact of the tariffs.
And everyone coalesced around this idea that there was a one-off increase in inflation.
You can look through it.
It wasn't going to be this vicious cycle, an ongoing inflation threat.
Did you agree with that assessment at the time?
And do you still think that that's what tariffs could do in terms of inflation?
I agree with that assessment at the time.
I still agree with that.
But I think your prior guest touched on it, which is it really depends on what the other
countries end up doing.
If there ends up being a tit-for-tat and one country raises tariffs, they respond, and
you go back and forth indefinitely, that could lead to a longer-term imprint on inflation
and potentially inflation expectations.
And, of course, we don't know what our own tariffs are going to be, let alone what other
countries are going to respond with.
And so we just need to be patient and see.
I had a note come in from one of the Wall Street analysts that had a line that I thought
was really valid, and that is that if you're going to forecast inflation, you have to have
a theory of inflation and what's causing inflation.
We've got relatively strong labor markets right now, and we've got concern about inflation.
Real interest rates just keep rising, and they're working in opposition to your rate
cuts.
What's your theory of inflation, and how come we're seeing this kind of real rate reaction?
Well, I've done a lot of soul-searching on why I missed the inflation run-up in the first
place.
I was surprised on the run-up.
I was also surprised on the disinflation that followed it.
And the one thing that's been constant is it was not the labor market on the run-up
or the disinflation.
It was mostly supply factors.
And so supply chains got gummed up.
It took a lot longer to resolve.
The inflation took off.
You had the war in Ukraine also pushing inflation up.
And then many of those factors unwound or didn't get worse, bringing inflation back
down.
So monetary policy's role, in my judgment, in this episode has been to keep long-run
inflation expectations anchored, and it has provided some gentle cooling to the labor
market.
I don't think the supply factors are what have caused the labor market to gently cool.
I do think monetary policy has been doing that.
And so you put all that together, it says that when I thought we were applying two feet
on the brakes of the economy with monetary policy, we might only have been applying one
foot on the brake.
And so this goes back to where ultimately are we going to settle?
We're going to have to let the economy guide us.
We are now paying as much attention to CPI again as we are to the labor market.
But the labor market comes up in early December.
We had a really, really strong September and a really, really weak October.
Where is the labor market as far as you're concerned?
I think the labor market is in a good place right now.
Again, the anecdotes that I get, I look at the data, the official statistics, which always
have uncertainty.
There's even more uncertainty about the labor market statistics, not just because of the
hurricanes and the Boeing strike, but because of the large immigration flows, which we're
not exactly sure how big they are, and they're time varying.
So what is this month's break-even level of job growth?
Your guess is as good as mine.
So I look at the official statistics, and then I marry it to what we're all hearing,
my colleagues and I, from all of our contacts around the country.
The labor market right now is strong.
It's a healthy labor market.
Jobs are available.
Businesses are feeling good.
We want to keep it that way.
And so as we get the data in, I'm going to continue to do my own outreach, and all of
the other presidents are going to do their outreach to the businesses, large and small,
and labor groups to get a sense of, is the labor market cooling slowly?
Is it heating up?
Or is it cooling quickly?
And those will be important judgments into our policy deliberations.
Your former colleague, Bill Dudley, wrote a Bloomberg opinion piece earlier this week,
basically saying that there's this possibility that Trump enacts policy quickly and forcefully
in a way that doesn't give the Fed enough time to respond, and without the proper tools
to respond.
Is that a concern you also share?
I think fiscal policy is always an input into our deliberations and into our analysis and
assessment of the economy.
I don't think that's new now.
And it's not just U.S. fiscal policy.
It's what happens with other countries, what happens with our trading partners.
And so that type of uncertainty, we're used to dealing with it.
Obviously, we would like to have less uncertainty.
That'd be great.
But it's the world that we live in, and we will take all the information we can as we
get it and incorporate it into our thinking.
Speaking of uncertainty, there's been a lot of concern about what Trump 2.0 would mean
in terms of jawboning the Fed and how he felt about Jay Powell.
The FOMC had this plan during the first iteration of Trump that maybe they even move Powell
to chair of the FOMC if he was going to take over the chairmanship of the actual Fed.
Would you basically all act as a group to potentially thwart anything that was coming
at you that would negate the Fed independence?
We are all committed to our dual mandate goals.
Everybody around the table, all of my colleagues, stable prices and maximum employment.
So number one, we're all committed to those goals.
Number two, I don't think those goals are controversial.
I think everybody across the political spectrum wants us to get inflation all the way back
down to 2% and wants to keep a strong labor market.
So I think that also provides us a lot of support.
And then there's built-in continuity into the structure of the Fed that Congress designed.
Governors serve up to 14-year terms.
The presidents are independent, the presidents of the 12 reserve banks.
These structures help us provide continuity.
I'm confident that between the people who are there, our commitment to our dual mandate
goals, and the structures that are in place, I'm confident that we will do the right thing
and focus on the economy.
The housing market, how do you explain what's going on, the fact that prices aren't coming
down?
And if you keep rates higher than anticipated, we've already seen mortgage rates go up since
you started cutting.
Is the housing market dead?
Well, the housing market, as I've studied it, and this is an issue all around the country,
the lack of affordability, not just for low-income workers, but for middle-class families and
more, it's really one that we've underbuilt housing for the last decade.
Following the great financial crisis, we just structurally underbuilt housing.
So there's, in a sense, a shortage.
And as I think about back to the notion of a neutral interest rate, think about a neutral
mortgage rate.
If we have structurally underbuilt housing, and there's a lot of demand for housing, what
interest rate is going to clear that market?
All else being equal, you would think a higher interest rate would clear that market.
And so I think the housing market has its own unique dynamics that are going on that
are driving this, more than just a macroeconomic landscape and more than just monetary policy.
So the Fed raises its hands and says, it's not something we can fix?
Yeah, we can't fix it.
I mean, if we said we're going to cut interest rates to try to support housing affordability,
setting aside the rest of our goals, what would that probably do?
That would probably push up the price of housing.
And so would that actually improve affordability?
And so I don't think monetary policy is well suited to address the structural issues that
are going on in the housing market.
We've touched on absolutely everything.
Can we finish on financial markets?
Sure.
You know them well.
Are you worried about cutting into an asset bubble?
You know, I always go back to when then-Chairman Greenspan in 1995 declared a rational exuberance.
Sure.
1995 he declared it, and the stock market went up for the next four years.
I look at that episode and think if the Fed had tried to use monetary policy to address
that bubble, it would have done more harm to the economy than the fairly mild recession
that followed when the tech bubble burst.
And so I just think monetary policy is the wrong tool to try to address asset bubbles.
Do you think there's something that needs to be addressed?
Well, you know, bubbles are easy to spot in hindsight.
If we really are in a higher productivity environment, if we're in a higher growth
environment and corporate earnings are going to continue to climb, one might look back
and say, hey, these asset prices are not irrational.
So it's hard to judge right now.
If I knew where productivity was going, I'd be able to give you a more definitive answer.
Just looking at markets right now, equity is very close to all-time highs.
We've got credit spreads that are at incredibly tight levels.
For investment grade, tighter than anything we've seen so far this century.
For high yield, I think you've got to go back to pre-GFC.
And you know what happened next.
We're cutting interest rates into that.
We have authorities down in Washington, D.C., a Trump second administration that could be
cutting taxes going into that as well.
What is on your radar with regards to that?
What would you watch to say, actually, something going on here that maybe we need to pay a little
bit more attention to?
Well, from a financial stability perspective, traditionally, the biggest sources of financial
instability are leverage and maturity transformation and the intersection of those two.
That's why banks are inherently risky.
So, for example, a lot of people have looked at private credit and said,
this is a huge growing asset class, isn't this scary?
As I've looked into it, they seem to be much less levered than banks,
and they generally have longer term funding.
So in those two primary dimensions of financial instability, leverage and maturity transformation,
it doesn't seem to be riskier than banks, probably less risky than banks.
So we continue to look for leverage.
We continue to look for maturity transformation.
