Will Japan & Rich Asian Countries Welcome Immigrants?

FUNG BROS.
592 followers
25 Video Views·Oct 24, 2024
Japan Korea Taiwan and Singapore are
letting in a lot more foreign workers
now to help solve their current labor
shortage issue is it about time and how
will it all go let's talk about it but
they got homogene they saver but what
about the labor will they ever give them
papers let's run the clip this would
have been a rare site just 10 years ago
foreigners working on a Japanese
construction
site one of them Wang is Chinese
initially a friend told me that life
would be easy here and that I could have
a better
salary and South Korea will be bringing
in some 110,000 migrant workers this
year to work at its farms and factories
these sectors are facing a labor
shortage as younger South Koreans deem
those jobs dirty and dangerous the
country's treatment of Migrant workers
is now under close scrutiny cna's liyong
tells us more boom listen man you got a
labor shortage a lot of people aren't
having kids in these countries so you
need to import workers however Andrew
there's a lot of questions surrounding
what is the life of these workers like
because they can only stay in the
country as long as their employers allow
them to right so we're going to talk
about kind of why it's such a big deal
for countries like Japan and Korea to
let in foreign workers because that's
not something they always did on this
amount there was always some foreign
workers but not in the amount that they
are about to have because they have a
major labor shortage especially for
farming and you know Blue Collar jobs so
we're going to talk about it please hit
that like button check out other
episodes of the hot pop boys and check
out smile ass sauce on amazon.com right
now I'll tell you this man when we went
to Tokyo Andrew most of the workers uh
not all but like at 7-Eleven were from
Nepal and I remember like we just
recently went to a Yaki niku restaurant
and I looked at the kitchen and the
kitchen was a lot of like you know I I
didn't know they look like part Asian
part like Indian and then I remember
like they were just like you know
because they had spent time in Japan so
not only are there uh this is like
becoming so much of a thing that I'm
meeting people in New York that used to
live in Japan from Neal right so now
like as you guys know there's different
situations for different migrant workers
some are only brought over on special
visas that only they can only stay so as
long as their company is there's certain
other ones that are on a different level
Visa one year two year three year right
right right and then obviously some do I
think stay and become citizens but is
there really a path for them uh is Japan
going to allow it and other stuff like
this so let's talk about it David why
why is it a big deal for Japan Korea
Singapore and Taiwan to be doing this
well here's the point these are first
world economies Japan Korea Singapore
Taiwan they need a lot of immigration
due to the economy Andrew this is
happening in all first world economies
globally right and it's not just because
these countries aren't having enough
kids it's true that the birth rates in
these countries are is not very high or
if not negative but it's just a shortage
also because more people are leaning
into the White Collar educated jobs
which also gives them oftentimes
opportunities to leave those countries
and immigrate to the west to get
educated and possibly stay and work
there or or whatever country of their
choice right whatever country they are
going to obviously them getting educated
actually gives them more options on an
international scale right different
banking jobs finance jobs science jobs
engineer remot work remote work right uh
whatever so obviously a lot of they need
labor for like the farming jobs and like
the construction jobs and that's what
you're starting to see more of for
example in this article Andrew a lot of
the uh workers in Japan at this
confectionary Factory that makes like
traditional candies are
Vietnamese interesting right right right
uh Point number two Andrew there's a lot
of questions of cultural fit of
potentially different manners or just
like fitting into the culture right so
you're bringing in a lot of people from
a vastly different Society
uh usually a you know third world to the
first world it could be the second world
to the first world as well it just
depends on different levels and
basically are these people going to fit
in with the cultural flow right and and
as you can see like from the clip it's
like there are Chinese workers going to
Japan so it's not only from Nepal and
other countries like that it could even
be from China like Chinese workers U
construction workers our Uber drivers in
Tokyo were Chinese yeah that's true
right um I don't know what visas they
were on but you know they were driving
Uber so I guess like yeah I mean this is
a question for anytime um like how do
you get a worker who is from a different
country and maybe is not a master at
that at the new language yet to come
over there work efficiently for some
years and possibly stay there longer or
go back like how do you integrate them
like right and if they are going to go
back ultimately which I think is
ultimately like for example Andrew
Japan's hope like are they at least
treated fairly enough while they're
there that the whole interaction is just
like kosher on both sides like
everybody's happy with what they got out
of it I actually think that Japan and
Korea will not want people to stay and
become Japanese and Korean unless they
like buy into to like a 12 out of 10
level but as long as they're paid well
enough while they're there to send the
money back then it's just a positive
experience for everybody right right I
mean I would say obviously I've heard
bad stories obviously there's uh some
stories of people in that Advan country
or treating the migrant workers you know
badly and stuff there's some cases going
around but ultimately I mean ideally the
situation is like yeah they Japan they
obviously are an island so like they
know everybody that's coming over you
know it's not necessar it's not as easy
to snake sneak into Japan as it is would
be like America right right right
there's no borders um Point number three
East Asia has always been uh relatively
ethnically homogeneous more so than the
Himalayas or Southeast Asia or Central
Asia so it's like I guess them dealing
with like different looking people is
newer yeah but I guess like is it
different like in Hong Kong there was
always for some time now like Filipino
or Indonesian like home help like
housekeepers and and nannies and stuff
like that so is it kind of uh a similar
situation or is it like kind of
different I think it's a little bit
different when you have somebody in your
house like cooking and cleaning versus
like literally like Singapore is even
letting in Mass immigration at a
mid-level not just low level I think
Japan and Korea they're still keeping it
relatively low in Singapore they're
starting to move to like even mid-tier
jobs because the whole society wants
High tier jobs right who do you think is
going to be more strict Singapore or
Japan because both countries are very
strict in what they expect of people who
come to these countries and want to work
right like Singapore's going to be like
hey you got to learn English you have to
learn English and then Japan's going to
be like you have to speak Japanese all
right here's the thing about Singapore
they got a lot of really strict laws but
they're a little bit more loose on like
oh you like look different you like
dress different it is more diverse yeah
who with it as long as you follow a very
strict set of laws in Japan not only do
they have strict laws they have strict
social norms that it's true that some
people can be very offended by if you
violate the social norms right I almost
feel like Singapore's culture is really
it's not really ethnically based even
though it's probably 60 70% Chinese but
it's actually fairly diverse and really
I feel like the Singaporean culture is
really just like how strict it is like
do not litter I definitely don't sell
drugs uh learn English be respectful
talk bad on each other's races yeah yeah
you can't publicly talk bad about other
races and be racist yes um Point number
four what role will technology and
strictness play that kind of comes back
to it can countries that have been one
monoculture be like Singapore which
Singapore is like a really attractive
place for a lot of people because they
have the law and order but they have the
diversity on the cultural side that's
why food in Singapore so good yeah and
then point number five Andrew the work
culture in East Asia can be extremely
strict and possibly more intense than
the regions where uh the people are
coming from so can they adapt it like
you know what I mean they're just like
working here 80 hours a week is normal
that is our Baseline expectation yeah
yeah I mean it'll be interesting I mean
I think the whole management issue uh is
it's I mean it's going to be a big thing
and people are going to have to figure
it out and uh you know when you're a
country that needs
workers uh yeah you're going to have to
figure things out so right right right
all so let's just get into some of the
comments Andrew do you think it is
people not wanting to marry and have
kids because everybody's enjoying a
first world lifestyle is that the Crux
of this that late late stage capitalism
First World countries everybody's got
access to all like you know nice things
and materialized people care about
fashion you know how caring about
fashion is like something that's more
middle class and up you know what I mean
like is that just the whole reason no no
I I mean I think it's a lot of like the
level of work that people are really
trying to do like yeah again I don't
imagine that many second like young
generation of Japanese people wanting to
do construction work right because they
see the opportunities of media obviously
AI Tech is blowing up you know uh no
longer do they want to work in a factory
everybody's jobs are moving up in that
country you want to work on automobiles
you want to work at least a service
industry at least serve in a cool
restaurant right that's everybody's
dream so yeah I do think things are
changing and uh it's going to be
interesting I mean again I feel for
these countries that are going to have a
are they going to have a labor shortage
is is Nepal going to have a labor
shortage because so many nepales are
leaving to go to other countries to work
right yeah that's a good question I
guess it would depend on like What
factories or like manufacturing really
exists within that locality I know for
example like China wants to maintain
their blueco collar workers because they
got factories that they to work at but
probably to be honest blueco collar work
probably pays better in Japan just like
you know what I mean like blue collar
work in Latin America pays way less than
being a bluecollar worker in America
right yeah it's a similar situation um
somebody said I like how Japan is not
diverse is that so wrong and is that
such an evil statement in
2024 that's an interesting point it's an
interesting point because obviously the
Western world has like it's like people
don't really understand the W
immigration to the West is not not in my
opinion just a moralistic thing it's
because the West has its hands all over
the world whereas Japan doesn't really
do that I mean obviously post World War
II so that's why they don't have as much
right you know what I mean like if you
own like diamond mines in like all
across Africa you're going to have
African immigration but but is it like
is it about time that Japan gets a
little more diverse and it's not just
diversity for diversity reasons again
it's like Japan almost needs to get more
diverse for literally the labor
situation right uh that's a good
question that's the internal debate
within Japan right now and I think can
they adapt obviously it's better if they
could just get Highly Educated highly
motivated you know law-abiding citizens
diversity that's the way the world is
headed you can't fight the S of time are
we going to assume that every migrant
who migrant worker who goes to Japan is
going to love Japan wants to be Japanese
I don't think they want they want the
ones they do though they want the work
but how many of them are really going to
buy in like or are you just going to
take what you can get Japan yeah I think
it's a good question I mean
realistically I don't know yeah women
may buy in more than guys I don't know
who knows I mean that's that's a that's
a gender Theory I or whatever like um
somebody said why are East asan so
obsessed with white collar Mobility is
it the Confucianism and the historical
bureaucracy and civil service exams
because that is what is causing off this
all this you know to your point about
like constantly wanting like I got a I
got an office job now I want want like a
pol you know what I mean like the the
jobs up the supply chain or whatever the
the value chain um somebody was saying
please don't end up like Canada
obviously there's a big beef in Canada
right now and Canada does not have a lot
of uh does not have a border with Latin
America so they needed to fill in the
labor shortage they shipped uh they got
a lot of immigrant us from India but
then right now there's a huge like
cultural War about that in Canada right
right so basically people are saying
like you know at the end of the road
most countries seem to end up with the
immigration strategy but it seems like
they handle the immigration all
differently well I guess the big
question is here how will Japan handle
the immigration situation are they going
to handle it is the Japanese government
and the Japanese people going to handle
it the same way are they going to open
up to these new migrant workers like
with open arms you know I but again
migrant workers have been in Japan for a
while like we said like seven eight
years ago when we went to Japan like
there was already foreign workers
there's foreign workers in every country
I've ever been to especially the big
cities yeah especially the big cities
there are foreign workers you know who
will take that job so it's just kind of
this the amount is new you know what's
really interesting and it's like so
tough because everybody's going to come
up with this example that example
there's no one answer but it's almost
like does the incoming immigrant need to
treat the current culture of where
they're Landing like a religion you know
how in the old days people used to
conquer each other and like make people
either convert to at least in the west
cuz I think the West is more religious
but like convert to each other's
religion do they need to treat the
native culture like a religion that
they're buying their way
into or as long as they handle their job
they deliver what they need to the
shareholders of the company that is
providing them the Visa is that the end
of the
transaction questions yeah let us know
what you guys think in the comments
section below I think for me my final
takeaway is AI
AI in America it's not going to work as
people like have individual freedoms
right like as long as you can maintain
the Law and Order in the society like
Singapore does culture can shift right
because the ancient culture's been
documented but yeah and like maybe the
government should if they're really so
worried about diffusion or whatever like
documented more but yeah why not have
more people around it's really about
obeying the law and keeping like people
feel safe and again like this is not
like the immigration issue in America
where there's like a lot of people
crossing the border whe it's families
men and women sometimes it's all guys or
whoever it is like and how it's like
kind of messy in America it's it's you
know when Japan gets it everybody's
going to be documented usually I mean I
know like there's cases of undocumented
workers but of course because you know
companies they they want cheap labor and
every country's every country has
companies that are going to do that
every business owner is going to take an
undocumented worker for cheaper bro cuz
they worried about their bottom line
yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah but uh anyways
uh yeah maybe Japan is super strict and
only wants the workers that are all
fully documented and really want to come
but then that's also going to limit the
amount of people they can take so
anyways guys uh interesting things
happening in Asia right now uh not but
also similarly in a weird different
Dynamic things is happening in America
but because the society is different it
may change the implementation in the
details let us know what you think in
the comments down below and until next
time we out peace
