New labor deal won't change Boeing's financials tremendously, says Bernstein's Doug Harned

Invest Insight
9 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 22, 2024
Doug Harned, Bernstein aerospace and defense senior analyst, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss news of Boeing reaching a tentative deal with the machinist's union, impact of the strike on the company, the challenges facing CEO Kelly Ortberg, and more.
Boeing reaching a tentative deal which could end the strike after more than a month.
Workers are set to vote on that strike, or I should say on that settlement, on Wednesday.
It's the same day the company releases its third quarter results.
And joining us right now for more on all this is Doug Harden.
He's Bernstein's aerospace and defense senior analyst.
You look at this deal, you're looking at it from the perspective of investors.
Does this, is this a good deal?
Up 35% across the board.
Well, look, I think what's important here, they've got to get this deal done.
And I think this has been a real struggle.
It's pretty much in line with what we were expecting on it.
But I think you ultimately have to get it done.
Kelly Ortberg's taken over.
We've sort of looked at this situation at Boeing in three stages.
First, getting the strike resolved, the capital raise cleared.
Second, we need to see a plan on how he really
sees taking the company forward and getting it fully recovered.
And finally, they have to execute.
And you can't get to the plan unless you get this strike situation resolved.
So in our view, this had to get done if this goes through.
And it seems reasonable to us that it would.
The 35% increase is not going to really change the dynamics or the financials
in the company tremendously.
They've got to get the deal done.
So does it change the margins, though?
No, not at all.
It's got to.
Well, it will a little bit.
So when you look at this, it's all in Puget Sound.
So it affects 737, it's 777, 767.
And what it does do, you're looking at labor.
Touch labor on an aircraft is on the order of 3% to 4% of total cost.
So doing a raise like this over four years, yes, it will affect the margins.
But I don't think it's going to be dramatic.
And also, they are putting in place a cost reduction plan to reduce headcount overall by 10%.
That will offset some of this.
But I don't think it's a huge effect on margin.
OK, Doug, we're looking at a stock that you can't see it.
But on the screen next to you, this stock is down nearly 40% this year.
Sits at about 160 bucks right now.
What do you think the fair value for this company is today?
Well, our target is 195.
And that's a 12-month target.
Now, the challenge they have is that you're basically looking at cash pressure here
because they've got $45 billion in net debts.
That's going to be coming out.
They're going to have to pay that down over the next few years.
So that means very little cash back to shareholders.
But when we look at this on an EBITDA basis long term, we get to 195 price target.
But I want to just stress that I think the short term is very interesting.
And by short term, I mean the next six to nine months.
It gets more difficult when you see, can they really execute?
And by execute, I mean get production rates up on the max first,
get production rates up on the 787.
That's going to be the key thing here.
Doug, you keep saying they have to get this done.
The stock is up three and a quarter percent on the idea that this vote is coming Wednesday.
What happens if the union votes it down?
Well, that's, of course, that's always possible.
I think that's, I would view that negatively.
I think what they propose here, I think it fits right in with the modeling we've done.
And at this stage, it would be an awfully long strike as well for the IAM if this went
more than six weeks.
So, yeah, I would say it's negative if they can't get it done.
I figured that, but negative to the tune of how much in the stock?
Well, you're probably looking, maybe going right back where you were before today.
I mean, we're looking at some significant upside today.
But again, by not getting it done, that doesn't, it's a question of timing.
Will this take one more week?
That's probably not a big deal.
Historically, we've found when you have a strike situation like this, and there have
been four of them, IAM strikes, it takes about two to three months to get production back
up to somewhat of a planned level.
So, you know, whether it lasts one more week, two more weeks, you're still going to see
that effect over two to three months.
I think it's just being able to look ahead at the horizon, seeing that you're going to
clear this.
We'll see on Wednesday.
I think the odds are this will go through, but it's hard.
You know, it's always hard to predict.
