The Secret of Japanese Swords - Science View

Ancient Edge
3 followers
1 Video View·Oct 21, 2024
Japanese swords forged with techniques forgotten by time, may be on the edge of a breakthrough.
The Japanese sword.
Awesome functionality honed into a graceful form has led them to be called metal-made art.
They're known to be unbending, unbreaking, and keenly sharp.
Over history stretching back more than a millennium,
countless expert swordsmiths have furthered the craft.
And yet, one period of this lineage is shrouded in mystery.
Methods used in the 16th century and earlier have been lost,
the details of their techniques now unknown.
What kind of materials were used, and under what circumstances?
Researchers have worked to uncover the truth behind these swords.
Japanese swords, embodying the spirit and mastery of their creators.
In this episode, we use science to unsheathe the mystery within the metal.
Gifu University. It is here that the science behind Japanese swords.
Is being pursued by a devoted researcher.
Nakata Toshiya is an associate professor specializing in the study of material strength.
He had previously researched materials for use in devices like automobile frames.
However, he's found a new source of inspiration.
A Japanese sword, believed to have been made in the 16th century or earlier.
The blade is shrouded in mystery.
Swords resembling their modern shape are thought to have first emerged around the 11th century.
In the long years that followed, their functionality in cutting was progressively improved.
But in the 17th century, with the birth of the Edo Shogunate,
Japan entered an era of continuing peace.
Swords were valued less as weapons than as decorations.
The swords from previous eras came to be called ancient swords,
and the techniques for their creation were lost to the sands of time.
Nakata has made it his mission to seek out these lost methods.
What could have caused the methods for creating ancient swords to fade into history?
Exhibiting a wealth of weapons, the Japanese Sword Museum may hold some answers.
We don't have much left of the techniques we already have.
Some of the techniques we already have have been lost,
and some have been combined with new ones along the way.
So it's difficult to say how much of the old techniques have been preserved,
or when new ones have been added.
Sword-making techniques were passed down from master to apprentice,
shared only among a small number of people, and never committed to writing.
These are the lost traditions that Nakata pursues.
He believes that the specific qualities of the metal are key to the solution.
One trait of Japanese swords is that a single blade contains different points
with varying qualities like hardness and durability.
Nakata believes that revealing these qualities might lead back to the traditional methods.
In this program, we closely examine two procedures
that could play a role in realizing the swords.
The first is folded forging.
The second, quenching.
We witness the processes at a Japanese sword forge.
This is sword maker, Miyashita Masayoshi.
He showed us just what Japanese swords are made of.
Tama-hagane, Japan's unique form of steel made from iron sand.
It's softer and more flexible than the iron ore typically used for western swords,
lending Japanese blades their distinct properties.
Folded forging is a process developed exclusively for Japanese sword making.
First, a mass of tama-hagane heated to over 1,000 degrees Celsius is struck with a hammer.
Then, a slit is cut down the middle, and it's folded in half.
The newly folded steel is hammered again, and then folded.
This repetition continues dozens of times.
Work continues for three days.
By repeating the process, folded forging imbues the strength for which Japanese swords are known.
The proof of the forging is marked on the blade.
The folding creates countless delicate patterns that artfully line it.
Layers just 1,000th of a millimeter in thickness
are overlapped more than 30,000 times to form the complex patterns.
This process of folded forging that gives Japanese swords their strength
is the same one to give their beauty.
After forging, the hot steel is cooled swiftly with water in the process known as quenching.
This crucial step is needed to give Japanese swords their sharpness.
However, within the reputation of being unbending, unbreaking, and keenly sharp,
a contradiction is concealed.
To keep it from breaking, a blade requires durability and flexibility.
This allows force to merely warp it without breakage.
But to keep from bending, a blade must be hard.
Hard swords are also brittle when a certain degree of force is applied.
Sword makers are able to combine the contrasting properties
of hardness and flexibility into a single blade.
The answer lies in changing properties brought by shifts in temperature,
mastery of the science of steel.
To reveal the details, two cooling methods were compared.
The first sample is heated to around 830 degrees,
the approximate heat at which quenching is performed.
Then it's submerged in water to swiftly cool it.
After the temperature drops, the metal is secured.
Force is applied by adding one kilogram weights one by one.
When a total of four kilograms are added, the metal finally snaps.
With the other sample, the metal is cooled gradually at room temperature
over the space of 15 minutes.
The metal's temperature drops.
Once again, weights are applied.
This time, when the weights reach four kilograms,
the metal bends but doesn't break.
The only difference between these methods is cooling quickly or gradually.
Why might this distinction occur?
Steel is composed mostly from iron and carbon.
When it reaches a certain temperature, the carbon atoms move between the iron atoms.
If steel in this state is rapidly cooled,
the iron atoms contract, trapping the carbon among them.
The metal forms an extremely hard martensite structure.
When the metal is cooled slowly, the carbon atoms are allowed to escape almost entirely.
This forms the more durable perlite structure.
The process of quenching forms both of these types of steel at the same time.
Quenching is performed simultaneously,
raising the question of how the cooling times can be individually regulated.
The answer is an important step taken just prior to quenching.
A clay-like substance is being prepared.
The material is then poured into a large container.
This is quenching soil, made from a mixture including clay, charcoal, and grindstone powder.
Since the ingredients and their proportions have a direct effect
on the quality of the sword, the details are a carefully guarded secret.
Once the quenching soil is prepared, it's spread along the sword before quenching.
Areas where the soil is thinly applied grow hard.
In other words, changing the thickness of the soil
directly affects the amount of time needed for the metal to cool.
The blade with quenching soil applied is placed inside the furnace.
The entire blade is heated uniformly.
Once the temperature has been sufficiently raised, it's submerged in water.
The sections where quenching soil is applied thinly cool quickly,
while the thicker areas retain their heat, cooling slowly.
This is the secret to making steel that has both hard and flexible portions.
The sword is complete.
The white wave-like markings upon the blade are known as blade patterns
and are created as a result of the quenching soil.
They came from the technique carried down for over 1,000 years
to make both a strong and aesthetically pleasing blade.
The method is based heavily in scientific properties.
However, the details of the materials and temperatures
greatly affect the properties of the sword,
leaving the process for sword making in the 16th century and earlier to be largely a mystery.
We asked Miyashita,
if these techniques were revived in the modern world, would you like to use them?
Many scientists are attempting to uncover the secrets of the ancient blades.
One among them is associate professor Tanaka Manako.
She explains that research of the swords has progressed since the early 20th century.
The swords have been observed to destroy metal structures.
There are two people who have done this.
The first is Chikashige, a professor at Kyoto University.
He has done research on the relationship between the west and the east,
and has published a book on this subject.
He has also written about the observation of metal structures on Japanese swords.
It used the then-cutting-edge utility of the microscope
to examine cross-sections of the swords.
Differences in hardness and impurities were drawn out by hand.
This data shows the composition found in sections of the blades.
Levels of phosphorus, sulfur, and manganese
clearly reveal the structure of Tama-hagane within it.
Tanaka is currently working on a process to analyze the structure of Tama-hagane.
She can analyze Japanese swords without breaking or damaging them.
Neutrons, known for their ability to pass through matter,
can be used in data analysis.
They're expected to reveal qualities of steel,
such as the crystal structure and size, condition, and inner effect of quenching.
These images display a sample analyzed directly before and after quenching.
Tanaka views Japanese swords as a research subject holding great scientific appeal.
Meanwhile, Nakata has made great efforts to decode the process in creating historical swords.
In April 2022, he launched a crowdfunding project to begin individual research.
He began with a preliminary experiment on a modern Japanese sword.
It measured the hardness throughout the blade.
These were the results.
This shows a cross-section of the sword, with the lower area being the edge.
The red sections are the hardest, with blue sections becoming softer.
Nakata's experiment shows the edge to be extremely hard,
but the area just a few millimeters from it to grow progressively softer.
To perform even deeper analysis, various cross-sections were removed.
From these, the strength of the steel was measured.
The numbered sections are where samples were taken from.
This is the actual sample.
In order to accurately gauge the degree of strain when pulled,
it's been machine cut into this shape.
The sample is pulled vertically, examining the warping of the metal.
It was discovered that samples from near the edge would not significantly stretch,
but rather break when a threshold of force was exceeded.
By contrast, samples taken from the interior or sides
stretched significantly and were less prone to breakage.
Nakata has concluded that the varying strength of the steel
could reveal the ways in which folded forging and quenching were performed.
He plans to conduct this experiment on actual ancient swords.
While the steel is still in the process of being forged,
his research has commenced from the smallest of samples.
Nakata believes that the research may hold great significance in the modern era.
Japanese swords have attained a unique evolution
over the course of more than a millennium.
Their mystery acts as a call to arms
for researchers who wish to uncover the secrets of the sword.
