Eugene Delacroix, France's Most Influential Romantic Painter

Romantic Realms
7 followers
Eugène Delacroix, France's most influential romantic painter.
A version of this appears on my website, dianedurantywriter.com.
This post focuses on Eugène Delacroix because the Metropolitan Museum
is running a major exhibition of his works in late 2018.
I will say up front that I'm not Delacroix's biggest fan.
I wouldn't want any of his paintings hanging in my home,
but Delacroix was enormously influential during the 19th century.
If you're interested in the progression of 19th century art,
or if you're a fan of Monet, Cézanne, Matisse, Picasso,
or a host of other painters of the late 19th century,
he's someone you should meet.
He's also interesting for his viewpoint on reason,
emotions, and the creation of art,
which I'll get to at the end of this essay.
The Met's exhibition includes over 150 works by Delacroix,
but few, if any, by earlier French artists.
I'm maniacal about knowing contexts,
so my goal here is to help those who aren't well-versed in art history
to understand Delacroix by showing how his works fit into the art milieu of the time.
First section.
Introduction.
What this essay is excerpted from.
My discussion of Delacroix is part of a chronological survey
called Seismic Shifts in Subject and Style,
19th century French painting and philosophy.
The essay looks at how French artists switched from creating works such as
Madame Recamier, on the left,
to Lux Con Evoluté by Matisse, on the right.
Artistic trends are not the result of some collective consciousness working its will.
They are simply the styles that the majority of individual artists,
in a given time, choose to embrace.
In Seismic Shifts, I seek the reasons for those changes
via a combination of art analysis and philosophical detection,
which happens to be the sort of problem that fascinates me.
The essay covers 18 French artists from the neoclassicists,
romantics, and naturalists,
through Manet, the impressionists, post-impressionists,
pointillists, symbolists, and academics.
In the philosophical detection sections of the essay,
I searched for the comments of those artists on four issues that are crucial for artists.
First, the role of training for an artist.
Is it essential?
Is it unnecessary?
Is it detrimental?
Second, what are the roles of reason and emotion in creating art?
Third, is the subject more important than the style of work, or vice versa?
And fourth, who is qualified to judge art?
Next section, Neoclassicism.
Because I'm focusing on Delacroix in this post,
I'm skipping the sections of Seismic Shifts
that discuss the French Academy, the French Salon, and the Rococo style.
But we do need to look briefly at the neoclassicists,
the style that was dominant when Delacroix and the other romanticists came on the scene.
The neoclassicists were at their peak from the 1780s to the 1820s.
For centuries, artists had believed that the function of art
was to educate men by showing the good and the beautiful.
Neoclassical painters continued that tradition.
Figures in their paintings were usually grand and heroic.
They moved in a world where heroic and dramatic events are possible.
The neoclassicists had a distinctive style for showing this world.
Precise lines, meticulous details, clear lighting, and balanced compositions.
Next section, Neoclassicists discuss art.
How did the neoclassicists respond to the four issues
that we are following regarding art and philosophy?
The most prominent figures, David and Ingres,
seem to operate on the Enlightenment assumption
that man can know reality through the senses and logical thought
and can act to improve himself and his world.
So, on the matter of training for artists,
David and Ingres both thought it was essential.
They were both academically trained and they both ran
highly successful ateliers for aspiring artists.
Second question, what role does reason play in the creation of art?
David said, quote,
the guide of genius is the torch of reason, end quote.
Ingres said that good art is the product of hard work and education.
On a broader scale, David and Ingres assumed reason was involved in art
because they saw art's purpose as didactic
and both teaching and learning involved disciplined mental effort.
Third question, what's the relationship between style and subject?
David said that style is more important than subject,
that he seems to have meant that it's acceptable to use well-known subjects
as long as one interprets them for oneself.
Ingres apparently concurred when he said that artists did not need to seek out the new,
quote, our task is not to invent but to continue, end quote.
And the fourth question, who should judge art?
David thought the people should judge art
since artists themselves were not always competent to do so.
Ingres said that taste is based on education and experience,
which implies that aesthetic judgment requires observation and rational thought.
Next section, Romanticism.
During the 1820s, Neoclassicism was replaced on the cutting edge of art by Romanticism.
However, Neoclassicism and Romanticism continued to exist side by side for several decades.
In 1855, Ingres and Delacroix each had a room full of paintings
on display at the Universal Exposition in Paris.
Now you might logically ask, what exactly is Romanticism?
Tricky question.
Scholars agree that Romanticism's origins reach back at least to Edmund Burke's
1757 inquiry into the origins of the sublime.
But no artist at the time, and no scholar since,
has been able to define exactly what Romanticism means.
By the mid-1820s, about 150 different definitions
had been suggested, none of which gained general acceptance.
If you start considering modern definitions,
Ayn Rand's definition of Romanticism or the meaning behind a romantic dinner,
the list gets even longer.
Perhaps the main reason for the early disagreements on what Romanticism is,
is that its premises and implications differed from one country to another,
one decade to another, and particularly from one discipline to another.
In philosophy, German romantics such as Fichte, Schelling, and Schopenhauer advocated outright
mysticism.
The whole body is nothing but objectified will, i.e. will become idea.
That's Schopenhauer.
In literature, authors such as Schiller, Hugo, Dostoevsky, and Rostand
stressed the individual and his emotions.
In the visual arts, Romanticism was largely confined to painting.
Beginning with Piranesi, Fuseli, and Goya,
artists rebelled against the noble simplicity
and quiet grandeur that Winckelmann had advocated,
and which, in the form of neoclassicism, had swept through Europe during the late 18th century.
Romantic painters focused on subjects calculated to arouse strong passions.
The passions could be as positive as love or as negative as terror.
The important thing was to make the viewer feel something.
The first important French Romantic painter was Baron Antoine Jean Gros,
1771 to 1835.
His Napoleon in the Pest House at Jaffa, 1804, a huge 18 by 23 feet,
illustrates the Romantics striving to evoke emotions.
General Bonaparte, in the center,
touches one of his soldiers who's suffering from the bubonic plague.
People of this time considered such an action either magnificently brave or suicidal.
Possibly both.
Theodore Géricault, the next important Romantic painter,
favored anonymous modern figures in dramatic situations.
His breakthrough painting was the 23-foot-wide Raft of the Medusa, 1819.
Its depiction of a shipwreck that ended in death and cannibalism
was calculated to rouse horror and pity in the viewers.
Next section, Eugène Delacroix.
When Géricault died in 1824 at the age of 33,
Delacroix became the most prominent artist among the French Romantics.
In 1827, he and Ingres each had significant works on display at the Paris Salon.
Ingres' Apotheosis of Homer, 1827, and Delacroix's Death of Sardinopolis, 1827,
vividly illustrate the differences between the neoclassicists and the Romantics.
Seldom have two such radically different paintings been produced
in the same city within a year of each other.
And each was a size that you could not miss, about 13 by 16 feet.
Incidentally, the Met's Delacroix exhibition has a sketch of the Death of Sardinopolis
and a small-scale reproduction of it by Delacroix.
The original is too large and fragile to travel transatlantic.
The Apotheosis of Homer, on the left, shows the author of the Iliad and the Odyssey.
It's a genius to whom all ancient and modern artists pay homage.
Homer and his admirers are arranged in front of a classical Greek temple under a clear blue sky.
The Death of Sardinopolis, on the other hand, shows a despot from ancient Assyria,
that's modern Iraq, who has learned that he's about to be conquered and has ordered his henchmen
to slaughter his harem girls and his horses so that no one else can enjoy them.
Sardinopolis, reclining at the upper left,
is impassively observing a maelstrom of death and destruction.
The styles, as well as the subjects of these two paintings, are diametrically opposed.
Ingres's composition is balanced and symmetrical,
with a strong focal point established by the temple's pediment
and by the central placement of Homer and the angel who's crowning him.
Delacroix's composition has two long diagonals that move the viewer's eye back to Sardinopolis's
reclining figure. The rest of the scene is asymmetrical, full of chaotic movement.
In the Ingres painting, the light pours in from our left, casting few deep shadows.
In Delacroix, the room is dimly lit and full of shadows,
making the scene more turbulent and confusing.
The very brushstrokes are radically different in the two paintings.
Ingres's outlines are precise, his brushstrokes are indistinguishable.
Delacroix's brushstrokes are easily visible and his outlines are fuzzy or blurred.
As a side note, Delacroix was capable of executing a flawless finish
when he considered it appropriate for the subject.
In this portrait of his aunt, he depicted the facial features with precision,
with the lace of her headdress with a very free hand.
For Ingres and the other neoclassicists, the purpose of art was didactic,
to depict truth and beauty, and thus to teach the viewer how to be a better,
more moral person. The restrained, low-key mood is appropriate for such an intellectual aim.
For Delacroix and the Romantics, the purpose of art was to evoke a strong emotion.
In Sardinopolis, a dozen variations on terror.
A gloomy and chaotic style is appropriate for that goal.
Evoking emotion is what Delacroix did best.
In one of his most famous paintings, Liberty Leading the People, 1830,
Delacroix showed common people in a dramatic situation, as Géricault had done.
Incidentally, this one is not in the exhibition either.
Here, in a commemoration of one of Paris's many rebellions against royal authority,
the allegorical figure of liberty triumphantly leads Parisians across piles of corpses and rubble.
At the left, Delacroix included a self-portrait in a top hat.
The boy on the right is often regarded as the inspiration for Gavroche in Hugo's Les Miserables.
Belos points out in the novel of the century that the boy is wearing a student's cap,
and Gavroche was a student only of the street.
As in the death of Sardinop... I say that word too fast.
As in the death of Sardinopolis, Delacroix here favors blurred details and murky colors.
Delacroix seldom painted such contemporary events.
He favored instead exotic milieus, religious subjects,
and scenes from authors such as Shakespeare, Byron, and Sir Walter Scott.
In these, Delacroix used a brighter palette,
but even here his colors are murky compared with the clear hues of Ingres.
Murky colors and blurry details are characteristic of Delacroix's style throughout his career.
Next section, Delacroix discusses art.
What did Delacroix have to say on the issues that we're following regarding art and philosophy?
In 1853, he wrote, quote,
nature is far from being always interesting from the standpoint of effect and of ensemble.
If each detail offers a perfection, which I shall call inimitable,
these details collectively, on the other hand,
rarely present an effect equivalent to the one which results in the work of a great artist
from the feeling for the ensemble and the composition.
End of that quote.
Selecting details and arranging a composition, which is what he's talking about there,
implies that conscious thought has a role in the creation of art.
Delacroix's assertion that artwork conveys a message confirms that,
quote, is there not a moral attached even to a fable?
Who should reveal this better than the artist,
who plans every part of the composition beforehand
in order that the reader or beholder may unconsciously be led to understand and enjoy it?
End of quote.
But Delacroix also saw emotions as invaluable
and disparage rational thought when painting.
Quote, I do not at all like reasonable painting.
I recognize that it is necessary for my turbulent mind to be agitated,
to destroy its bonds, to try out a hundred manners before arriving at the goal,
the need for which torments me in everything.
There is an old leavening, a pitch black depth to satisfy.
If I'm not agitated like a serpent in the hands of a pythoness, I am cold.
This must be recognized and be submitted to.
And this is a great pleasure.
Everything that I have done well has been done in this way.
End quote.
It's no wonder that Ingres, a highly cerebral painter,
regarded France's most famous romantic as the devil incarnate.
Passing Delacroix at an exhibition, he growled, I smell sulfur.
Next section, Baudelaire and Delacroix.
We now turn briefly to a man who is not an artist,
but an art critic, a relatively new phenomenon.
During the 19th century, several factors combined to make art critics enormously influential.
Due to the Industrial Revolution, the standard of living was rising
and more people could afford to purchase art.
Increased wealth and productivity also led to widespread literacy and greater leisure
after centuries when most people had struggled from dawn to dusk for mere subsistence.
Inventions such as the steam-powered printing press,
wood engraving, photography, lithography, and inexpensive wood pulp paper
made it easier and faster to transmit ideas and images.
More people than ever saw and read about the latest developments in art.
Yet there were still no accepted standards for judging art.
This provided the perfect breeding ground for the emergence of professional art critics
who made it their mission to tell the public which type of art they ought to approve of.
Critics' views of the Paris Salon exhibitions were printed in periodicals
and circulated widely in pamphlet form.
Among the critics who achieved lasting fame were Baudelaire, Ruskin, and Zola.
We're going to look here only at Baudelaire.
Baudelaire was born in 1821, about the time Romanticism burst onto the French art scene.
He died in 1867, the same year as Ingres died.
Baudelaire's Flowers of Evil, 1857, was arguably the 19th century's
most influential collection of poetry.
The opening lines to his readers reveal Baudelaire's horrendous sense of life.
Stupidity, delusion, selfishness, and lust torment our bodies and possess our minds,
and we sustain our affable remorse the way a beggar nourishes his lice.
Baudelaire's published comments praising Delacroix boosted Delacroix's fame and influence.
In fact, much of what is accepted as the Romantic attitude toward art
was actually Baudelaire's interpretation of Delacroix.
Regarding Delacroix's style, Baudelaire said,
From Delacroix's point of view, line does not exist, for no matter how thin it may be,
a maddening geometer can always suppose it thick enough to contain a thousand others.
And for colorists who seek to imitate the eternal palpitations of nature,
lines are never other than the intimate blending of two colors, as in the rainbow.
If you peer intently at Delacroix's Liberty Leading the People, or some of the paintings
of the Metropolitan's Delacroix exhibition, the lines, the outlines actually seem to vibrate.
According to Baudelaire, what makes Delacroix distinctive is not a style or a subject,
but an emotion, a feeling, rather than a way of thinking or acting.
There remains for me to note one last quality in Delacroix to complete this analysis,
the most remarkable quality of all, and the one that makes him the true painter of the 19th
century. It is the singular and obstinate melancholy that runs through all his works,
and that is expressed in his choice of subject, by the expression of his faces,
through gesture, and in his kind of color.
End of quote. In his obituary of Delacroix, Baudelaire pithily summed this up, quote,
Delacroix was passionately in love with passion and coldly determined to seek the
means of expressing it in the most visible way. I could go on, but I will stop it here.
As I said, this essay is an excerpt from Seismic Shifts in Subject and Style,
19th century French painting and philosophy. That's available on Amazon as a Kindle book.
If you're interested in the, if you're interested in the development of French art in the 19th
century, check it out. And if you've enjoyed this essay, check out diandrantiwriter.com
and my Patreon page. Thanks for listening.
