King Arthur and Folklore in the Art of Edward Burne-Jones

Edward Burne-Jones
2 followers
Sir Edward Coleyburn Jones was a baronet, an artist, a designer and many other types of
craftsperson besides. But how exactly did he use legends and mythology and things even from
the Arthur cycle in his work? Let's find out in this week's episode of Fabulous Folklore.
Hello there and welcome to Fabulous Folklore, the podcast for all things folklore, occult and
just a bit weird. I'm your host Icy Sedgwick, blogger, fantasy author and your guide into
these rather mysterious realms. I've got some rare things to show you so come on in,
take a look around but be careful not to touch anything. These things sometimes bite.
Well hello there and welcome back to Fabulous Folklore with me your host Icy Sedgwick.
We are on to our third week of the folklore and art, or mythology and art as it's kind of turned
out, month that we've ended up having. And also, me being me, I decided to have a look at the
calendar to figure out what I was going to do next and I'd completely forgotten that July actually
has five Saturdays in it and had only planned for four artists. So no matter, I've got it sorted
because what I figured that would actually do is it's Lammas or Lunasa on the 1st of August which
is the Sunday so I thought why don't we have the episode on the final Saturday of July being about
traditions and legends and so on associated with Lammas and Lunasa much like we did with
the summer solstice last year. So that is what we're going to do for the final week of July.
So I've got it all sorted. So this week we are going to be having a look at the art of Edward
Byrne Jones. Like I said at the beginning of this series, Victorian artists often drew on myths,
legends and fairy tales to fuel their work. Now they did do this because of the fact that these
things all made great subject matter for commissions, which is a fact exploited to great
effect by John William Waterhouse, but these stories also allowed artists to comment on their
age in pictorial terms. So the rewriting of a myth or the choice of a singular moment from a legend
could give the artist a visual voice. And as we saw last week, Evelyn De Morgan was a true genius
at lending established stories a new perspective through her composition and treatment of the
narrative. Now this could also work in much more derisive ways, which is what we're going to have
a look at with Byrne Jones. And yes, it is true, the Victorians do have a lot to answer for more
widely, but there is a reason for my choice of this period for this theme because of the fact
it was a period in which mythology and folklore appeared a lot in art. True, they did use these
and to reinforce patriarchal and colonial ideals. But on the other hand, these paintings did bring
these legends to a wider audience, and that is ultimately the goal of both my blog and podcast.
So therefore, it seemed like an interesting dovetail. And again, like I've said before,
on a practical level, many of the paintings are in the public domain, so I can share them here.
And when I say here, obviously this is also going on YouTube as well. So like always, I'm going to
put the link to the video below. So if you want to see the paintings as I'm talking about them,
you can. If you're happy to just look at them on my blog, you can. I'm going to leave it entirely
up to you for what works better for you. But anyway, let's have a look at the artwork of
Edward Byrne Jones. So who was Edward Byrne Jones? Well, he was actually born on the 28th of August,
1833, and then died on the 17th of June, 1898. He's most often associated with the pre-Raphaelite
art movement, and he did also work with William Morris, whom he met at Oxford. He was an upper
class by birth, despite having a knighthood later in life, and he was actually born in Birmingham.
But his mother died when he was very young, so he was essentially raised by his father,
who was a Welsh frame maker. Now, Byrne Jones's knighthood actually came along in 1894,
something that did not sit well with his socialist friends, or indeed his wife,
Georgiana, but he did insist that he did it for the benefit of his son.
A memorial service was actually held for him at Westminster Abbey after he died,
at the request of the Prince of Wales. So it kind of shows the circles that he was moving in by that
point. Now, he was famous for being a multidisciplinary artist. Some of his most beautiful
work is actually in stained glass. He also designed ceramic tiles, mosaics, tapestries,
and jewellery, and this put him at the forefront of what's known as the aesthetic movement.
And the whole point of aestheticism was that art held value for its beauty,
and for its ability to stir an emotional response. So the story or moral behind the work
shouldn't actually play a part in its value. So you could enjoy something just because it
was nice and aesthetically pleasing, rather than it having to speak to you on a moralistic level.
Now, despite this, Byrne Jones did explore mythology through his work, and Greek myth,
in particular, appears within the paintings. But he did draw from the Arthurian legends and
traditional fairy tales as well. I've tried to choose a bit of a folklore-worthy selection
for this episode. So we're going to start off with Parn and Psyche, which he did between 1872
and 1874. And I chose this one because it depicts a very different element of the Psyche myth.
Now, in case you've never heard it before, this is the story in which Eros, a god of love,
falls in love with Psyche. He spurs her away to a fabulous palace, and he comes to her every night,
and they're man and wife, and all this kind of jazz. But he doesn't want her to know he's a god.
I've never understood that part of the story, but that is what happened. He didn't want her to know
that he was a god, so she was never allowed to look at him, and he would only visit after dark.
Now, her sisters, who were completely jealous of the wealth in the palace,
tell Psyche to disobey her lover, and he might be a monster for all she knows.
So one night, she sneaks a peek by a lamplight while he's asleep, which would have been fair
enough were it not for the drop of hot oil that landed on Eros waking him up. Enraged that she'd
disobeyed him, he leaves and basically goes back to his mother Aphrodite. Does seem like a little
bit of a teenage drop, but I'm not going to argue with mythology. Psyche is therefore left alone,
and she's basically wandering in the forest. She's scared, she's depressed, and she actually
considers ending it all. And at one point, she throws herself into a river, but the river god
puts her back on the bank as if to say, no, you're not doing that today. And at this point,
she encounters Pan, the great god of the wilderness, who was also sitting by the river.
Now, he recognises that she's, and I quote, labouring under an excess of love,
and that's from Apuleius, who wrote about this. And he basically tells her not to attempt to
end her life again, advising her to cease to grieve, and to instead worship Eros. Because
Pan is basically twigged that if she hangs around long enough and continues worshipping Eros,
he will change his mind. He does also call Eros the greatest of the gods, and I think in many
cases, Eros does actually have the potential to do the most damage, considering the fact he just
needs to shoot you and you fall in love with someone. But there we go, so Pan's like, you
know what, it'll be fine, just keep worshipping him, all will be well. Which is an interesting
agony ant. But meanwhile, a furious Aphrodite catches up with Psyche and sets her forth trials
to prove that she's worthy of Eros. So first, she has to sort a mountain of seeds, which Aphrodite
thinks is going to be an impossible task, but an ant colony actually help her to complete the task.
Next, Aphrodite sets her a task to gather wool from a very dangerous sheep. But a river god takes
pity on her and essentially says, don't take it from the sheep itself, look at all these tufts of
wool from the fleece on the bushes, just gather those. So she does. Next, she's then sent to the
underworld to collect water, and Zeus actually takes pity on her, and sends his eagle to help
her do it. And finally, Aphrodite sends her to the underworld to collect some of Persephone's
beauty cream, and this is supposed to be so wonderful, it'll make you beautiful and youthful
and all that kind of lovely stuff. Now, Persephone, again, gladly helps, and she sends her on her way
with a box containing some of the promised beauty cream. Problem is, Psyche gets a little bit too
tempted, shall we say, by the prospect of having a goddess's beauty cream, and she thinks, oh, maybe
I'll use a little bit of it myself. Now, she opens the box, and unfortunately, it only contains the
Eros comes across her, basically realises that this has all been a little bit of a drama that
nobody really needed, and takes her to Olympus, where Zeus makes her the goddess of the soul.
So why choose Pan? Well, it's a pretty rich myth in terms of visuals, and many paintings focus on
the first meeting of Psyche in Eros, or the point when Psyche looks upon her husband for the first
time. So you see quite a lot of those kind of images. So why did Burne-Jones choose this fleeting
moment from the tale? I mean, when you look at it in the book that's actually available on
archive.org, it's literally like two pages, like two-person pages. Pan's very much a cameo in this.
And he is a fascinating figure, but why did Burne-Jones choose it? Well, he's often linked
with the zodiac sign Capricorn, and we did cover this way back in January in the Zodiac Origin
Myths episode. And also, Pan doesn't really neatly fit into the Titan-Olympian binary of Greek
mythology, and there are some people who will say he's the son of Hermes. Other people say that he
sits outside of the great family tree, and doesn't really belong to either group. So there we go,
he's a very confusing god in that regard. But he's very wild, he's untamed, he's a nature god,
often associated with sexuality, and always associated with these wild rural places.
And the Romantic movement actually adopted him as their primary deity during the 18th and 19th
centuries, since he essentially stood in opposition to everything the era represented. And when you've
got this mass industrialisation and things like that going on, they went for like the most
uncivilised god that they could find. Now incidentally, people didn't actually build
temples to Pan, instead they chose to worship him in caves or grottoes. And he's basically the ideal
god for the Pre-Raphaelites, with their focus on nature and the pre-industrial landscape.
So in this particular point in the painting, Burne-Jones is depicting Pan comforting psyche.
Now to really stretch the metaphor, this becomes a moment where the wildness of untamed nature
basically comforts the soul. And Pan is also right in his reading of Eros, so the painting
also becomes a testament to the wisdom offered by the natural world. Now it is possible that
Burne-Jones chose this scene to make this point, and it's also possible that he did so because
Pan was a popular topic. Miles A. Kimball actually points out that Pan was seen as a figure representative
of asceticism. So he'd already been popular in the mid-19th century as this avatar of the natural
world. And writers and artists often focused on his sexuality and the wild abandon that apparently
followed Pan wherever he went. But as Kimball points out, the aesthetics question why something
needed to be useful and have value, so that's basically the same as Pan. And they also saw
moments of ecstatic experience, which is obviously something offered by Pan as well. So the cult of
usefulness basically falls apart in the face of Pan's merry capering. I'd like to think that
Burne-Jones basically included all of this as an aesthetic manifesto, but that might be reading too
much into it. Now we're going to go on to the next painting, and that's the Beguiling of Merlin, which
he painted between 1872 and 77. So very, very different, so we're going from Greek mythology to
Arthurian legend. And in this particular image, we see Merlin trapped in a hawthorn bush by the spells
of Nimue, Lady of the Lake. Now this refers to an episode in the relationship between Nimue and
Merlin. And in some legends, she's a fairy, and in others, she's simply a magician. But the stories
have become tangled over time. And at the heart, the Merlin-Nimue story basically follows the
fairy lover trope, in that a mortal man falls in love with a fairy and then goes to live with her
in her realm. Obviously, regular listeners will recognise that very much as the Thomas the Rhymer
story. Of course, Merlin is no mortal, so the story does incorporate some changes. And in some versions,
there is an indication that the goddess Diana is actually Nimue's godmother. Now, Nimue promises to
give Merlin her love in exchange for the magic that he knows. So for a time, Merlin pays her
regular visits. And the last time that he goes to visit, Nimue casts an enchantment upon him, and
following his sleep, he essentially ends up staying with her, and the world never sees him again. So
it's quite a nifty way to write him out of the stories. But this is the story point that we see
in the painting. Nimue has just put him to sleep, and Berthelot points out that in the Lancelot
story, Merlin actually arrives at the lady's manor with the intention of deflowering her,
and he's already seduced other women with promises of teaching them magic. So in this version,
Nimue's use of magic to basically neutralise Merlin is kind of justified. But here we also
see elements of Berne-Jones's own ambivalence to women. Joseph Kessner notes that Berne-Jones had a
tendency towards seeing women as either the saving soul or the bewitching enchantress. Nimue is cast
as the latter, portrayed as a deceitful woman. And Berne-Jones's own wife, Georgiana, even
admitted that her own brother had described Berne-Jones as a misogynist. Now such an attitude
didn't prevent him from having an affair with one of his models in 1868, and at this point,
the model Maria Zimbarko actually threatened to drink laudanum and drown herself over the affair.
Now we actually see Zimbarko again and again playing various characters from mythology and
fairy tales in Berne-Jones's work. And in The Beguiling of Merlin, Zimbarko plays the temptress
while casting Merlin as the innocent victim. And only those really familiar with the legends in
their entirety would know that there's a little bit more to the story than this quite binary way
of looking at it. So we're going to move on to the Wheel of Fortune from 1875 to 1883. And this is an
absolutely fabulous painting in my view, but it doesn't depict a specific moment within a myth,
but rather a popular concept. And that's the idea of Fortuna and her wheel. Now we did do an episode
on Fortuna many, many moons ago, so I'll put a link to that below. But essentially,
she represents the vagaries of fate. So in many ways, the concept actually warns against hubris,
because what goes up must come down, as it were. And obviously, the same works in reverse. So here,
the painting shows people raised up or cast down depending on the turning of the wheel.
And Fortuna herself oversees the turning of this wheel. Now the central male figure who's
marking him as a king, while another man stands on his shoulder, while the king stands on the
shoulder of a poet wearing a laurel wreath. So it is sort of a little bit difficult to tell if
they're being raised up or put down, though the desperate gaze of the poet at Fortuna's feet would
imply he wants to be raised up. Now the central point was that it didn't matter if you were a
king or a commoner, Fortuna still held your fate in her hands. But notice Fortuna's expression in
this painting. She doesn't take any delight in what she's doing, but nor does she express any
malice about it either. So if anything, she's the epitome of an indifferent and distant goddess.
Nothing that she's doing is personal. None of it is intended as a slight against or a favour for
a specific individual. It's literally just chance. And Burne-Jones himself even commented that,
and I quote, my wheel of fortune is a true to life image. It comes to fetch each of us in turn,
then it crushes us, end quote. He sounds like he was a really cheerful guy.
Now Burne-Jones actually took his inspiration for the male figures from the Sistine Chapel,
while he took ideas of Fortuna's drapery from Botticelli. Now we're going to move on to our
penultimate painting, so we've got slightly fewer in this one, and this is the Rose Bower from 1890.
Now this was part of a commission to illustrate the legend of Briar Rose across four panels for
Buscut Park in Oxfordshire. And instead of depicting different scenes to tell the story,
as we would be used to, instead he's chosen to use four different paintings that all capture
the same moment in time, albeit from different locations. So this is the point in the Sleeping
Beauty story at which the court has all fallen asleep and the rapid growth of the Briar Rose
has overtaken the castle and Sleeping Beauty is now asleep. The first panel shows the sleeping
soldiers amid the thorns. The second panel is the council chamber. The third shows weavers
asleep at their task in the garden court. And then the final panel, which is this one,
depicts Sleeping Beauty on her bed. Now the title of the series comes from the Brothers Grimm tale,
published in 1812, and each painting features a four-line verse on the frame, which was composed
by William Morris. Now Charles Perrault first told the tale in the 17th century, calling it
La Belle au Bois d'Aumente, and that just translates as Tale of the Sleeping Beauty.
Now this is not the original, original version, in which the prince actually violates the princess
while she's asleep, which leaves her pregnant. And then it's the suckling motion of one of her
babies, because she gives birth to twins in her sleep, that dislodges a splinter in her finger
and wakes her up. And I can't think why Disney didn't adapt that one. But anyway, Burne-Jones
had actually visited the Sleeping Beauty story before, both for some tile designs in 1864
and a painting in 1869. And the prince entering the Briarwood, which is the one from 1869,
captures the moment that the prince finds the earlier knights asleep among the thorns.
Now obviously it does rely on prior knowledge of the story for the painting to make sense.
But in the four-part panel series, we take our cues from the title of the series.
And Burne-Jones chose the scene of the sleeping princess as the final panel for a reason,
so we don't actually get to see her woken up. Because he wanted people to invent their own
version of what came next. So would the knight reach the princess? Would he be able to wake her
up? The ending of the story is left entirely to the viewer. Now it is obviously ideal fodder for
a Pre-Raphaelite artist, because it involves chivalrous knights, a damsel in distress,
and a certain dreamlike quality to the entire story. And remember, the Pre-Raphaelites sought
to recapture what they saw as a lost spiritual quality to the medieval age. And fairy tales
offered the ideal source material, even though many artists chose instead to depict figures
from mythology or poetry. Now in this case, Burne-Jones captures his perfect woman in the
Sleeping Beauty as a beautiful damsel awaiting rescue, rather than the wicked temptresses that
we see elsewhere. Now we're going to move on to the final painting of this episode,
which is The Last Sleep of Arthur and Avalon. This was actually painted between 1881 and 1898,
so he was actually working on this one when he died. Now I've put this one in after The
Rosebower, even though The Rosebower was finished first, purely because it feels like the right place
to end, because like I say, he was working on this painting when he died. And we've basically come all
the way back round to King Arthur for one of his most famous paintings, and this is the work that
most consumed his life. It's a huge painting, over six metres wide, and it was originally commissioned
for the library of Neyworth Castle, and his patron George Howard also liked the Arthurian legends,
but he left the topic to Burne-Jones. Now the story behind this painting comes from Le Morte
d'Arthur from 1470 by Thomas Mallory, and in it King Arthur mounts this big battle against Mordred,
except he suffers a fatal wound and he's taken to Avalon. Here he lies in a deep slumber until
he's called back to the world, and his head rests in the lap of Morgan le Fay. Now in many ways,
the painting is more about death than sleep or resurrection, and the fin de siècle raged around
Burne-Jones as he worked on it, and essentially what happened was the reverence that the mid-Victorians
had for Arthur had long since faded, and Burne-Jones had his own stuff going on because he had other
members of the pre-Raphaelite brotherhood had died. He did manage to reconcile with Morris,
with whom he had actually fallen out with earlier, but there is a sense of sort of broken bonds and
time passing and things being ruined really, and I think that the world that Burne-Jones knew when
he started out as an artist had changed so much and Burne-Jones was just completely impervious
to changing with it. When he began the painting, the Victorians loved the Arthurian stories of
chivalry, and the notion of a sleeping Arthur waiting until he's called back to the world
really captured their imagination, and we did cover this way back when in the King in the Mountain
episode as well. A very, very common story trope, and indeed Burne-Jones and Morris actually bonded
over their mutual love of Lamorte d'Arthur when they were at university, and they saw the medieval
age as superior to the materialism of the Victorian period. Although, side note, remember
that Burne-Jones did go on to accept a knighthood, but you know, never mind. But the problem was
Burne-Jones really overly identified with Arthur, to the point that in 1885, just four years after
he'd started, he asked Howard if he could revise the commission and Burne-Jones ended up creating
a smaller painting for Howard instead, and then continued with The Last Sleep of Arthur and Avalon
on his own. Many described him as being obsessive about the work, and as far as he could, he withdrew
from public life, preferring instead to work on the painting, and as W. J. Constable puts it,
and I quote, more than any of the major figures among the pre-Raphaelites and their successors,
he found in his art a means of escape, a way to withdraw into a hortus inclusus where the
artist alone could dwell, remote from the horrors bred by the industrial revolution, end quote,
and essentially, the painting had become Burne-Jones's attempt to find Avalon in a very
real sense. So, what do we make of Edward Burne-Jones? Well, it is clear that he had a genuine fascination
for the Arthurian legends, and he does put his own spin on them, but in doing so, he is actually just
entering into a long tradition of writers creating new versions. So, Arthur and his court first
appeared in Welsh stories before the 11th century, and then Geoffrey of Monmouth, Historia Regum
turned up in the 12th century, which expanded the tales to turn Arthur into a world conqueror.
By the late 12th century, Chretien de Troyes had turned the legends into romances, adding the
grail and the love affair between Lancelot and Guinevere. Later cycles would add the sword and
the stone, before Lamorte d'Arthur appeared and essentially tied everything up. So, basically,
Burne-Jones's different takes on the legend is ultimately nothing new, and it is indeed something
familiar to us because, I mean, how many versions of Merlin-related things have there actually been?
Now, Burne-Jones essentially turned to fairy tales, legends and myths because it's what people
commissioned him to do. You don't often see him just exhibiting and selling them from exhibitions
like you do with De Morgan. Instead, Burne-Jones painted because people asked him to. But he does
seem to still infuse his paintings with his own views on gender, particularly his dim view of
women. So, where Waterhouse and De Morgan use them as central characters, Burne-Jones casts them in
relation to those around them. And whether you're a goddess, a fairy or a sleeping beauty, you really
only have two options of femininity. So, on one hand, you can be disinterested, seductive or
deceitful, or on the other hand, you can be virtuous, obedient or Madonna-like. So, you're
not really given a huge amount of choice. Now, true, many of the myths and legends are themselves
incredibly rigid in terms of gender depictions, but Burne-Jones never seemed to grasp that people
are never so simple and binary thinking really does leave you ultimately satisfied because it
creates no room for nuance or any kind of new ideas to come forward. And to be fair, it's a wonder
that he ever managed to capture such gorgeous colours when he had such a black and white view
of the world. So, what I want to know is, what do you think of the work of Edward Burne-Jones? Obviously,
you can tell me what you think of the man as well if you want. Again, as always, you can post comments
on the blog post or the YouTube video, depending on how you're encountering this. You can tweet me,
Instagram me, whatever. All the links are below, as always. I hope you enjoyed that. I'm actually
not a huge fan of Burne-Jones' work to start with because it always just feels a little bit like
someone's doing almost a parody of the Pre-Raphaelites, if that makes sense. I mean,
there's one of his paintings in the Lang Art Gallery in Newcastle and it's nice enough, but
it's nowhere near the quality of a Holman Hunt or something like that, but maybe that's just me.
I don't know. We are going to do Rebecca Solomon next week because I thought it would be quite nice
to have a nice even balance between male and female artists. And as I say, then the week after,
we will have a look at folklore and legends associated with Lammas and Lunasat, so I hope
you hang around for those as well. We will be going back to more traditional folklore-y type
things in August, so if you're not really that bothered about art, stick around. We are kind of
going back to that sort of stuff as well. I hope you have a marvellous week ahead and I would like
to point out as well that if you are listening before the 24th and 25th of July, we are doing
the next Rural Gothic event, which is all around cults and so on. So if you want to find any details
about that rather than me kind of yell them at you now, you can find the link to buy tickets and also
find out what we're going to be covering across the two days in the show notes below. If you are
listening to this after the 24th and 25th of July, don't worry, you'll still be able to buy the replays
and still enjoy everything as well. So without any further ado, I will let you crack on with
whatever else it is that you've got planned for your day and I will see you next week when we have
a look at Marianne Stokes for our final Folklore in Art episode. Cheerio! Well, thank you for
listening and thanks for visiting Fabulous Folklore. I hope you enjoyed your stay. If you did, why not
consider subscribing in your podcast app of choice. If you enjoy the show, why not leave me a review
and help other listeners to find it as well. And if you'd like bonus exclusive episodes of the
podcast, then why not support me on Patreon. It does help me to keep the show going and it means
that you get a little bit extra every month as well and you can find all of the necessary links
in the show notes below. So without any further ado, I will bid you adieu and I hope that you
have safe travels wherever you're going on to next.
