Risk assessment and fieldwork

Discovered in China
13 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 18, 2024
David Alexander has conducted research on disasters since 1980. His main foci of interest are emergency management and planning, earthquake science, disaster epidemiology, and theoretical issues in disaster risk reduction. He has also studied cascading disasters and disability and disaster.
Hello, now we're going to discuss some procedures associated with field work.
Field work is very necessary for many of the projects that we do
and it is a serious business. It does involve risks
and it does involve care with what one does to ensure that there aren't adverse
consequences with it. So field work is a serious business.
It is no joy ride but of course despite that it can be
great fun. So what are the risks in the field?
Well there are risks associated with sustaining injury
which of course could be fatal if you fall off a cliff or something
or run over by a bus or whatever. There may be a need for emergency medical
care if something happens associated with illness, infirmity or
injury. There can be conditions where the
situation locally is unstable and one suffers violence or threats
for example violent robbery or one is in a situation that's highly polarised and
simply dangerous from this point of view and one could get lost, marooned,
stranded or even kidnapped in some parts of the world.
For example where travel arrangements fail or
again where there are risks associated with the breakdown
of social order and that might involve a need for specialised health care or for
or even for being repatriated in some form.
Most of the time of course none of this really applies and
field work is pretty safe but you don't want to be in a situation where there
are these difficulties and where you're reliant on help especially if
it's likely to fail. So it's a good idea to look at the risks in the field and to
assess them in such a way that you are prepared
to reduce them and tackle them if there is
some likelihood of something happening. So it's worth reviewing your research
strategy, your field strategy to ensure that there is no likelihood or a
very low likelihood that you cause injury or offence to other people, for
example offence to people you are interviewing.
Injury I think is less likely if you are merely doing
questionnaire type surveys but if not then
for example if you hire a guide or something and you go into a dangerous
place and injury results then we would want to avoid that.
There are risks associated with eating unfamiliar food
in places where hygiene standards are low, gastric poisoning for example.
Risks associated with running out of money possibly because your wallet is
stolen or something like that. Risks of accidentally causing damage
for example by driving a vehicle off the road or something
and risks of trespass or incursion or being taken for a spy or goodness knows
what. Further risks being arrested or
imprisoned for something whether or not one
is actually culpable probably not but we've seen recently for example how in
the Middle East a researcher doing a simple and
harmless project was taken as a spy and subject to serious imprisonment if
not torture. So there is a risk that one could be
taken for someone who has done something wrong
and then incarcerated as a result or whatever happens
after that. There are some risks that one could
actually be part of a disaster for example studying in a seismically active
zone and then finding oneself in the midst of an earthquake
and that is the sort of risk that does occasionally materialize
it happened to me. Likewise with floods, eruptions
and transportation crashes. Well risks of that kind can't be completely
eliminated but they perhaps should be considered.
Also one needs to be careful about cultural transgressions
doing the wrong thing violating cultural norms
especially where you have rather conservative societies with
very strong cultural norms that you are expected
to observe. That is merely a question of awareness
and doing the right thing. Hopefully one is not going to contract a disease but
one should be careful where contagious and infectious diseases
are present that one has the right vaccinations and
one does the right thing regarding the possibility of infection.
So there you are in the field with kamikaze taxi drivers, unscrupulous
merchants trying to rip you off, rickety aircraft
floating around the sky, shaky travel agents where you're not sure whether
your means of transport is going to turn up or not,
diabolical weather and perhaps even a sudden unexpected coup d'etat or a
bombing or something. These are things that can happen. The
world is a remarkably unstable place so what you should do is try to manage
the risks associated with field work and there are forms that the university
would expect you to fill in if you're going somewhere exotic or
perhaps even if you're going somewhere well known
in order to be sure that you have taken the idea of risk management
seriously. So the first thing you could do is to think the risk
through in the place that I'm going to to do my field work
what happens, what are the risks. You can do some research
on what are the possible threats or risks
or hazards associated with the place in question.
So you can build scenarios what might happen to me as I go out into the field
and I do my work, what do I need to avoid and what do I
need to take care over and in so doing you can conduct a risk
assessment which is certainly what the form
requires of you and risk assessments for field work are now increasingly
the norm and you can perhaps rank and list
the risks and order them by likelihood and consequences
so that the high likelihood risks and those with the biggest consequences
take most of your attention. You can consider what has happened in the past
not necessarily to people doing field work but to
people in the area in question and don't forget to activate travel
insurance that will cover you adequately for example for work done as part of this
university there is an online form at the UCL
website for travel insurance that should be
activated every time and go somewhere where insurance is needed and if one is
overseas at least in some of the more exotic
places it's a good idea to register with one's consulate so that
consular officials know that one is there.
Right now when you have the list of things that might happen
then it is perhaps a good idea to use a risk matrix or something similar or at
least think it through in these terms is what may happen likely is it very
likely or not very likely at all and if it does happen are the
consequences likely to be negligible slight moderate or severe
and of course for anything with severe consequences or a high likelihood
then the best strategy to do the field work in safety
needs to be thought through. That brings us to field work ethics
it is important that when one goes to places with different cultural standards
and different practices and traditions that these be taken account of
and observed properly otherwise the result of that may simply
in the lightest cases be that one is looked at askance
and cooperation is withdrawn in the worst cases there may be legal
consequences resulting in arrest for having done something that is
regarded as culturally unacceptable particularly for example with respect to
clothing for example if you go to Iran as a
female then you cannot go around with your
head uncovered and in fact quite a few westerners arrive
at Tehran Khomeini airport and they forget this and they've packed
their headscarves in their hold baggage and they have to get off
the aircraft with one of the airline's blankets over
their head because they cannot pass customs until they are properly covered
so that is simply something that needs to be taken account of and there are of
course many other behavioral standards that
whether or not they are acceptable to you as a researcher if you want to get
your work done and you want to avoid trouble you have
to take them properly into account so you must ask yourself
what are the local standards of behavior and local customs that have to be
observed when one is there in the field for
example I spent some time doing research in the villages
of Viti level the main island of Fiji and some of the islands of the Lao group
and in that there are definite standards of behavior because
village Fijians are very formal and they're great lovers of ceremony
for example they do not drink alcohol although they do drink Yangona which is
the carver root it does have mildly soporific effects
but they drink lots and lots of it and it really isn't quite like alcohol
they have furniture but they don't sit on it they find it uncomfortable and
they find it much more comfortable to sit on the floor
but if you sit on the furniture whilst they are sitting on the floor then you
are putting yourselves above them which will be regarded as the height
of arrogance you don't uncover your knees if you have
a backpack you lower it as a sign of respect when you're in the village you
don't leave it on your back and you treat people according to their
rank with the chief of the village being of course the most important person to
be deferred to followed by the village holders now what
would happen if you are disrespectful well if you're extremely disrespectful
you might simply be run out of the village
if you're moderately disrespectful then people will be quite unpleasant to you
and they will be unhappy at your behaviour because of
its insensitivity if you are respectful and you show that
you understand the customs and the traditions then you can
get on extremely well and will find them tremendously hospitable
and of course for field work that is what you need
so then there are questions of ethical approval
of your work now if you're working simply from UCL
and you have for example a questionnaire then there are two routes to ethical
approval depending on the nature of the
questionnaire if the questionnaire is thoroughly
uncontroversial it does not involve intrusive questions and you are
questioning adults between the age of say 18 and 65
and when you've got the answers they will be treated anonymously
and moreover you give full information to the people being questioned
about their rights their right to withdraw from the
study for example and so on then you only need departmental level
approval which means going to the UCL Institute for Risk and Disaster
Reduction Research Ethics Committee who can grant approval on seeing the
questionnaire and associated documents if instead you are interviewing
for example vulnerable people we had a couple of years ago a student
who did a thesis on people sleeping rough in a
large city and that will be regarded as
questionnaire surveys of vulnerable people so she had to go through full
ethical approval which involves the UCL level ethics committee
looking at the form you've filled in and the questionnaire and any
necessary supporting document to verify that you have taken all procedures
correctly all precautions to ensure that you won't misuse data or give
offense so people with disabilities
elderly people who may have limited ability to limited cognitive ability
children and young people who are under the age of consent
and traumatized people and so on are all regarded as vulnerable
and if the results in some way do not guarantee
anonymity that also might be problematic and full ethical
approval is required now a lot of ethical approval is for the sort of
things we don't do in disaster research for example using stem cells
or taking samples from people's bodies of blood or
plasma or skin or whatever so we don't need to worry about some of those
technical aspects but we do need to consider when we're using questionnaire
research what's in the questionnaire and who are
the respondents so what questions are you asking if you
have a questionnaire is there any semblance of intimate personal
information there is there anything that could be used to
identify the interviewee that might get the interviewee into
trouble in some way have you fully anonymized the results
of the questionnaire so that when they fill in the form or answer your
questions verbally they cannot be identified from what
you've written down or recorded have you done the right thing regarding
this with respect to consent for example
they have been informed fully of their rights if you're making recordings of a
conversation that they have given their full consent
for the conversation to be recorded and so on and in short anything
that might upset the person being interviewed
has to be thought through and dealt with before
the data collection campaign starts so you wouldn't wish to put interviewees
at risk and above all we wouldn't wish to see
a reprisal from interviewees who would argue perhaps with legal threats
that what you've done is in some way wrong or has caused harm or damage
so we trust that most questionnaire surveys will be entirely harmless they
will produce good and useful results without having to
cause any problems for those who've contributed to
the work so you certainly won't be asking questions like excuse me are you
the member of the local mafia or have you ever murdered someone
and essentially then when you do your research
and also above all when you plan it do so with prudence care and foresight
