Warning For AirBnb's | Data Point Just Flipped

Money Mansions
1 follower
#Business
This is a Data centric Analytical approach to the Nashville Tn Housing Market. We look at trends in active listings, median price, mortgage rates, contracts, rent rates
Airbnb just took a turn for the worse.
If you were thinking about buying or selling an Airbnb,
you're gonna wanna watch this
because in Tennessee,
where demand has been going up and up and up,
Airbnb owners have been struggling
mainly because of supply.
What I have now is something on the demand side.
This is a comparison of inventory from 2019.
In other words, if it's green,
the green areas are counties
that have more inventory than 2019.
Now, if you can see,
the brightest green counties are Sevier,
that's Gallenburg,
Davidson, okay, that's the core of Nashville,
and Shelby, that's Memphis.
Now, what's interesting about all three of these,
they're the three largest markets for hotels and Airbnbs.
So when I posted this chart the other day,
look at Nashville, let's go back to this chart.
Okay, if we look at Nashville's active listings,
473 in February of 2022.
This was the lowest active listing reading on record ever,
lowest active listing reading.
So it doesn't surprise me that you can look
at the Airbnb listings right here
and see that we also had almost a non-existent,
non-owner occupied Airbnbs for sale, and we did.
And now all of a sudden it's exploded.
Now, why has it exploded?
Well, this has primarily been a supply story thus far.
Let me show you, we're gonna get to some crazy,
crazy demand information.
You're gonna love this.
It's not AirDNA, by the way.
I'm not even gonna use AirDNA.
Look at this right here, okay?
So this right here was in March of 2022.
I was just up here a couple months ago.
I wish I would have taken a video of it.
It's unbelievable, okay?
But this was in March of 22.
Let's see what it's like today, okay?
Today, look, all of these are non-owner occupied Airbnbs.
Everywhere you look, you can go down.
There's just row after row after row after row.
They're all the same thing.
There are these cookie cutter, four bed.
I think there are three bath.
Let's do it here too, look.
Okay, this is what it looked like March 22, nothing.
All right, now we see, boom,
just row after row of non-owner occupied Airbnbs.
That's what these are.
Okay, so supply has exploded.
Now, why is that crazy?
Because so far, this whole story has been a supply issue.
The people selling their Airbnbs now
are frustrated because of supply.
And believe me, a lot of their income has dropped, okay?
So it's dropped because of supply, not because of demand.
In fact, I had a conversation with someone who owns
just in this area on a podcast the other day.
I'll play the clip here, and you can hear him
say with his own words, his net income dropped
to a third of what it was in 22 and 23.
How's the Airbnb, can I ask about that?
Yeah, it's down, yeah.
So we've got 17 Airbnbs.
The rents are down, and it sucks
because we made, I think our net profit last year
was 300 grand probably on the entire portfolio,
and I bet we'll make 120 this year.
No, are you serious?
Yeah, net profit.
Do you have any of them that are more profitable,
or are all 17 down?
We have two sets that are really close to downtown
that are, we have one set on 2nd Avenue
where you can just take an Uber straight in
to the good part of 2nd Avenue.
We're in Chestnut Hill on those.
And then we have two in Elizabeth Park,
so you can throw a stone and hit downtown basically.
And those are doing the same as they've always done.
It's wild that it went to 100,000 in income,
but again, it's because of supply,
until, where'd it go, this right here.
What I present to you is Exhibit A.
This is Tennessee hotel tax revenue over time.
You can see this.
When COVID happened, March of 2020,
what happened to occupancy tax?
It tanked.
Of course it tanked.
Nobody could do anything.
Okay, it dropped to 176 million.
Somehow they still got some revenue in 2020 to 2021.
I guess they're, you know, some, I don't know, who knows.
Okay, and then it skyrocketed.
Now, on top of this skyrocketing,
in, I want to say 2022 at some point,
they did raise taxes.
And so some of this can be distorted
by local occupancy increases in taxes.
Okay, so the increase is a combo of actual demand increasing
and increased in taxes, which makes what just happened,
what just happened in the latest tax report for Tennessee.
Now, I know this looks small,
but you got to understand this is an annualized number.
I'm adding up the last 12 months
and just plotting them over and over and over.
So we went from 475 to 469.
That's a $5 million drop in hotel tax revenue
in one month, in one month.
And what I can see from the reporting itself
is not only are we down almost 10%,
but now the fiscal year is down 4% for the year,
in fiscal year 2025 for revenue.
Now, this is a massive, massive problem,
but let's go to this.
When we peel the onion back,
we can see that Davidson County
is actually still increasing
in their local occupancy tax collected.
Okay, so they're still increasing, but barely.
The other big markets, which is Sevier, look at Sevier.
Sevier actually peaked in April of this year,
and they kind of nosedived in August.
They went from 15.4 million annual.
Now they're down to 15.2.
So they're starting down.
This could be an inflection, guys.
This could be an inflection point.
We're starting to see the same in Shelby.
Shelby, believe it or not, is number three,
the third largest county in Shelby.
And here in Shelby, Shelby actually peaked
in December of 23.
They're down almost 50,000.
Now, keep in mind, guys,
what we are seeing is two out of the three,
largest hotel tax revenue counties are dropping,
and we have not seen this in Davidson County yet.
So as of yet, Davidson County is still increasing
in hotel occupancy.
Now that could be that people are choosing hotel rooms more,
or it could be there's so many.
There are so many.
It's just unbelievable.
Right now, it's all supply, guys.
If you are having trouble,
it's because they're cookie-cutter supply.
What is working, though, in Sevierville and Gallenburg
and in Nashville are unique, high-quality,
and great locations.
You've got to have good locations for Airbnb,
short-term rental, okay?
Now, I have my McFerrin listing.
It has $50,000 in annual income that it's been getting
for the past three years, and it's not stopped.
They're on track to get $50,000.
This is exactly what Brandon was saying.
We have two sets that are really close to downtown,
so you can throw a stone and hit downtown, basically,
and those are doing the same as they've always done.
So it makes sense that the McFerrin listing
would do so well in Airbnb,
but because it's a unique, boutique, one-bedroom hotel
where you can get a bedroom, a full kitchen,
a full bathroom, it's 800 square feet,
it's going to beat hotels any day of the week.
Now, I did have a comment.
They said, you cannot bank on that revenue,
and at first, I was like, yeah, you know,
they make a good point, you gotta be conservative,
but then I thought, well, you know what?
Actually, you can see,
because this is always gonna have demand.
The location is A+.
There's always gonna have demand for that,
so if you wanted to do a worst-case scenario,
you'd have to go back to 2008.
Let's go back to 2008.
What happened in 2008?
Well, what we can see from 2008 is that in 2008,
we actually peaked.
We peaked at $160 million in revenue for 2008.
Okay, that was actually the peak, all right?
What happened after that is that by 2010,
we troughed, and we troughed at 137, okay?
Now, the reason I bring this up
is because if you have a good Airbnb in a good location,
the fact is is that modeling what happened in 2008
is a perfect way to do it,
which is a 15% drop in revenue over two years,
and then it starts going back up.
I think that's worst-case scenario.
Now, tell me if I'm wrong.
You guys disagree with me if I'm wrong,
but the bottom line is we are seeing an inflection point.
It's starting in Gatlinburg and in Memphis,
but it's hard not to wonder,
is it going to spread to Davidson?
It does not look like Davidson
is slowing down at this point, okay?
The answer is Davidson still has demand,
but Tennessee revenues are starting to drop.
Now, in Davidson, it's so highly competitive.
You do not want a cookie-cutter Airbnb.
Don't go cookie-cutter if you're gonna go Airbnb
in Nashville.
Find a creative, narrative,
something that's flying under the radar,
something like a one-bed, one-bath,
and a high-demand area
where hotels aren't gonna be built there
because your houses are there.
You've got a unique boutique, one-bedroom hotel,
but if you go for these four beds,
unfortunately, and I feel bad
because I've talked to some developers
that have developed these.
I've actually talked to multiple developers
who've developed these.
It's not working out,
and so you have to go to the next best case.
I mean, I talked to some on 12 South.
I've talked to some in the nations.
I've talked to some up here.
I've talked to multiple up here
where I'm showing you these off a weekly.
The cookie-cutters aren't working.
That's what this is showing, okay?
And believe me, this isn't even the canceled listings.
This isn't even the LLCs
that are trying to trade off of the MLS.
This could be an inflection point.
If the demand is inflecting,
we're in for an interesting next 12 months.
Now, think about this.
We've got September and October
that have been impacted by Helene.
A lot of Gallenberg was not impacted,
but we could see some impacts from Helene,
both people needing a place to stay, higher occupancy,
and people who lost their ability
to make revenue on their house, lower occupancy.
So it's really uncertain how it's going to play out.
We're gonna keep an eye on it,
but what we could be witnessing
is an inflection point in travel demand,
and if that's the case, buckle up.
So far, it's just been a supply story.
Thanks for watching.
