Take Fed's dot plot ‘with a grain of salt’: Strategist

Financial Action Task
1 follower
3 Video Views·Oct 12, 2024
Welcome to Stocks in Translation.
I'm Jared Blickrey, hosting alongside
the voice of the people, Sidney Freed.
Thank you for tuning in.
And a few housekeeping notes.
Be sure to like, subscribe, and comment
on Stocks in Translation on Spotify, Apple Music,
YouTube, wherever you get the podcast.
Very special introduction today for Kevin Mond.
He is the President and Chief Investment Officer
at Hennion & Walsh.
And Kevin, you were one of the first guests
I booked as a producer way back in the day
at Yahoo Finance 2015.
Midday movers, you guys might remember
the best 15 minutes on television.
Just a couple years ago, I was only 12 at the time.
Yes, you were doing, you were quite,
you were quite prodigious.
Today we're gonna be talking about
a bunch of different things.
The Fed, and that leads to our phrase of the day,
which is dot plot.
And we're gonna take a peek at the Fed meetings
and their drama.
This episode is brought to you by the number seven.
That is the number of industry groups,
besides semiconductors,
that have returned over 20% this year.
So that means that the rally has broadened
and we're gonna tell you guys who is buying
for that number two spot.
Before we really get in,
we'd like to get your overview of the markets right now.
We've got stocks relatively high, some at record highs,
but there's always fears, worries, doubts.
Fed is easing, though.
How are you talking to your clients about this?
Well, as a portfolio manager,
I would start by saying the short-term outlook,
at least for me, is cloudy.
But the longer-term outlook becomes much clearer.
And there's a couple statistics
that allowed me to have that optimism
that I'd look a little bit further.
Historically, the Fed has cut interest rates
12 different times when the market was at
or near record highs, just as they are right now.
And Jared, in all 12 cases,
the market was higher 12 months out by an average of 14%.
We also know that going back to 1946,
there have been 12 bull markets.
The average length of those bull markets is about 5.3 years,
with an average cumulative return of 180%.
The current bull market is only two years old,
with a return of about 64 and a half percent.
So if history serves as a guide,
and of course this time could be different,
but we have at least two more years of this bull market
to hit historic averages,
which ties in nicely with that Fed's two-year outlook
for cutting interest rates.
Yeah, two years here.
My issue with the one year, you know,
we look back to 2007,
that's one of the big ones in the example.
All right, so the market peaked in October
or something of 2007, and then a year later,
it was still doing pretty well,
but the stuff had not really hit fully the fan yet.
So when you look two years out, you know,
we had a big decline.
I think market finally bottomed in March of 2009,
so it took a while for all that negativity to kick in.
Any worries that it happened this time?
I mean, my biggest worry is that the Fed arrived
too late to the party once again,
and by definition, the Fed will always be late to the party
because they're data dependent,
and the data they're looking at is backward looking.
The question just becomes, how late to the party are they,
and how much damage was done to the economy
by keeping short-term interest rates
at five and a quarter percent for as long as they did?
Now they got a 50 basis point rate cut, that's good.
They acknowledged that they were late to the party,
but what about looking forward?
A lot of people aren't talking about it,
but they also increased their forecast for unemployment
to end this year at 4.4%,
and they lowered their forecast for real economic growth,
GDP growth, just 2%.
This is perfect because our phrase of the day is dot plot,
and this kind of gets back to,
let's just define it here.
I'll do that.
It's gonna take a couple minutes, so bear with me,
but the dot plot is a chart used by the Federal Reserve
to show each member's projection for future interest rate.
19 of these members total,
consisting of seven Federal Reserve System governors
for the entire Federal Reserve System,
and then 12 regional Federal Reserve Bank presidents.
So not every fed regional bank president
votes on every monetary policy in each meeting,
but they do get their voice heard through these,
they're called this SEPs, Statement of Economic Projection.
So just your first blush thoughts about the dot plots.
Are they useful to you?
Take them with a grain of salt.
They change as much as the forecast for the weather does.
As we saw coming into this year,
the Federal Reserve coming into this year
was forecasting a total of 225 basis points in rate cuts
by the end of 2026.
Oh, so that's even more, yeah?
That was even more, three this year.
In June, they took away two of those
and pushed them out to 2526.
Now in September, they not only cut by 50 basis points,
but they brought back another two cuts.
So what it tells me is that the path forward
for interest rates is lower.
The total amount of rate cuts,
the increments that they do them within,
is anybody's guess.
Nobody has a crystal ball.
Chair Powell doesn't have a crystal ball.
Well, he's very careful to say,
he almost says himself, take these with a grain of salt.
These are not predictions,
these are just projections by individuals
that happen to be aggregated.
I guess it comes back to the question,
has the Federal Reserve gone overboard on communication?
They had a big powwow a few years ago
around the pandemic time, coincidentally,
and they said, yeah, we're gonna dial some things back,
but has it been enough?
Over-transparency has led to a great deal of confusion.
Because now the market tries to parse
between everything Chair Powell says or doesn't say
in each one of his press conferences.
Remember, they only update that dot plot chart
in their summary of economic projections four times a year.
All those other meetings,
they just announce what their actions are or not.
So we only really get to hear from them four times a year.
So we're left guessing and speculating
in between each one of those meetings
and parsing all their words.
And then, of course, he comes out
like he's the coach of the New York Jets
at the end of the game
and has to deliver a press conference
and account for why they did or didn't do something,
or account for why Aaron Rodgers
threw three interceptions yesterday and the Jets lost.
I just wanna hear Powell say,
we gotta get back to fundamentals here.
The dot plot is only like a decade or so old, right?
One or two decades old.
So what was life like before we had the dot plot?
Tell us, Kevin.
Yes.
And I've been on Wall Street for 32 years, so I remember.
Prior to that, it was really bed chair people
such as Alan Greenspan coming out
and telling us what their thoughts
and projections were for the market,
serving as the one single voice beat
for all of those voting members.
The one thing to remember about this dot plot chart, though,
as Jared pointed out,
each dot represents a different view of that voting member
for where they believe interest rates
are gonna be this year and the next two years.
But if you look at the dot plot chart,
there's no unanimity there.
In fact, the dispersion between those thoughts
and those forecasts are quite different.
So for all of those economists
and all of those investors who rely upon the dot plot chart,
take it with a grain of salt.
It's a good tool,
but you shouldn't be making investment decisions
on that basis.
Why are the dots, they're anonymous, right?
But then you hear that official speaking.
People try to match them up
and it's this big game that people play.
Right, but what's the point of them
being anonymous at that point?
Well, that's a deep philosophical question.
Yeah, I don't know.
Transferred to a degree.
Average Joe here, just asking a question.
Well, you know what's funny is,
way back in the day,
this was before I was covering markets,
and you go back to the 80s, but maybe even 92,
you didn't get a Fed announcement on the day.
You had to look at the money supply statistics
the following week to infer what the Fed was doing.
Were they cutting rates?
They didn't tell you.
You had to infer that.
So now we get transcripts on a six-year delay.
They had none of that.
But I guess to the point
that maybe they've gone a little bit overboard.
Overboard, yeah.
Can I ask, as a portfolio manager,
what do you tell clients about the Fed
when it comes to their profile?
Their portfolio, sorry, profile.
I tend to remind clients that we'll do the job for you
with trying to parse between
what the Federal Reserve is telling the market.
And the Federal Reserve still only has two mandates
that I'm aware of unless they've changed their own bylaws,
and that's to promote full employment
and maintain price stability.
So control inflation and keep unemployment
somewhere between 3 1⁄2 to 4%,
depending upon who's definitely used.
Everything beyond that isn't within their control.
And everything that they do,
whether it's use their balance sheet
or cut short-term interest rates,
is to help achieve those two mandates.
So let us actually review what they're telling us
and we'll adjust your portfolios accordingly.
It's too confusing for experienced professionals
to understand and parse through the Fed statements,
much less an individual investor.
What about, do you ever look at the Fed
in relation to the rest of the world,
especially with respect to currency?
Because currencies are just relative to each other.
And where I'm kind of going with this
is that a lot of the differences
between interest rates are expressed in currencies.
And we've just seen the dollar
kind of screaming higher last week.
It's a short-term move, but it's significant.
When I see the dollar screaming higher like that,
I think, well, what's going on?
Because if the Fed is cutting, you would think,
well, if they're truly leading the way,
you'd see the dollar go down.
Is this risk aversion?
What are we seeing?
The outlook for the Fed being as aggressive as they were
with that first rate cut the second time around
has decreased significantly
following last week's job report.
In fact, the tenure right now
is hovering back at 4% again.
That's above 4% today.
Yeah, and we're barely out of inversion territory
because the two years at 3.9.9, once again.
Conversion was inverted for two years,
almost a record long time, and now it's not.
One more question on Fed transparency.
We get all these speeches by Fed officials,
and a lot of times they cluster,
and a lot of times they just contradict each other.
And that's been the case
as long as I've been following this stuff,
which probably goes back 20 years or so to 2004, 2005.
But has it always been that way
where you just see the Fed official
kind of tripping over each other's comment?
Is it useful?
I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing.
We do want them to be independent.
We want them to express their own viewpoints and opinions.
We don't want them all just marching to the same drumbeat
if, in fact, they don't agree with that drumbeat.
So I'm not necessarily opposed to them
expressing their differing opinions,
but to a portfolio manager,
it's very difficult for me to get a feel
for what's going to happen next
if they can't even agree with one another.
And the dot plot is just another sign
of how much they tend to disagree every single quarter.
Well said.
Oh, you have a question?
I was going to say,
do we put a little too much emphasis
on 25 basis points, 50 basis points?
From here on out, it's a rate-cutting cycle, right?
If you don't really understand this so much,
what do you say to people who are like,
does it matter how much?
All I would say is that I pull up the dot plot chart
and sit down with individual investors,
and I explain to them,
and these are 17 to 19 different voting members,
and these are all their opinion
of where interest rates are going to be.
You see how different they are?
But also look at it.
One thing that we can all agree on
is the path forward is down.
And if interest rates are going to come down
over the next few years,
as the Fed is telling us they're going to,
if yields are lower and inflation continues to moderate,
those are pretty strong tailwinds for both stocks.
So let's focus more on the longer term
and less on the shorter term.
Very good.
We need to take a short break here to hold that thought.
Coming up, we're going to be talking runners up
in the AI trade, and we've got quite a few.
Plus, for all you quant lovers,
we've got a discussion for you on factoring
that you will not want to miss.
All right, we are back,
and this episode is brought to you by the number seven.
That is how many industry groups
have returned over 20% this year after chip stocks,
which are actually number one at 70%.
So just as a reminder,
when we classify stocks at the very top level,
we have sectors.
Below that, we have industry groups,
and then just industries.
So let me just tell everybody what these runners up are.
In media and entertainment, so far in 2024,
they're up 30%.
Utilities up 27%.
Insurance, 26%.
Food and staples, stuff people need, 26%.
Telecom, 24.
Capital goods, like heavy equipment, 24%.
And banks, they're just under 20%, but they round up.
So a lot of typically boring stuff
as far as investors are concerned.
Utilities, which is now an AI trade.
Insurance, food and staples, telecom.
But this stuff is flying.
What's going on?
Utilities really are a backdoor play in the AI revolution.
We know these data centers require tremendous amounts
of electricity to power all these intensive algorithms,
whether it's electricity-based,
whether it's natural gas-based,
or what we're finding as of late, nuclear power.
And all of these data centers
can't manufacture their own power.
They have to turn to the utilities of the states
that they operate within.
So not only do utilities pay,
generally, attractive dividend yields,
not only are they generally more defensive in nature,
but now they're a backdoor play into the AI revolution.
Investors realize that.
You see more and more flows going into utilities.
But just be careful,
because some of those utilities are now priced
pretty expensive versus the market as a whole.
I'm interested in these individual things,
but I have to ask,
who comes up with sectors versus industry groups
versus industry groups?
It's a very dark, remote room somewhere.
Basel, Switzerland, I'm pretty sure.
Also, isn't utilities a sector, technically?
A utility is a sector.
And an industry, in an industry group?
So, yes.
Both?
So, when you look at the broad categories,
yes, utilities is a sector.
I was pulling this up on a terminal somewhere.
I'm gonna leave the name unknown,
but that's what it's spelled out.
So who comes up with this stuff?
All right, so we have several classifications.
Bloomberg has one.
There's one called GICS,
which is General, well, I don't even want to.
Industry Classification.
There you go.
This sounds like a job for me, honestly.
Yes, Global Industry Classification Standard.
So, I think we generally use GICS
because it's kind of the standard.
But, yeah, it's just a few people who decide this stuff.
And there's a lot of wiggle room.
Like, telecom, you now see in this category,
you see it's Communication Services,
Alphabet, Netflix, Verizon all together.
So it doesn't make a whole lot of sense,
but you gotta start somewhere.
So that's what we're dealing with.
What are you telling clients?
I will get to these other sectors
because I know the rally is broadening out,
but what are you telling clients
about investing in AI right now?
So I'm reminding clients that investing in AI is a long game.
If I could draw the analogy to baseball,
I would suggest that we're in batting practice
of a double header.
That's how long the runway is here.
And there's gonna be more companies that fail
than succeed as they try and align themselves with AI,
whether they're an enabler or adopter of AI.
So you need to be patient
and you need to look past the headlines.
I often get asked the question across the country,
can you find me the next NVIDIA?
And I think that's doing a disservice to the whole team
because that's one stock,
that's a semiconductor and chip.
And that's not the only investment opportunity
that exists within the AI ecosystem.
I could argue right now that data centers
are in fact an even more critical component
to that ecosystem
and offer even more attractive investment opportunities.
So build a diversified portfolio,
so don't just look for the one home run.
And are you telling people to get into utilities
as a backdoor play?
Absolutely, absolutely.
And capital goods.
So we're talking heavy equipment here,
but some of that ties into materials and infrastructure.
It looks like there are a lot of related plays.
Any one that you think might be lagging
or maybe a better opportunity
on a short to medium term basis?
The one area that I like right now,
we know that these data centers run hot.
They draw a lot of electricity, right?
So they need tremendous amount of cooling.
We found a company called Vertiv not so long ago.
No one ever heard of Vertiv.
They're in the industrial sector.
Who would think an industrial company
has anything to do with AI?
What do they do?
They supply the electricity, the infrastructure,
and the cooling solution to data centers.
And then within SmartTrust,
we found two other companies that are similar.
Modine Manufacturing and a company called Comfort Systems.
These are companies that align with the data centers,
nothing to do with AI,
but the data centers need them to run.
It's an interesting investment opportunity.
You have to peel back the onion
and you'll find a lot more areas to invest in.
How do you approach investing broadly,
choosing between stocks, choosing between ETFs
or alternative assets?
Crypto.
What's a little thesis here?
I don't invest in crypto.
I still don't understand it.
And I'll never put my client's money
into something where I can explain to them
why it moved up or down in a given day
beyond just supply and demand, right?
So what we try and do with each one of our clients
is build a portfolio that's consistent
with their goals and objectives.
Is it income?
Is it growth?
Is it combination for each?
What's their investment timeframe?
In other words, how much are they gonna be investing
this pool of money for?
And what's their risk tolerance?
We always remind investors,
don't just change your risk tolerance.
Don't get more aggressive when the market's going up
just as much as you shouldn't get less aggressive
when the market is going down.
There was a great study done
by a University of Michigan professors.
And for anyone who's listening,
I don't know if you like Michigan, Ohio State,
I'm staying out of that whole debate.
But he looked at 30 years of stock market returns.
And what he found was that over those 30 years,
95% of the return of the S&P 500
took place in just 1% of their trading days.
Now, I don't know when those 1% of their trading days
are gonna be.
You know, you get the big 5% days
or after the big 5% down days.
That's when they occur.
You need to stay invested.
Here, we gotta get to who were better.
And this is one of my favorite segments on the show.
So we're just gonna dive into it.
Quant factors.
This is something that we're gonna have to define.
So I'm gonna do this very briefly,
then we can get into the discussion.
Quant factors are measurable financial metrics
used by quantitative investors to evaluate stocks
to improve portfolio performance and reduce risk
through systematic analysis.
Hope that's clear.
I got it, I got it.
I just don't love the word quant for all you listeners.
It's just math.
So basically, we're breaking down the markets
into math terms and we're figuring out
what kind of styles are doing better.
So there are many factors.
I'm gonna give you just a few.
Value, as in over value, under value.
Growth, as in strong earnings potential.
Momentum, is it moving?
How fast?
Size, we got large cap, small cap, mid, micro.
Volatility, what is the trading range?
What is the projected trading range?
Liquidity, does the stock have the volume
that you need to get in and out easily?
And then dividends, are you getting paid to own it?
So Kevin, the question for you is,
among all these and any other one,
you just pick whatever you think.
You know, it could be a couple.
What do you think is clicking right now?
What do you like for investors?
I like all those and we consider all those
within our portfolio construction process.
We just had an investment team meeting this morning
before I came into New York City.
Good timing.
And we were discussing the rotation
out of growth into value.
As I came into 2024, I suggested my macro theme
for the year was an expansion of the rally.
Beyond the MAG-7 growth technology stocks
into the other 493 non-magnificent or un-magnificent stocks
that tend to be value oriented.
So we're looking for those companies
that now are trading at reasonable multiple,
have strong balance sheets and often paid dividends.
That's the value area.
We're not abandoning growth,
but we're now taking some of the money
that's off the growth table and moving it into value.
For someone who has a very long runway,
someone in their 20s and 30s, like me,
should they be rotating into value
or should they keep with those growth names?
I don't assume just based on someone's age
what their risk tolerance is, right?
Because I know a lot of young investors
who are very risk averse.
I know a lot of very old investors who are very hungry
and have a bigger rask appetite.
So what I would suggest is you build a diversified portfolio
and include growth in value oriented companies,
but consistent with what your risk tolerance is right now.
We see more value in value going forward,
pun intended, completely.
We see more growth opportunities in value going forward,
but we're not gonna abandon growth completely.
And does diversification to you mean
invest in all of the sectors at some point,
a little bit or a lot?
Like, are you supposed to go all in on,
not all in, a little bit of everything?
Or just passive, like S&P 500 or bust?
So can I use another quant term?
Please.
Or add standard deviation to the next one, okay?
Oh boy, oh boy.
I don't know if I like where this is going.
Which is a measure of risk.
So what we do is we build portfolios
to stay aligned with a certain defined standard deviation
over the course of the year.
And that standard deviation aligns with the investor's
You guys love utilities.
I love utilities,
especially for the more conservative investors.
So we're gonna choose the different types of asset classes,
whether it's stocks, bonds, alternatives, cash,
and within those, the sectors and the areas and the geographies
that stay consistent with that standard deviation,
but keeping the most return potential.
So that's how we build it.
And I'm guessing that you're gonna say
diversify within the caps too, right?
A little bit of large cap, a little bit of small cap?
Not necessarily all of them all the time.
We're overweight large cap right now.
We do have some exposure to small cap,
but I'm not in the camp right now
that thinks a soft landing is guaranteed.
I think that is still up in the air right now.
And if that is the case,
you wanna have that much of your portfolio in small cap
if the economy might continue to grow.
Risk of no landing?
Is that back on the table?
I think it is until we find out more
from the Federal Reserve.
And I think we have a big election coming up too,
and we don't know the outcomes of that election.
Let's get a little personal.
Talk to us about the inception of your career.
No, not that bad.
Talk about the start of your career.
What was your first job?
So I got my MBA and I got a job at Lehman Brothers
in their management training program.
I was able to move into fixed income derivatives,
very fortunate at that time.
And over my 11 year career,
I moved up the ranks to become a senior vice president,
CEO of their bank,
and CEO of their high net worth product and services group.
Everything was going great.
And 9-11 happened and I was in the financial center that day.
And I never went back to our building after that.
And my whole perspective on life really changed after that.
Wow, tell us more about that.
So after that day,
we moved into the Citibank building in Midtown.
And I don't know if you remember back at that point in time,
but they unveiled on 60 Minutes
that the terrorists had blueprints for other buildings.
Guess what?
That was another building.
So the epiphany moment for me came,
I got out of the subway, 399 Park Avenue,
and there was an army tank
parked outside the entrance to our building.
That seems obvious.
There's usually not army tanks
parked outside of buildings in your city, right?
Go through there, the TSA tile checkpoints,
got up to my office and my assistant said,
you can't go in your office right now.
Today's the day they're installing the bulletproof glass.
And you took that as a sign.
I love what I do.
I love the company.
I didn't see the writing on the wall.
2008 was four years after that.
But I wanted to do what I did closer to home.
I had two young girls at that time.
I was leaving at 5.58 in the morning,
getting home at seven o'clock at night.
I wasn't able to be the father that I wanted to be.
It was getting more complicated.
And I was very fortunate to meet one of the partners
from Henion and Walsh's brother
at a cocktail party in my hometown.
Six months later, made the decision to move there
and it's been a great 21 years.
Wow, thank you, good for you.
Thank you for your story.
My pleasure.
And we got to wind things down.
24 minutes passes so fast.
We want to make sure that you check out
all our other episodes of Stocks in Translation
on the Yahoo Finance site, as well as the mobile app
and your favorite podcast providers.
That's all for now.
Sending it back.
♪♪
