4. Philosophers and Kings: Plato's Republic, I-II

Population History
1 follower
3 Video Views·Oct 8, 2024
"Introduction to Political Philosophy (PLSC 114)
Lecture 4 introduces Plato's Republic and its many meanings in the context of moral psychology, justice, the power of poetry and myth, and metaphysics. The Republic is also discussed as a utopia, presenting an extreme vision of a polis--Kallipolis--Plato's ideal city.
00:00 - Chapter 1. Introduction
03:04 - Chapter 2. What Is Plato's ""Republic"" About?
17:38 - Chapter 3. I Went Down to the Piraeus
22:05 - Chapter 4. The Seventh Letter
30:00 - Chapter 5. Analyzing the Beginning of ""Republic"" and the Hierarchy of Characters
38:13 - Chapter 6. Cephalus"
There is one person in here, I don't know who it is,
and you will not know who it is yet.
But there is one person in here for whom
the reading of Plato's Republic will
be the most important intellectual experience you
have at Yale.
It is a book that one of you will go back
to time and time again, and it will stick with you forever.
And what I would like you to do is to remember this.
And four years from now, when most of you
are ready to graduate, if that one person in here
would email me and let me know who it is.
OK?
Maybe it's you.
Maybe.
Possibly.
Or you.
OK.
But this is the book that started it all.
The Apology, the Crito, these are warm-ups to the big theme,
to the other, to the big book, the Republic.
Every other book in this political science
that has since been written, beginning
with Aristotle's Politics and moving on to the present day,
is, in one way or another, an answer, a response
to Plato's Republic.
It started the whole thing.
The first and most obvious thing to say about the Republic
is that it is a long book.
Not the longest book you will ever read, but long enough.
And in fact, in part because of this,
we are only reading approximately half
the book, the first five books, to be more specific.
The first five books that deal with and culminate
in the best city, Plato's ideal city, what he calls
Calypolis, the just city, the beautiful city,
ruled by philosopher kings.
The second half of the book turns in somewhat different,
certainly equally important directions, but would take us
much more time than the time we have allotted to deal with.
So, you will read that on your own, you can take another
course, what have you. The Republic is a very
perplexing book, you will find out.
Its meaning will not be evident to you on a first reading.
It may not be clear to you on a tenth reading,
unless you approach it with the proper questions and the proper
frame of mind. So, let's start by asking a
simple question, what is the Republic about?
What does this book deal with? This is a question that has
perplexed and divided readers of Plato, almost from the
beginning. Is it a book about justice,
as the subtitle of the book suggests?
Is it a book about what we today might call moral
psychology and the right ordering of the human soul,
which is a prominent theme addressed in this work?
Is it a book about the power of poetry and myth,
what we would call the whole domain of culture,
to shape souls and to shape our societies?
Or is it a book about metaphysics and the ultimate
structure of being, as certainly many of the later
books of the Republic suggest? The theory of the forms,
the image of the divided line, and so on and so on.
Of course, it is about all of these things and several others
as well. But at least at the beginning,
when we approach the book, we should stay on its surface,
not dig, at least initially, too deeply.
As one of the great readers of Plato of the last century once
said, only the surface of things reveals the essence of things.
And the surface of the Republic reveals that it is a dialogue.
It is a conversation. We should approach the book,
in other words, not as we might a treatise,
but as we might approach a work of literature or drama.
It is a work comparable in scope to other literary masterworks,
Hamlet, Don Quixote, War and Peace,
others you might think of. And as a conversation,
as a dialogue, it is something that the author
wants us to join, to take part in.
We are invited to be not merely passive onlookers of this
conversation, but active participants in that
dialogue that takes place in this book over the course of a
single evening. Perhaps the best way to read
this book is to read it aloud as you might with a play to
yourself or with your friends. But let's go a little further.
The Republic is also a utopia, a word that Plato does not use,
was not coined until many, many centuries later by Sir
Thomas More. But Plato's book is a utopia.
It is a kind of extreme. He presents an extreme vision
of politics. He presents an extreme vision of
the polis. The guiding thread of the book
is the correspondence and we will look at this in some length
and you will discuss it in your sections, no doubt.
The guiding thread of the book is the correspondence,
the symmetry between the parts of the city and the parts of the
soul. Discord within the city,
just as discord within the soul, is regarded as the greatest
evil. The aim of the Republic is to
establish a harmonious city based on a conception of justice
that, so to speak, harmonizes the individual and
society. How to achieve that?
The best city will necessarily be one that seeks to produce the
best or highest type of individual.
Plato's famous answer to this is that the city,
any city, will never be free of conflict, will never be free of
factional strife until, in his famous formula,
kings become philosophers and philosophers become kings.
The Republic asks us to consider seriously what would a
city look like ruled by philosophers?
In this respect, it would seem to be the sort
of perfect bookend to the Apology.
Remember, the Apology viewed the dangers posed to philosophy
and the philosopher and the philosophical life from the
city. The Republic asks us what would
a city be like if it were ruled by Socrates or someone like him?
What would it be like for philosophers to rule?
Such a city would require, so Socrates tells us throughout
the opening books, the severe censorship of poetry
and theology, the abolition of private
property and the family, at least among the guardian
class of the city, and the use of selected lies and
myths, what would today probably be called ideology or propaganda
as tools of political rule. It would seem that far from
utopia, the Republic represents a radical dystopia,
a satire in some sense of the best polity.
In fact, much of modern political science is directed
against Plato's legacy. The modern state,
as we have come to understand it, is based upon the separation
of civil society from governing authority, the entire domain of
what we call private life separated from the state.
But Plato's Republic recognizes no such separation or no such
independence for a private sphere.
And for this reason, Plato has often been cast as a
kind of harbinger of the modern totalitarian state.
A famous professor at a distant university was said to have
begun his lectures on the Republic by saying, now we will
consider Plato the fascist. And this was, in fact,
the view popularized by one of the most influential books
about Plato written in the last century,
a book written by a Viennese émigré by the name of Karl Popper,
who in the very early 1950s, right at the height of the Cold
War and, of course, the end of the conclusion of the Second
World War, wrote a book called The Open Society and Its Enemies.
He wanted to know what were the causes or who were the
people responsible for the experiences of totalitarianism,
both in Stalin's Russia and in Hitler's Germany.
And in the course of this inquiry, he concluded that not
only Hegel and Marx were important in that particular
genealogy, but this went back to Plato as well, Plato
principally. Plato, who he accuses,
Popper, in a passionate, albeit not very well-written
book, accuses Plato of being the first to establish a kind of
totalitarian dictatorship. Is that true?
Well, Plato's Republic is, we will discover as you read,
it is a republic of a very special kind.
It is not a regime like ours, devoted to maximizing individual
liberties, but it is one that puts the education of its
citizens, the education of its members, as its highest duty.
The republic, like the Greek polis, was a kind of tutelary
association, and its principal good, its principal goal,
was the education of citizens for positions of public
leadership and high political responsibilities.
It is always worthwhile to remember that Plato was,
above all, a teacher. He was the founder of the first
university, the academy, the Platonic Academy,
where we will find out later Aristotle came to study,
among many others, Aristotle being but the
most famous. Plato was the founder of this
school. This, in turn,
spawned other philosophical schools throughout the Greek
world and later the Roman world. With the demise of Rome in the
early Christian centuries, these philosophical academies,
these philosophical schools, were absorbed into the
medieval monasteries. These, in turn,
became the basis of the first European universities in places
like Bologna, Paris, Oxford.
These were, in turn, later transplanted to the
New World and established in towns like Cambridge and,
of course, New Haven.
We can say today that this university is a direct ancestor
of the Platonic Republic, of Plato's academy.
We are all here the heirs of Plato.
Think of that. Without Plato, no Yale.
We would not be here today. I think that is a fact.
I'll let you just ponder that for a moment.
In fact, let me even say a little more about this.
The institutional and educational requirements of
Plato's Republic share many features with a place like Yale.
For example, in both the Platonic
Kallipolis, the just city, as well as this place,
men and women are selected at a relatively early age because of
their capacities for leadership, for courage, for self-discipline
and responsibility.
They spend several years living together, eating together in
common mess halls, exercising together and studying together,
of course, far from the oversight of their parents.
The best of them are winnowed out to pursue further study.
And eventually assume positions of public leadership and
responsibility.
Throughout all of this, they are subjected to a course of
rigorous study and physical training that will lead them to
adopt prominent positions in the military and other branches of
public service.
Does this sound at all familiar to you?
It should.
Let me put it another way.
If Plato is a fascist, what does that make you?
Plato, of course, is an extremist.
And he pushes his ideas to their most radical conclusions.
That's what it is to be a philosopher.
But he is also defining a kind of school.
He regards the Politeia, or the Republic, because that is the
original Greek title of the book, Politeia or Regime.
He regards the Politeia as a school whose chief goal is
preparation for guidance and leadership of a community.
If you don't believe me about this, maybe you will consider
the words of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, one of the great
readers of Plato's Republic.
Rousseau wrote in his Emil, to get a good idea of public
education, he says, read Plato's Republic.
It is not a political treatise, as those who merely judge books
by their title think, but it is the finest, most beautiful work
on education ever written.
Rousseau.
So there we go.
Let's look in a little, let's now peek into the book itself.
Just peek, don't go too far.
Start with the first line.
Who remembers what the first line is?
Oh, come on, you should know this.
You're looking at the book, you're cheating.
I went down to the Piraeus.
Why does Plato begin with this line?
There's a story that I heard, I'm not sure altogether true,
but it's a good story at least, about the famous German
philosopher, Martin Heidegger, who said that on his first
teaching of the Republic, he went through the whole book,
taught the whole book in one class, in one seminar,
one semester.
The last time he taught it, the final time he taught it,
he never got beyond the first sentence.
I went down to the Piraeus.
What does it mean?
Why does he begin with this?
I went down, going down.
The Greek word for this is katabasis.
I had made a descent.
There is a book by a famous contemporary of Plato's,
a man named Xenophon, who wrote a book called the Anabasis.
The Anabasis means a going up, an ascent.
But Plato begins this dialogue with this statement.
I went down.
The descent to the Piraeus, it is clearly
modeled on Odysseus' descent to Hades in the Odyssey.
And in fact, the work is a kind of philosophical odyssey
that both imitates Homer but also anticipates
other great odysseys of the human mind,
works by those like Cervantes or Joyce.
The book is full, you will see, of a number of descents
and ascents.
The most famous climb upward, although we will not actually
read these parts for this class, concerns
the climb to the divided line, the famous image
of the divided line in book six, and the ascent
to the world of the imperishable forms.
And then in the last book of the Republic, book 10,
there is once again a descent to the underworld,
to the world of Hades.
The work is not, in a sense, written simply
as a sort of timeless philosophical treatise
but as a dramatic dialogue with a setting, a cast of characters,
and a firm location in time and place.
Let's say a little more about that time and place.
Already indicated in the phrase or in the sentence,
I went down to the Piraeus.
Plato was born in 427, which is four years
after the commencement of the Peloponnesian War.
He was a young man of 23 when the democracy
in Athens was defeated.
And he was only 28 when the restored democracy
executed his friend and teacher Socrates in 399.
Almost immediately after the trial of Socrates,
Plato left Athens and traveled extensively
throughout the Greek world.
And upon his return, he established this school
at Athens called the Academy for the Training of Philosophers,
Statesmen, and Legislators.
Plato lived a long time.
He lived until the age of 80.
And except for two expeditions to Sicily,
where he went at the request of Dionysius
to help try to establish a philosophical kingship
in Syracuse, he remained in Athens teaching and writing.
The Republic belongs to that period of Plato's work
after his return to Athens after the execution of Socrates.
The dominant feature of Plato's political theory,
David Green, a great reader of Plato,
has said, is the root and branch character of the change
it advocates in existing institutions.
Plato's desire for a kind of radical makeover
of Athenian and Greek political institutions and cultures
grew out of his experience of political defeat and despair.
The utopianism of the book is in many ways
the reverse side of the sense of profound disillusionment
that he felt at the actual experience
of the Athenian polis.
This was not only true of his experience at home,
but of his failed efforts to turn Dionysius' kingship
in Sicily into a successful example of philosophical rule.
In fact, we have, and I want to read to you in just a moment,
a lengthy transcript of Plato's own account
of why he came to write The Republic.
One thing, of course, you note in The Republic
is that Plato is nowhere present.
He is not a participant in his own dialogue.
He is the author, but not the participant.
We don't know precisely what Plato thought.
But we are helped, at least, by a kind
of intellectual autobiography that he wrote,
and that we still have, in what is conventionally
referred to as the seventh letter.
Plato wrote a series of letters that we have.
People have argued over the authenticity of them,
although I think by now it is established that they are his.
And in the most famous of these letters,
the lengthy seventh one, he gives us, again,
something of an autobiography and tells us
a little bit about why he came to write this book.
Isn't this amazing that 2,000, 2,500 years ago,
we still have the letters of the man who wrote this book?
So let me read to you what Plato says about how
he came to write this book.
When I was a young man, he said, and this
is written as he's very old, when I was a young man,
I felt, as yet many young men do,
I felt at the very moment I attained my majority,
I should engage in public affairs.
And there came my way an opportunity
that I want to tell you about.
The democratic constitution, then loudly decried
by many people, was abolished.
And the leaders of the revolution
set themselves up as a government of 30 men
with supreme authority.
This is referring to the tyranny of the 30
that existed after the Athenian defeat.
Some of these men, some of the members of the 30,
you must understand, were relatives of mine
and well known to me.
And what is more, they actually invited me at once
to join them as though politics and I were a fit match.
I was very young then, and it is not surprising
that I felt as I did.
I thought that the city was then living
a kind of life which was unjust, and that they would bend it
to a just one, and so administer it more justly.
So I eagerly watched to see what they would do.
And you must know, as I looked on,
I saw those men in a short time make the former democracy look
like a golden age.
Those are the, referring to his relatives,
men like Critias and Carmides, who
turned Athenian politics into a tyranny in which, he says,
makes the democracy look like a golden age.
Let me continue in Plato's words.
I looked at this, you see, and at the men
who were in politics, at the laws and customs,
and the more I looked and the older I grew,
the more difficult it seemed to me
to administer political affairs justly.
For you cannot do so without friends and comrades
you can trust, and such men it was not easy to find.
For the city, you see, no longer lived in the fashion
and ways of our fathers.
Eager as I had once been to go into politics,
as I looked at these things and saw everything
taking any course at all with no direction or management,
I ended up feeling dizzy.
I did not abandon my interest in politics
to discover how it might be bettered in other respects,
and I was perpetually awaiting my opportunity.
But at last I saw that as far as all states now existing
are concerned, they are all badly governed.
For the condition of their laws is bad almost past cure,
except for some miraculous accident.
So I was compelled to say, in praising true philosophy,
that it was from it alone that was
able to discern any justice.
And so I said that the nations of the world
will never cease from trouble until either the true breed
of philosophers shall come to political office,
or until that of the rulers shall, by some divine law,
take to the pursuit of philosophy.
And there you see, in that wonderful letter
and that kind of probing self-examination
of his early motives and expectations,
you see the disillusionment of the older Plato,
looking on what the tyranny had done,
but also looking at the states, the nations of his time,
seeing their management, seeing their decay and conflict,
and saying and suggesting that no justice will ever
be expected until, as he says at the end,
kings become philosophers and philosophers
kings, a direct reference to the Republic.
This little autobiography, he goes on
at considerably greater length, I should say,
but this provides a kind of introduction, as it were,
to the Republic.
We have Plato's own words here, the way
he viewed politics and his reasons
for his political philosophy.
And yet, in many respects, if the Republic
was the result of comprehensive despair and disillusionment
with the prospects of reform, the dialogue
itself points back to an earlier moment
in Plato's life and the life of the city of Athens.
This remarkable letter was written
when Plato was very old, approximately 50 years
after the trial and execution of Socrates.
But the action of the Republic takes place long
before the defeat of Athens, before the rise of the Thirty
and the execution of Athens.
It refers to that period that Plato says in the letter
looked like a golden age when many things seemed possible.
And that brings us back to the opening,
the descent to the Piraeus.
The action of the dialogue begins at the Piraeus,
the port city of Athens, somewhere
around the year 411, during what was
called the Peace of Nicaeus, that
is to say the peace that endured a kind of respite
truce that was established during the fighting
between Sparta and Athens.
And at the very beginning of the dialogue,
we see Socrates and his friend Glaucon.
What are they doing?
Do you remember?
What are they doing at the very beginning?
Where?
Let me put it a slightly, yes, they
are walking back to Athens from the Piraeus.
But maybe to put it a slightly different way,
they're patrolling the waterfront.
What is the Piraeus?
It is the harbor of Athens.
And what do you expect from harbors?
What are harbor cities like?
What do you find down at harbors?
Water.
They're seedy, aren't they?
You find various kinds of disreputable and maybe
unseemly things going on there.
We are forced to ask ourselves, what are Socrates and Glaucon
doing there?
Why are they there together?
What are they doing?
What do they expect to find?
These seem to be questions that immediately come to mind.
We learn shortly afterwards that they
have taken this descent to the Piraeus
to view a festival, a kind of carnival.
It sounds like something one might
expect to see in a Fellini film, a kind of carnival,
carnaval, a Mardi Gras, where a festival is going on.
A new goddess is being introduced
into the pantheon of deities.
This seems to suggest that, referring back to the Apology,
that it is not Socrates, but the Athenians who innovate,
who create and introduce new deities.
Socrates remarks that the Thracians,
the display of the Thracians, put on a good show,
showing that his own perspective is not simply
bound by that of his city.
It suggests, from the beginning, a kind of loftiness,
an impartiality of perspective, characteristic
of the philosopher, but not necessarily the citizen.
And on their way back from this festival, from this carnival,
on their way back, they are accosted, remember.
They are accosted by a slave who has been sent on
by Palamarchus and his friends, and who orders
Socrates and Glaucon to wait.
Palamarchus orders you to wait, the slave says.
He orders you to wait.
He is coming up behind you.
Just wait.
And of course, we'll wait, Glaucon implies.
When Palamarchus and his friends arrive,
we find that his friends include
Ediomantus, who was Glaucon's brother,
and Nicaratus, who was the son of Nicias,
the general who has just brokered the peace
that they are now enjoying.
That's a famous piece of Nicias.
And they challenge Socrates, stay with us or prove stronger.
Stay with us or prove stronger.
Could we not persuade you, Socrates asks.
Could we not persuade you to let us go?
Not if we won't listen, Palamarchus says.
And instead, they reach a compromise.
But Socrates and Glaucon come with Palamarchus and the others
to the home of Palamarchus's father,
where a dinner will be provided for them,
and later a return to the festival
where there will be a horseback race.
It seems Glaucon says we must stay, and Socrates concurs.
Why does the book begin with this opening gambit?
Is it simply a ruse to get the reader's attention
in some sense, or to rope you in with some promise of what's
to follow?
Already from the very opening lines,
we see in this clue to the theme that is going to follow.
Who has the title to rule?
Is it Palamarchus and his friends
who claim to rule by strength of numbers?
Can we persuade you?
Not if we don't listen, he says.
Or Socrates and Glaucon, who hope
to rule by the powers of reasoned speech and argument.
Can we convince you?
Can democracy that expresses the will of the majority,
the will of the greater number, be rendered compatible
with the needs of philosophy and the claims
to respect only reason and the better argument?
That seems to be the question already posed
in this opening scene.
Can a compromise be reached between the two?
Can the strength of numbers, as well as respect
for reason and the better argument,
be, in some sense, harmonized?
Can they be brought together?
Is the just city, perhaps, that Socrates will later consider
a combination of these two, of both force and persuasion?
That will be something left to see.
But I think you can see the big themes of the book already
very present in the opening scene of the dialogue.
And the first book is really a kind of preamble
to everything that follows.
OK, you with me so far on this?
Let's talk a little bit about the participants
in this dialogue.
It is a dialogue.
It has a fairly large number of characters,
although only a relatively few number of them
speak in the book.
And yet, it's something very important,
as we would want to know in any play or novel or movie.
We want to know something about the particular people who
inhabit this dinner party that Socrates and Glaucon
have been promised.
Who are they?
And what do they represent?
There is Cephalus, who we will see very quickly,
the father of Palamarchus and whose home they are attending.
The venerable Patra Familias, the venerable father
of the family.
Palamarchus, his son, a solid patriot
who defends not only his father's honor,
but that of his friends and fellow citizens.
And we will also see Thrasymachus,
a cynical intellectual who rivals Socrates
as an educator of future leaders and statesmen.
And of course, it is the exchange
between Socrates and Thrasymachus
that is one of the most famous moments of the book.
And there is, in the first set of dialogues,
a distinct hierarchy of characters, you might say,
who we see later on express those distinctive features
of the soul and the city.
Cephalus, we learn, he has spent his life
in the acquisitive arts.
That is to say, he's a businessman.
He's been concerned with satisfying the needs of his body
and making money.
He represents what will later be called
in the Republic the appetitive part of the soul, the appetites.
Palamarchus, whose name actually means warlord,
think of that, the warlord, is preoccupied with questions
of honor and loyalty.
He tells us, to get a little bit ahead of ourselves,
that justice is helping your friends
and harming your enemies.
He seems to represent what Plato or Socrates will later
call the spirited part of the soul, something
that we want to return to.
And Thrasymachus, a visiting sophist,
seeks to teach and educate, anticipating
what the Republic will call the rational soul,
the rational part of the soul.
Each of these figures, in many ways,
prefigure the relatively superior natures
of those who come later in the dialogue.
The two brothers, Glaucon and Adeimantus,
whose exchange with Socrates occupies, for the most part,
the rest of the dialogue from book two onwards.
The two brothers, who incidentally
are the brothers of Plato, I should say,
we know, to my knowledge, we know nothing more
about Glaucon and Adeimantus from history.
But Plato put them into his dialogue.
They will always be remembered as the two brothers
in the dialogue.
And again, they seem to represent
something quite different.
And bear this in mind as you are reading the book,
because it is easy to kind of forget who's talking
and what they represent.
Adeimantus is, we will find, the kind
of hedonistic and pleasure-seeking brother.
And Glaucon, whose name means something like gleaming,
shining, is the fierce and warlike of the two brothers.
And of course, there is the philosophically-minded
Socrates.
Again, each of them seems to represent, in a superior way,
the key components of the human soul,
the appetitive, the warlike or spirited, and the rational.
Together, these figures form a kind of microcosm of humanity.
Each of the participants in the dialogue
represents one of the specific classes or groups
that will eventually occupy the just city to which Plato
or Socrates gives the name, Kallipolis, the beautiful city.
All right.
In the five minutes or so that remain,
let's just talk for a moment about the first conversation
with the head of the family, Cephalus.
We don't need to look at this at great length.
I'm sure in your sections you might
want to talk about the arguments a little more
specifically that are used in these first three
sets of conversations between Cephalus, Palamarchus,
and Prasimiticus.
The question, I don't know if it is more importantly,
but the question I want us to examine a little bit here
in the time remaining is what, again, these characters
represent.
Cephalus, as his name implies, Cephalus, what does that mean?
Do you know?
Head, yes.
Cephalus, head.
The head of the household, but also, clearly,
the claims of age, of tradition, of family.
And at the beginning of the dialogue,
when Palamarchus has brought his friends back to the house,
we see the aged father, Cephalus.
He is just returning from prayer.
He has just returned from performing certain acts
of ritual sacrifice.
And he greets Socrates, in many ways, as a long lost friend.
Perhaps you have had this experience yourself,
a slightly, always slightly uncomfortable one.
When you bring a group of your friends back to your house,
you're expecting to have a good time.
And your grandparent is there and says,
oh, it's so good to see a bunch of young people.
I want to talk with you.
And it's always a slightly uncomfortable moment,
you might say.
We are all to have experience of this kind of thing.
Everybody knows it from either end.
I'm not a grandparent, thank God.
But I feel the same thing often when
my son brings his friends that maybe
that I've known for a long time.
Oh, how are you doing?
I don't want anything.
I want to get away.
And Socrates does something rather abrupt.
Tell me, Cephalus, what's it like to be so old?
What is it like to be like you?
And do you still feel the need for sex?
Can you imagine that, saying that to someone's grandfather?
Do you have a little idea of the character of Socrates?
And Cephalus is so happy.
Oh, thank God I'm past that, he says.
Thank God I no longer feel this erotic desire.
And at my old age, I can spend my time.
As a young man, that's all I did.
I was thinking about sex all the time.
And when I wasn't thinking about that, I was making money.
But now, I've had my fill of both.
And I can spend my later years, the twilight of my life,
turning to the things about the gods,
performing sacrifices commanded by the gods.
You might say, why does Plato begin this way?
Well, Cephalus is, as it should be clear,
the very embodiment of the conventional,
in both senses of that term.
He's not a bad man, by any means.
But he is a thoroughly unreflective one.
And in attacking Cephalus, as he does,
Socrates attacks the embodiment of conventional opinion,
the nomos supporting the city.
Note the way Socrates manipulates
the dialogue, the conversation.
Cephalus says that the pious man, the just man,
practices justice by sacrificing to the gods.
And Socrates turns that into the statement
that justice means paying your debts
and returning what is owed to you.
Cephalus, in an easygoing manner, agrees.
And then Socrates says, well, what would you think
about returning a weapon that you had borrowed
from a friend or someone who was in a very depressed,
we might say, depressed frame of mind?
Would that be just?
How do you explain that?
Would you do that if justice means paying your debts
and giving back to each what is owed?
And at that moment, Cephalus excuses himself
from the dialogue and says, rather abruptly,
I have to go out and continue my sacrifices in the garden.
Socrates, in other words, has broken the bond
of tradition and traditional authority
that holds the ancient city and the ancient family together.
Cephalus is banished from the dialogue.
Tradition is banished.
And we never hear another word about it
for the next 400 or so pages.
That's the way Socrates begins this dialogue,
or that's the way Plato has Socrates begin it.
And we'll look a little more at some of these
in our class for next time,
and then move into the characters
of Adeimantus and Glaucon.
Anyway, start your reading, continue your reading,
and your sessions, your sections are going on this week.
So enjoy yourselves.
