The Milkmaid by Johannes Vermeer: Great Art Explained

Art Exhibitions
6 followers
Johannes Vermeer was producing simple domestic interiors of middle-class life. His paintings were quiet, private, and unassuming. Secular works that contained stories of real human relationships. #Artexhibitions
By the mid-17th century, the age of flamboyant Baroque was in full swing.
It was an art movement that came from conflict. Europe had experienced the Reformation and
Counter-Reformation, the Wars of Religion and Inquisitions. The art being produced in Catholic
countries had become a powerful tool of propaganda, characterized by a heightened sense of drama,
movement and theatricality that had never been seen before. But in the Netherlands,
a new wave of realism was sweeping across the country. Johannes Vermeer was producing
simple domestic interiors of middle-class life. His paintings were quiet, private and unassuming,
secular works that contained stories of real human relationships. Vermeer's art would be
totally forgotten about right up until the mid-19th century, the age of the camera.
His incredible mastery of hyper-realism would lead some people to question the authenticity
of Vermeer, to question whether he used mechanical means to achieve such perfect illusions.
For some people, as we shall see, Johannes Vermeer is considered a cheat.
In 1556, the Habsburgs took over the Low Countries, what today is the Netherlands,
Belgium and Luxembourg, and ruled it as a Spanish province. It was a clash of two
dramatically different cultures. The Northern territories were Protestant, the Southern,
Catholic. The Eighty Years' War ended in independence for the North in 1648.
While the Southern Netherlands remained Catholic and a part of Spain,
in the North the strict Protestant sect of Calvinism became the nation's official religion.
Religious imagery was banned and an emphasis was placed on simplicity in both worship and
decorative style. The sharp break with the old monarchist and Catholic cultural traditions
would mean that Dutch art had to reinvent itself almost entirely.
We know Vermeer was born in Delft in 1632. Then next to nothing is known about him,
until he married Katarina Bolnes in 1653. She was Catholic, and Vermeer almost certainly converted
to Catholicism secretly before they married, probably at the insistence of his wealthy
mother-in-law, who at first opposed the marriage. Although Catholic mass was banned, freedom of
religion in the Dutch Republic was official, and converting to Catholicism didn't bring Vermeer
any personal or professional disadvantages. The couple moved in with Katarina's mother,
and Vermeer spent the rest of his life in the same town, the same house, slowly producing
paintings in the same room, on the second floor, at a rate of 2 or 3 a year. It is thought Vermeer
produced 60 or so paintings, of which only 36 survive today. Vermeer and Katarina had 15 children,
of which 11 survived. We know at least 5 other adults lived in the same house,
as well as Vermeer's own 11 children. And yet he never shows us any suggestion of family,
or the chaos that naturally comes with a household that big. It is safe to say that the peace and
quiet Vermeer depicts in his paintings was not what he experienced in real life. Maybe that is
the point. Genre paintings were scenes of everyday life, ordinary people engaged in
common activities, that both reflected and helped define ideals about the family, love,
morals, courtship, and duty. In the 17th century, the Dutch Republic dominated global trade,
and was the wealthiest country in the world. But the Dutch Calvinists were a frugal and austere
group, naturally inhibited and embarrassed by wealth. Smaller, quiet secular paintings became
hugely popular, and no longer the preserve of the church or aristocracy, or even the very wealthy.
Paintings could be found in shops, taverns, and houses. It was a boom time for artists.
Along with paintings, maps started to appear in homes, appealing to the Dutch desire for order.
Cityscapes were an emblem of self-determination, and a sense of pride in the young Dutch Republic.
While Dutch Calvinists denounced devotional artwork in churches,
they explicitly encouraged devotees to turn their attention to the visible world around them.
One of the most successful subcategories of genre painting was the kitchen scene. The Dutch saw
hard work as spiritual, and household economy as a holy virtue, moderation in all things.
There were so many Dutch artists producing genre paintings, but if we look at these two
paintings on the same theme, we see there were none quite like Vermeer, whose quiet settings,
serene lighting, cropping, and ambiguousness made his scenes more universal than most genre paintings.
Artists borrowed themes and compositions from each other readily. There was no shame in copying.
Once a theme took off in sales, artists would produce their own variations.
Vermeer's paintings are all small, but the milkmaid is very small.
It is oil on canvas. According to conservators, it took two months to paint.
The first thing to note is that she is not a milkmaid, but a domestic kitchen maid.
She is a young woman of a strong build, wearing a crisp linen cap, a blue apron, and work sleeves
pushed up from thick forearms. The unassuming maid is poised between action and introspection.
She is slowly pouring milk into a squat earthenware vessel, commonly known as a Dutch
oven. Her concentration and careful pouring suggest she is following a precise recipe.
The Dutch oven has a deep rim, so a lid can be put on top for cooking.
In front of the pot are broken pieces of stale bread. It is thought she is making some kind of
bread pudding. Her transformation of stale, unusable bread into something edible, and her
careful use of ingredients, would have been picked up by the 17th century Dutch as an illustration
of domestic virtue, a greatly admired value. We don't know who the model is, but Vermeer
couldn't afford to pay models, so used his family and servants. It could be Tanika Everpol,
a maid in Vermeer's house, but if it is, it is not meant to be a portrait.
Vermeer is really showing his astounding ability to suggest a vast range of textures.
The rough, inexpensive material is a sharp contrast to his later paintings of middle-class women.
After the milkmaid, Vermeer never again painted a working-class theme.
The maid is wearing a starched cap. He has painted wet-on-wet here, as well as on other
areas such as her sleeves. Then he adds texture with layers of thick paint or impasto.
The arm is a masterclass in wet-on-wet technique, the rolled-up sleeves revealing a perfectly
rendered tan line. The edges of her forearms are soft, suggesting movement. We can feel the tension
she has to maintain to let the milk pour out so slowly, and we can also sense the liquid falling.
It really is as if her arms are moving. He would do something similar with the guitar
strings in this painting, covered in my video Great Art Cities London.
The maid is wearing a yellow chamois leather top, painted with lead-tin yellow, the brightest
yellow pigment available in Vermeer's time, and one of his preferred colours. He would use the
same yellow pigment in later representations of the famous fur-trimmed morning jackets adorned
by elegant women. The rough reddish stitching is not meant to be decorative, and tells us it is a
purely practical garment. She wears a heavy blue apron over a red wool skirt, which suggests that
the picture was painted in winter. In Vermeer's day, there were a limited number of pigments,
and he only used about 20 of them. But along with lead-tin yellow, he did use expensive ultramarine
a lot. It was made from crushed lapis lazuli, a semi-precious stone imported from present-day
Afghanistan. We know Vermeer struggled financially most of his life, and we think it was his patron,
Pieter van Rookven, who supplied the artist with such costly pigment. The strange green sleeves are
called moorsmoorven, or mess sleeves. They are not part of the yellow bodice, but are worn separately
to protect against staining. We can see them in other works. Rather than underdrawing, Vermeer used
a monochromatic layer, where he would identify tone, lighting and composition. He uses different
blocks of colour for different areas of the painting, which adds to the luminosity. Vermeer
famously uses a sort of pointillism in the bread and basket, which suggests light as it flickers
off the broken surface of the stale bread. He uses dabs of ochre to show us the rough edges of the
dry bread, giving us a texture which suggests staleness. We first see his use of pointillé in this
painting, and the technique appears in about half of Vermeer's works. The entire still life on the
table is a masterpiece, that uses a combination of thin glazes, impasto, colour and a perfect
depiction of light refraction on every single crumb. Unusually for the time, Vermeer uses
impressionistic dabs of blue here, which act as reflective highlights and intensifies the brick
colour of the stoneware. Kitchen maids were often portrayed in Dutch paintings and literature
as discrete objects of desire, and sexually threatening to the home. Vermeer possibly
acknowledged the tradition of the maid as a sexual being, by placing one of the delft tiles behind her
depicting Cupid. It is thought that she is in a cold kitchen, because here we can see a foot warmer.
These were wooden perforated boxes with hot coals inside. There is a possibility Vermeer was using
the foot warmer symbolically, as in popular literature they were often associated with
the heat of sex. More likely, he is referring to her inner warmth. The 17th century male viewer
would have noticed the contrast of the rough leather sleeves with the fleshy nudity of her
exposed forearm, which they would have found titillating. While we can't dismiss this erotic
subtext, I do believe that Vermeer, though not from the servant class, did marry above his station
and treats the subjects of a lower class woman with dignity and empathy. Vermeer's focus is on
the maid as an ideal woman, a paragon of homely virtue. She might be seen, even today, as the
essence of the Dutch character. Strong, simple and direct. The painting is built up along two
diagonal lines that draw our attention to the pouring milk, the focal point for both us and the
maid. On the wall are a frame, a bread basket and a pail. They each retain their own distinct form
and texture, but they also cascade down towards the stream of milk. The painting is from a low
angle, which gives her monumentality. Vermeer uses the classic pyramid shape as stability,
which I have discussed before. He not only used the same props again and again in his paintings,
but he also recycled the same poses. This is a pose we have seen before in this painting,
but although the upper class woman is surrounded by expensive furnishings and the kitchen maid
has nothing but her clothes, both women command our respect. This x-ray shows us that originally
Vermeer had an overflowing clothes basket here, but painted over it. He also had a map on the
wall behind the maid. By taking these away and leaving the whitewashed wall, it not only isolates
the figures, but also reflects light and cleanliness. If we look again at this painting,
we can see there are dirty dishes waiting to be cleaned, suggesting the servant is lazy and
disorganised. If Vermeer had left a full laundry basket, he would be telling a different story,
and by removing this and the map, he creates an uncluttered backdrop, both physically and
psychologically. Vermeer often placed a chair or table or curtain in the foreground of his
paintings to create a theatrical barrier and reinforce the sense of privacy between the
figures and the viewer. It also adds depth and three-dimensionality. We can see the type of
window if we look at this painting Vermeer created of his aunt's house. Windows in the
17th century had small uneven panes. Top-left lighting is an artistic convention that goes
back to ancient Rome, and as we've seen, the windows in Vermeer's works are almost always
to the left. In this painting, he shows them as full of imperfections, and they are not clear,
leading to a more diffused softer light. My favourite detail is this cracked pane,
which lets in a little beam of unfiltered light. Light is of course what Vermeer is famous for,
the flow of light from left to right and its intensity activates the canvas. The light
gradually and perfectly diminishes as it flows from light to dark. And every nail, hole, crack
and crevice is treated with the same attention to detail as the pouring milk. Vermeer takes a white
wall and elevates it to a picture within a picture, a stage setting for the artist's quiet
little drama. The amount of work Vermeer produced was pretty meagre, and when he died his work was
owned by just one or two collectors in the small town of Delft. The lack of exposure ensured that
his name just disappears from art history completely, until 1866 when a French art critic
wrote about him. Photography was just becoming popular at this time, and people couldn't help
but connect Vermeer's hyper-realistic work with the new technology. Almost immediately the
suggestion arose that Vermeer used a camera obscura, the forerunner of the modern photographic camera,
as a way of copying. A darkened room has a pinhole on one side, and through this hole an inverted
image is projected via a lens into a darkened space, onto a canvas inside. Now the question is,
did Vermeer use one to create his work? The pro-camera argument is the lack of underdrawings
in his work, the perfect perspective, and the portrayal of objects out of focus. Like every
theory, there are endless variations. The artist David Hockney famously made his case on the matter,
and in the 2013 film Tim's Vermeer, they claimed to reproduce a Vermeer. You can find links to
As we know, plenty of great artists didn't rely on underdrawing, and if Vermeer did rely on a camera
obscura to trace an image, then there would be an underdrawing. The strongest argument for his use
of mechanical help is his extremely accurate perspective. Along with the hyper-realism,
people asked, how is this possible? Recent evidence shows that he used a more rudimentary
method to obtain accurate perspective. So far, pinpricks have been found in 13 Vermeer paintings,
including the milkmaid just above her right hand. In fact, it is visible to the naked eye,
as we can see. A string with chalk on it was attached to the pin, which the painter would
have snapped to get perspective lines, a common method among Dutch artists. My question is,
why would Vermeer use this method to work out perspective, if he was simply tracing the image
with a camera obscura? Of course, there is a possibility he used optical aids of some kind,
but I'm not convinced, and there is no solid evidence. To be frank, I don't think it's that
important. If it is true, it is just one process of making a painting, and doesn't detract from
Vermeer's unique genius. The introduction of quiet everyday scenes of life, unfolding
in private households, was among the most striking innovations of the Dutch Golden Age.
Vermeer infused his scenes of daily life with layer upon layer of meaning. We come out with
more questions than answers, and that's exciting. There is an intriguing mystery about the milkmaid
that keeps us coming back. In 1672, France invaded the Netherlands, and Vermeer fell
victim to the disastrous economic climate that followed. The art market collapsed overnight,
and he would die just three years later, leaving behind a wife, 11 children, and enormous debts.
His large family had to sell everything just to survive. We can't really say Vermeer was forgotten,
as he was never really known. Perhaps it is the quiet, unassuming nature of Vermeer's work that
means it took hundreds of years for him to even get noticed. Perhaps the world came to realise
that the quiet moments are often the most profound.
