Lecture 32 : Marketing - R&D interaction

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 5, 2024
Hello, I am Jayanta Chatterjee from IIT Kanpur.
We are continuing with our sessions on B to B business to business marketing, industrial
marketing with technology focus.
Our current sessions deal with market orientation and cross functional marketing R and D interaction.
We have in the previous session discussed in detail about market orientation and we
are now focusing on the cross functional particularly marketing and R and D interaction.
This is where we were at the end of the previous session, where we looked at the kind of information
need and knowledge transfer needed by the pioneers.
And then we were discussing about the same needs for the fast followers.
So, fast followers as we know focus on the pragmatists as opposed to innovators and early
adopters.
So, they bring out improved or less expensive versions of products that originally introduced
by the prospectors or the pioneers.
So, they simultaneously defend a core market as well as they explore growth in new markets.
So, their information focus closely monitor customers reactions to pioneers or prospectors
offerings and they at the same time monitor competitors activities successes and failures.
So, they limit new product introduction to categories that have shown promise.
So, they are not as bold risk takers at the as the prospectors or the pioneers they are
far more cautious.
And then we have other two types of strategy archetypes that we have discussed in a previous
session.
So, the third archetype is the people who focus on operational excellence they are the
low cost defenders.
So, as opposed to the prospectors and fast followers these low cost defenders gaining
their strength from operational excellence provide quality products or services at the
lowest overall cost that gives them lot of strategic pricing manoeuvrability.
Generally their products may be less technologically sophisticated, but their competition benchmarking
will be as prominent as in the case of the previous two types.
And so they continue to benchmark against price cost and performance of the competitors.
So, they try to focus actually their price warriors usually and they are able to do that
because they have operational excellence which allows them to have the lowest cost in the
industry.
So, they focus on the other types which are they are also defenders, but they are differentiated
defenders as opposed to the low cost defenders this is the fourth strategy archetype as we
have discussed before.
They focus on customers value for individual niche segments their information focus therefore,
is on skilled segmentation to identify customer segments that value superior quality as well
as service.
So, they are trying to defend, but in a differentiated fashion by virtue of their superiority in
product and service they closely monitor customer satisfaction and identify opportunities
to increase share of the customer wallet and they analyze the reasons for customers defections
they analyze the reasons for defections of their own customers as well as competitors
customers and that is how they actually derive their competitive strategy.
So, these are the four types strategy archetypes and their information needs the sharing needs.
Now in all of these marketing has a crucial role to play because as we have discussed
before marketing is a boundary spanning activity and boundary spanning means they are at the
boundary of the organization and the market they are at the boundary of organizations
contact with the competition and they are also at the boundary of all the other departments
because the marketing in this kind of market oriented organization which we are discussing
the kind of organization which have very good interaction and integration among all the
different departments particularly marketing and R and D.
So, marketing here is at the boundary with all the other departments. So, they have lot
of communication with other departments as well as with external stakeholders. So, all
the four strategy archetypes that we just now discussed depend on marketing to make
the information flow happen in their desired fashion. So, in the technology focused marketing
organization greater inter functional coordination are noted because that makes radical innovation
happen that make fast following happen that makes low cost defending happen that makes
differentiated defending happen. So, in all of the situations we need the marketing
to play a key role as a kind of information flow manager and because that creates faster
product development lower cost product development and it appears as a key role in at every stage
of the marketing process. So, this block diagram in front of you represents the team work in
product development the role of information and knowledge flow and the players in this
that make this team work happen. So, we are basically looking at information integration
quality orientation that leads to product quality, team identity, customer influence
all of that relates to the product innovativeness. At the same time the product innovativeness
relates to product quality and ultimately the product innovativeness means there is
an encouragement for risk taking and monitoring by senior management, but remember what we
are actually again and again emphasizing in these interactions and integrations to
happen the marketing has a key role to play. We will just now see again some other roles
or associated roles played by marketing like for example, team interaction, interaction
among the different parts of the organizational departments.
We obviously need communication team orientation and appropriate reward system just now we
discussed all that to be there to make these things to happen. So, for example, for good
communication the team must simultaneously cooperate as well as compete because in many
organizations particularly technology focused organizations often two or three different
types of product developments will be internally encouraged to compete for resources with each
other and so that the best will win. So, there will be therefore, flow of communication
is extremely important here. So, that silos do not appear barriers do not appear. So,
that this simultaneous cooperation as well as competition internally can happen because
we are trying to harness diverse opportunities and diverse functional perspectives and that
means that we have to engage in constructive conflict resolution. Again in all of these
we expect the marketing department to play a leading role.
The team orientation of course, needs leaders with clear set of values, we need confidence
in each other, we need trust among the different team members and of course, we need the reward
system which should promote teams and organizations and not always the individual. Of course,
there will be some situation like for example, the field marketing people, the field sales
people there the individual contribution is very clear and there we may have some reward
systems which are individual based, but in the engineering department, in the R and D
department, in the technology and marketing liaison role what we call the internal marketing
functions, we may actually focus on group reward systems.
So, these two types of reward systems, one in which individual contribution is rewarded
like in field sales or field marketing and in all the other cases we have the group or
position based reward system because there we focus on long complex projects where outcome
based rewards are more appropriate. So, what we are trying to say is that not only we need
the top management encouragement, the marketing department to work as a shepherd of communication
and the flow to be maintained among all the different departments, it must be complemented
by the proper managerial reward system because they should not work at cross purposes.
This cross functional marketing and R and D collaboration very, very critical for high
tech firms. In fact, for all technology focused technology enhanced activities we need this
because the technology focused companies are very dependent on new product flows. So, the
innovation and new product flows depend on this cross functional integration and that
is why we are in our we are we are devoting these two sessions to this particular discussion.
The need for R and D marketing integration in fact is greater when innovations are complex
and the environment situation is uncertain and the organization has a continuing focus
on the so called fuzzy front end or that what we called a pioneering stage of the product
life cycle, early stage of the product life cycle which is sometimes called the fuzzy
front end because situations are very fluid in this kind of industry at that kind of product
development stage. And there again the marketing and their close
communication with the R and D and technology departments play a very crucial part because
we have to at every stage take care that no rivalry develops between R and D and marketing
because that is quite possible to happen as we will just now see because the expertise
in R and D and expertise in marketing both are very valuable, but they are a little different
they are related, but different in nature and that may actually sometimes create inter
departmental rivalry and we have to in this kind of organization take good care that does
not happen because that will reduce the information flow, knowledge sharing and that will contribute
to failure because the most important part is that the marketing department brings the
voice of the customer into the development process.
In today's organizations particularly technology focused organizations marketing departments
are not away from the product development they are actually an integral part of the
product development team they are all the time bringing in to the in the development
process the customer voice and they are liking they are disliking and prototypes are tested
minimum viable products are tested and the feedbacks are brought in. So, that the final
product can be developed. So, R and D is always focusing on what is technically feasible and
marketing is always focusing on what really makes sense for the customer what brings value
to the customers problem solving process and therefore, both must closely work together
in fact in technology focused organization both are customer facing functions not product
development is an internal function and marketing is an external function they work hand in
hand they are together in front of the customer they are together back inside the organization.
So, R and D and marketing interactions are to be matched the barriers are to be understood
and resolved and high tech culture that values engineering more than marketing is sometimes
detrimental. So, we have to understand the backgrounds and orientation between these
two departments and often actually we have to encourage co-optation faster cooperation
faster cooperation and communication flow and we will just now see what are the differences
and how do we manage different situations and different sometimes R and D will take
lead sometimes marketing will take lead. So, for breakthrough products marketing and
R and D interaction will assess market opportunities determine what the industry market segment
the company should engage in they will look at market development priorities they will
assess the product feature set to start with and in the final form generally in this process
the R and D will take lead whereas, for incremental innovation the focus will be on commercialization
on finishing the minimum viable product in it to its final form here R and D will be
assisting marketing strategies marketing materials collaterals, but the lead will be played by
marketing. So, what we are saying is that this is a constantly
changing role as the product life cycle goes on at some stage R and D is leading subsequently
marketing is leading and this roles keep on playing. So, just like in a fluid and flexible
football team people go up and down the field all the time and roles are interchanged often
even to confuse the competitors and this is something this kind of agility this kind of
flexible changing of positions are possible and must be practiced because we should not
allow this different orientations between R and D and marketing personnel to harden
we have to retain the flexibility. So, that they can change their roles because
as such by the very nature of their jobs their time orientations are different because R
and D focuses more on the long term marketing once immediate results as well as long term
results. So, the projects preferred by R and D are the breakthrough type of products projects
where as marketing likes incremental projects the ambiguity tolerance in case of marketing
will be high because they are dealing more with the external world normally, but what
we are trying to say is that these traditional difference in orientation between R and D
and marketing personnel we may not actually totally accept or allow to harden in good
well integrated organizations where marketing and R and D are constantly interacting and
that we achieve by interchanging their roles transferring people from one activity to the
other activity. So, that these are the called we call these
informal techniques as co-optation that means one type of person will be co-opted in the
other kind of function. So, marketing people will be co-opted by R and D R and D people
will be co-opted by marketing that happens more often than the other thing R and D people
they go out in the field and work with marketing side by side in front of the customer, but
ideally we would like both way flow possible. So, that the co-operation is really feasible
and really takes place communication flows freely and the conflict is always constructive
conflict. So, that is what we were meaning by co-optation
building of informal networks and product knowledge credibility will be shared on both
sides formation of strategic coalitions and even marketing may be working on minor improvements
of the products even outside R and D. So, co-operation will be enhanced by physical
co-location in many high tech organizations technology focused organizations it is always
desired that the marketing and R and D and product development teams are co-located.
So, that there are more what we call around the water cooler that means there are more
informal interactions and more exchange of tacit knowledge through social interaction
because there is a same famous model called the sake model where we look at this knowledge
flow as socialization externalization s e internalization and integration. So, this
process is often helped this knowledge flow process knowledge management process often
is helped by co-locating the teams together and that obviously, makes the communication
free flowing that actually and discourages knowledge hoarding information hoarding and
that actually makes the expectations about interdepartmental communication free flowing.
In fact, it has been found that in this type of integrated organizations the marketing
personnel identify more with the whole organization and the total perspectives rather than with
the departmental parochial interests this is a very interesting observation that has
been made by many researcher and in organizations like Intel or organizations like AMD or organizations
even like Microsoft we really see this free flow between marketing and R and D and product
development really happen and we see marketing people who are connectors as opposed to parochial
landlords. So, finally, we are talking about developing
integrated goals that means the organization goals take precedence over departmental goals
and even if marketing managers identify strongly with the marketing department they communicate
more with when integrated goals are stressed. So, this is the two true boundary spanning
function that is performed by the marketing department. So, that brings us to the conclusion
of our session on market orientation and marketing and R and D marketing and technical marketing
and product development functional integration for the growth of technology focused technology
dominant organizations. Thank you.
