Tackling the real issues you’re facing and answering a lot of listener questions that have come in about student loans. We’ll chat about the impact of possible political changes on loan forgiveness programs, share tips on managing your loans during servicer transitions, and give advice on everything from autopay issues to whether you should buy property in Hawaii.
In today’s episode:
00:00 Introduction 00:38 Parent PLUS loan consolidation, Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), marriage and student loans 17:40 Advice for new graduates, administrative forbearance, early income recertification, PSLF buyback 30:19 Interest accruing during forbearance, PSLF credit for past payments, timing PSLF 41:32 Forgiveness timelines when there’s a gap between undergrad and grad loans, interest capitalization
📩 Get the brand new IDR calculator that minimizes your student loan payments so you can use the money on better stuff: https://www.studentloanplanner.com/yo..
For this week's episode of the Studio One Planner Podcast,
we have a lot of listener questions that have come in,
and so I'm just gonna try to tackle
as many of those as I can get to in today's episode,
and obviously feel free to put me on faster speak,
or double speak, or 1.5x,
or whatever you do in your podcast.
Some of these are gonna be relevant to you,
some of them won't be,
but I think all of them are pretty pressing questions.
So I hope you enjoy.
The first question today we're gonna talk about
is how the double consolidation mess
is affected for Parent PLUS folks
by this whole pause and what to do.
Good morning.
I have four children,
and I took Parent PLUS loans out for two of my children,
and my wife has taken Parent PLUS loans out
for my other two children,
and we are both married.
We file our taxes that way.
I have a question regarding my wife's student loans.
I already double consolidated my student loans
because those two children have graduated college
and are moving on to their professions.
My wife's student loans that she pulled
from my other two children,
they are still in college
and do not graduate till May of 2025.
Can I start the double loan consolidation process
prior to them graduating?
I'd like to try to take advantage of that as well,
based upon your videos that I've watched, numerous ones,
that the due date is July of 2025,
and I should be starting to December of 2024
to complete this task.
Those two children will not be graduated till May.
All of their student loans should be pulled by that time,
but I'd like to understand some options
for those two students that I would like
to process the double loan consolidation
and take advantage of that,
because currently my wife and I have a lot of money
tied up in Parent PLUS loans for all four of our children,
and I'd like to try to do the best I can
to mitigate any of those future costs wherever possible.
Any feedback or phone calls or information
would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you, and hopefully you can help me out.
So in general, when you've got these Parent PLUS loans
and you're trying to figure out,
can I start double consolidating them sooner
if I've got kids still in school?
The answer is yes.
You can double consolidate before the last kid is done.
What you generally have to do
is just take advantage of the fact
that Parent PLUS loans,
you can get them out of this deferment period,
and you can go ahead and do that consolidation.
But the problem is, of course,
is if you have everything shut down in a system completely,
then you can't take action until that stuff is fixed first.
So that's kind of what we're stuck at right now.
The one positive thing I'd say with the injunction
is that the rule that phases out
the double consolidation loophole
is actually part of the SAVE plan.
So if SAVE got struck down kind of randomly,
the double consolidation thing might go away as well
in terms of the limit on it,
and then that might not be July 2025.
So everything kind of depends on what happens
with this lawsuit for that.
So now another question.
Hello, Travis.
My name is Mike.
I just wanted to start by saying
that I appreciate your podcast
and everything that your company does
to help out student loan borrowers
with providing unbiased information.
My big question is, with the election coming up,
is there a chance that if President Trump is elected,
that he will get rid
of the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program?
I know that in the past,
he's talked about getting rid of it
when he was president previously,
but my concern would be
if we're already enrolled in the program,
trying to get that,
can he ax the program to where
we no longer have that possibility?
I'm up to get my loans forgiven this year,
so it doesn't affect me so much,
but my wife isn't until next year.
So we spent then nine, almost 10 years,
and then if he axes that program out,
we'll have more debt,
and it'll just cause a lot of problems financially
for our family because we were told
that there was this plan,
and then all of a sudden,
they just ripped it out from under us.
I know it's hard to speculate based on an election,
but I think that's a question that me
and a lot of other PSLF borrowers have right now,
is if President Trump is elected
in this upcoming election,
is the PSLF program possibly going to go away
and affect people that are already paying
into this program and counting on it?
So I appreciate you taking my question
and your time,
and hope you have a good rest of the day.
I remember I had an article about Trump repealing PSLF
and could he and would he and those kind of things,
and that article was really popular
when he unexpectedly won back in 2016,
and people were really worried about it then.
You want to just take a sober look at this
and say, well, what does the law say?
First of all, the law says you got to do PSLF.
It's got to be allowed.
So you can't just repeal PSLF
unless you have 60 votes in the Senate,
because that's what you have to have.
You don't have the filibuster being overturned yet.
Since the filibuster has not been overturned yet,
you would need 60 votes in the Senate to repeal PSLF.
So let's say you had Trump win
and Republicans win both houses of Congress.
Well, if that were to occur,
they would still need 60 votes in the Senate
to get rid of PSLF.
Now let's say that everything in the world is tossed out
that's not in the law.
In terms of IDR plans like SAVE,
well, then IBR is still an option.
And the big thing that I'm concerned about
is the payment cap for IBR,
people not being able to access IBR due to that,
due to how long it's been
since people have recertified their income.
The good news is I don't think you have to worry
about Trump repealing PSLF at all.
What I would be concerned about is
will IDR plans be significantly scaled back
so that it's harder to get into PSLF?
And I think that we'll be able to think of
some creative ways around that if that does happen.
We'll probably have to think of some creative ways
to get people into PSLF,
or into, I mean, I should say, income-driven repayment,
income-based repayment specifically,
if SAVE gets tossed.
But that's just a wait-and-see kind of thing.
We'll have to wait and find out.
Now another question.
Hi, Travis.
My name is Katie,
and this is a financial planner question.
My husband's from Montana and I'm from Hawaii.
We have two properties in Montana that we rent out,
and we're living in a really small two-bedroom apartment
here in Honolulu.
I recently was offered an early inheritance to buy,
and my father's advocating that we do it here in Hawaii.
And our ultimate dream would be to have the girls
rafting and backpacking in Montana in the summers,
and here in the rest of the year for school in Hawaii.
So I would just love to get your opinion
to think outside of the box.
Do we buy a house, a smaller apartment for cash,
and lower expenses that way,
and stay somewhat uncomfortable?
Or do we take on a mortgage and buy a home
that might be a better investment and more comfortable?
I'd love to maybe hire you for those services
to look at our financials,
or just get your opinion on that.
I'd love to hear from you.
Thank you so much.
So this is a fun question,
because I think that this one is just kind of like,
what's the most optimal way to set up my finances
for this dream, right?
I wanna live in where the weather's great,
and the outdoors are incredibly enjoyable
when the weather's nice.
And then when it's not nice,
I wanna go live in a really nice place
where it's not too cold, and I can enjoy that.
So I think that the way I would think about this
is tourist season in the hot areas,
probably in the summer,
even though it's not as pleasant as it is
during the winter, right?
So I would suspect that a primary residence
that is allowed to be put on Airbnb
would be pretty valuable to tourists in the summer.
And then my guess would be that for the winter months
in a cold place like Montana,
that there wouldn't be much of a market
for renting out a nine-month rental
or something like that in a place like Montana.
So I think the optimal thing to do would probably be,
now, the thing about homeownership
in an expensive place like Hawaii
is homeownership is kind of difficult to justify
from a price-to-rent ratio in Hawaii,
just because it's a very high-priced area
relative to what you can rent for.
But I would just say if you have financial abundance,
I would probably look at maybe buying a place,
like owning a place in Hawaii,
even if it's a little bit more expensive.
I'd probably try to see
if I could put it on Airbnb in the summer
and then take the money from Airbnb
and then use that to rent a place out in Montana
where you probably could find
a similar kind of Airbnb kind of situation
in Montana for three months a year
and possibly even negotiate a better deal
off-market, off of Airbnb
after maybe you've stayed there for two summers in a row,
you might be able to just contact the owner directly
and get a better deal
because of how much the fees are that the platforms take.
So that's kind of a fun way to think out of the box.
I think that I love it when people think out of the box
about what's possible for their financial lives.
That's a great question.
If somebody had a random question like that
and just wanted to see
what financial planning could do for them,
you could go to slpwealth.com slash pod
for an intro call link.
So let's just keep listening.
More questions.
Hey there, kind of a long-time listener here.
I want to thank you for your podcast.
I have a couple of questions about getting married
and how they relate to income-free certification.
Some basic facts.
I'm a federal employee.
I'm a little less than three years out
from forgiveness with PSLF.
I have about $26,000 in student loan debt.
I make, as of right now,
about 56,000 before taxes.
So that's kind of my situation.
My fiance makes pretty much the exact same amount of money
as I do.
She's going to take a little bit of a pay cut soon,
but not significant
because she's going to go back to school in January
and she has zero student loan debt.
And we are hopefully going to be able to send her back
taking out very, very little,
maybe less than $5,000 in loans.
But that's not really what my question is about.
My question is, because I'm a federal employee,
she's eventually going to have to be working part-time
while she's in school.
She's going to go on my health, vision,
dental benefits, et cetera.
Pretty obvious reasons.
I have great coverage, so grateful.
But although I'm pretty confident that for 2024,
we were going to want to file separately,
if my labor contract gets awesome for some reason,
that may make our incomes more disparate
and then we would file jointly.
And I really want to make sure
when I put her on my benefits,
I don't screw up that we won't be able to decide
between jointly and separately because I have a FSA
and I really could not find the answer anywhere
that if we were to file separately,
but she has been reimbursed for healthcare costs
through my health insurance, but from my FSA,
if that is fair game.
I don't know if that makes sense
that she would be getting her medical costs reimbursed
from my FSA, but she, we're filing separately
is not like a dependent of mine
and like I'm a household of one.
I couldn't really figure out a straight answer.
It seemed pretty clear with dependents like children,
which we don't have any,
that they will be able to access my health insurance and FSA
even if they weren't claimed as a dependent on my taxes.
But I could not get a really clear answer on spouse
if you're filing separately.
Just want to make sure I don't mess that up.
And like, she's got to go on my health insurance.
So if that means we have to file jointly, that's fine.
It's just something to kind of plan ahead for
because it's definitely going to raise
my income based repayment,
which yeah, again, isn't until July of 25.
So I've got time, but as we're sending her back to school
and trying to budget for that,
I do want to kind of have the planning ahead
of what kind of loan payment might I need to budget for
if it is going to go up
because of the health insurance situation.
I would love your help with that.
Thanks again, really appreciate the podcast.
It's a huge help, especially since she doesn't have any loans
so it's just me trying to figure it out for me.
One thing I would say
is just don't let the tail wag the dog.
First of all, you got to think, is my loan forgivable?
Is it forgivable with all the context of all this mess
that's going on with the lawsuits and such?
Like we might be in a situation
where some people that have modest sized debts
just really cannot get forgiveness
because it just isn't functionally possible, right?
If the save plan goes away,
somebody might not be able to get their loans forgiven
via PSLF potentially.
So I think that would be step one
is figure out even if forgiveness is even on the table.
If it's not on the table,
then you don't have to worry about anything.
You should just file a joint
and not worry about any of it, right?
In terms of benefits in general,
the merit filing separate impact does have limits
on like how much you contribute to FSA
and HSA kind of situations.
A lot of times if you were,
and this is just me talking
based off of my conversations with the tax team,
I'm going to put that disclaimer out
that I'm not a tax professional
and we hire tax professionals.
But my understanding is that if you file separate,
if each of you has like your own HSA or FSA,
you can like contribute up to the max for you
and individually if you each have one,
but you can't do the full family contribution
to just one of yours.
In terms of paying out benefits,
I think that that's something that I would have to defer to
on the tax team to be honest.
My guess would be probably you couldn't
if you file separate.
But I do think that a spouse could be on your health
insurance if you're married filing separate.
So keep in mind like a lot of stuff with the IRS
does not impact your benefits.
Your benefits don't even know how you file your taxes
other than are you a spouse or not?
And then think about the tax status name,
married filing separate.
Well, it doesn't mean you're married, right?
It says it literally in the title of the status
of the tax filing.
The good news is married filing separate
very rarely has any negative impact on benefits
for the exception of HSAs and FSAs
tend to have a little bit lower cap if you do separate.
Now another question.
Hey, there's a question about the state's plan injunction.
Listen to the podcast episode.
So I know that with all the changes to IDR,
one thing that they introduced was if you were on
an income plan going towards forgiveness
and going towards PSLF, you could like pay ahead.
My payment is 60 bucks.
If I paid 600 at once, it would count as 10 payments
as if I, you know, it wasn't gonna count as one.
It would count for each month that I paid for.
And so I'm curious,
cause you could do it for as long as
until your recertification date.
Mine's like July of 25.
So I've saved in jeopardy,
but I could afford I'm getting a little bonus
to just pay my next 12 payments upfront now.
And then theoretically get 12 payments counted
towards my PSLF with the current payment amount.
Cause it's obviously gonna go up like
I'm sure there'll be speculation on your end,
but do you think that would be an option
to avoid paying a higher payment amount monthly?
If I just had the money to pay off the whole year
at the rate I currently have and get those 12 more months
until my recertification date in July of 25,
and then, you know, whatever happens happens
if my payments higher or lower,
then that's what it's gonna be.
So I'll just kind of maximize the low payment I have now
since I could afford to just pay a lump sum right now.
I'm sure it'll be speculation.
Cause if save goes away,
that may be something they would address.
I don't know.
So thanks.
So the problem with this whole injunction
is like the paid ahead stuff, paying a lump sum.
And I just wouldn't even fool with that right now.
It's so messy.
I've got just so little confidence
in Department of Education at the moment
that I just would not at all try to game the system
or anything unless I was forced to.
So what I mean by forced to is let's say your employer says
you have to use this money on your loans.
There's no ifs, ands, or buts about it.
And it's gotta go only towards loans.
You know, in that kind of situation,
if you have no choice at all,
if you cannot defer that reward till a future year
or a future period, if you are forced to do it,
then I would try to time it up
where it's right after your annual income certification date.
So if that's, say it's July 1,
I'd try to make a lump sum right after that
to get up to 12 months of credit in theory.
But the problem is, is right now,
they're issuing all kinds of conflicting guidance, frankly,
and just, it's all over the place.
And I just would not trust at all making any extra payments.
I think what we're gonna be living with
with this injunction is effectively,
it's either gonna say, hey, it's all okay,
in which case they'll probably try
to call this administrative forbearance
and retroactively count all of it.
If save is unexpectedly held up,
if part of save is struck down,
they might try to do the same.
And then if save is completely blocked,
then I think that they will try to do PSLF buyback
when people hit 120 months of credit.
That's gonna be a mess too,
but you'll have to make those payments
after the point where you think
you would have been at 120 payments.
Then you apply for PSLF buyback and you do a lump sum.
So it's just a big mess,
but I would just say the general answer is
you need to wait and then wait to do
that lump sum PSLF buyback like later.
Now, another question.
Hi, Travis.
My daughter is a recent May 2024 graduate
of veterinary school.
She'll be starting a new job in August,
making $130,000 a year.
Unfortunately, she's got student loan debt
of about $375,000.
With all the changes currently happening
in the student loan world,
especially with the late changes
to the save program and uncertainty,
what advice do you have for new 2024 grads
going forward and how they should plan
for their student loan programs?
Thank you.
So for new grads,
I think I would just say
you can't consolidate at the moment
with the injunction in place
and your grace period's six months.
So technically after your six month grace period is up,
you can apply for IDR,
and I probably would.
So if we still do not have an answer by,
you know, a lot of people graduate in June,
so six months after that,
it's basically November.
So if we still don't have an answer
on this whole save lawsuit by then
and the online application to consolidate
is still not present,
then I would probably just go ahead
and do a paper application
for income driven repayment,
and you could at least say,
hey, I applied,
and I applied for income-based repayment,
so at least you can start getting credit
on that $0 a month payment amount
based off of your most recent tax return.
So we have to do paper applications
for Parent PLUS borrowers all the time,
so we do know how to do it.
Basically, you have to submit an IDR application in there,
and you, you know, generally speaking,
have to also provide proof of income,
and it's a big old mess, to be honest.
But we're just gonna have to wait and see.
I think that's the short answer,
is I would just say the good news is
is if somebody just graduated,
it's probable that if you did,
you just graduated from vet school,
then like you probably were an undergrad
from 2016 to 2020,
and so if you are a new borrower as of 2014,
which becomes more and more and more likely
every single year, right,
because that new borrower as of 2014
means you didn't have any existing balance on that date,
and if you are a new borrower,
then IBR, which is in the statute of the law
and can't be touched without 60 votes in the Senate,
is the pay-as-you-earn plan, basically.
It's 20 years until forgiveness,
10% of your income.
It is guaranteed to offer forgiveness in the law,
so they can't just change it or touch it like that,
and it allows you to file taxes separately.
So I think for me,
I have comfort in just that overall picture
that somebody making 130 with 375K of debt
is still in great shape financially
because you can still treat that 375
as a very attractive income tax
instead of a, and I say attractive
because it provided the means to earn 130K
instead of coming out of undergrad and earning 70.
So you take 10% of your IDR payment
off the top of that 130.
That's about 117 or so, right, left over.
117 is the income as if you were making $0,
sorry, as if you had $0 of student loan debt.
So I think that there's still a lot of hope here.
There's still a lot of glass half-full situations,
even in this really confusing and difficult season.
Now another question.
Hi, my name is Annie.
I'm in Ohio.
I'm pursuing PSLF, and I'm on the safe plan.
I just want to confirm
that based on our current understanding,
administrative forbearance on our accounts
means these months do count towards PSLF.
You've probably said it before.
I think we would all be happy to hear it again confirmed.
Thanks.
I wanted to feature this one simply
because I wanted you guys to hear it from me.
It does not count.
It does not count, and I know that's difficult to hear.
I think I've hopefully said that many times
in the podcast here,
but I wanted to just make sure
that we have no misconception here
that this whole safe plan forbearance
does not count towards PSLF.
And the reason is because Department of Ed has vibes.
I mean, seriously, Department of Ed
is making it up as they go along.
They're not really following things very carefully.
I mean, it's like technically the injunction
stopped the whole safe plan rule
where the administrative forbearance counts towards IDR,
and then now it doesn't
because they put the kibosh on the whole rule.
But the thing is, what's kind of crazy
is like some of the administrative forbearance stuff
counting for PSLF is like in a different rule.
So it's like, why doesn't this count?
I don't have a great answer for you.
I think that it's because they're essentially saying
the safe plan is completely illegal in the injunction,
and therefore you can't,
it's not even a qualifying kind of period of forbearance
because it's not a qualifying plan in the first place.
I'm not real clear why Department of Education
decided to not count this period for PSLF,
but they are not counting it
unless there's an unexpected victory in the courts,
and then they would probably
retroactively try to count it.
So that's what we're dealing with right now.
And I hope they do retroactively change it,
but they're saying very clearly it does not count.
So let's do another question.
I had a question regarding people
who were prematurely asked to recertify their income.
So for background, I had my loans with Mohila,
and I had a $0 per month payment
because it's based on my income from back in like 2019.
And my income recertification date is in March every year.
And back in February,
Mohila asked me to submit documentation
to recalculate my payment,
after which my payment went from $0 per month
to $600 per month.
And shortly after that,
the Biden administration had pushed back
the income recertification dates
to no earlier than November of 2024.
At the time, my payment still showed
as being $600 per month with Mohila,
despite guidance from the federal government
are saying that if borrowers were asked
to prematurely recalculate their payment
and their payment went up,
it would go back to whichever payment was lower,
the old payment or the new recalculated one.
So my understanding is that my payment
should go back down to $0 per month.
I called Mohila about that,
and they said basically to just sit and wait,
and eventually it would go into their system
and be reverted back to $0.
But then my loans were subsequently transferred
to Ed Financial, where it still shows
I have a payment of $600 per month.
I've called them multiple times about this,
tried to explain it.
They're saying their hands are tied
because there's been some sort of freeze
or injunction on all of the IDR accounts,
and they're not able to make any adjustments
to monthly payments or recalculate any payments.
So as it stands, I now have a $600 per month payment
that I don't really want to make
because previously I was making $0 payments
that were counting towards forgiveness,
seemingly helpless staff at Ed Financial.
So I was just wondering,
I mean, surely I cannot be the only borrower
in this situation.
Have you guys encountered anything like this?
What are you guys recommending that people do?
Because as it stands now,
I'm sort of choosing between
either paying the $600 a month payment
that I really shouldn't be paying
on guidance of the federal government,
and just hope that one day it will be reimbursed
or continue to make my own $0 a month payments
and just wait for the federal government
to issue more further guidance,
and then hope that these missed payments that I'm making
eventually become recognized as $0 payments
that will contribute to my forgiveness counts for PSOF.
I'm looking forward to your input on this.
Thanks.
No, you are not the only person
dealing with this recertification problem.
So I want to give you guys a peek behind the curtain here
as to how the income recertification process works.
You might've heard that they're allowed
to just pull your information directly from the IRS info,
but I think that's part of the whole rule
that's currently been dealt the injunction.
And so what happens with this stuff
is 90 days before they tell you,
hey, it's time to submit your information
to recertify your IDR payments.
So that's 90 days before is when they tell you,
hey, it's about time to recertify your income.
And then 35 days before, roughly, they say it's due.
And they send you the information,
they send you an email,
hey, you've got to recertify, it's time.
And then 10 days before your recertification date,
if you haven't turned it in by that point,
you potentially get kicked out of the plan,
you can't stay on the,
well, you don't really get kicked out of the plan,
your payment just goes up to the cap, basically,
if you haven't submitted that information.
If you're on a capped plan, if you're on an uncapped plan,
they might switch you out of the,
you know, if you were on save or repay,
they might switch you into some sort of alternative,
standard type of plan or something like that.
So basically, the gist is,
if you're unsure about recertifying,
I would kind of wait until maybe a safe number
might be like half a month before,
two weeks before the actual due date,
because then you're not late,
but you're still waiting up until the very last second.
Now, I mean, to be honest, right now,
it doesn't even matter because, you know,
everything got recertified, but everything got frozen,
right, and so everybody's dealing with this
save for merits if you're on that.
Now, if you are on a different plan, right,
if you were on the pay plan or something like that,
or IBR, then it would matter more
about getting that payment recalculated
because that is the guidance from the Department of Ed,
that it's supposed to not happen,
certification before November 2024,
it's supposed to get kicked out
if you recertified earlier than that,
or if your date was before that,
and ultimately, it might require filing an FSA complaint,
so if you just Google search FSA complaint,
that is the quickest way to submit a complaint
about something that's wrong with your servicer,
and that's probably the most effective way
if you want to submit something quickly and efficiently,
and then you can escalate from there to like an Ombudsman,
you can do a CFPB complaint if you wanted to,
but also you could get your constituent services office
involved for your congressperson or senator,
and that's also effective
if all your other options just don't work.
So remember FSA complaint, it might come in useful
if you Google search that to submit a complaint next time
instead of just wasting hours on the phone
with these servicer reps that often have no idea what to do,
and just to avoid recertifying early,
and the next time you do it,
I would just know that rule about the 90-35-10 rule
where it's actually late at 10 days
before your certification date,
you can turn it in two or three weeks
before it's due without consequence.
Now for another question.
Hi, my name's Krista Ben-David.
I worked with Dan last year for the PSLF
and working towards my forgiveness.
My 120th payment is actually this month
or should be this month,
but with everything that's going on,
I'm just not sure that I'm eligible to submit
or how that would work for me.
I've been in forbearance through Mojila
since they've transitioned off of the platform,
I think since May,
and I haven't made a payment since then.
I don't fully understand the retrograde buyback
that you're talking about in your podcast,
so I wanted to come here and send a message
to see if you have any more information on that.
I have been submitting my verification through the hospital
pretty much every few months
so that I am up to date in my account
before it went out of the transition
was up to date since I think about January or February.
So I had only about six payments left,
which would have equated to August being the last payment.
Just curious on what your thoughts are
and what I should do, thanks.
So for this one,
I think that you need to go ahead
and try to do the PSLF buyback.
I think you need to wait
until you're at your 120th month of credit,
and then I think that you need to go ahead
and apply with the PSLF application
and say, I believe I qualify.
And then I think that I would go ahead
and try to be one of the very first people
to test the PSLF buyback and say,
hey, figure out what I should have paid
during these months that I was in forbearance,
and then I wanna be able to pay that as lump sum
and be done.
And then if you need to escalate things
or an FSA complaint
or getting constituent services involved
or even us involved,
email us after you've gone ahead
and applied for PSLF buyback
by submitting your actual formal application.
So I think you need to go ahead
and apply first,
and then I think that you need to,
potentially, if they have problems,
I think you need to do an FSA complaint,
and that'd be wonderful if you were successful
with PSLF buyback.
I think we need to have you on the podcast
because I think a lot of other people
wanna see how successful you've been with it as well.
So good luck,
and I hope you go ahead and submit
once you think you qualify,
which should be very, very soon.
Now let's do another question.
Hello, yes, thank you.
I appreciate your videos on Instagram.
I was wondering what's going on with,
specifically with aid advantages.
They've been saying that we're on forbearance
and 0% interest,
but then our balance keeps going up.
When I initially started asking some of the reps there,
they said, well, they're not sure
what's going on with the state plan.
And then now the vernacular is turned into,
well, since the state plan is on positive forbearance,
once it goes back into repayment,
they're gonna remove the interest.
I don't really have that in writing
other than one of the representatives put that in chat
and I printed out the chat,
so I just have something.
The other piece of it,
I made an extra payment
and it was under the lower state plan amount.
And instead of it going to principal,
it went to the interest since interest was accruing.
So then I had to call them
and tell them to move that payment
from being applied to interest
to being applied to principal.
So it makes it really complicated
to see how to navigate that
since it seems like the representative for aid advantage
really, they're kind of all over the place.
They're just now starting to have the same answer.
And on top of that,
it seems like if I do want to make extra payments
and make it towards principal,
it's kind of a pain in the butt
to call back after it processes
and make sure that it's applied to principal
and so on and so forth.
So just wanted to kind of hear your thoughts,
just curious what you've seen with that.
Thank you much.
Basically, what I would tell you
is every time servicers often make mistakes
and they often don't do something
and don't apply something,
Department of Education's promised,
until weeks or even a couple months
after they've promised it
because Department of Education,
again, just governs based on vibes
instead of based off of actually
a lot of things that are written down very clearly.
And so I think that's why some of this interest is accruing
is because Department of Ed hasn't really
helped servicers implement a lot of the things
that they have promised already.
And so I do think that that stuff will be reversed.
One point about payments being made to the interest
instead of the principal,
payments are always supposed to be applied first
to any existing accrued interest
that's already on the account.
So usually what happens is you have principal
and you have your accrued interest
and that's historical stuff that's just accumulated.
So technically, payments always go
towards accrued interest first
and then they go to principal.
It's money you still owe on that accrued interest,
so it still is fine to have the payment
go towards that accrued interest.
You're actually not even really supposed to have an option,
but it's just something to know
that it's a lot of times that accrued interest
is not current interest that's being charged,
it's interest that has already existed
from when you were an in-school deferment, for example.
So just a fun fact.
Let's do another question.
Hi, I have student loans that are parent plus
and some graduate loans.
I do work for a government,
so I should get loan forgiveness.
I thought the deadline was September, but it was incorrect.
That was in June,
so you could get credit for past payments you've made.
I didn't know what the best scenario is
for me moving forward.
Do I need to consolidate, move everything to a direct loan,
change whatever how the payment is?
Not sure how much that goes up a month,
but it's a sizable amount that I do owe.
Love to hear from you, whatever suggestions,
or if I need to subscribe
to get the student loan planner itself.
So hopefully I can figure out a plan
to get me out of debt in less than 10 years
to get some credit for my past ones.
Thank you.
So for this question, I mean, again, I would just say,
if you've missed the IDR account adjustment,
it's not the end of the world.
I think that your existing loans
might already have some credit,
like some of them might, right?
If you have any loans at all,
that your IDR account adjustment
possibly is sort of like somewhat applied
like to existing loans.
Now for the PS left adjustment,
you know, with forbearance and such,
I mean, it kind of depends, I think.
So I mean, I think what I would do is just,
first of all, can't do anything right now
because everything's on freeze anyway.
I would first go ahead and apply for PS left
and just go ahead and send all that stuff in,
at least get yourself on to being tracked.
And if you've got 10 years,
I'm assuming this person's up PS left eligible
for their parent plus and their grad loans themselves.
So I think that what I would try to do
is just try to first of all, get a plan overall,
figure out, you know, what would your payments be on ICR?
What would your payments be on IBR?
And then what would your payments be on save
if by some miracle it survives?
And then see if you could get forgiveness,
see if there's creative things you can do
to get low payments enough to get forgiveness
under any of those plans.
Sometimes you can get forgiveness
under all three of those plans
because your debt to income ratio just makes sense.
And then it's just,
you're going for forgiveness no matter what.
It's just the question is how much will you pay?
So I think you just got to figure out,
can you get forgiveness under all the plans
or just some of them?
And then you would want to think about
when they unblock consolidation,
could you potentially consolidate and get some credit
from like a weighted average kind of thing?
Because that's what the new rules are supposed to be
is they give you weighted average credit
instead of giving you credit
based on the loan that's the oldest.
So hopefully that helps.
And let's do another question.
So my question is,
is the PSLF and IDR waiver and consolidation waiver,
are those protected under any sort of law?
My main concern is I consolidated
to hopefully take advantage of payment count recalculation.
And my concern is at some point they're going to be like,
well, you consolidated and that resets your counter.
So I've been looking for clarification on that.
Obviously my hope is that they stay true to the word
and just update my payment count.
But I'm just curious about that,
if that's protected by any sort of law or statute.
So the honest answer about this one is no,
there is no law that protects the IDR waiver
or the PSLF waiver.
But we have to think bigger when it comes to these things.
Specifically stuff sticks to the degree
that it's impossible for anybody
at the Department of Education or otherwise to unwind it.
So in terms of the IDR account adjustment
and the PSLF waiver, right?
If they were to say, hey, this was not allowed,
that would require them to reinstate all the loans
that have already been forgiven.
If we're talking about something being overturned
like the IDR waiver or the PSLF waiver,
first of all, you would need a lawsuit that challenges it.
There is no lawsuit that is challenging that at all.
The IDR waiver and the PSLF waiver are already over.
So those are things have already finished.
That is very different from what happened with the save plan
where actively the law was about to go into place
or the rule was about to go into place in full
and they sued to block it.
If you really think about what it would mean
for the IDR waiver and the PSLF waiver to somehow be undone
by some court or some sort of administration or something,
you would have to go back
and reset everyone's payment count to zero.
That is something that probably does not get you
a bunch of savings in terms of like the CBO score.
So that's not like a revenue raiser really
in the same way that raising taxes would be a revenue raiser
or reducing spending would be a expense producer.
There wouldn't be really much of a political reward
for something like that,
whereas something like the save plan
has a very tangible CBO cost that is yet to be realized,
which is the $400 billion cost.
Why am I concerned by the save plan
to a lesser degree pay and repay?
Those are the things we have to pay attention to
because somebody challenged those before the period
that you can't really challenge it anymore.
If they had waited until save was fully in force,
they really would not have been able to challenge it.
So that's kind of why that happened the way it did.
Now, some people might hear my answer and say,
oh my gosh, should I be worried?
Answer is no, I don't think you should.
I really just think that is just a function of,
you just have to go based off
of what would be possible for them to undo
and what would not be possible for them to undo.
So let's do another question.
Hey, Travis, this is Aaron from Michigan.
I have a question about the buyback program
for PSLF being on the save plan.
I'm on track to hit the 120th payment
this month in August, 2024,
but like everybody else on the save plan,
I am now in forbearance,
so I can't make that payment currently.
My plan is to do a buyback so I get credit for it.
And I know I need to wait until after this month
in order to do it.
The question I have is about the timing
because I also know I need to have my employment certified.
So should I submit the employment certification form first
and wait for that to go through
before submitting the buyback request?
Or should I submit them at the same time?
Or should I do the buyback request first
and then submit the employment certification form
once I get the paperwork for that?
I've heard different things calling
into the student aid, Mojila people.
So I just would love your advice.
Thanks so much.
So for this one, I would be aggressive.
I would go ahead and submit
because you say you believe that you qualify.
I mean, that's kind of the way you do
with a PSLF application in any way.
If you haven't submitted your UCF form,
but you're already at the 120 months,
you submit basically the same PSLF application
basically that you use to certify your employment.
Along the way, you just check a different box.
So it just says, I believe I qualify
versus I'm looking to recertify my employment.
So I would just go ahead and submit that.
And then if you get rejected,
then you just have to probably appeal
and do this buyback stuff.
Because let's be frank, nobody's done the buyback before.
Really, this is the first time
anybody's even thinking about buyback
because of this administrative forbearance
from the state plan.
So you'll have to be a pioneer here
and just give it a try and let us know how it goes.
Another question.
I had applied and completed my double consolidation
of my Parent PLUS loans
with the final servicer being Mojila
as I work for a nonprofit and I want to pursue PSLF.
It is completed on the Mojila site
and payments began May 1st.
I had submitted a paper application for SAVE
as my income-driven plan
in order to qualify for PSLF at the end of May.
As nothing was showing on the Mojila site after a month,
I uploaded the application directly on their site
on July 2nd.
When I called mid-July,
I was told that they have both applications for SAVE
and it would be up to 90 business days
to process the application.
This was before the legal stays.
The FSA site still has the final consolidation
listed as under review
with a date in April of earlier this year.
With my paper SAVE still floating somewhere at Mojila,
is it worth sending in a second application for IBR?
It doesn't seem like pay is being offered,
but that might be also due to current stays.
I would not, in this case, submit a second application.
I would just say that there's nothing else we can do
but wait.
I mean, ultimately for Parent PLUS borrowers, right,
that were hoping for the SAVE plan that might not get it,
what do you do?
Well, repay could be an option.
Pay could be an option when the debt settles.
And worst case scenario, IBR should be an option.
And IBR is a lot more generous than the ICR plan
because it's 15% of income
with 150% of the poverty line as a deduction.
And that's if you're not a new borrower.
If you're a new borrower, then it's even better.
Now, for Parent PLUS borrowers,
a lot of those folks would not qualify
for the new IBR status
because of being a new borrower as of 2014.
But I did have a Parent PLUS borrower recently
who was a new borrower
because she had her own loans from like the 80s and 90s.
And then she took out loans for her kids,
you know, 2016 to now.
And so she was a new borrower
because her old loans were already paid off
when she borrowed her first loan after 2014.
So a lot of loopholes, but I know it's frustrating.
Let's do another question.
Hi, this is Justin.
The one aspect that I don't ever see reflected
in any of the calculators or on your blog
is how to think about when you have a gap
between your undergrad and grad.
I wasn't quite sure if your loans aren't consolidated,
if they get forgiven at different timelines,
and then how that would potentially affect your payments.
I just never see this piece actually addressed.
And I feel like it's a relatively common situation.
So for this one, I think that, you know,
you just want to think in terms of,
did you get any credit during the ID or waiver?
If you did, then that could potentially be added
to your entire consolidated loan.
But if you have undergrad loans, you have a gap,
and then you took out grad loans,
there are two different forgiveness timelines.
Now, you know, in terms of
the two different forgiveness timelines,
you know, it depends on what happens with the save plan,
because that's the only one, you know,
repay used to be 20 years for undergrad,
25 years for grad.
You know, new IBR is 20 years for everything.
Old IBR is 25 years for everything.
So, you know, we just have to see what the desk settles
with this lawsuit stuff.
And then we got to kind of figure out
what you would do based off of
however the desk settles, basically.
Hopefully that helps.
I know it's a pretty common situation.
What usually happens, though, is the undergrad debt,
at least for a lot of our clients, is very tiny
compared to the grad debt in a lot of cases.
And so then you really get a situation
where the grad debt is dominating the strategy,
and the undergrad debt is just sort of along for the ride,
because, you know, a lot of times it's not a huge amount.
It's $20,000 to $30,000,
compared to maybe five to 20 times that amount, potentially.
If you did a dental specialty residency,
it'd be probably 20 times the undergrad amount.
So that's just kind of why we don't go into that case,
because the undergrad debt doesn't drive the strategy
the grad debt does.
Now, another question.
Hi, my name is Jane.
I'm a longtime listener,
and I guess second time following on.
I had two questions that came up during the transition
from the old Mojillo platform to the new Mojillo platform.
I just got off the phone after being on the phone
with Mojillo for an hour and a half
before I eventually got hung up on by my representative,
who had placed me on hold many times.
So I thought I would come here next.
When the transition happened,
I received a notice that my interest had been capitalized,
which I thought seemed wrong,
because I didn't ask to be transitioned between platforms.
To be clear, I am not on the save plan.
I'm not a public service loan forgiveness person.
I'm on the pay as you earn plan.
So I received a notice that my interest had been capitalized.
So that was obviously very concerning.
I thought this must be a mistake.
I used the secure messaging platform,
and they said my inquiry was too complex
for them to answer that I should call.
So I waited to see maybe it was a mistake
and it will be addressed.
I got my August notice of my statement,
and it said that my interest had been capitalized,
that my new balance was $25,000 more
than it had previously been of my principal.
So I finally called,
and I was told that it was not because of the forbearance,
placed on hold for a very long time
until I was given an explanation
related to something called a monitor run.
And so my question for you is what is a monitor run?
Are student loan servicers allowed to look
at how our repayment has been going?
Which to be clear, I've never missed a payment.
I've been on auto pay the whole time
and I've made many extra payments for my loan.
The only time I didn't make payments
was during the COVID forbearance.
I asked many questions about what a monitor run was.
I could not find anything about it on the internet.
So she said, maybe it's an internal term.
So I'm hoping that this is something
that one of you has heard before
that you could address on the podcast.
My second question was about auto pay
on the new MoGila platform.
My instructions were not translated properly
for auto pay when it transitioned.
So I had been paying an extra $300 a month
on top of my pay as you earn amount,
since it was based off my 2018 income
and I can afford a bit more now.
So when that was transferred over,
it was transferred over incorrectly.
So the 500 total dollars was spread out
among all the loans.
So as a result, I could not figure out how to change it.
I tried many things until finally I canceled my auto pay
and then I reset it up,
which I still couldn't figure out how to set it up.
So I just set it for the minimum payment for now
so I could direct my additional payments
to the highest interest loan.
So my question is, is there any way to properly do this?
I tried to do it over the messaging.
It wouldn't let me when I was on the phone with them earlier.
She said she couldn't do anything
because since I had canceled it,
it didn't show as being set up again yet,
even though it shows on my end.
And as a result, because I pressed cancel,
apparently now for a month or two,
however long it takes for them
to get the auto pay properly set back up,
I will not get my 0.25 interest rate reduction,
which is a big bummer.
I guess a little bummer, it's not that much money.
Anyways, I hope that you could help with those two questions.
One, about what the heck is a monitor run
and am I being bamboozled
with this interest rate capitalization?
And number two, how can I get my auto pay instructions
to be followed by Mojito?
Thank you so much.
Yeah, this totally sounds like something
they just made up for the lulls.
I mean, I'm like, what?
What are they even talking about?
I mean, maybe they saw some sort of like
forbearance or something
that they should have capitalized the interest
and they didn't and then they should have,
but that just sounds really bizarre.
So I think that I would probably file an FSA complaint.
That's what I typically tell people, right?
I would just go to the FSA complaint,
just Google search, that's what I would do,
and then go to the website
and then just file the complaint.
And that's a lot more efficient
than dealing with the servicer directly
because then Department of Ed jumps in
and they just have a process
for how they handle and resolve complaints.
So that's one way I would do it.
The other thing I would say
is I would be a little concerned
that you said you're paying extra
and you're on the pay plan
just because a lot of times if you're on pay,
you probably need to go for forgiveness, right?
So if you're doing pay,
I guess what I like to do is say,
keep all your options open for forgiveness just in case.
And until you're like totally sure
that you're gonna go pay off your loans,
I'd kind of tell people not to pay extra on their loans.
Take the money, invest it,
max your retirement accounts,
build your emergency savings,
maybe buy a house,
literally do everything else but pay extra on your loans.
And then when you were absolutely positive
you're gonna pay off your loans,
you wanna have good term life insurance,
good disability insurance,
especially if you're in a medical profession.
And then from a position of strength,
then you start making ginormous payments.
And your first payment should probably be enormous
just because you're really committing.
I kind of like that approach
versus paying two or $300 a month extra.
But if you're really positive,
you're gonna go for payoff
and it's not unreasonable to do what you're doing.
But I would just follow the episode
and complain to try to get that interest non,
what's the word, uncapitalized, I guess.
So yeah, one more question basically
is one I'm getting a lot from people
and it's sort of like, what do I do?
What do I do?
I mean, do I need to be worried?
Can I still get forgiveness?
To me, this is kind of like a situation
where there's a big lawsuit
and we just don't know what the resolution's gonna be.
And it's kind of like one of those situations
where the estate tax limit is 10 million exemption
and it's set to go down to one million
and you're somebody with a small business
that's worth $5 million and you're old
and you're about to pass away
and you're like, oh, I don't wanna have
my entire business valuation taxed at 40%
so I can pass it on to my kids.
Tax legal advisor, what should I do?
Should I panic?
And the reality is is usually Congress does the right thing
but at the very last second,
knowing when they're forced to.
So this is a situation where the courts
are just like really stepping in aggressively.
I mean, you could really say that the,
you know what I mean, the executive branch
stepped in pretty aggressively as well, right?
I mean, so everybody's stepping in aggressively
with their preferred policy outcomes
and it's just gonna be settled by the courts
and then from a point of political pressure,
Congress might intervene and jump in.
And so what I think will happen is
if it's just an imposition of the pre-COVID rules,
which I think, again, is the most likely scenario,
that is not a disaster.
It is not good, I wanna be clear, it's not good,
but it's not a disaster
because if it was just pre-COVID rules, pay repay IBR,
those are things we can navigate around.
A lot more people are eligible for new IBR nowadays
than they were back in the day
when I first started doing this by a long shot.
So, you know, we can still get people a lot of benefits,
that's a lot of relief if it's pre-COVID rules.
If it's only IBR and that is it,
we will have to get a lot more creative.
We will have to be a lot more careful with like things like
what is your AGI, what is your payment cap?
We're gonna have to get a PhD level review
of payment cap calculations
to make sure people will be below caps and such
if they're going for loan forgiveness
or PSLF or something like that.
So, but we're not there yet,
so we just have to keep waiting.
And I appreciate you listening through
a pretty long episode today.
This is a little bit longer one,
but I thought all of the questions were so good
and I just really wanted to get to as many
as I possibly could.
If you wanna ask a question
that we'll feature on the podcast,
you can go to studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
Again, that's studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
And if you have the question,
I guarantee a lot of other people have the question too.
And we clearly have a lot of listeners
who have just a lot on their minds
and a lot of concerns right now.
So I'm really grateful everybody spent time to call in.
And if you need a backup plan for Save Repeal,
you can go to studentloanplanner.com slash book.
Thank you so much for listening to another episode
of the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
Have a wonderful week.