Renoir, The Grands Boulevards

Classic Art
36 followers
I think to us in the early 21st century,
this painting looks like quaint old Paris.
It does.
We see a horse and carriage.
We see a woman wearing a long Victorian dress
with a bow on the back and a pretty hat
strolling with her two children.
It really does look like a very quaint scene.
But to Renoir and to the people depicted on this boulevard,
this would have been incredibly modern.
This was a brand new boulevard that rebuilt Paris.
This was a new world.
This was as modern and as contemporary
as you could get in the 1870s.
And it's modern not only in terms of what it's depicting,
but it's modern in terms of how it's depicted.
This painting was made only one year
after the first Impressionist exhibition.
That term, Impressionism, had just been coined.
The idea of representing the city
in a series of fleeting brushstrokes
that seemed to catch the moment was a radically new idea.
Renoir was one of a group of artists who were doing this
who became known as the Impressionists,
who had, as you said,
their first exhibition the year before.
So we might think about Monet or Camille Pissarro
and Degas, all of them painting different aspects
of this new sense of modern life in Paris.
Paris was, at this moment, being rebuilt
from an old city with narrow, winding streets
to a city of wide boulevards flooded with light,
a planned city lined with shops and cafes and trees,
the city of Paris that we know and love today.
It was to be the new imperial city under Napoleon III.
And it wasn't just the architecture
or the city planning that was being rebuilt.
In a sense, French culture was being rebuilt.
It was just five years earlier
that France had been humiliated in their defeat
against the Germans in the Franco-Prussian War.
And here we have a rebirth of a kind of modern optimism.
But none of that politics is apparent.
Ben was interested in giving us a cross-section
of what we might see if we walked outside
onto the boulevards in Paris.
So on the left, we have a figure sitting alone on a bench,
reading a newspaper.
Just to the right, we have two men who are talking,
who look rather well-dressed, maybe businessmen.
Then just to the right of that,
that small family led by a mother,
and then some figures in a carriage coming our way.
The city was a place to view,
and one could be a kind of dispassionate onlooker,
a flaneur.
You said before that the form of the painting
was also radically modern.
And I think that's also hard for us to understand,
because to us, it looks quite normal.
And we love Impressionist paintings like this.
But the sketchiness that we see here is radical.
Renoir has reduced these trees to big, broad brushstrokes
in some areas that sweep across,
and also little dabs of paint.
He's not rendering the type of tree
that's represented here.
We might guess that it might be a London plane tree, perhaps,
but we don't know precisely what it is.
This is not about conveying the specifics
of any individual form,
rather than representing the momentary.
And that notion of the momentary, of the fragmentary,
is such a modern and urban idea.
It's really perfect for this scene.
Well, in representing the fleeting,
but also representing an optical experience.
What does this look like to my eye at this moment?
Not what I know about a tree,
but how I actually perceive and experience that tree
with the light coming through it on a bright summer day.
And he's remarkably successful in doing this.
Look at the carriage, for instance,
with the white horse and the driver,
and then the couple in the back.
It's only the barest notations,
and yet it feels as if that horse
is moving forward towards us,
and we can almost hear its hoof falls.
So this becomes an environment
that is filled with light, motion, and filled with sound.
We talked about this painting
as being this remarkably new and modern image
in both its form and its content.
But in some ways, Renoir is also stepping back
just a little bit.
He's giving us some clues about a recession into space.
We have a diagonal line
that appears to recede into the background,
much like a traditional orthogonal
going from the bottom right,
and moving back up toward the left.
And especially at the top of the apartment houses
and the top of the trees.
Exactly, but we fail to really calculate
a measurable distance into space,
and that was something that was required
of paintings in the 19th century.
And he's also not quite dissolving
the form of the human body
as much as, for example, Monet is from exactly this time,
like the Boulevard de Capucines, for example.
The figures are really reduced
to just a short few strokes of paint,
and you can't see fashion, you can't see gesture.
Very characteristic of Renoir
is this interest in human beings and their social lives.
We're still getting a sense of family groups,
of people talking to one another, of sociability.
This was a city inhabited,
and Renoir has created that social dynamic
that populated this new urban experience.
Right, but where other artists are interested
in depicting the sense of alienation
or aloneness of that experience in the city
that was really different from the small-knit communities
that had made up Paris before that,
Renoir is showing us this more optimistic side
of modern life.
โชโชโช
