Pilot's Reckless Mistakes Kills Instagram Star!
2 Video Views·Oct 2, 2024
This haunting video was taken just moments before a pilot's reckless mistake killed a plane full of
Instagram stars shortly after takeoff. Several of the passengers posted photos and video literally
minutes before they were to meet a fiery death. Sit back and get ready because this is a tragic
story with a lot of lessons that we can learn from. I'm Hoover and welcome to your Pilot Debrief.
Our story takes place in Scottsdale, Arizona in the early evening hours
when a Piper Comanche aircraft carrying six people crashed and was destroyed
just 70 seconds after takeoff. The 23-year-old Instagram model Mariah Coogan posted this video
as she boarded the aircraft. Mariah is sitting in the middle row and seated next to her is 28-year-old
Anand Patel. Anand was a successful entrepreneur and social media influencer who is known by the
nickname Happy. Happy shared this photo just prior to the flight as he was excited for what might have
been his first time flying on a private aircraft. Seated in the back of the airplane are 22-year-old
Helena Lagos who is a part-time Las Vegas fashion model and 23-year-old Iris Rodriguez who is
visiting from Honduras. You can see the two pilots in Mariah's video but there's two important things
you need to know. First, this video is reversed because of how Mariah filmed it so this is the
way it should look and the second thing is that only one of these guys is a real pilot.
32-year-old Eric Valente is the real pilot on this aircraft and he's sitting in the right seat.
Eric has an airline transport pilot certificate and is a certified flight instructor and he had
about 5,200 hours of total flight time but he only had about 200 hours flying Piper Comanches
and the very first time that he flew the accident aircraft was when he flew it from north Las Vegas
down to Scottsdale to pick up the student pilot. The chief pilot at the company that Eric worked
for said that he was a great pilot and he will be missed but we'll talk more about Eric later.
28-year-old James Pedroza is a student pilot and he's sitting in the left seat for the flight.
About two months prior to the crash, James shared on Instagram how he had just bought the aircraft
but really he had only bought a fractional interest and I'll explain why that's important
later. For now, what you need to know is that even though James is an avid traveler, he's
essentially a brand new student pilot and he's the one that's organized this trip. The other thing
that's really important to know is that student pilots are not permitted to act as pilot in
command of an aircraft that is carrying a passenger. This means that James should have been
in the right seat and Eric should have been in the left seat and this should have been a
non-instructional flight but this was just the first reckless mistake that contributed to this tragedy.
In order to understand all the contributing factors to this disaster and see how some of
the holes in the Swiss cheese model lined up, it's important to understand how James and Eric
ended up flying together. You see, James didn't really own the plane. He bought kind of a fractional
interest in it from his friend Josh. The real owner of the plane was someone that we'll call Mr. B.
James was down in Scottsdale and he wanted to take his friends up to Las Vegas where he was a VIP
host at the Mirage nightclub. The only problem was the plane was at the North Las Vegas airport
and James needed someone to fly it down and pick them up. James's old flight instructor had backed
out of the trip so James called Josh for help but Josh was also unable to bring the plane down so
Josh put James in touch with Eric Valente to do the trip. However, when Eric heard that James was a
student, he told Josh that this flight would not be instructional in nature because he hadn't even
sat down with James to do any ground lessons. Now keep that in mind because remember Eric is in the
right seat for the flight and James is in the left seat and wait until you hear what Eric said
on the radio. The other thing that's worth noting that almost prevented this flight from happening
is the fact that the aircraft owner, Mr. B, he only met Eric for the first time on the day of
the accident and he questioned who he was and he even considered not letting him take the aircraft
but he eventually agreed to let Eric proceed with the flight. The other shocking thing is that the
had no idea that James planned to take four passengers with him on the trip and perhaps
if the owner knew that then he most likely wouldn't have allowed the flight to happen.
The aircraft they're flying is tail number November 9456 Papa and it's a 1964 Piper PA24-260
Comanche. This is a video that was shared on Instagram by James, the student pilot, and you
can see just how small the aircraft is even though this aircraft is marketed as capable of having
seating for six most pilots won't take more than four adults especially if you have luggage or they
might only allow for a dog or a small child in the very back and if you look closely at this image
from the video according to the owner these are just seat cushions resting against the floor
there's nothing holding them in place and the investigation confirmed that there was no seat
structure in the aft area where two of the girls were sitting. Look if someone tries to get you to
fly in a plane that doesn't have a properly secured seat that might be your first clue to not
get on the plane and just because an aircraft has six seats in it that doesn't necessarily mean it
can carry six adults but we'll talk more about that later because that wasn't the only issue
on this flight. At the time of the flight there weren't any known malfunctions with the aircraft
so the pilots had every reason to believe the aircraft was in an air worthy condition
in fact all of the previous flights the aircraft seemed to fly just fine without any problems.
According to a witness James showed up at the airfield with his four friends and while they
were hanging out waiting for Eric to show up with the plane the witness overheard James talking about
how he needed just a few more hours before he could solo the aircraft. The witness also said
that he was surprised to find out that all of them were going to try to fit in the airplane
but he didn't say anything about it. The witness would go on to say that after Eric showed up with
the plane during the boarding process Eric came into the lobby and he appeared flustered but Eric
didn't say anything. Remember Eric had said this was not going to be an instructional flight that
meant Eric flew down there planning on James flying in the right seat for the trip back to Vegas.
That's why in my opinion I think there's two reasons that Eric might have appeared flustered.
First just like the aircraft owner it's possible that Eric had no idea there were going to be four
passengers showing up with James for the flight and I think the second reason he might have been
flustered is that maybe James asked Eric if he could sit in the left seat and be the one to do
the takeoff or fly the plane perhaps wanting to show off a little bit for his friends.
Eric has enough experience and training to know that James shouldn't be in the left seat
and I can't think of any other really good reason why James would end up sitting there
and the truth is we don't know why James ended up in the left seat and it wasn't possible for
the NTSB to determine who performed the takeoff or who was on the controls when they crashed.
However I wanted to share my opinion because I can see how Eric might have found himself in a
difficult position because he's about to get hired as the instructor so he'd be risking his job if he
said no and refused to do the flight. I'll talk more about this later but one of the big lessons
from this tragedy is that it's so important for pilots whether you're an instructor or not
to set limits before you fly with someone or before you take a job. You have to be willing
to say no or just walk away from a flight sometimes and unfortunately Eric gets in the
aircraft in the right seat and they taxi out for takeoff. The tower controller cleared the
flight to taxi to runway 03 for takeoff. This runway is over 8,000 feet long and the tower
is located near the center of the runway. Using footage from some of the airfield cameras the
NTSB was able to piece together what happened. From the time they start the takeoff roll to the
time they impact the ground is only about 70 seconds. As soon as they get airborne the tower
controller noticed the wings rocking left and right. Another witness on the ground confirmed
seeing something similar saying the nose was also pitching up and down and the movements were so
aggravated it almost seemed as if the pilot was playing around. The tower controller said that
eventually the aircraft appeared to be stable on wings level flight as they passed by the control
tower which remember is halfway down the runway. However the controller said it didn't sound like
the aircraft had enough engine power so listen to what she said and the pilot's response.
I'll talk about the pilot's response in a minute but as the aircraft continued to fly away
it started a left-hand turn near the departure end of the runway. It continued that left turn
until it went into a nose down configuration and crashed. You can see what happens in this video
clip here. This was taken from a traffic camera and you'll see the aircraft enter the frame at
the top right as it's making the left-hand turn. I have to warn you though that this footage might
be tough to watch for some viewers.
What caused them to crash? First of all we know that from witness testimony they confirmed it was
Eric talking on the radio who said we're good we're just a training lesson. To me that indicates that
it's possible that James was the one doing the takeoff and although the aircraft was struggling
to climb Eric might have just assumed that that was due to the fact that James was flying and not
necessarily because there was anything wrong with the aircraft. The temperature at the time of their
takeoff was 28 degrees celsius or 82 degrees fahrenheit and because the field elevation is
about 1500 feet that gave them a density altitude of around 3000 feet. According to the NTSB
under those conditions at max gross weight the aircraft should have been capable of climbing at
a rate of 700 feet per minute but here's what really happened. The blue line on this chart
shows the aircraft altitude during the flight. You'll notice that the data starts when the
aircraft is already 59 feet above the ground and that's because the camera footage prior to that
was washed out so the NTSB had to approximate what happened before that point. The NTSB concluded the
aircraft started its takeoff roll about 45 seconds prior to the first data point on this chart and
became airborne 18 seconds prior to this point. That means it took them 18 seconds to climb 59
feet above the ground and then they continued the climb at only 270 feet per minute for the
next 27 seconds and then after that they virtually stopped climbing. The most important thing you can
take away from this is that when you try to take off if your aircraft isn't performing the way you
expect it to perform then as long as you have runway in front of you just abort the takeoff and
set it back down on the ground. These are the kind of things that Eric should have been thinking about
before they took off. This is only his second flight in the aircraft he's letting the students
sit in the left seat it's night time and it's probably an unfamiliar airfield for Eric and he's
got a fully loaded aircraft. This is another great reminder to always use the full length runway
whenever you have it available for takeoff because remember it took them 18 seconds to make
it 59 feet in the air and at that point they had over 4,000 feet of runway remaining to set it back
down and figure out what's wrong. The tower even asked them if there was a problem and for some
reason Eric said they're a training lesson and they keep flying even though the aircraft wasn't
climbing and as soon as they started that left hand turn they exceeded the critical angle of
The NTSB determined that one of the contributing factors to the crash was the number three engine
cylinder valve spring. The spring had broken into four pieces and examination of the other five
cylinders revealed no anomalies. The investigation concluded that the spring failure happened during
a previous flight but they couldn't determine how long ago that was and that spring failure
caused a degraded engine power output which reduced the aircraft's climb capability but this
wasn't the root cause of the tragedy. If you remember from earlier James had bought a fractional
interest in the aircraft from his friend Josh. That's how James was able to use the aircraft.
On the day of the accident Josh must have had a premonition because Josh was worried about the
number of passengers on the plane and their weight and he texted James and this is the text conversation
Unfortunately James has no idea how to do that so Josh asked him about the passengers and their
luggage. James listed off only five weights even though there's six people on the trip. Those
weights added up to 675 pounds and James said they'd only have about 10 pounds of luggage.
Josh asked him about the gross weight of the plane which really he's asking him what the
useful load is and James correctly said that it's 1,200 pounds. That's basically how much
weight they can carry for passengers, luggage, usable fuel, and drainable oil. Ultimately Josh
says they're good but he told James to go over all this with Eric and this is just another hole in
the Swiss cheese model because Josh highlighted the risk and assumed that James would at least
go over the numbers with Eric. Unfortunately my guess is that never happened and perhaps Eric
didn't bother to do a weight and balance calculation either because the combined weight
of all six passengers was actually almost 950 pounds and that meant they were about 135 pounds
over their max gross weight when they took off and their center of gravity was just over two inches
after their limit and I'm sure that to this very day Josh regrets not doing more to keep them safe.
The broken cylinder spring that I mentioned earlier wasn't detectable on previous flights
because those flights weren't done near the max gross weight. However it became very noticeable
when they tried to take off with six people on board and they needed all the engine power they
could get. It really sucks that the spring was broken because if it wasn't then they just might
have survived but that's no excuse for not doing a weight and balance calculation or making the
other reckless mistakes on this flight and to top it all off the toxicology test found cocaine and
ecstasy in James's blood and urine but because it was such a low amount and due to the fact that
cocaine has a very short half-life the NTSB determined that drug use was not a factor in
this tragedy. The NTSB said the probable cause was the flight instructor's failure to maintain
aircraft control during the initial climb as a result of the aircraft being loaded above its
maximum gross weight. However I think the root cause of this tragedy was Eric's decision to
conduct the flight with James in the left seat and it sucks because I think Eric found himself
in a tight spot and he didn't say no. He could have easily done a weight and balance and said
I'd really like to take you but the weight is just too much and I've only flown this aircraft
once before or if he really felt compelled to do the flight then he should have made James sit in
the right seat and then perhaps Eric would have recognized how poorly the aircraft was performing
and made the decision to set it back down on the runway but we'll never know for sure and six lives
were lost in this terrible tragedy. If you want to watch another video about some reckless mistakes
that other pilots have made be sure to check out one of these other videos on the screen
and I'll see you next time.

