Homes Sales Are Climbing With Lower Mortgage Rates

Property Profit
1 follower
I'll just open with this today.
The rate of home sales is picking up,
especially compared to last year at this time.
The number of homes in contract across the country
has risen for the last few weeks.
The purchase mortgage applications
are up for five weeks in a row.
It seems like mortgage rates
that are getting closer to 6%
are starting to shake loose a few transactions.
These moves are small and it's early.
It's not a big rush of home sales, of course,
but we're just looking for any signs of resuscitation
for this body, which has been nearly dead
all year long in most of the country.
And we can finally start to see some.
So in the video today,
we'll look at the latest pending home sales data
and also the pricing data
where we can see just a tiny bit of heartbeat
in the home buyer activity.
The home buying metrics are showing slightly higher
than a few months ago
and higher than last year at this time.
Last year in the fourth quarter,
the skies were darkening quickly
as the mortgage rates rose to 8%.
Now it's too early to declare victory.
Of course, we're just teasing out
the first signals of hopeful recovery
in the weekly data.
Next week, we're doing our October webinar.
That's Thursday, October 10th at 10 a.m. Pacific.
It's a super fun time to be watching the data deeply.
So where and how much can we see
the home buyer behavior changing right now?
We'll cover all the details in the webinar.
If you really need to understand what's happening,
especially at the local level,
we'll spend the full hour diving into that data.
So there's a link in the description below
to register and join us for the webinar next Thursday,
October 10th.
Click that to save your spot.
There's so much going on in the data right now.
Don't miss it.
At Altos Research, of course,
we track every home for sale in the country every week.
All the pricing, all the supply and demand,
all the sales, all the changes in that data
so that you can understand it immediately as it happens.
I'm Mike Simonson.
I'm the founder of Altos Research,
and it's now the end of the third quarter, 2024.
It's been a really weak year for home sales,
but maybe, just maybe this market is turning the corner.
So let's look at this week's data.
There are 362,000 single-family homes in contract.
So starting with the pending home sales today,
that's been climbing all September.
That number has been climbing all September
from like 357,000 earlier in the month.
It was just under a 1% increase for the week.
And we compare that to last year and 2022
when home sales were falling by 1% per week.
So this is measuring the total count of homes
that are in contract right now.
We're showing 6% more homes in contract
than last year at this time.
So homes stay in contract for 30 to 40 days.
At the end of the month, a bunch of sales closed.
So next week, we'll have more sales completed
and fewer homes still in contract.
So there's a step down each month
of the first week of the month.
So next week, we'll start October
with fewer sales still in the pending process.
There are 362,000 single-family homes in contract now.
Next week, we'll maybe have 350,000
as a bunch of those sales will have closed.
So that's the total homes in contract.
When homes are taking offers faster
than the sales are closing,
the pending count, this pending count climbs.
And that's what we had in September.
So when we look at the new contracts pace,
the homes that took offers
and went into pending status this week,
we want to know if that pace is up or down also.
And in fact, the pace of new contracts
picked up 1% this week to 63,000 single-family homes
with another 12,000 condo sales underway.
So we're showing here this new pendings data.
The new pendings are up 1% for the week.
And this week saw 11% more contracts started
than last year at this time.
So 11% more offers this week than last year.
In fact, this week, there were more sales started
than either of the last two years.
Remember that this was when mortgage rates
were spiking in the fall of 22 and 23.
The breaks were on hard for the fourth quarter,
both those years.
So the comparison,
while we don't have a lot of sales happening,
is definitely more than either of the last two years.
And you can see the lines here from 22 and 23
really tanking at the end of September.
So the weekly number ticked up from last week.
That's a good sign.
The comparison against last year is getting very easy now.
So we should continue to show year-over-year home sales gains
for the whole fourth quarter.
In this view here,
we're of the weekly new contracts pending.
You can see the dark line at the right end of the chart
is definitely coming in ahead of the last two years.
See that steep drop in the 2022 line in particular.
So these comparisons are now easy.
And it's the fall,
so sales won't continue to climb week over week.
But if we continue this relative strength,
you're going to start to hear the headlines shift positive.
So this is the evidence right here
that the consumers are reacting just a little bit
to cheaper mortgage rates.
Now, I've been pointing to this moment for several weeks now,
and it just hit.
The question is,
does the momentum keep up into the first quarter of next year?
Because that's when it'll really count.
So inventory has been climbing too.
Last year at this time,
people who were expecting mortgage rates to fall in 2024
would ask me if falling mortgage rates
would potentially lead to a lot of pent-up sellers in 2024,
who would perhaps flood the market with listings,
which might then be imbalanced with buyers
and lead to a price correction.
So remember that fear, that question from back then?
Like at the time, it seemed very clear to me
that if rates fell in 2022,
inventory would fall also.
If rates rose, inventory would rise.
So that fear was misplaced.
And it turned out rates rose or stayed high
all the way into the third quarter of 2024,
and inventory rose that whole time too.
So now rates are falling.
They're past their peak.
What's going to happen with inventory?
Inventory is still rising right now.
It's not super late in the year
for the supply of unsold homes to keep climbing,
but it could be that maybe we're seeing lower rates
shaking loose some of those sellers
who've been sitting on the fence for two years.
I think we're probably seeing investors
in the big markets like Central Florida and Texas
maybe look to unload some underperforming assets.
Those states, which had appeared to have topped out
in inventory a few weeks ago,
have recently had supply re-increasing.
The sales rates, though, in those places are inching up too.
So it's not just inventory dumped on the market.
More home sales is really meaning slightly more.
More homes for sale means slightly more sales can happen.
So we had the Hurricane Helene this week,
which disrupted a big chunk of the country.
Next week, I'm looking for declines in inventory
and new listings.
Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, North Carolina.
It can sometimes be surprisingly difficult
to see the immediate impacts of natural disasters,
but this was a big one,
so I expect we'll be able to track it.
It wouldn't surprise me to have inventory
knocked down a couple percent next week,
and that'll throw a wrench into all our forecasting models.
So we'll keep a watch on that.
Meanwhile, new listings.
There were 63,000 new listings unsold this week
with another 9,400 immediate sales.
It's not a lot, but it's slightly more.
It's a slightly more healthy pace than last year.
So I chatted with an Atlanta broker friend this week
who mentioned they've suddenly had
a few more multiple offer scenarios on the best listings,
which hasn't been happening all year.
The immediate sales rate where we would track that,
the immediate sales as a percent of inventory still
is about as low as it's been since we've been tracking.
So that number doesn't show any real broad gains in demand
despite that anecdote,
but it is something to keep watching.
So in total, there were 6% more sellers this year than last.
That's in the range where it's been all year.
It's not a flood of sellers,
and we really still want to see more sellers.
We want to see that continued growth
in the listings volume.
That means more selection for buyers
and ultimately means more sales.
The new listings count dropped this week from last,
and I mentioned last week that I expected it to do so.
In this chart, you can see this year's line
is generally fewer sellers than in years prior,
except for 2023.
We've talked about how the market
was really shutting down hard last year,
so sellers were running away.
And so what I believe this is a healthier market
requires growing new listings, and it has been.
So 5%, maybe 10% more sellers each week than a year ago.
Now, at the same time, as I've mentioned,
I'm always on the lookout for conditions
that get imbalanced, too many of one side.
So if, for example, that fear of lower rates
will shake loose a bunch of pent-up seller supply,
maybe too much, that forces prices to plummet.
So that's the fear.
If that were to happen,
we'd see it in this new listings line here.
It would have to start climbing
above the gray lines of the past.
We don't see that.
What we see is maybe healthy market growth.
Do I dare call it healthy?
Healthier, maybe is relative, back from the dead.
Whatever the label, we gradually see fewer sellers this fall.
We will, because it's the fall.
And it'll be interesting to see
if we have any relative upward trend
compared to the last two years.
Mortgage rates have moved sideways
for a couple of weeks now,
but what if they drop into the fives?
That's worth watching here, this new listing supply.
And we're going to watch how supply reacts,
as well as watching demand react
to the newly lower mortgage rates.
Home prices are holding up also.
As I mentioned this last week,
basically all the measures of home prices
are showing just slightly positive gains for the year,
up two or 3%.
None of the price measures are showing big strength, of course.
In fact, they're actually the weakest.
They've been in like five or more years,
but they're up, they're positive.
Prices stayed resilient
through the weakest demand times in the market this year.
Now with these lower mortgage rates,
as I've been showing,
you know, what looked like maybe green shoots of buyer demand,
it seems unlikely that home prices
will face downward, renewed downward pressure.
For buyers right now,
it's slightly improved demand for homes
at the prices the market is currently asking.
For me, that applies to a scenario
where home buyers have been sitting on the fence,
sitting on the sidelines,
waiting for a big price correction,
is unlikely to materialize.
We don't see price declines really anywhere in the data.
Now, since rates are down
and we're past the peak of pricing time for the year,
mortgage payments on a home you buy today
are like 10% cheaper than they were last year at this time.
Payments are 14% cheaper
than the worst point of May this year.
Payments are down, home prices are not.
Those same payments are 53% higher
than they were at the cheapest moment during the pandemic.
So nobody is fooled into thinking these are bargains now,
but they're 14% off the peak.
So let's take every improvement we can get
because it helps home buyers.
The median price of all the homes on the market
is $443,000 right now,
that's down a tick from last week.
It is about 1% more than last year at this time.
The median price of the newly pending contracts,
so remember there's more contracts this week,
this is the price that people are buying.
It actually ticked up for the third week in a row
to just under $390,000, just a tiny bit.
This is the view that we have here.
So the median price of the newly pending contracts,
these contracts are staying 3% to 4%
more expensive than a year ago in that range.
That's roughly where we're now expecting to end the year.
Home prices up maybe 3% over 2023.
I don't see any evidence of dropping further.
I also don't expect any conditions
to create any opportunity for home prices to jump meaningfully,
at least not until the spring.
That's a long way off though.
So in fact, you can imagine how,
you know, that stays true for a whole nother year.
And we wrap today with the leading indicator
for future home prices,
and that's the percent of homes on the market
with price reductions.
This percentage has been hovering around 40%
for several weeks now.
There's a bit of a cap on price cuts
between discouraged sellers withdrawing listings
and with just marginally more offers being made for purchase.
So that's keeping a cap
on the price reductions across the market.
So here's what I'm looking for next with price reductions.
So see the curve here for 2024 is now fewer than 2022.
That period in 2022 led to year over year
home price declines in the spring of the following year.
That was like a four to six month lead time.
If because we have a few more buyers this autumn,
that leads to an earlier peak in the price cut season.
What I'm watching for is if this year's curve
trends under 39% in October,
maybe finishes the year under 36.5%.
That would be 36.5% of the active listings
at the end of the year
had taken a price cut from the original list price.
If it comes in fewer than that red line here from last year,
that would set 2025 up
for more likely home price appreciation,
more likely than we had this year.
This is a leading indicator
is sort of coming in like the other measures.
None of it is pointing lower.
It's all flat.
It's less annual price appreciation
than we used to get pre-pandemic.
In this post-pandemic era,
we're much more likely to tread water
on home prices for another year or more.
Now that could change quickly.
Of course, the big trends from earlier in the year
finally shifting now.
And that's why we do this data work each week.
If the buyers really start moving,
we'll see it in this data quickly.
If sellers come out of the woodwork,
we'll see that too.
So for your home buyers and sellers,
these conditions can change fast.
So it can be very impactful
for smart decision-making.
And they need to hear the data coming from you
so they know how to act.
So you should join us at Altos Research.
Go to altosresearch.com
and book a free consult with our team.
We will help you know how to talk about the data
and the market with your clients and prospects today.
There's a link in the description below to join us.
Click that and let's get started.
Also, the next webinar is next Thursday, October 10th.
Don't miss that for the full hour-long deep dive.
All right.
Thanks, everybody.
