Architect Liz Diller: “You have to be a mind reader" | Louisiana Channel

Lost Treasures
16 followers
Oct 1, 2024
Liz Diller is one of the heroes of contemporary architecture. Even though she never wanted to become an architect. We visited her in her famous New York studio.
When you design a piece of architecture,
you're never just landing from outer space
onto something brand new.
You have to be a mind reader,
you have to somehow be an archeologist,
you have to be a psychiatrist and psychologist,
you have to be a dreamer and a poet and all of that.
And you have to be a politician also.
You have to be a lot of things to be an architect
and to want to be an architect.
I never wanted to be an architect.
I wanted to be an artist.
And I went to art school,
I painted, sculpted, made films.
And then when I went to college,
I also was studying art.
But in my school, there was also an architectural program.
And I thought, you know,
maybe I'll just try a course
and just see what it was all about.
And meanwhile, my parents were telling me,
it's stupid to be an artist,
you'll never make a living.
Take your creative energies, put them into architecture.
And so, and if you don't want architecture,
maybe dentistry.
So for this part of my life,
I made the wrong equation,
architecture and dentistry and art.
When I took my first course in architecture,
I was really interested to take more.
And I ended up transferring
into the School of Architecture at Cooper Union.
I got a degree, a professional degree in architecture,
never with the intention of being an architect.
I wanted to work with space.
I wanted to work in real time and in all different media,
but not the profession of architecture.
And slowly, a little by little,
I teamed up with my partner
who is my romantic partner, Rick Scofidio.
And we started to do independent projects in public space.
And then we did a small architectural project and another.
And I realized at some point
that it's possible to have ideas
and execute them and connect them to the ground.
I had this epiphany at one point.
And I would say before that I was very skeptical
because architecture did not seem intellectually
so stimulating.
It seemed like a bit of a corrupt profession.
It was dominated by men.
It was for the wealthy.
And it just seemed like it wasn't something for me.
And then I learned that maybe I had something to say
and something to contribute.
Yeah, I think between art and architecture,
there are many, many similarities.
One is connection with the public,
communication with the public, having something to say.
Another is just sort of the process,
the creative process is really not that different.
Even art, very often commissions involve contracts
and budgets and schedules.
The kind of art I was interested in was art
that was sort of critical and was connected with real time,
the politics, the economics,
the social structures of the day.
It was a time where there was a kind of institutional critique
going on where everybody was rethinking sources of power
and who has the voice to say and to speak.
And so that was very compelling for me.
And the question was, can I translate
some of these interests and issues
through the medium of architecture
as opposed to the medium of film
or the medium of installation art and so forth?
And I found that it's possible, but I never abandoned.
To me, it's kind of like a false division
because all of our work in the studio is about space making
and it's about the public
and it's about challenging institutions
and conventions of the everyday, all of them,
whether they be independent art projects
or performances or buildings.
It's just a question of how many legal aspects
there are in the way between you and the expression.
And so some are more complicated.
In some cases, you have to convince many people.
Like in our architectural projects that deal with cities,
you have to really, they're very expensive.
And so you have to be able to speak with lots of tongues,
different tongues, different voices to different people.
When we're doing independent work,
we're kind of speaking in our own voice and that's enough.
So there are obviously there are differences,
but they feed off of each other in our studio.
It's interesting, I would say as the master,
the only masters I had were 20th century.
So I don't go back in time that much
because the work doesn't exactly appeal to me
or my understanding of the world.
And so we're talking about between the wars
and then post-World War II.
So I think one of the architects
that has always drawn me in is Le Corbusier.
And I had his works, all of his works on my shelf
all the time and I pick them up.
And I learned really more from exploring Corb
than I did from school.
And a plan and what looks right in your brain.
And his trajectory over time was also really interesting
from a kind of formalism to an expression,
kind of an expressive form, more poetic.
And so I was very interested in this trajectory
and all the new ideas that he put on the table,
different scales.
And then I would say that the other person
that I would maybe call a master in my education
and when I got really involved in architecture
was Cedric Price.
1960s British architect that did mostly unexecuted projects.
But his thinking was really brilliant.
He challenged many conventions of buildings,
of educational institutions, of cultural institutions,
of how architects work with clients.
And for me, for example, the Fun Palace that he did
was a huge stimulation and it was basically
what the Shedd, our project in New York, was based on.
And so I still felt that there was a connection
between something that was conceived in the 1960s
and today.
Pottery's Think Belt, the kind of dispersed
education system made on obsolete railway.
These are all ideas that are very relevant.
And so masters don't necessarily mean permanent,
static buildings on hilltops and massive and muscular.
They're sometimes just ideas.
And he was a great teacher.
And so one learns and is sort of seduced
in different ways by the work,
whether it's drawn or whether it's executed.
I can't do an art or architectural work without sketching.
It's basically goes from the brain to the hand,
to the sketchbook or receipt or napkin or my hand
or whatever because there's a kind of analytical process
where you convert something that's ephemeral,
like a thought into something that is material.
And for me, I don't know the scale of it.
I don't understand the materials of it,
but I have a kind of hunch about an idea
that has a physical manifestation.
I have to draw it.
And my tools are usually sections and plans
because when you put them together, you get 3D.
And so I think in 3D through 2D.
And so sketching is always,
and even perspective sketches and so forth.
And sometimes I tear a piece of paper
and make a little model.
But ultimately, the tools of today are so sophisticated
that to translate something from a sketch, an idea,
a cross section into something with three dimensions
that you can quickly see.
It's a fantastic ability to have that tool
to be able to model space.
But there's no point in modeling something
that doesn't exist yet.
And it has to exist as an idea and on paper before, I think.
You can put points and identify what points in space are
with keys and a keypad.
And that's my criticism in a way of young students today
that learn precisely on the computer
and they have to make commitments in space
before they actually analyze them and criticize them.
So it takes so much longer to do it that way,
to model something and then try to interpret it back into,
really, does that make any sense?
So I think the most economical, smart, fast,
iterative process is sketching and then computing,
using the tools, computer tools,
and then sketching again and using physical models
and using all the tools in the toolkit
to advance an idea forward.
I came to New York when I was around six years old.
My parents and my family emigrated from Poland.
And my father didn't have a job and we were quite poor.
And I was delivering newspapers and just to help the family,
even as a young kid, helping my brother.
But I learned to, when I learned the language
and I started to understand where I was,
I started to realize that New York is full of immigrants
and New York is full of, it's a very idiosyncratic city.
It's just a collection of everyone
whose identity is not New York.
It's from every place else.
And I went to school here
and all the way through university.
And then I started to teach here and my studio is here.
And the way I always imagined my career forward in New York
was I was inspired by New Yorkers.
I was inspired by the New York art scene,
very, very important in the 70s.
When I went into architecture,
I never in a million years would think
that I would do something in New York,
that I would ever have the opportunity to do something here.
And what happened was just totally magical
that Mayor Bloomberg came into office after Giuliani
and there were a series, this was post 9-11.
And really, even though we started in the mid 80s
and early 90s to do some things,
we did a project in Japan and we did some small projects,
it wasn't really until just after 9-11
that we had an opportunity to do something here.
And that was the High Line and also Lincoln Center,
two very, very important projects
that came in the wake of this huge disaster.
It came in the wake of a new mayor
and a group of people around him,
his administration that was very sophisticated and smart
and believed in architecture and public space and culture.
And so I was the beneficiary
of being at the right place at the right time
and was able to, with Rick, my partner, Rick Scofidio,
together start, really launch this practice forward
in a much bigger way.
And the studio went from 10 people to 30 to 60,
and it continued to grow.
New York is a very real estate oriented city.
Every square meter is valuable
and the old parts of the city get torn down
and new high-rises go up
and they're usually for the wealthy and condos.
And it's a city that's ruthless in many ways
and very much controlled by developers.
So I find that even though there's a beautiful history
of the birth of the high-rise building,
the tower in New York,
and just the, before it became just extrusions
of tall glass buildings that are everywhere
and monocultural, there was a very distinctive history
of tall buildings in New York
and how the city evolved organically.
So that has been inspirational
and working with old structures
and even like right through the 20th century,
saving structures that maybe nobody loves
is also something that is interesting
to preserve a history in New York
that doesn't have a very long history,
but it's kind of rich and so you want to keep it going.
So, I find that my role here,
since that moment at 9-11
is to be on the side of public space,
to protect the public from greedy developers
and to do the best we can for the city,
to keep it urban.
The High Line still is a mystery to me.
When we began in 2003,
it was just an obsolete piece of urban infrastructure
that hadn't been used for over 20 years.
It was all overgrown and a ruin.
And the mayor at that time, at the very beginning,
wanted to tear it down.
Already five blocks were torn down,
so he wanted to tear the rest.
And the developers that owned the land,
which was really kind of a, you know,
it was kind of wasteland.
The meatpacking district was already moving out,
so it wasn't even, it was post-industrial,
but it was pre-anything else.
And the property owners felt
that the High Line devalued their property
and so wanted it torn down
so that they can build everywhere.
And these two young citizen activists,
Robert Hammond and Josh David,
just decided that, you know,
that wouldn't it be a great idea to salvage this
and to turn it into a park?
They already saw the potential of it.
And we were also very lucky to be brought together
with a team, with James Corner and Peter Udolph,
and to imagine something new.
And we, it was a competition.
We clicked with the city and with Robbie and Josh.
And Rick and I at the time, we were still quite small,
but we had this feeling, this sense
that the very character of this overgrown,
this sort of ruin was so beautiful.
It was so beautiful to visit.
It was kind of the city's unconscious.
And when you went up there,
it's about eight meters in the air,
and it snakes through this part of Chelsea
and downtown west side of Manhattan,
that you see things that you're not supposed to see.
It's the unofficial New York.
So you see the sides of buildings, you see smokestacks,
you see billboards, you see backs of billboards,
you see lots of car parks,
shops with cars being repaired.
And it's not the beautiful New York that's on a postcard
or on a splash page for the city,
for advertising, for tourism.
It is a kind of nitty gritty, nasty alternative New York.
We loved that.
And we said that we wanted to preserve this,
and we wanted to protect the High Line from architecture.
That was the, you know, what we truly felt.
We had an idea about how humans and plants
could coexist there at the same time.
And it had to do with combing together,
not being side by side, like normally a path
and landscape is side by side.
It's very narrow, the High Line.
It's like, you know, sometimes there's no more
than eight meters, maybe, to go along a space.
So we had this notion of somehow inventing
this new strategy of what we called agritecture,
which is partially vegetation, partially kind of mineral,
so vegetal and mineral systems together.
And then inventing a new language for sitting,
for watching, for doing all the things one does in a park.
And in this park, you know, you could never really
bring your dog or ride a bicycle.
You really can't do anything.
So it's about doing nothing.
And we love this idea of how do you do nothing
in an interesting way.
And so this project came to life that way
with this kind of inspiration.
We wanted to use the kinds of plants
that got self-seeded there, that, you know,
the High Line sometimes is exposed in front of the river,
in front of the beating sun.
Sometimes it goes between buildings
and the space in between is shadowy and wet.
And there are all these different ways
in micro-climates there.
And they produce different ecologies.
And that was interesting.
That happened naturally in the kind of weird,
it wasn't real nature.
It was naturally in this industrial kind of setting.
And we wanted to preserve that kind of thing, that feeling.
And so we, a lot of the plants that are there are wild.
And the way they work together
and the seasonality of it, so forth.
So what happened, and fast forward to even pre-COVID
and now, it's one of the most attractive places
in New York, biggest tourist attraction.
And we speculated that maybe 400,000 people a year,
conservatively would come to visit the High Line
and just before COVID, it was 8 million people came.
And all of these property owners that were worried
about devaluing their property,
their property just rose in value.
And they built all around it
and turned the property over and over
and escalated the cost.
So it was totally unplanned that way.
It was never conceived
that it would attract visitorship from abroad.
We thought it was a neighborhood park.
And so we were very surprised.
And in many good ways, also in some maybe not so good ways,
but on the very good side,
it produced this viral effect all over the globe
and leaders, mayors and others with power
realized that you can take urban infrastructure
like highways and railroad trestles
and underutilized spaces of infrastructure
and actually convert them into public space.
So it was an example that really worked
and that it catalyzed a whole development
that people also thought that economically
happened to them when it happened here,
which is not really replicable everywhere.
So, but the realization that public space
that people still,
even though we're always in front of our computers
and we sort of think that we've lost that social thing,
actually really not.
People still love to go to parks.
People love to promenade, very old-fashioned idea.
They like to look at each other, people watch
and they like green things, you know?
And so public space is very much alive.
And I think that this project
was a kind of interesting rebirth
and I'm very proud of that.
I believe that public spaces and cultural institutions
are part of a human infrastructure that's as important,
and it's very, very important that government supports them
just like clean water, clean air,
the education system,
and all the systems and government system,
the systems that we have in play
that society has invented to preserve
a culture, a human society.
So I believe that these are essential.
They're essential for cities and for cities to grow.
They can't just grow with just more and more people.
They have to grow proportionately
to make a city really viable
with a balance of education system,
with a balance of places to work and places to live
and cultural institutions and spaces for the public
and civic space and open space.
It's a question of proportion
and keeping that in some intelligent way.
That's why city planning is really important,
that someone really cares about the growth of cities
because usually cities are divided into pieces of property
and you just, you care about that piece of property.
Governments should really enforce this broad idea
that it's the public good and a necessity for life
and for having a good society.
Just before the night
You don't have to have it
Punch, rooks, sharks, rush out
For the bleach, the river
The topic of architecture and memory is a complicated one
and it probably has too many facets
to even try to respond to.
But maybe first off,
that when you design a piece of architecture,
you're never just landing from outer space
onto something brand new.
That place has a history before you came there.
That program has a history before,
that you have to either work with or critique
or find a new way.
So you enter some place in the progress of things,
some place and you enter into some kind of cycle often
and you work with what's inherited
and you work forward with what's inherited.
So cultural memory,
architectural and disciplinary memory
is very, very important.
Very often students think they're inventing something
I just look 30 years ago, somebody did that better,
much better.
So history is very, very important
and knowledge about history is important.
There are different kinds of also memory
when you step into a building
and you feel like you've been someplace,
like it feels like someplace before
and places have memories also.
And I think about this a lot
when I think about places of commemoration,
like a spot where some battle happened
or people were killed when you think about
the site of 9-11 or you think about a battlefield
or you think about a concentration camp
or you think about just a place
where Marilyn Monroe had a cup of coffee.
All of those places I think still have aura,
have a kind of aura and you could bring it out,
you could bring out that memory
in the way that you work with it forward.
So I really believe in carrying memories in architecture
and building on histories.
The V&A Project is a very interesting project for us
because it takes so many different aspects
of our cultural history
because the V&A collects everything.
And having the challenge to bring all of these different
eclectic collections together in one place
with all of these memories,
with all of these histories is a fantastic opportunity.
And so this project,
which will be in an existing building also
that has a little bit of a memory,
short memory of the Olympics.
It was a media center.
But inside of that,
to find a way of exposing these collections
or a collection of collections to the public
in a way that has never been done before,
very close to the artifacts
without that kind of prophylactics
like that you usually have.
You usually have a piece of glass
and you always have everything at an arm's distance
and guard is looking over at you.
So to be able to have some proximity to this
and to make sense out of something that is so eclectic,
the V&A has pieces of architecture,
large pieces of architecture.
It has teaspoons.
It has articles of fashion.
It has urns and busts and paintings and stage sets
and you name it.
They collect everything like the U.S.
and the Smithsonian Institution
has this collection of everything.
Our inspiration was the Cabinet of Curiosities,
this idea of putting things together
that actually don't belong together
and telling new kinds of stories by their juxtaposition.
So we love this project
because it doesn't make any sense in a way.
But what we love about the potential of it
is to create an experience for the public that is sublime
and that sublimity comes from the exposure
to this millions of artifacts,
to understanding even when you come from the street
and you come through this storage collection
and you come through the floor
and you enter a big space that's surrounded
and recedes in deep space with all of these artifacts
and you could come in and you could see some of them.
You can't see everything, but you can see some.
That experience by itself is just a fantastic experience
that this institution carries all of these histories
from different cultures and different time periods.
And that's a beautiful and overwhelming idea
that museums are the caretakers of these histories.
I think the role of the architect is a kind of voice.
It's maybe an intellectual voice
and it's a contributor to culture in a real way.
People live in your buildings.
It's a huge responsibility actually
to take on making public institutions
that people will forget you,
but they're going to use these institutions
for the next 50 years or longer,
a hundred years if you're really lucky
and if they're still relevant.
But it's a huge responsibility and that even safety
and even being able to satisfy the needs of a person
in a program then and also being able to anticipate
a future that you don't know
and be able to anticipate something.
You have to be a mind reader.
You have to somehow be an archeologist.
You have to be a psychiatrist and psychologist
and you have to be a dreamer and a poet and all of that.
And you have to be a politician also.
You have to be a lot of things to be an architect
and to want to be an architect.
I think the closest in some ways is a film director
in terms of the process
because you have to bring so many talents together
and so many pieces of expertise
and you have to work with people and inspire them
and to execute something, just to execute something
and have it be an artifact or an orchestra conductor
to do, it's not just you and your brain in an attic.
It's you as a leader.
So you have to have that leadership.
At the same time, our practice is very different
than most architectural practices
because for us, it's making a performance,
a new unique idea about an opera
is as interesting as making a building
or doing a master plan or making a public space
or even designing a glass, a drinking glass
or something like that.
Our work is sort of, I would say, across many, many fields
and often to execute our work,
it takes very unusual types of people to help us
because we don't really know how to do everything.
But when I think about the work that we've done,
we're always bringing together librettists
and composers and choreographers
and scientists and weather experts
and meteorologists and crime experts
and it's like you name it.
There's a kind of generosity that people feel towards us
and we have a curiosity that's kind of limitless
and we like to explore things we don't know anything about.
In fact, I often say that the best work comes
from doing things that you're totally unqualified to do.
You just jump off the cliff and you do it and you learn
and it's the best thing you've ever done.
Well, the world is kind of a scary place
and it's moving so fast that we can hardly keep up.
Architecture is static and it's fixed usually
so we have to think about how architecture can keep up
with a world that's changing so fast.
One of the biggest issues for architecture, of course,
is carbon footprint and the environment
and how architecture has contributed negatively
in this way and now with a new consciousness
of limited resources and trying to think about
the environment in a way that conserves energy
and works with recyclable materials and so forth.
This is something that every architect,
just to be a good citizen, really must do.
But how to translate our care for the planet
into good architecture is very, very important.
To not abandon the importance of design
and the importance of the craft of architecture
to solely doing the world good by working responsibly.
So responsibly is also with invention,
with new thinking, with taking on new technologies,
with being able to critique new systems
and invent new institutions.
So I think many younger generations feel like,
what's really important, where do I put my energy?
And I would say that it's everything that architecture was
plus very new concerns that have to guide the work.
I also think that because of the speed of the world
and because we're in a kind of culture of obsolescence,
we basically build things and tear them down very quickly,
which is anti-environmental, we have to think in a new way
about what permanence means
and flexibility means in architecture.
And when you think about the buildings
that have taken a lot of endurance
are like the building that we're in,
this industrial building, it's kind of very generic
and it used to be a warehouse
and now it's a place that there are fashion designers
and architects that are able to do creative work in.
But if you thought that way for the future of architecture,
it really wouldn't work
because we don't want to make generic buildings
that are just frame structures that can take anything.
So to distinguish between the generic
and the flexible is very, very important.
So can we make architecture that's distinctive
but that still can foresee its translation
into futures that we cannot possibly anticipate?
And that's what I like to think about
and it's a great challenge.
Basically, if we solve this kind of problem,
we'll prevent architecture itself from becoming obsolete.
