Gongfu & Bowl Tea | Brewing Tea (Part 3)

TEA & Brewing
11 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 1, 2024
In Part 3 of our tea brewing series, we explore two distinct brewing methods: Gongfu Cha and Bowl Tea. While Gongfu emphasizes precision, multiple infusions, and skillful pouring, Bowl Tea offers a simpler, meditative approach, allowing the leaves to steep naturally. Discover the differences between these methods and how each enhances the tea experience in its own unique way.
Hello, tea friends.
Yi cha hui you.
Through tea, make friends.
Welcome back to our ongoing series, Brewing Tea,
where we discuss the history, lore,
and practicalities of tea brewing,
all with the aims of improving your tea practice.
This week, we're gonna be talking about
bowl tea and gongfu tea,
how they work together, what makes them different,
and how to use them in your practice.
So have a seat, get out a bowl and a cup,
and join me as we jump into bowl tea and gongfu tea.
In our tradition, we practice five brewing methods,
three types of bowl tea, gongfu tea, and whisked tea.
Today, we're not gonna be talking about whisked tea,
we're gonna be talking about gongfu tea and bowl tea.
And we're not gonna be demonstrating
or talking about all the steps
in any of the three kinds of bowl tea or gongfu tea.
We'll save those for later videos.
I promise, in later videos,
we will get into the details
of all three types of bowl tea and gongfu tea.
Today, I wanna talk about their relationship
and how they work together,
a little bit about where they come from.
Though not a detailed exploration of their history either.
That will also come in later videos.
Today, we're mostly gonna be talking about
the way that they work together, what their purpose is,
and how they stay next to each other
and create the fire of a tea practice.
And I say fire because there's a really good analogy
which relates to charcoal.
When we're making charcoal fire for tea,
we always remember that a single piece of charcoal
is not that hot.
It's two pieces of charcoal near each other
and there's space between them
that creates the flame that heats our water for tea.
In the same way, gongfu tea and bowl tea really function
when they're kept distinct but put together, right?
Having both of these in my tea practice and in my tea life
is such a benefit.
It brings so much joy and helps me in so many ways.
And I can see the effects of those
who only have one or the other
and how they're limited in certain ways.
And having both in our tradition is such a boon,
such a blessing to have.
Bowl tea is the older of the two.
There are three types of bowl tea that we practice.
One is leaves in a bowl, one is side handle brewing,
and one is boiling tea.
All three of those are really important.
And they're all three very ancient
and go back a long time.
A really simple way of looking at this
is to say that bowl tea is more relaxed,
more ceremonial, more meditative,
less about the tea, more about us,
whether that be as individuals
seeking some meditative peace through our tea practice
or as a group sitting in harmony and silence
and connecting to each other and to nature
and, of course, to ourselves.
Gong Fu tea, on the other hand,
is about sensitivity, subtlety.
It's about refinement.
Gong Fu means mastery.
It means skillful mastery through self-discipline.
So Gong Fu tea is about learning and growing
and continually improving
and creating the finest cup of tea possible,
always pursuing that perfect cup,
which is in itself impossible,
but it's great to have ideals that we can never reach
that we continue to strive and grow
throughout our entire life.
Bowl tea, we could say, is about equanimity
and Gong Fu tea is about sensitivity.
So these two work together in harmony.
And when you think of them in those terms,
equanimity and sensitivity,
actually, these are the wings to awakening in Buddhism
as well.
The Buddha spoke about equanimity and sensitivity
as the wings to awakening
and how we need to cultivate equanimity,
which is an ability to accept things as they are,
to just be with things as they are,
to not fight against reality,
but allow it to be and see it more clearly,
and sensitivity, which is to experience more,
more and greater depth
and greater understanding and wisdom.
Too much of either one and we get off balance.
If we get really sensitive and we don't have equanimity,
then we will react.
If we aren't able to be peaceful and equanimous
with the degree of sensitivity we have now,
increasing it will mean that we will react more
and we'll continue to react more and more and more
and that's not healthy for us.
Similarly, if we're very equanimous
but have no sensitivity, we're not really awake.
That's kind of like a sleep state
or like someone who's on heavy drugs.
They're at peace and they're calm,
but they're also not awake.
You could poke them and they don't really feel anything,
so they're not really there.
We want to have both of these things rise together
and this is how bowl tea and gong fu tea
work together as a practice.
We create a sensitivity to tea.
This could include, we could open this up
and it could include an exploration into tea knowledge,
understanding the types of tea,
how they're processed, where they come from,
understanding all the linear information
that is out there about tea, cultivating that,
and also improving your skills.
Not just by copying or aping,
but by doing experiments.
In our tradition, we practice a lot of experimentation
in our gong fu tea so that we can realize experientially
why we brew tea like this versus like this
and continue to experiment and grow and learn
and try different things,
and that way we have an evolving and growing tradition
that is actually hundreds of years old.
We can honor tea in that way
by bringing it to its highest potential
because tea leaves arrive to us and they are unfinished.
They are like the ingredients that need to be put together
and cooked into a delicious meal.
Of course, you have to start with the right ingredients.
This is why cooks in really nice, high-quality restaurants,
they do their own shopping.
They don't even trust their sous chefs.
They go to the market themselves
because you need really high-quality ingredients,
which is to say, in our case,
we need really good, high-quality tea,
but then you need to prepare it well.
You need to be able to put it together with skill,
and that's what gong fu tea is doing.
It's honoring tea by bringing it to its highest potential.
Bowl tea, on the other hand,
is about just allowing the tea to be whatever it is.
In bowl tea, the materials aren't so essential.
The methods aren't so essential.
It doesn't matter if the tea's too hot or too cold,
there's too many leaves or too little,
too bitter, too strong.
Let go of all those twos.
You can think of it in this way.
In bowl tea, we're letting go of the qualitative mind.
We're letting go of the evaluatory mind
and getting into a state of equanimity,
just being with the tea,
communicating with the tea, non-verbally,
not in some kind of fufu or spiritual way,
but actually communicating bodily to the actual aromas,
not labels or descriptive terms in our head
that are attempts to conceptualize
the flavors that we're experiencing or the aromas,
but the actual aromas unpacked
and the actual bodily sensations and feelings,
and then beyond.
And so bowl tea is about a relaxation,
and gong fu tea is about a hypersensitivity
and a growing, growing, growing focus, right?
And they work together in this beautiful, beautiful dance.
One of the questions that we get asked a lot
is how we choose a tea for any given session,
and there's a lot that goes into that.
The weather, if you know what your guests have eaten,
what kind of guests you have, what kind of session?
Are you gonna have a casual one
where we have a chat and hang out,
or a deep and meditative one?
These are all relevant, what kind of tea you wanna make,
but one of the key factors that goes into choosing
what kind of tea we're gonna prepare
and how we're gonna make our chashi
is which of the five brewing methods we're gonna use.
One of the three bowl teas, gong fu tea, whisky,
which of the brewing methods also is a determining factor
in which tea we're gonna choose
and the chashi that we're gonna make.
Each of these chashis requires different form
because the movements of our body are very different, right?
In bowl tea, we use a lot of big muscle groups
because bowl tea is a relaxation.
It's a movement into equanimity.
So when we brew bowl tea, we're using big muscle groups.
We're using the arms and shoulders.
Gong fu tea is more refined and subtle,
so it's a lot of small muscle groups, right?
And gong fu tea requires different teaware out.
So not only is there different movements,
but there's different teaware on the table,
and so you're moving differently
and you have different teaware arranged
in a different way than you do for bowl tea.
So knowing your brewing method, gong fu or bowl tea,
will determine, in part, what tea you're gonna brew
and also how you're gonna arrange your chashi.
Bowl tea and gong fu tea, their magic,
like the charcoal, is the space between them.
The space between them is what gives them power.
And what that also means is
that we have to keep them distinct.
It's their distinctness that creates that space,
that creates that fire, that creates their usefulness
in the practice and life of a chajian.
So keeping them separate is really important.
And this is why you often hear me joking
about why I don't appreciate,
for myself and for my students,
I don't appreciate teaware that smushes
or blends the boundaries of these two.
A good example of that is what we call bups,
something that's not a cup and it's not a bowl,
it's something in between,
and you've now kind of smushed bowl tea and gong fu tea.
And as a guest, of course,
I can always appreciate whatever tea anyone serves to me.
That's my role as a guest,
is to connect to the heart of the kindness
and hospitality of my host who's offering me tea,
not to sit there in a snobby way and say,
oh, this tea's not good enough
or their brewing method's not good enough,
but to sit and enjoy.
But at the same time, just to take a step back,
as a tea lover, when you use those kinds of teaware
that mush things together,
it's hard for me to know how to be in that ceremony,
how to relate, how to sit, how to be,
because they both have such very, very different energies.
And so when we smush them together,
part of the mind wants to turn on
the qualitative part of your mind.
It wants to say, oh, this cup is shaped improperly
for gong fu tea.
It shouldn't be like this.
It should be porcelain.
It should be this.
It should be shaped like a tulip.
It should, you know, because we've done the experiments
and we, ourselves, not because Buddha says
or my teacher says or his teacher says,
but because we've experimented and we know these things.
And then on the other hand,
there's the bowl tea part of the mind
that wants to just let go and be okay.
So both of those are there and competing
when we have those things mushed up, right?
We have to keep them separate.
Also, keeping them separate honors the lineages
from which they come.
It's like if we were making a fusion album in music
and we had studied some African drumming
and then we had gone and studied flamenco guitar
from real old school flamenco guitar teachers.
And we wanted to make an album
that brought these two things together.
Of course, we want both of our teachers,
our African drum teacher, our flamenco teacher,
we want them to be proud of what we've done.
We want them to look at the album and tell their friends,
look at what they've done with our beautiful flamenco.
Look at this cool new album.
We don't want them to feel like,
what have they done with our flamenco?
They've mixed it up and mushed it up.
We don't want that.
We want the evolution and change and growth of our tradition
as it moves forward generation to generation
to be just that, a positive evolution that honors the past
and grows towards the future in powerful ways.
And that those evolutions come out of the spirit
of the practice, out of the brewing method itself,
not out of our whims or the things that we happen
to be able to find, et cetera.
But out of the spirit of that thing,
that's how we evolve and grow, through understanding.
So it's really important that these two things
remain distinct and apart from each other.
And in that way, you'll find that you get that charge
between them and you get that ability
that really makes them work so well together.
Bold Tea picks up where Gong Fu Tea leaves off
and Gong Fu Tea picks up where Bold Tea leaves off.
And they allow you to explore a much larger territory of tea,
a much larger territory of the world of tea
and the practice of tea, when you have both of them
working together distinctly, but close together.
Of course, this doesn't mean that they don't overlap,
that Gong Fu is pure function and Bold Tea is pure aesthetics
and that the method and the teaware
just absolutely don't matter at all in Bold Tea
because it's just about meditative ceremonial space.
That's not true.
There is some form in it.
There are some practical elements of the proper design
of the side handle, the best bowl and the best shape
of the bowl and all of those practical details,
which we'll get into later in other videos.
And in Gong Fu Tea also, there are aesthetic things
and Gong Fu Tea can also be very meditative.
It can also be deep and powerful
and create a ceremonial space.
So they certainly overlap.
They certainly overlap, but keeping them apart
means more keeping the methods apart,
keeping the respective teaware apart,
the respective chashi apart
and the respective approach apart.
That's very, very important.
And so that we can make sure that we honor the lineages
of both of them and also so that they will create
that space that works so well together
and expands our ability to practice
and share tea with others.
Having both of these things in my life as a Cha Jin
has brought me tremendous growth
and a tremendous amount of joy
and also helped me in so many ways
because I find that like the equanimity
and sensitivity that we spoke about,
bowl tea and Gong Fu Tea work so well
when they are in perfect balance.
If you have too much Gong Fu Tea,
you start to get snobby,
you start to get hypercritical, hyperfocused
and there are a lot of tea snobs
in the world, unfortunately,
and that element of tea can make tea sometimes unpleasant.
Sometimes you go to a place
and there's really expensive tea
worth thousands of dollars and experts there
and the experience is not very enjoyable.
I've had some of my best sessions in my life
in the mountains with a monk in Japan, for example.
The two of us were drinking tea out of a Hello Kitty teapot
in one cracked bowl and he didn't know anything about tea
and those were some of the most transcendental
tea sessions of my life.
And then I've had those sessions
with tea that was worth thousands of dollars
and the greatest experts of the tea world there
and I left feeling like the tea
was a little underappreciated.
You know, maybe some dear friend
invites us over to their house
and they've opened their home
and their hospitality and their heart to us
and we have a chance to connect
and we miss that chance to connect
because we're caught up too much
in our evaluatory process,
looking at them and thinking,
oh, this tea's not good enough,
it's not to my taste
and that brewing method's not good enough.
You know, I wanna be able to shut all that off
and because I practice bowl tea,
I can shut it off.
I can shut it off and just show up
and drink their tea and enjoy their tea
and their hospitality and connect to them right away.
But too much bowl tea
and we become kind of tea guzzlers.
We just, you know, guzzle, guzzle tea
for years and years
and we don't increase our sensitivity
or our understanding of tea or our skill
and that's a bit like getting into music
but never really learning the instrument
or really learning how to play,
just learning two chords
and playing those over and over and over again.
You're missing out also on a lot of dimensions of tea
and you start to, you know,
you're also incapable of really describing your experience
or passing on your experience
or answering the questions of your guests
after a ceremony when they ask you
about the tea that you've prepared
and about the experience itself.
So we really need to work with these two things together
and when they are together,
you have a really much stronger and healthier tea practice.
In the great library of tea wisdom and tea stories,
there's one story that captures very, very, very clearly
the difference between bowl tea and gongfu tea
and how they relate to each other
and it also happens to be one of my favorite tea stories.
So I'm really happy to be able to share it with you.
It's about Rikyo, who is one of the constellations
in the tea world,
one of the greatest masters of all time.
He lived several centuries ago in Japan
and he lived in feudal Japan
and in a society that was very stratified.
So there was nobles and peasants
and they didn't really react
or interact with each other very much.
And he, of course, was a noble.
He was the tea master to the shogun
and got to participate in even serving tea to the emperor.
So he was, you know, very high lord and had his own school
and, of course, in those days,
for someone wealthy like him,
everything would be delivered to the kitchen door
that the people needed on a daily level
and the servants and household staff
and all that would have been there
to receive all those deliveries.
For some reason, we don't know why,
Rikyo became enamored with the fishmonger
who delivered the fish to his compound every day.
They grew to be close friends.
You can imagine that fisherman in the beginning
being so nervous.
The lord of the house himself wants to talk to me, what?
You know, and looking down at his shoes,
not knowing what to say.
But over time, they began to get closer and closer
and that washed away and they developed a familiarity
and they would sit in the kitchen and sip oil tea,
sencha, simmered tea, and sip bowls of it and talk.
And Rikyo loved him and instructed the servants
that anytime I'm not with a guest or busy,
if he comes, I wanna be there to receive the fish
and have a chat.
And so the two of them would chat like that.
And over time, they became very close.
And then one day, Rikyo began to notice
that there was something on the fisherman's mind.
He had something he wanted to ask Rikyo.
He needed something.
He assumed he needed money.
So he waited for the right opportunity
because he could tell that the fisherman
wasn't going to ask because their society's very polite.
So eventually, he found the right opportunity
and he said, you know, I can tell there's something
on your mind.
What is it?
Go ahead and tell me, what brothers?
Do you need help?
I'm happy to help you.
And the fisherman looked down and was very nervous.
Well, yes, there is something I've been meaning to ask you,
but I know you'll say, no, that's why I didn't ask.
But you see my wife, she keeps nagging again and again.
And well, it's on my mind.
It's just that, well, we would love to have you
to our home for tea.
And Rikyo's eyes lit up, he was so happy.
Yes, of course, I would love to come to your home for tea.
So they set a date.
And on that day, Rikyo gave the fisherman
a very special gift.
He brought one of his highest students.
Now, Rikyo's students were also all nobles like him.
They were the sons of samurais.
They were wealthy landlords.
And so taking along one of his senior students
was a powerful gift because what he was saying
to the fisherman was, I'm not ashamed of our relationship.
I don't care, it's not some secret just for the kitchen.
I'm showing it to the world that you're my friend.
And that's a very, very, that was a very, very
powerful statement and a very powerful honor.
And so the two of them went to the fisherman's hut.
They drank some simple tea, ate a small meal, and they left.
And after the gate closed and the fisherman went back inside
and they had walked a little bit into the street,
Rikyo stopped and put his hand on his heart,
closed his eyes and sighed with a big smile and said,
that was one of the most transcendental tea sessions
in my entire life.
And then started walking home.
The student was blown away by this.
He was incredibly confused.
This man had served tea to the emperor.
He had served tea in beautiful forests and monasteries
at the end of retreats.
He had all these epic tea sessions,
when flowers were in bloom in all these amazing places.
Finally, he couldn't take it anymore.
When they were about halfway home,
he stopped his teacher and said,
master, I don't understand.
How could that have been one of the most
transcendental tea sessions?
That man did everything wrong.
He had the bowl in the wrong place.
All the teaware was organized improperly.
His skills were all done very, very casually
and not in the way that you teach us.
He whisked the tea poorly.
The tea itself was lower quality and it was gritty.
Everything about the whole ceremony was improper
according to all the teachings that you have given to us.
So how could that be one of your
most transcendental tea sessions?
How could it be?
And Rikyo looked his student deeply in the eyes
and he said, that man did not invite us to his home
to demonstrate his tea brewing skills.
Now, the story ends there.
But actually, if you push the story forward,
you understand a lot about Zen
and a lot about gong fu tea and bowl tea
because you better believe the very next day,
Rikyo would be scolding his students
for not doing it properly.
So here you have one of the greatest masters
in all the history of tea, a constellation, really,
in our sky, who knows deeply all the skills
and how to teach them,
and is on his students about doing it properly,
but he's able to set all that down
and connect heart to heart in the true spirit of tea.
He hasn't lost that.
Now, these are the relationship between bowl tea
and gong fu tea, and if you really want them to work well,
you understand that relationship,
you understand that dynamic,
and you understand also to honor them and keep them apart,
not blend them or mix them with any kind of teaware
or chahashi or method
that sloppily infuses one with the other
because it's when the methods are kept apart
that they really function
and allow you so much more room for growth
and depth in your tea practice.
It's our commitment in these videos every week
to give you some homework that go along with the lessons
so that you can practice and grow during the week
and share in the comments below
about what doing that homework does for you,
we can have an ongoing discussion
in the comments here in the video
and talk about it and talk about our learning
and sharing and growing together.
Of course, the homework for this week
will be to brew gong fu tea and bowl tea
and notice the differences.
Notice the differences in the muscle groups
and how you're using finer muscle groups for gong fu tea
and how that affects your mind and its sharpness
and how you relax more in bowl tea and let go.
Notice maybe which of your teas
is more suitable for one or the other.
Most teas can be bowl tea or gong fu tea,
but they might be more suitable for one or the other.
And if you pick that up, you'll be picking up also
part of what makes that brewing method what it is.
If you can find why a particular tea
is more suitable to bowl tea or gong fu tea,
you will, in other words, understand a little bit more
about the purpose and effect
and use of that particular brewing method.
So try to focus on all the differences
and the ways they work together.
If you want to do an experiment
where you do blend a little bit together, be naughty.
It's great, be naughty, break the rules a little bit,
blend a little bit of bowl tea and gong fu tea,
see what happens, see what happens when you do
and see what the effect is.
And I think you'll find that it's much better
when they are kept pure and separate
and used in a practice in that way.
If you'd like to support these videos,
go to globalteahut.org and subscribe to our magazine.
Every month, you'll receive a 60-page ad-free magazine
that covers tea from every perspective,
including history, science, folklore, ethnography,
tea processing, teaware, and you'll learn a ton
with these 12 issues every year.
Of course, you can't learn about tea just from reading.
Every issue also comes with a few brews of a tea
so you can drink tea with people all over the world
and learn about tea through that as well.
And of course, it comes with an app also
so you can connect to that tea community,
host tea gatherings, go visit other people
and visit their tea gatherings,
ask questions about teaware, about gong fu tea and bowl tea
and all the things that we're covering
in these videos and more.
And all of the proceeds from that are gonna be used
in a non-profit way to support our tea center,
which you yourself can also visit.
We host two 10-day courses every month.
You can find out more at teastagehut.org
and come visit us and stay with us
and go much deeper into this practice.
Also, we have a huge array of gong fu teaware
and bowl tea teaware on our website.
The proceeds from that all are saved
and go towards building our future bigger,
brighter center called Light Meets Light.
Thank you for joining me in this brewing tea series.
Do your homework, make some comments below,
get out a bowl, get out a cup
and enjoy some beautiful tea.
After water, the most important element
in tea preparation is fire.
Join us next time on Brewing Tea
as we explore fire, the teacher of tea.
