Lecture 19 : Supply Chain

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 26, 2024
Hello, welcome to our next session on B to B marketing with technology focus. Our topic
for this session will be supply chain management. We have discussed industrial selling, we have
discussed industrial procurement, earlier we had discussed about distribution in the
context of the marketing mix in B to B. This supply chain management in a way is a complete
view of all these activities right from the source to the final customer, the entire chain
of operations are normally looked at by supply chain management.
So, the formal definition we will come to just now. So, we are looking at therefore,
an innovative approach to the distribution process and we are going to look at the various
links that integrate production and customer through the various activities.
So, the integration of business processes from end user backwards to the original supplier
manufacturer supplier that makes product services available and flow through the value chain
and the generated information flow all that are covered by this topic of supply chain
management. So, this diagram is an excellent depiction
of a supply chain management in all its aspects. You see on the left hand side at the extreme
we have the supply the suppliers that terminology will include the manufacturers and may be
the factory warehouse and so on. But going forward from there we are looking at the various
blocks operational blocks of procurement operation distribution and logistics customer
service ultimately to the customer. So, the customer is getting it from the distribution
and logistics block who are backed up by operations and procurement and then it goes finally to
the supplier. So, this is the entire chain and the arrow which is given at the bottom
shows that the flow of product is from the left to the right.
But if you see the bidirectional arrows which are on top the very top one indicates information
flow. Now, information flows up and down this supply chain because information flows up
information is generated when the product services go forward from the source to the
customer information will be generated at every stage and information also will be generated
from the customer end which will have to flow back to provide the feedback to the supply
system. And out of the information various analytics generate intelligence and that also
flows back and forth. Now, the cash flow that means the money that is paid by customer in
exchange of the products and services primarily flows from the right to the left as opposed
to the product flow from the left to the right. But that arrow is also bidirectional because
there will be sometimes some refund or some surplus stock disposal etcetera. So, therefore,
some money may also flow from the left to the right that is why that arrow is bidirectional.
So, we are therefore, in supply chain model looking at the all the activities related
to planning, buying, making, moving, selling everything even the act of final delivery
and acceptance etcetera are also part of the supply chain in case of B to B.
Now, the supply chain as we know it today in most organizations which is on the extreme
right hand side the stage 3 was not always like this. In fact, even today a start up
organization or a very small organization operating within a very small ecosystem may
actually be at stage 0 which is on the extreme left hand side. Because there things happen
almost in an ad hoc fashion. So, products are purchased or products are ordered as and
when necessary there is not a much of a system at that stage because as a start up you are
at a very early stage. So, you are still almost in a laboratory sort of scenario.
Or initial prototype to realization scenario. So, at that stage we will have lot of ad hocism
and therefore, lot of person to person communication making the procurement and delivery payment
etcetera happen. In stage 1 there are some functional distribution and formalization
that takes place. But in a stage 1 organization there still will be some duplication the same
source may be supplying to different requirements to the different departments. So, there are
therefore, double arrows from the different nodes because it is not fully stream lined.
So, there are duplications and there are overlapping flow of products information and so on.
The stage 2 is where many organizations are there even today. Here some computer based
software based integration happens. So, the source that means material raw material procurement
stage to the manufacturing stage to the delivery stage to the acceptance stage all that are
well integrated. And that is why you see there are not very many overlapping activities and
the whole thing is well planned and happens in an integrated fashion.
In the last block or stage 3 in fact most automotive manufacturers like Maruti or Mahindra
or Tata motors they operate at stage 3. Because they not only connect the source procurement
manufacturing and other aspects of operations delivery all that within the organizations
are definitely networked and integrated. But in these organizations they are tier 1 suppliers.
So, for example, for automobile manufacturers the people who make the body parts suppliers
who make the steering system or the brake system suppliers who make the door lock system
all this sub assemblies or building blocks of the car or of the motor vehicle are all
connected to the sort of what we call the expanded enterprise.
Supply chain network. So, they are very tightly coupled. So, the steering system manufacturer
will know time to time almost moment to moment they will know that what are the changes happening
at their customer end. That means the car manufacturer or the vehicle manufacturer they
are production schedules are tightly locked to the production schedule and delivery schedule
of the tier 1 suppliers. So, the steering system manufacturer will know exactly what
are the demands because many of these systems operate on just in time basis or there are
all efforts made. So, there are not lot of inventory pile up in the pipeline. So, this
almost coupled networks make that low inventory system possible and because each player exactly
knows the requirements of the upstream players. And the upstream players know that what is
happening with the production and delivery of the downstream players. So, that is called
the stage 3 which we call the expanded enterprise where internal and external processes are
integrated allowing each enterprise in the value network to focus on their next stage
customer and core competencies and value creation all that are quite integrated.
But in many cases you will find organizations at stage 2 where there are alignments across
the sub processes and levels of management operations management processes are integrated
and they display world class performance and continuous improvement. But they may not be
connected to their the network of their external suppliers or as it happens in case of the
extended enterprise sometimes even the automobile manufacturers top customers or B to B customers
may also be connected to this network that we will not see usually these external connections
we will not see in at stage 2 operation. But in stage 2 operation all the internal operations
are pretty much connected and networked. So, the goals of supply chain management I
was mentioning about inventory just now, but not only inventory all kinds of waste even
activity wise wastes of duplication etcetera are must be minimized. So, minimize duplication
harmonize the operations and the systems overall. So, that quality and productivity both are
optimized. Time compression also is a continuing need time crunching because as we know again
the famous saying the time is money and that is more true in case of business to business
operations. So, the compression of the order or even the need generation or need identification
to the process in between to the order and then order onwards to the various operational
processes leading to the final delivery this entire cycle time will be continuously crunched
. So, there are many instances for example,
in the automobile industry you can easily find some of those case studies on the internet
and you will find that many cycle times have been reduced to one tenth or even one fiftieth
of the previous standards. So, this is a process. So, waste reduction
and time compression both are a moving goal organizations are continuously improving their
performance on these and the increasing the flexibility of the whole system is also another
major goal of the supply chain management system. So, that if there are sudden shifts
in the customers requirements or there are sudden changes in the market place then the
whole supply chain management must be able to respond to that quickly.
So, for example, automobile manufacturers again I will continue with that example they
will often have sudden demands of certain types of vehicles from the market which to
which they have to quickly respond or they may often have a tremendous pressure to reduce
the delivery lead time of certain models at that stage they want the supply chain management
which is in an that stage three where the expanded enterprise. That means, the organization
the manufacturing organization of the automobile manufacturer as well as their major suppliers
they all must respond flexibly to this sudden increase in demand or sudden change in the
demand pattern etcetera. So, waste reduction time compression flexible
response and finally, unit cost reduction these are the supply chain management goals
and this unit cost reduction utilizing the optimization procedures in the supply chain
management are again areas where some of the major manufacturers like automobile manufacturers
have achieved tremendous result over the last 40, 50 years. And you can find many of those
famous cases in companies like Toyota or even our Maruti or Tata motors you can find lot
of examples which are available on the web and it will be worth reading those.
The supply chain management efficiency and effectiveness for these things that we just
now discussed about waste reduction time compression flexible response all these have become popular
possible more and more because of the advent of internet technology and various kinds of
supply chain software. Many of those software which were earlier in different other companies
a lot of those have already got all integrated in Oracle or SAP and such major software suites.
So, in the supply chain we have physical supply physical distribution and we have information
production in information distribution. So, the controllable elements in the supply chain
system or the logistic systems another name you can look at it from the bottom upwards.
So, we have plant and warehouse locations where strategic placement of plants and warehouse
they increase the customer service level and reduce the cost of transportation and the
time of transportation. Going up from there the production planning system the material
handling system the packaging system the inventory control the warehousing the transportation
to the warehouse the logistics and communication the order processing and manufacturing and
the order taking and customer service in that respect all these are all integrated in the
SCM. So, virtually no logistical decisions can be made without evaluating how it might
affect the other logistical areas because it is understood now very clearly that these
entire system operates like an ecosystem. So, if you tweak at one end something you
have to also adjust then all the other layers or other blocks on the network. So, you can
actually read in detail this controllable elements in the logistic system under each
heading and they are pretty much clear. Some of the elements which we were talking about
just now that we need to crunch the time we need to reduce the unit cost etcetera. So,
in this particular slide we are showing the common elements of the logistic service and
in the responsive logistic service which advances customer satisfaction and improves the seller
buyer relationship we will see focus on these activities as well as targets of improvement.
We will see V M continuous focus on delivery time which I was talking about just a little
while back where we have seen 10 is to 1 or 50 is to 1 improvements in the recent past.
Delivery reliability a very interesting concept where we frequently measure the logistic service
delivery reliability by way of looking at capability of having products available to
meet customer demand and we see what percentage demand has been met on time and all these
will be continuously measured. The elements are clear the activities under each are also
that way easy to understand and again I would say that go through this slide in detail I
am not covering each and every point because they are very easily understood.
Some of the concepts may be interesting to refer is that for example, the ease of doing
business here the supply chain management actually plays the logistic service plays
a major part in improving the customers level of satisfaction with the ease of doing business.
So, here we look at the range of factors including the ease with which orders can be placed returns
can happen credits can be issued in case of returns and billing and adjustment are all
handled in ease of doing business. So, you see there are major this satisfaction
elements have been identified on the left and what those blocks mean what kind of activities
are covered by those blocks are explained on the right. So, the B to B logistical management
considerations are by way of logistic facilities transportation inventory management all that
and the inventory management is I just now mentioned and again I am emphasizing it because
this is a major element of cost that is almost embedded in the logistic system.
And often there will be pile up and that is actually a totally infructuous expenditure
it no way adds value to the entire value chain and therefore, production and demand are to
be perfectly matched that is therefore, a primary goal of having a good logistic system
that is what we saw in that stage 0 to stage 1 to stage 2 and stage 3 all the application
of software and all the application of networks all the application of internet applications
are for basically managing inventory more effectively and efficiently.
Because this is the first sign the inventory build up will be the first sign that something
is not in order in the logistic system. So, that is why this is very tightly monitored
and the other thing is in inventory as opposed to the B to C system where there are many
many buyers and there are many many suppliers the fluctuation happens not only in inventory
in an uncontrolled fashion because this multitude of suppliers and multitude of buyers can absorb
fluctuation. But in B to B we are dealing with few suppliers and few buyers comparatively
of course, as a result of which the uncertainty can really throw the whole system out of gear
unless it is actually designed for that kind of flexible response that is what we mentioned.
So, we need to have that ability in the system to take some variable shocks.
So, that concludes our short session on supply chain management which is a complimentary
activity this whole logistics management system is a compliment to the sales management system
to the distribution management system to the procurement system all that particularly we
discussed at length about e procurement etcetera and e commerce in all that a sophisticated
logistic system is absolutely required and the presentation that we handled today in
this session gives you some first understanding of the way it is achieved and the building
blocks of a flexible responsive fast time crunched logistic system.
Thank you.
