Lecture 46: Hermite operator

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 26, 2024
Welcome back, last lecture we are discussing about the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.
So we will give in this lecture we are going to give an alternate proof for Heisenberg
Uncertainty Principle.
So, there are two main operator in physics what we do is that with the state function
if you are acting this is f of x, these two are the fundamental operator which is equal
to f prime of x. One thing easy to notice is that if we look at the inner product of
P f of g this is equal to integral minus infinity to infinity x f of x then g x bar dx which
is minus infinity to infinity f of x and x is a real number. So, we can write this as
dx which is equal to minus infinity to infinity f of x P g x bar dx which is f P g. Therefore,
P is self adjoined and in case of the Q if we look at Q f of g this is equal to minus
infinity to infinity f prime of x then this is g x bar dx.
Now if f is in the Schwarz space so now by doing the integration by parts what we get
is that this is first quantity f of x g of x minus infinity to infinity it is going to
be 0 so by integration by parts we get this is f of x and then g prime of x bar dx which
is nothing but minus of f of Q g. So, therefore Q star is equal to minus of Q. Now what we
would like to derive the Heisenberg uncertainty principle using these two fundamental operators.
So now towards that end let us define the Hermite operator which essentially is I will
define L f of x this is equal to minus f double prime of x plus x square f of x applying
P and Q twice what we are going to get Q star and P twice we will get this operator that
is the Hermite operator.
that first the Heisenberg uncertainty principle will imply that L f f this is greater or equal
to f f for all f in the Schwarz space. So, now let us write in order to apply the Heisenberg
uncertainty principle let us assume integral minus infinity to infinity mod f x square
dx this is equal to 1 then only we are going to apply Heisenberg uncertainty principle.
So now let us look at left hand side which is L f f so this by definition is minus infinity
to infinity minus f double prime of x plus x square f of x this is L f and then by inner
product definition f x bar dx. So, this is minus infinity to infinity minus f double
prime of x f bar of x plus minus infinity to infinity x square mod of f of x square
dx.
So now if I if we do perform the integration by parts then the first one f prime of x into
f of x minus infinity to infinity is going to vanish then so what then minus minus will
be plus so this will be minus infinity to infinity f prime of x and then this is derivative
of that is f prime of x bar dx plus this is so this is mod of we can so this is nothing
but minus infinity to infinity mod of f prime of x square dx plus minus infinity to infinity
x square mod of f of x square dx okay.
So then by using the Planck's rule theorem what we will get that this is 4 pi square
integral minus infinity to infinity xi square plus into mod of f at xi square d xi the first
one and then plus minus infinity to infinity x square mod of f of x square dx. Now this
is a square plus b square then this is going to be greater or equal to 2ab so therefore
this is going to be greater or equal to 2 times this is 2 pi minus infinity to infinity
xi square mod of f hat of xi square d xi whole to the power one half into integral minus
infinity to infinity x square mod of f of x square dx whole to the power one half.
Now we are assuming that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is true therefore this is greater
or equal to 4 pi into 1 over 4 pi so which is equal to 1 which is nothing but f f because
we are assuming that the integral mod f square dx is going to be equal to 1 okay. Now if
g is a Schwarz class f is any arbitrary Schwarz class function not the integral is 1 then
the standard trick define let define g is equal to f by norm so what do I mean by that
this is equal to minus infinity to infinity mod of f of x square dx whole to the power
1 over 2. So therefore as you can see that integral minus infinity to infinity mod of
g of x square dx which is equal to 1 therefore we can apply we know that L g g in our product
this is greater or equal to g and g this will imply that L f by norm f and f by norm f in
our product is greater than f by this L is a linear operator so we can pull it out so
this is L f f so this shows that if Heisenberg uncertainty principle hold then this is going
to be true.
Now how to prove the question is that how to prove the Heisenberg uncertainty principle
using this two fundamental operators okay so as usual we have defined let us say a is
equal to a f of x this is equal to f prime of x that is q of f and x fx the p of f then
as we have noticed a star this is going to be equal to minus of f prime of x plus x fx
therefore and now you look at a a star of f this is going to be a or rather a star of
a if I want to look at a star then acting on a f this is equal to a star acting on a
f is f prime plus x f now a star is equal to minus of f prime is f double prime so rather
I will let us write one more step minus of f prime plus x f prime plus x f prime plus
x f so this is equal to minus of f double prime and then the x prime x prime is plus
x f plus x f prime this is the first one plus x f prime plus x square of f now this
is equal to minus of f double prime and plus x square of f x f prime minus and this is
plus will go away minus of f this is nothing but L minus of I acting on f this is what
is our a star a f so thus if we are assuming that so now you can see that a star of a f
and g this is equal to integral over a star a f at x g of x bar dx minus infinity to infinity
which is equal to I will first write down the definition of a star then this is going
to be minus of a f prime of x plus x time a f of x whole into g of x bar dx.
So if we do integration by parts you look at that minus of a f prime is minus of a f
into g bar of x which vanishes then what we will get is that minus of infinity to infinity
a f of x and then g prime of x bar dx and for the next one what we have got is that
this is integral minus infinity to infinity a f of x then x g x bar dx so this is minus
infinity to infinity a f of x into g prime of x plus x g of x this whole bar of dx which
is equal to a f and then this is a g that is what we have claimed this is the linear
algebra one what we are proving it. So therefore thus a star f a f of f this is equal to a f a f
which is greater or equal to 0 okay. So now you define so as a consequence what we have got is
that L minus I f inner product of f that is greater or equal to 0. So now what we want to
prove the Heisenberg uncertainty principle so for that define a t for any t positive you define a t
f of x f prime of x any t real number so plus t x f of x and therefore just as before one can say
that this is a t star form would be minus of f prime of x plus t x f of x. Now what we know is
that a t star of a t of f comma f this is greater or equal to 0 because this is nothing but the norm
of a t of f and a t star of a t of f this at x this if we do simple calculation then
what we will get that this is equal to minus of a t of f prime at x plus t x a t of x.
So we will just take the derivative so what is a t of f prime at x this is equal to f
prime plus t x f whole prime this is equal to f double prime plus t f derivative with
respect to f and plus t x f prime and then if we are adding this 2 so this is minus therefore
a t star a t f at x this is equal to minus of f prime plus t f of x plus t x f prime
of x plus t x into f prime of x plus a t is again t x f of x.
So this is equal to minus of f double prime of x plus t f of x plus t x f prime of x plus
t x f prime of x plus t square x square f of x now here there are the minus signs over
here this is minus this is minus minus minus. So then this is minus of f double prime of
x minus t f of x this gets cancelled and plus t square x square f of x. Now this is
a quadratic equation on t so now if I look at a t star a t f of inner product of f this
we know that this is greater or equal to 0. So this is t square and then x square f f
inner product from this and then minus t f f inner product and then minus f double prime
and f this is greater or equal to 0. Now this is a quadratic equation and on t which is
what we have got is that 1 minus 4 a is f c is f double prime of f this is greater or
equal to 0. So this will imply that x square f inner product of f multiplied by f double prime
equal to 1 by 4 and again so this will imply that integral minus infinity to infinity x square mod
of f of x square d x and then what we have got is multiplied by minus infinity to infinity mod
prime of x and f of x d x is greater or equal to 1 by 4. Now this implies that minus infinity
to infinity x square f of x square d x. Now if we do again integration by parts what we
are going to get is that this is minus infinity to infinity f prime of x square d x this is
greater or equal to 1 by 4 and then this will imply that minus infinity to infinity x square
mod f x square d x and this is nothing but minus infinity to infinity 4 xi square if I take it out
then this is by Planck's rule which would be greater 1 by 4 pi square is coming out 4 pi square
that is so Heisenberg's uncertainty principle we can get it down. Thank you.
