Lecture 42 : Solving problems using Lagrange's equation of first kind

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 26, 2024
Hello and welcome to another session of Classical Motion of a Single Particle. So, in this session
we will solve two interesting problems of classical mechanics using the method which
we just discussed that is the Lagrange's equation of first kind ok.
So, if you remember that Lagrange's equation of first kind is given by this one this equation
that is for a particle of mass m, m r double dot which is the mass times the acceleration
minus. So, the force to which is excluding the constraint force ok. So, this is only
the force where the particle is subject to and this is not the force related to some
contact or some tension or some response of any medium or material. So, this is the force
field in which the particle is subject to move and this excludes any type of constraint
force ok plus lambda times lambda times gradient of phi is equal to 0 where lambda is the undetermined
multiplier of Lagrange and phi is the holonomic constraint which we consider here. So, phi
is a holonomic constraint ok. So, we can start with a very simple case where a particle
is moving in a circular orbit. So, now, you see our approach will be to
identify the constraint. So, in a circular orbit the if I say the particle is moving
a particle is moving in let us say x z plane. So, let us say like this I can take this is
the x direction this is the z direction I say a particle which is at p. So, this is
the origin o and the particle is moving in a circle let us say in the anticlockwise direction
ok. Then you can always say that ok. So, this is x and this is z ok and if this is
the polar angle theta and this is r then of course, x is equal to r cos theta and z is
equal to r sin theta that we all know. Now, coming back to the problem. So, in this
problem first I can write. So, M I have a motion in 2 D and that is my choice that is
not a constraint actually ok that is the choice ok you can say that the motion is on 2 D,
but then the constraint is that the now the particle has to move in a circle of radius
let us say small r ok. So, I can now say that this small r is a constant.
So, M x I can actually write this thing in this way. So, M r double dot minus F i ok
plus lambda now first we will attack this phi. So, what is the constraint here the constraint
is x square plus y square will be equal to r square which is constant. So, phi will be
equal to x square plus y square minus r square and that is equal to 0 ok. So, I just write
this x square plus y square minus r square ok that is equal to 0.
Now, here I am just telling that it is just moving in a plane and for this type of motion
you just see that there is I am not saying that any force is acting other than the force
of constraint for example, ok. So, I do not know that is there any force field because
when I am saying that a particle is hanging vertically in a in the case of pendulum I
know there is G is acting ok, but here when a particle is just moving in a circle I can
simply say ok the maybe the motion is only due to the force of constraints and this type
of force is actually not present. So, I can actually say this is not present.
So, this is 0 ok using Cartesian coordinates I can actually write then m x double dot ok
plus lambda. So, here also I have to take the x component which will be 2 lambda x ok
is equal to 0 and. So, I should not put like this and m z double dot plus I think I have
made a mistake over here. So, instead of writing z I have written y everywhere I will simply
change that to z yes ok yeah and here as well ok. So, you will see and m z double dot
ok will simply be plus lambda 2 lambda z is equal to 0 ok.
So, now you will have an equation which are 2 equations which are quite similar ok. So,
now, you can see that we have to eliminate lambda to find an relation between x and z
ok and now for that what we will do this is also pretty easy to do. So, I just use this
thing that x is r cos theta and z is r sin theta and r is a constant here. So, only variable
this. So, x is r cos theta that means, x dot is equal to minus r sin theta theta dot ok
and then x double dot will be equal to minus r cos theta theta dot square and then there
will be minus r sin theta theta double dot ok.
Similarly for z I know r sin theta z is equal to. So, z dot will simply be equal to r cos
theta theta dot and then z double dot will be equal to minus r sin theta theta dot square
plus r cos theta theta double dot ok. So, now, you just put these things over here.
So, I what I write in green now. So, in green I will have the these 2 equations actually
these 2 ok, but in polar coordinates ok. So, r is a constant for our system that is the
constraint ok. So, I can write then m times m times minus r cos theta theta dot square
minus r sin theta theta double dot plus 2 lambda x is r cos theta cos theta and that
will be equal to 0. I have also from this equation this z equation I have m minus r
sin theta theta dot square plus r cos theta theta double dot ok then I will have plus
2 lambda r sin theta which is equal to 0 ok. What I can now do? I can just multiply
this this equation by cos theta. I can multiply this equation by sin theta ok. If I do and
then I just subtract the first one from this second one what I will have you will see that
I will have m minus r sin theta cos theta theta dot square here and here I will have
minus m r cos theta sin theta theta dot square. So, they will cancel each other again I will
have here plus 2 lambda r cos theta sin theta here I will have plus 2 lambda r sin theta
cos theta. So, they will again cancel each other the only term which will be remaining
is this thing. So, I will have then r cos square theta theta double dot minus minus
r sin square theta theta double dot that will be equal to 0 if you just do this ok.
And, then you will actually have r. So, cos square theta plus sin square theta times theta
double dot equal to 0 and finally, you will have this is one this is constant which is
nonzero finally, you will have theta double dot equal to 0. So, you see that means, that
theta dot is constant ok. So, this is exactly what is expected from a pure circular orbit
or pure circular motion. So, you see I even do not know what actually
which force is causing the motion in a circle I just know that there is no force other than
the force of constraints and since the force of constraints are prohibited here in this
Lagrange's equation of first kind I will I did not mention about them then I started
and finally, I get this equation ok. So, theta dot equal to constant and now of course, from
that you can solve for theta which will be a linear function of time.
I will now do the usual example of a simple pendulum, but with always the fixed length
ok. So, the simple pendulum is having a mass m, but now it is moving actually in a arc
of a circle of length L and this is the fixed length of the string and the weight is working
vertically downwards. So, I am again defining this is my x axis and this is my z direction.
So, this is actually negative z direction negative z direction. So, if I do that then
the Lagrange's. So, for a simple pendulum for a simple pendulum with fixed length of
the string we have again m r double dot plus now here I know that I have some constant
force which is tension and everything I know I do not want to talk about them the only
force force field to which the particle is subject to move is the G field ok. This is
the earth's gravitational field and the force is m g, but in the downward sense. So, I will
write that m r double dot plus m g. So, you just remember here I just made there is a
minus sign. So, here of course, you can actually write
right from the beginning the minus sign there is no problem with that and then you write
this is the gradient times the constant of this ok. Again here the constant is exactly
the same as that of a particle moving in a circle x square plus z square is equal to
l square which is a constant ok. So, you will have the same form here x square plus y square
minus l square ok. The only thing you will have is that for along x direction you will
have along x direction you will have m x double dot is equal to minus 2 lambda x because along
x direction there is no force field acting to which the particle is subject to move ok.
But along z direction along negative z direction you have a force field and that is why you
actually write then m z double dot and this becomes then plus sign because G is acting
vertically downwards. So, along minus z direction. So, I will write plus m g is equal to minus
2 lambda z. I already have found how to handle this type of problem and actually. So, we
simply again cast this Cartesian coordinates in the plane polar coordinate system. So,
here we will simply write you see that x is equal to I can just simply say that this is
an angle theta ok. So, x can be given by l sin theta and z is given by l cos theta
because if this is l and this is the angle theta. So, then this is l sin theta and this
is l cos theta. Now one thing we have to take proper caution
that is z by definition is negative in this downward direction that is why we will write
this minus l cos theta because if you just say l is just a positive number which is the
radial distance and if you define also theta to be positive in the anticlockwise direction
ok measured from this vertical direction ah then you can actually write this is minus
l cos theta ok. This is ah something just a convention to make sure that z is negative
ok. You can also redefine your angle theta from this direction actually and from there
you can actually also have the same situation ok just try that as well.
If you have x is equal to l sin theta and z is equal to minus l cos theta then your
x dot will simply be l cos theta theta dot and your x double dot will simply be minus
l sin theta theta dot square plus l cos theta theta double dot ok. Then you will also have
y dot is equal to sorry then you will also have z dot is equal to minus l. So, cos theta
is minus sin theta theta dot which is l sin theta theta dot and then z double dot will
be simply equal to l cos theta theta dot square plus l sin theta theta double dot ok.
Now we will write the equation of Lagrange of the first kind for the system in the plane
polar coordinate system and I use this green ink again. So, m times the whole thing m times
this thing ok and I can say that minus l sin theta theta dot square plus l cos theta theta
double dot minus l sin theta theta dot square plus l cos theta theta double dot ok is equal
to minus 2 lambda x. So, if you remember this equation ok. So, x is l sin theta l sin theta
ok I can actually write just like this plus this equal to 0 ok yeah.
What will be the equation for z ok m z double dot? So, z double dot is this thing m l cos
theta theta dot square plus l sin theta theta double dot ok. So, both the terms they have
the plus sign then you have here m g that is the difference between the x direction
and the z direction and you will have 2 lambda l cos theta ok is equal to 0. Now here again
it should be minus. So, I just write because your z is minus l cos theta by convention
ok. So, now, what you will do you will simply multiply cos theta with this whole thing.
So, cos theta you multiply ok here you multiply sin theta with the whole thing and then you
add them up if you add them up then you again see that the first term will go away with
this term ok. So, it will be minus m l sin theta cos theta theta dot square here it will
be plus m l sin theta cos theta theta dot square. Again if you just take. So, this is
actually multiplied with the whole thing the same here ok. So, this term with the Lagrange
multiplier will also go away because it will be 2 lambda l sin theta cos theta with plus
sign and here it will be 2 lambda l cos theta sin theta with minus sign.
So, finally, you will have l cos square theta plus sin square theta. So, here you see here
this term gives l cos theta times cos theta. So, cos square theta theta dot theta double
dot and here you will have l sin square theta theta double dot plus m g sin theta is equal
to 0 and then you can write l theta double dot plus m g sorry there is an m which is
missing. So, here I should write m for both yeah and here I will get rid of the m then
I can simply say this is g sin theta is equal to 0 and then again for theta tending to 0
I will have we have theta sin theta is theta ok tending to theta and the equation of motion
is given by theta double dot plus g by l theta is equal to 0 ok.
So, what is this? This is again the equation of dynamics of a simple pendulum where the
angle theta is very very small and that is the popular form where you can see that the
simple pendulum is actually performing a simple harmonic oscillation ok under the assumption
that theta is tending to 0. So, you see even using this Lagrange's equation of first kind
the same technique that we do not talk at all about any force of constraint we have
not mentioned anything about the tension T we just use the geometrical constraint itself
that is x square plus z square is equal to l square which is a constant using that we
finally, found the equation of dynamics and once you have equation of dynamics you can
simply solve the equation for theta and theta dot ok.
So, in this way we can solve many interesting simple problems in the framework of Newtonian
mechanics and actually you will understand that many problems in Newtonian mechanics
where the constraint forces are complex in nature and you even do not know how to account
for them this type of method is super useful ok. And one such problem I will give you that
is the concerning the motion of a particle which is now moving downward and in inclined
plane you will be supposed to solve that using this Lagrange's equation of first kind in
the assignment ok. Thank you very much.
