Pour le gouvernement de Michel Barnier, le premier grand défi sera de bâtir le budget 2025 face à une Assemblée sans majorité claire. L'urgence est réelle : après un été marqué par un vide politique, les délais prévus par la loi ne seront pas respectés. Le budget, initialement prévu pour le 1er octobre, sera plutôt dévoilé le 9 octobre. L'enjeu est de taille, avec une dette de 3 000 milliards d'euros et une France sous surveillance européenne pour déficit excessif. Dans ce contexte, Michel Barnier ouvre la porte à des hausses d'impôts, un virage auquel Emmanuel Macron s'était jusqu'ici refusé. Mais la situation des finances françaises est-elle vraiment aussi grave que le gouvernement l'affirme ? Pour en parler, notre invité Jean-Claude Trichet, ancien président de la Banque centrale européenne et ancien gouverneur de la Banque de France. #france#finance#dette 🔔 Abonnez-vous à notre chaîne : https://rfi.my/YTfr 🔴 Suivez RFI en DIRECT vidéo ici : https://rfi.my/YTliveFR 🌍 L’actualité du monde et de l’Afrique en direct : https://www.rfi.fr/fr/ Rejoignez-nous sur Facebook : https://rfi.my/FBfr Suivez-nous sur X (Twitter) : https://rfi.my/Xfr Découvrez l’actu en images sur Instagram : https://rfi.my/IGfr Recevez les dernières infos sur Telegram : https://rfi.my/TGfr
Hello Jean-Claude Trichet.
Thank you for accepting the invitation from RFI, former governor of the European Central Bank, former governor of the Bank of France.
It is in this context, and we will come back to it, that Michel Barnier opened the way to tax increases, which Emmanuel Macron had refused until now.
But first, the observation, the situation of the finances of France, is it really very serious, as the government says, unprecedented, exceptional?
I think we can say it. Indeed, we only take the measure, if you will, of the problem when we compare ourselves to other countries.
And when I compare France to other countries, I think the government is right to say that the situation is very serious,
because we have, as far as deficits are concerned, not only, probably for this year, next year and in the medium term, let's say for 2027,
we have the most important deficit of the euro zone. As far as public spending is concerned, in proportion to GDP,
we have the most important expenses of the euro zone, so in proportion to our wealth, the wealth of each country.
And as far as the tax increase in proportion to GDP, we are the third most indebted country after Greece and Italy.
So precisely, since we are talking about comparison with other countries in the euro zone, where are we?
We are not yet precisely in the situation of Greece a few years ago, where it had been terrible, including with the adjustment that had followed the crisis.
No, indeed, we are obviously not in the situation of Greece. I knew myself, I was president of the European Central Bank.
Greece, Ireland and Portugal in 2010, in a dramatic situation because we could not finance ourselves at all.
And the European friends, let's say, and ourselves, the European Central Bank, we had helped them.
And then I met in 2011 Italy and Spain in a situation of no longer being able to finance themselves.
So, indeed, we are not there at all, naturally, but we must avoid being there.
Jean-Claude Richet, it's been years since we've heard that it's serious, especially these last few months,
but it's been years since we've heard that public finances in France are slipping.
And yet, when it was necessary to face Covid, the state paid.
From the point of view of a profane, of someone who knows nothing about the economy,
we say to ourselves, there is, in spite of everything, magic money coming out.
Why should it stop today?
There is no magic money.
There is money that the savers of the whole world, French, European and the whole world, accept to lend us.
That's it.
We are in permanent deficit.
We must constantly borrow from abroad.
The savers lend you money on the condition of having the feeling that you are not going to waste it and that you are going to repay them.
It's as simple as that.
And so the countries I just mentioned were countries that had lost, if you will, their credibility.
And by the way, they take away the interests of the debt.
It must be said, it's several tens of billions of euros each year.
It's a post in the budget of the state.
I think it's the second, I hope not to say nonsense, but a post to inherit the interests of the debt.
Of course, it's normal.
In a way, the savers lend you money averaging interest.
And we know it well, ourselves, French, since we have delivered one, etc.
There are interests to be paid and that are paid to us.
And we are happy when they are paid to us.
So in total, if you will, we have a situation, once again, that must be compared to other countries.
We cannot afford to have the most important deficit compared to other countries.
Because you were talking about interests.
Interests depend on the confidence you inspire, on the credibility of your own signature.
And the less credible you are, the more you pay dearly.
What is the risk if we do not make the necessary savings?
If we let the deficit flow, if we let the debt grow.
It's very simple.
We have known that in the past.
I have known that in the past.
The five countries I mentioned were in an ultra-difficult situation.
They obviously had to put their affairs in order, being helped by the European Central Bank.
We intervened massively on the markets to help them.
But of course, their recovery, when we are in a very bad situation, is always difficult.
And it is always the poorest and the most disadvantaged who pay the most the price of recovery.
So we really have to avoid being in a situation like this.
I believe in the interest of all French citizens and certainly of the rulers.
We will see what they will do.
But there is an obligation for results.
Precisely.
And there are two levers to try to secure the accounts.
We go back to the basics.
Forgive me Jean-Claude Trichet.
We spend less or we take more.
However, we understand that the new government intends to do both.
Namely, tighten budgets in ministries and perhaps increase taxes.
Michel Barnier gave some signs in this sense, saying that it would not keep the most modest,
nor those who work, nor the middle classes.
So who?
Maybe categorize them, maybe some companies.
Isn't that risky?
First, can we do both at the same time?
Isn't the accumulation of economies and increases in taxes in the long run a bad thing for the French economy?
First of all, there is an obligation for results.
If we do not manage to straighten things out and inspire confidence again in all of our lenders,
in all the savers around the world, then we will be in a very difficult situation.
In my opinion, and it seems to me that this is what the government has said, more or less,
we must start by reducing expenditure, knowing that we have an obligation for results.
And if the only reduction of expenditure is not enough, then there are recipes.
But we must not, in a way, reverse the order of the factors.
First of all, reduce expenditure.
Reduce expenditure in significant quantities, what does that mean exactly?
On the train of life of ministries, the train of life of the state, the budgets of education?
It's very simple. If I compare, once again, to other countries, and if I take the situation we are in,
basically, we spend about 10 points more of our national wealth than the average of the countries in the euro zone.
We are at 58%, they are at 48%.
And compared to the most comparable countries, clearly, the difference is about 8 to 10%.
So it will obviously have to be reduced considerably, it seems to me.
And once again, I insist on this point, some say it's in the French GDP, the French spend a lot.
But we spend, in proportion to the GDP, less public spending than the English and the Germans before the first oil shock, let's say in 1970.
So there is no tragic French GDP. We must be able to recover.
One last word, Jean-Claude Trichet, we have very little time left.
You were, as we said, at the head of the ECB.
The Draghi report published last week calls for massive investments at the European level
to ensure that the 27 remain in the world competition against China, against the United States.
Given what you tell us, it's impossible, France will not be able to contribute more.
France, they spoke for the whole of the euro zone, naturally.
The whole of the euro zone has an excess of savings compared to the United States, which have a deficit of savings.
We have more than 3% of excess GDP, they have less than 3%.
And so we must be able to invest in the directions suggested by Mario Draghi.
But of course, each country must do its own household, at home, it goes by itself.
Thank you very much, Jean-Claude Trichet, for being with us this morning, former governor of the ECB and the Bank of France.