« Jamais depuis la guerre en 2006, nous disait tôt ce matin une de nos correspondantes à Beyrouth, jamais le Liban n'avait connu une journée aussi meurtrière ». C'était hier, près de 500 morts dans les frappes israéliennes qui ont visé le sud et la plaine de la Bekaa. Et presque immédiatement, ces images d'exode pour des milliers d'habitants de la zone à la recherche d'un refuge plus au nord. Avons-nous bel et bien basculé dans une nouvelle guerre ? Pour en parler, notre invité Jadd Hilal-Giuliani, écrivain, professeur et chercheur franco-libano-palestinien, auteur du roman "Le caprice de vivre" (éditions Elyzad). #hezbollah#israel#liban
Ever since the war in 2006, as one of our correspondents in Beirut told us this morning,
Lebanon had never had such a murderous day.
It was yesterday, so nearly 500 dead in the Israeli strikes
that targeted the south and the Bekaa plain.
And almost immediately, these images of exodus for thousands of inhabitants of the area
in search of a refuge further north.
Hello Jadilal.
Hello.
Thank you for being with us.
You are a writer, Franco-Libano-Palestinian.
You live in France, but a part of your family is there, in Lebanon.
With what happened yesterday,
do you have the impression that we have indeed fallen into a new war?
It is true that this is a question that inevitably arises.
The precaution that I would tend to take,
given the testimonies that I can receive,
is to consider that every point of view on Lebanon is located.
So a part of my family,
you have to say things to a privileged person,
who is not Shiite, for example.
It is the confession close to Hezbollah,
geographically and religiously.
And I still think today that the situation is not very good.
That it is a religious conflict, right?
That it is a conflict that does not concern them,
but in any case that is far from ...
And on the contrary, there are some Shiite populations
who are largely impacted.
And we can indeed consider rapprochements in history,
especially with 2006,
with what happened with Hariri and the forced exodus.
The last war that marked Lebanon for a long time.
Since October 7, there was a kind of tacit agreement
between Israel and Hezbollah,
which consisted of excluding total war,
as it took place at that time, in 1996.
In 2006, we clearly took one more step towards this confrontation.
Yes, it's a huge step.
I would have a tendency, from the experience and testimonies I have received,
to date this step to what happened in Beirut,
with the assassination of the leader of Hezbollah.
Last July or last summer?
Yes, absolutely.
Because I think that for some Lebanese,
Beirut is a symbolic point.
When the conflicts were more localized in southern Lebanon,
the meaning was not the same of an intervention in Beirut.
Because we have traumas in mind.
Already in 2006 and even before,
every time there was an intervention in Beirut,
it was always disastrous for civilians.
And we heard the concern of the inhabitants of the capital,
because they say that the capital can be bombed,
and that maybe the next step is the terrestrial incursion.
This is what the United States would like to avoid.
We are not sure that they have the means.
It's difficult.
Anyway, what happened with the Beepers and the Tokiwokis,
there are many possible scenarios.
It can also be a first step.
It can be the preparation of a field,
due to the saturation of hospitals,
due to an updated database by Israel
on where the leaders of Hezbollah are.
There is also the part of the military troops,
the Redouane elite troops,
which were largely impacted by Israel.
With Iranian nuclear power in view,
it is one of the possible paths.
You mentioned earlier the confessional dimension of Lebanon,
which is obviously huge.
We know that it is a close-knit society,
that since the civil war,
each group must be represented by the government.
Israel claims to have targeted Hezbollah targets.
The presence of the armed movement on Lebanese territory
is a reality, with bases, with equipment.
How is it perceived by all Lebanese,
those who are not Shiites?
This is a difficult question,
and at the same time absolutely crucial for Lebanon.
That's why I said that the points of view must be located.
In reality, it is a society that is perceived
as a very mixed society,
but it is a very close-knit society.
It is difficult to know exactly what the Lebanese think.
But what is certain is that...
Do some people see the movement as a troublemaker?
Or is the general feeling
that it defends the interests of Lebanese or Palestinians,
as it has been doing since October 7,
with little support from Hamas?
What I can say is that the movement is certainly more
than a simple brutal and armed movement
for many people,
especially Shiite people,
who are helped enormously financially by Hezbollah,
whether in education,
in a social security system,
there is an alternative economy that is proposed.
There is a political representation,
there is a social role,
and there is a facade,
an armed part.
The question that arises is that
one, we cannot remove Hezbollah by slapping our fingers like that,
and two, especially, who takes over?
We are also in a society that is just
dealing with huge catastrophes,
which does not have a stable governmental position
that allows for a form of economic distribution.
We heard Benjamin Netanyahu yesterday
defending this very massive campaign
of air strikes and murderous strikes,
and the Israeli Prime Minister said
Hezbollah uses Lebanese as a human shield.
What does that inspire you?
Personally, from your point of view.
I find it very simplistic.
I think that many Shiite people,
especially historically,
and Palestinians in Lebanon, by the way,
are represented in Hezbollah,
whether we like it or not.
And conversely, indeed,
I believe that many Lebanese do not say it,
but consider that, in fact, in a way,
they would be very happy
if Hezbollah disappeared.
That Israel, in a way,
serves what they will never say,
because it is a taboo.
It is a taboo, indeed.
But this is what harms their interest, Hezbollah.
Iran has warned several times
against a dangerous escalation,
but in the end it did not have
a significant reaction on the ground.
Jadilal, once again,
how do you see Tehran's attitude
since the beginning of this war,
since October 7th?
I think it is a form of caution,
because, in reality,
the attack against Hezbollah
was devastating.
Globally, the United States,
I think, would intervene.
In any case, historically,
this is what has always happened.
So, there is a position of weakness
with the Gaza Front as well,
with Hamas,
which, unfortunately, has been...
Which also conditions
what is currently happening
in the south of Lebanon.
Unfortunately, it does condition.
The new head of French diplomacy,
Jean-Noël Barrault,
asked for an emergency meeting
of the Security Council.
We also heard earlier
that the European,
Joseph Borrell,
is very alarmist.
Do you expect something
from diplomacy,
whether it is French,
European or UN?
We are in the General Assembly
in New York, Jadilal.
In fact, there is a moral duty
which is to expect something.
Because we can't
not give a reason
to the people who are there.
So, it is the moment,
as Joseph Borrell said,
it is the moment to do something.
It is the moment to do something.
It is an imperative.
And at the same time,
you have to know that...
This is what I can perhaps
express as a writer
and perhaps as a person
intellectually engaged
in the conflict.
There are other ways
to get involved
which are to be maintained,
I think.
You also say
that it is a regional war
which could only be settled
by the actors of the region
themselves.
I consider that
in any case,
interventionism
must be conditioned
to the interests
of the people
who are participating.
Managed with caution.
Thank you very much, Jadilal,
for being with us this morning.